Conversion of garage to provide habitable space, demolition of the outbuilding to the rear and reconstruction, first floor side extension, new entrance porch and extension to the front elevation at ground floor
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Extensions
Character & Appearance
Conversion/Use
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 3 July 2026
by John D Allan BA(Hons) BTP MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 13 July 2026
Appeal Ref: 6010383
93 Hundred Acres Lane, Amersham, Buckinghamshire, HP7 9BP
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 (as amended)
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr Walker against the decision of Buckinghamshire Council.
• The application Ref is PL/25/6320/FA.
• The development proposed is the conversion of garage to provide habitable space, demolition of the
outbuilding to the rear and reconstruction, first floor side extension, new entrance porch and
extension to the front elevation at ground floor.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issue
2. The main issue is the effect of the proposal upon the character and appearance of
the area.
Reasons
3. The appeal relates to a two-storey, semi-detached dwelling set within a short
stretch of similar style and aged properties to the west side of Hundred Acres Lane
and within a wider residential neighbourhood. North of the appeal site, Hundred
Acres Lane comprises mostly similar aged red brick, two-storey semi-detached
homes with a mix of dual pitched and hipped roofs. South of the appeal site, the
character of the road shifts to predominantly detached homes. The proposal
includes conversion of an original attached side garage into living accommodation
with a first-floor side extension over and a single-storey lean-to projection across
the full frontage width of the plot.
4. The Council’s Residential Extensions and Householder Development
Supplementary Planning Document (SPD) was adopted in September 2013 and
provides general design principles and specific guidance for householders in order
to deliver high quality and well-designed development that makes a positive
contribution to its surroundings. In relation to two-storey side extensions, at
paragraph 34, the SPD advises, amongst other things, that they should be
designed to have regard to gaps and spaces between existing buildings in order to
respect the existing pattern of development. It specifically advises that where
buildings are in a definable visual row, the first-floor of an extension should be set
in from the boundary to prevent visual coalescing between buildings or an
uncharacteristic terracing effect.
Appeal Decision 6010383
2
5. The appeal property is one half of three semi-detached pairs (Nos 91-101 odd)
which form an obvious group of similar properties in a row between the junction
with Highmoor to the north and No 103 to the south, a detached property on the
cusp of where the character of Hundred Acres Lane noticeably shifts. These
properties (with the exception of No 91 on the corner) would have originally been
built with single-storey side attached garages up to each of their side boundaries or
else with a driveway leading to a detached garage in a recessed position. This
arrangement remains to be the case for all except No 97, which has a two-storey
side addition up to the side boundary with No 99.
6. I have not been provided with the planning history for the extension to No 97 and
there is no evidence to suggest that it post-dates the SPD. Neither do I have any
planning history for other first-floor side additions I saw along Hundred Acres Lane,
which are few and far between, including at No 70 opposite the appeal site, where
otherwise the overall majority of properties retain their original space to their side
boundary at first-floor level. As a consequence, most semi-detached pairs,
including importantly those at Nos 91-101, remain separate and visually
distinguished from each other, due largely to the retained space between them at
first-floor level. This imparts a clearly perceived and pleasing rhythm to the street
scene. Those that have extended at first-floor level are by far a minority. They have
not fundamentally changed the local development pattern but demonstrate to me
the disruption that can be caused to the harmony of the street scene by such
additions.
7. The appeal proposal would project the form of No 93 sideways at first-floor up to
the shared common boundary with No 95. Despite a minor recess behind the
dwelling’s front elevation, the side extension would fill the gap to the boundary at
this level. Whilst it would replicate the extension at No 97, it would represent
exactly the form of development the most up-to-date SPD specifically advises
against, and one which would significantly erode the space between the adjoining
semi-detached pairs along this stretch of Hundred Acres Lane.
8. I acknowledge that No 95 is unextended to the side, and that the appeal proposal
would not result in any direct coalescence with this property. Nevertheless, it would
contribute to a possible terracing effect should a similar proposal come forward in
the future for the neighbouring dwelling. I note the appellant’s argument that each
proposal must fall to be considered on its own merits, but conversely, like-for-like
schemes should reasonably be considered in a consistent manner. To deny the
occupiers of No 95 the ability to extend in an equivalent manner at some point in
the future would be unreasonable and difficult for the local planning authority to
resist.
9. The appellant has directed me to other side extensions elsewhere in the locality,
specifically two cases at Nos 18 and 20 Sheepfold Lane. In the case at No 18,
planning permission (Ref CH/2014/0806/FA) was granted post-adoption of the SPD
for development described as ‘part two storey, part single storey rear/side/front
extension incorporating garage and demolition of detached garage’. In the case at
No 20, planning permission (Ref CH/2017/1387/FA) was granted in 2017 for
development described as ‘Two storey side, single storey rear extensions and
single storey front porch extension’. In both instances the Council’s officer’s report
recognised the staggered relationship between neighbouring dwellings sufficient to
off-set concern relating to the extensions in each case reaching up to their
Appeal Decision 6010383
3
respective plots’ side boundaries. Despite the appellant arguing that similar
circumstances exist between Nos 93 and 95 in this case, I could detect no stagger
to the building lines of these neighbouring properties that was obvious or which
would mitigate any potential for harm. Neither the circumstances at Sheepfold
Lane, nor any other examples by way of photographs that have been presented to
me, draw any reasonable comparison with the appeal proposal.
10. Overall, I find that due to its siting up to the boundary with No 95, the proposed
first-floor side extension would be harmful to the character and appearance of the
street scene. As such, it would conflict with saved Policies GC1, H13, H15 and H16
of the Chiltern District Local Plan 1997 (Including alterations adopted 29 May 2001)
Consolidated September 2007 & November 2011, and Policy CS20 of the Core
Strategy for Chiltern District, adopted 2011. Between them, and amongst other
things, these seek to secure a high standard of design in all development that
respects the setting of buildings and the character and appearance of the street
scene, including specifically extensions to dwellings.
Conclusion
11. For the reasons given above, and notwithstanding the absence of any objections
from any interested parties, the appeal is dismissed.
John D Allan
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.