For the demolition of the existing rear extension and erection of a single-storey rear extension to infill the courtyard

📊

See the success rate & inspector analytics

Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.

Sign Up Free

Technical Issues Heatmap

Residential Amenity
Extensions
Parking Provision

Inspector’s Reasoning

Appeal Decision Site visit made on 8 June 2026 by Kim Vo MPLAN Decision by John Morrison BA (Hons) MSc MRTPI an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State Decision date: 07 July 2026 Appeal Ref: 6008479 51 Dryburgh Road, Wandsworth, London SW15 1BN • The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 (as amended) against a refusal to grant planning permission. • The appeal is made by Ms. Sylvia Westall against the decision of the Council of the London Borough of Wandsworth. • The application Ref is 2026/0180. • The development proposed is for the demolition of the existing rear extension and erection of a single-storey rear extension to infill the courtyard. Decision 1. The appeal is dismissed. Appeal Procedure 2. The site visit was undertaken by a representative of the Inspector whose recommendation is set out below and to which the Inspector has had regard before deciding the appeal. Preliminary Matters and Main Issue 3. Notwithstanding the above description of development, which is taken from the application form, the plans and accompanying details include a replacement front boundary wall and driveway gate at an increased height. The Council assessed the proposal on this basis, and I agree with their conclusion that the boundary works raise no concerns. My recommendation therefore focuses on the proposed rear extension. The main issue in regard to which is whether the proposal would provide appropriate living conditions for its occupiers, with specific regard to outdoor amenity space. Reasons for the Recommendation 4. The appeal relates to a two storey detached dwelling, with an existing single storey rear extension, in a residential area. Due to the infill nature of the dwelling on the plot, it has a unique layout where its rear decked courtyard with varying raised levels, is of a small size, that is fully enclosed by the rear wall of the main dwelling, existing single storey extensions and a high boundary wall. There is also a narrow gap to one side, as well as a space to the front. 5. The proposal would extend across the entire courtyard, resulting in its complete loss by reason of the extension’s size and position. Whilst the courtyard is small and the appellant considers it to have limited functionality, it still represents the only private rear external area serving the dwelling and thus retains a degree of amenity value. Its limitations, arising due to its reduction following the addition of the kitchen Appeal Decision 6008479 2 extension, do not justify its total loss, particularly given that patterns of use, personal circumstances, and ownership of the land can change, whereas the loss of this space would be permanent. 6. The space to the front of the dwelling contained domestic garden paraphernalia in it at the time of my site visit. Whilst this is a reasonably sized area, it is accessed by a drop kerb, entrance gates and is a large area of block paving. It therefore strikes me as more a driveway and off-street parking. I am acutely aware of the locality being a controlled parking zone and the dwelling would otherwise have no off-street parking if this area was given over as garden space. I have no data pertaining to on-street parking capacity in what is an otherwise densely populated borough of the capital. I cannot be satisfied therefore that relying on on-street parking for the house solely would be appropriate and therefore the scheme not giving rise to harms in other respects. 7. I would also question the usefulness of the space as a private garden given it would be on the public facing side of the dwelling. In these circumstances, and having regard to the above, the retention of the courtyard is important in providing a dedicated and reliable private external amenity space. 8. Planning approval ref: 2022/1644 for a proposed replacement two storey dwelling at the appeal site had included an external first floor rear terrace. The committee report for this permission acknowledged that this would have provided a higher standard of amenity than the courtyard, and I do not dispute the appellant’s view that the space is of limited quality and has its constraints. Even so, it is of an adequate condition and remains as a usable area, where one could sit out. That approved scheme is also not sufficiently comparable, as it related to a fundamentally different proposal for a replacement dwelling. 9. The courtyard is enclosed and the outlook from it restricted. However, it is open to the sky and is primarily bordered by single storey structures and a boundary wall, with the taller main elevations of the appeal property and Numbers 53 and 49 Dryburgh Road (Nos. 53 and 49) positioned further away. As a result, the space receives a reasonable level of daylight and natural ventilation. The openness above also prevents it from feeling entirely boxed in and allows for upward outlooks. Moreover, its enclosed nature offers a high level of privacy, contributing to a sense of seclusion within the space. 10. Whilst the timber decking is evidently in a damp condition, I see no reason why it could not be removed and replaced with an alternative surface or indeed done away with completely. Its removal would also improve accessibility by eliminating the need to step up directly from the kitchen onto the decking, thereby providing a more level and convenient transition. 11. The Housing Supplementary Planning Document 2016 (SPD) refers to minimum garden space standards set out in Policy DMH7 of The Development Management Policies Document 2016 (DMPD), requiring 10 square metres (sqm) for 1 and 2 bedroom dwellings and 15sqm for 3 or more bedroom dwellings. The DMPD has since been replaced with the Wandsworth Local Plan 2023 (LP) and the Council has referred to Policy LP27 of it, which specifies the same standards. As detailed in part 2.30 of the SPD, usable, private outdoor amenity space does not include any front gardens or parking areas. Appeal Decision 6008479 3 12. The appellant refers to Policy D6 of the London Plan, which sets a minimum of 5sqm of private outdoor space for 1-2 person dwellings, with an additional 1 sqm per extra occupant. On this basis, the appeal property, which is currently occupied by four people, would require 7sqm of private outdoor space, which the proposal would meet. However, Policy D6 makes clear that this standard applies only in the absence of higher local standards. In this case, Policy LP27 establishes a higher requirement, and is therefore the more relevant benchmark. 13. The courtyard, at the appellant’s measurement of 7.9sqm, currently falls below the 10sqm guidance for the existing two bedroom dwelling. It would not provide any rear garden space at all for the three bedroom dwelling to be created, which would require at least 15sqm. However, the Council refers to Policy LP27 applying to new dwellings and is therefore, not directly applicable in this case, and the SPD is guidance only. Nonetheless, it provides a useful starting point for assessing adequate amenity space. As the courtyard falls well below the suggested standard, this only serves to emphasise the value of the limited private outdoor space that does exist. Its small size also does not render it as a completely redundant space incapable of any use. 14. With the above in mind, the proposal would fail to provide appropriate living conditions for the occupiers of the appeal property. It would therefore be contrary to Policy LP5 of the LP and the SPD. Together, and amongst other things, this policy and guidance seek to ensure a substantial depth of the original rear garden remains free of buildings and structures, and that the nature and scale of amenity space is appropriate to the location of the development. Other Matters 15. Amended plans have been submitted with the appeal, proposing a raised terrace above the rear extension, with a privacy screen and balustrade, together with a landscape scheme for an upgraded front and side garden. Conditions have also been suggested by the appellant to secure the raised terrace and for the submission of a detailed landscape scheme. However, the appeal process should not be used to evolve a scheme and what is considered at appeal should be the same as was by the Council and interested parties at application stage. These amendments are also significantly different to the plans the Council made its decision on, and to take them into account would be procedurally unfair, as those entitled to be consulted have had no opportunity to comment. 16. Even if I were to take them into account, they may introduce additional concerns, for example, upon the living conditions of the occupiers of Nos. 49 and 53, as the raised terrace could increase the potential for overlooking and loss of privacy to neighbouring rear gardens and first floor windows. The raised terrace area was also not originally applied for, would require planning permission on its own right and its addition by way of a condition would be inappropriate. It does not, therefore, represent a fallback position. Moreover, the proposed landscaping to the front would not justify the appeal scheme, especially as the identified harm stems from the loss of the courtyard. 17. The amendment for the raised terrace is based on the first floor rear terrace approved under planning application ref: 2022/1644. However, that scheme is not sufficiently comparable. It related to a more enclosed terrace integrated within the building envelope of a replacement dwelling. By contrast, the amendment for the Appeal Decision 6008479 4 raised terrace would be more open and visible to the surrounding neighbours. The permission for that scheme also appears to have now lapsed. 18. There is no sufficiently compelling evidence to demonstrate that the appellant’s household needs for additional and improved internal space cannot be met through alternative measures, which might have a lesser impact than the appeal scheme. I remain to be convinced that the proposal is the only way to achieve the outcome the appellant desires. 19. The appellant states they no longer wish to implement planning approval ref. 2025/2436 for the erection of a roof extension to create an additional floor of accommodation at second floor, including the formation of a roof terrace to the front elevation. They would be willing to accept a condition preventing its concurrent implementation with the appeal scheme, if allowed. However, my concerns relate to the proposed rear extension only, with the Council expressing no issues regarding this approved scheme. Moreover, whilst the appellant is not able to implement this permission as a result of costs and disruption, it nonetheless indicates that an alternative outcome, which would retain the courtyard, could still be achieved. Conclusion and Recommendation 20. For the reasons given above, the proposal would conflict with the development plan and the material considerations do not indicate a decision should be made other than in accordance therewith. I therefore recommend the appeal is dismissed.  Kim Vo APPEAL PLANNING OFFICER Inspector’s Decision 21. I have considered all the submitted evidence and my representative’s report and on that basis the appeal is dismissed. John Morrison INSPECTOR
Expert Representation

Don't leave your appeal to chance.

Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.

Get Free Review How it works →