For the construction of first floor extensions and associated works Decision

📊

See the success rate & inspector analytics

Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.

Sign Up Free

Technical Issues Heatmap

Character & Appearance
Residential Amenity
Extensions

Inspector’s Reasoning

Appeal Decision Site visit made on 9 July 2026 by Elizabeth Lawrence BTP MRTPI an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State Decision date: 29 July 2026 Appeal Ref: 6010490 16 Praze Road, Newquay, TR7 3DD • The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 (as amended) against a refusal to grant planning permission. • The appeal is made by Mr & Mrs Steven Frazer against the decision of Cornwall Council. • The application Ref is PA26/01925. • The development proposed is for the construction of first floor extensions and associated works Decision 1. The appeal is dismissed. Main Issues 2. The first main issue is the effect of the proposal on the character of the street scene. The second main issue is the benefits of the proposed development for the appellant’s family. Reasons Character and appearance 3. The appeal site is located within an established suburban estate that is primarily characterised by detached bungalows and dormer bungalows. Whilst their designs vary, their front building lines are similar; there are modest sized gaps between the dwellings; and their heights rise as they follow the sloping topography of the area. This creates a relatively uniform roofscape that frames the soft landscaped front gardens, the wide highway with its grass verges and the more distant views towards the coast. 4. Praze Road is situated on land which rises to the south and west, with the dwellings on the west side sitting above road level and those of the other side below road level. The ridge lines rise uniformly, with the roofs of the dwellings on the west side of the road being higher and more prominent within the street scene, 5. These features contribute to the character and appearance of Praze Road and the local area, which is within the Porth Veor character area set out in the Newquay Neighbourhood Plan 2019 -2030 (NNP) Character Study. It states that within this area single storey dwellings and dormer bungalows contribute to the areas distinctive character, although the NNP notes that two storey housing has been developed along parts of Bonython Road and Lusty Glaze Road. It also advises that to help reinforce local distinctiveness it would be an advantage to use materials including natural slate, local stone and render. Appeal Decision 6010490 2 6. During my site visit I noted a row of two story dwellings at the northern end of Praze Road. Not only does this part of Praze Road sit at a lower level, the dwellings sit at roughly the same level as the road. As a consequence, they respect the overall roofscape of Praze Road and the area. Elsewhere within the estate there are some taller chalet and two storey dwellings. Typically, they sit at a comparable or lower level to the bungalows and dormer bungalows to the side of them and their ridge lines blend in with the roofscape of the street scene. 7. There are some exceptions where the heights of some dwellings materially exceed that of the dwellings on either side. They have disrupted the sense of rhythm within the street scene to various degrees. Rather than set a precedent they serve to highlight the sensitivity of the roofscape to change. 8. I have taken into consideration the first floor roof extensions/new dwellings referred to by the appellant. Although they are sited close to the appeal site, one fronts onto Bonython Road and two are sited beyond the junction with Bonython Road, where the roofscapes are not directly comparable to Praze Road south of this junction. Also, their combined height, design, appearance and relationship to the dwellings they sit alongside are quite distinct from the appeal proposal. 9. The appeal property occupies an elevated position on the west side of Praze Road and a short distance from the junction with Bonython Road. It is located at the end of a row of similarly designed bungalows and dormer bungalows, although both the appeal plot and the dwelling are particularly wide. The dwellings have rendered walls under plain tiled roofs, with some stone detailing and rise in a uniform fashion as they progress up the hill. The row of dwellings sit above the road level behind open, shallow front gardens that are contained behind low stone walls. 10. On the opposite side of the appeal site is the rear garden of a recently extended bungalow, (No.86). This dwelling is materially taller than the appeal dwelling, although the two dwellings are separated by the rear garden to No.86. Also, the dwelling at No.86 fronts onto a Bonython Road and has very different building lines to the appeal dwelling. As a result, whilst due to its combined height and width it is prominent within the street scene, the dwelling at No.86 does not impact on the character, appearance and identity of the dwellings within this part of Praze Road. 11. Together and amongst other things policies 1, 2 and 12 of the Cornwall Local Plan Strategic Polices 2010-2030 (CLP) and Policy C1 (7) of the Cornwall Climate Emergency Development Plan Document 2023 (DPD), support sustainable development. They seek to increase Cornwall’s built distinctiveness and require proposals to be of a high quality and demonstrate an understanding of their location. 12. Collectively NNP Policies G2, D1 and H1, similarly state that developments should reinforce a strong sense of identity. They should respect the height of neighbouring properties and seek to retain the tiered effect up and down hills. Materials used should be sustainable and positively enhance local character. Residential extensions should reflect the principles of the NNP Character Study and should not have a detrimental impact on the living conditions of the occupiers of neighbouring properties. 13. Together paragraphs 135 and 139 of the National Planning Policy Framework 2024 (the Framework) require developments to be sympathetic to local character and Appeal Decision 6010490 3 history, including the built environment and landscape setting, whilst optimising the potential of a site and not preventing appropriate innovation or change. Development that is not well designed should be refused, especially where it fails to reflect local design policies. 14. The proposal would radically change the size, character and appearance of the host dwelling. It would comprise a substantial chalet dwelling that would be materially taller than the adjacent bungalows along Praze Road. The proposed dormer windows would project forward of the front and rear roof slopes of the row of bungalows, where due to their siting, mass and height, they would emphasise the height, bulk and prominence of the resultant dwelling within the street scene. It would materially harm the strong sense of rhythm of the roofscape within Praze Road and would be totally out of keeping with the character and appearance of the street scene. This harm is not something that could be satisfactorily dealt with by condition. 15. Finally, the proposed detailed design and palette/use of external materials do not reflect the character and appearance of the existing dwellings in Praze Road. Whilst in itself this would not amount to a reason for dismissing this appeal it would further add to the prominence of the dwelling and thus the harm that would be caused to the street scene. 16. I conclude on the main issue that the proposal would result in considerable and unacceptably harm to the character and appearance of the street scene. It conflicts with CLP Policies 1, 2 & 12, DPD Policy C1 (7), NNP Policies G2, D1 & H1 and paragraph 135 of the Framework. The benefits of the proposed development to the appellant’s family 17. The Appellants have submitted details relating to the specific needs of their son and the benefits the proposed additional accommodation would provide. 18. Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) relates to the qualified right to respect for private and family life. The Public Sector Equality Duty (PSED) is set out in the Equality Act 2010. Amongst other things Section 149 of the Equality Act sets out the need to advance equality of opportunity and to foster good relations between persons who share a relevant protected characteristic and persons who do not share it. This includes persons with physical or mental impairments that have a substantial and long term adverse effect on a person’s ability to carry out normal day to day activities. 19. It is apparent from the submitted evidence that the appellants son has a protected characteristic for the purposes of PSED. Accordingly, I have paid due regard to the need to: - Remove or minimise disadvantages suffered by persons who share a relevant protected characteristic that are connected to that characteristic; - Take steps to meet the needs of persons who share a relevant protected characteristic that are different from the needs of persons who do not share it; - Encourage persons who share a relevant protected characteristic to participate in public life or in any other activity in which participation by such persons is disproportionately low. Appeal Decision 6010490 4 20. The specific accommodation requirements of the Appellants son are not stated, although the provision of space, flexibility and opportunities for a part independent and part communal living environment for him is identified. In favour of the proposal, I attach significant weight to these needs. 21. The findings on the first main issue relate to the impact of the proposal on the character and appearance of the street scene. The proposal would almost double the floor area of the dwelling, and the additional accommodation would result in significant enlargements in both the height and bulk of the dwelling above ground floor level. Little evidence has been submitted to demonstrate that the nature and amount of accommodation proposed is reasonably necessary to meet the appellants son’s needs. 22. Overall, when assessed in accordance with CLP Policies 1, 2 & 12, DPD Policy C1 (7), NNP Policies G2, D1 & H1 and paragraph 135 & 139 of the Framework, I find that the personal considerations advanced in favour of the proposed development do not outweigh the harm that the proposed scheme would result in. The interference of the Appellants and their son’s family’s rights under Article 8 of the ECHR would be both proportionate and justified. Other matters 23. With the proposal the property would remain as a single detached dwelling house. Accordingly, notwithstanding the arrangement of the accommodation, I agree with the council that there are no concerns regarding noise and disturbance. 24. Due to its elevated position, proximity and height, the proposed extension would be clearly visible from the rear garden of 18 Praze Road (No.18). However, it would broadly align with the dwelling at No.18 and the juxtaposition between the two dwellings would be similar to many estate dwellings. I acknowledge that it would result in some loss of daylight and sunlight within the adjacent rear conservatory at No.18. Notwithstanding this, the dwelling at No.18 has a wide westerly facing rear garden and both the garden and the rear facing rooms would continue to receive good levels of daylight and sunlight. 25. The cheeks on either side of the proposed first floor terraces would restrict over- looking from the first floor rooms and terraces. Despite this there would be glimpses of part of the rear garden at No.18 over the tall boundary hedge between the two properties. Views of the existing sitting out areas to the rear of the dwelling at No.18 and at the bottom of its rear garden would be screened by the cheeks to the terraces and the existing boundary hedge. Irrespective of this, the proposal would result in a sense of being over-looked, particularly due to the use of the first floor for day to day living accommodation. 26. The proposal also includes a first floor corner window at the front of the appeal dwelling which would serve the proposed lounge. This window would facilitate direct views towards the front entrance and driveway to No.18, resulting in both actual and perceived over-looking. This is something that could be satisfactorily dealt with by a condition which requires the window to be obscure glazed and have restricted opening. 27. The side elevation of the proposed first floor extension would be sited directly opposite and approximately 14 metres from the rear elevation of the dwelling at Appeal Decision 6010490 5 No.86. It would add to the sense of enclosure in the outlook from the ground floor rear facing windows and rear garden at No.86, although the impact would be limited by the lower ground level of the appeal dwelling. As the appeal dwelling sits to the north of No.86 it would not result in a noticeable loss of daylight or sunlight. Due to the juxtaposition and distance between the dwelling at No.86 and the closest proposed first floor terrace any views towards the rear facing windows at No.86 would be at an oblique angle. There would be more open views into the western section of the rear garden at No.86 although they would be partially screened by existing boundary planting. 28. For these reasons, although not significant the impact of the proposal on the outlook from and privacy within the properties at No.18 and No.86 add to the negative impact of the proposal. However, due to the modest level of harm caused it would not amount to a reason for dismissing this appeal. 29. The dwelling at 84 Bonython Road (No.84), sits at a higher level and at an oblique angle to the appeal dwelling. The garden at No.84 similarly sits at a higher level and is some 19 metres from the appeal dwelling. There is also mature planting close to the boundaries between the two properties. As a result of of these factors the proposal would not result in a material loss of privacy or have an overbearing impact on the outlook from that property. 30. Whilst I note the concerns expressed regarding a demand for bungalows, no policies that seek to retain bungalows to meet any such need have been brought to my attention. Property values are not a planning matter. Conclusion 31. Having regard to my conclusions on the main issues and all other matters raised the appeal is dismissed. Elizabeth Lawrence INSPECTOR
Expert Representation

Don't leave your appeal to chance.

Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.

Get Free Review How it works →