Ground Floor Extension and Re-provision of Private External Amenity Space
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Residential Amenity
Character & Appearance
Fallback Position
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 9 June 2026
by J Davis BSc (Hons) MSc MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date:15 June 2026
Appeal Ref: 6007240
1 Kelvedon Mews, Islington, London, N1 3FW
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 (as amended)
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr & Mrs Marine & Jean-Baptiste Gicquel against the decision of the Council
of the London Borough of Islington.
• The application Ref is P2026/0181/FUL.
• The development proposed is described as Ground Floor Extension and Re-provision of Private
External Amenity Space.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issues
2. The main issues are:
• the effect of the proposal on the character and appearance of Kelvedon
Mews;
• the effect of the proposal on the living conditions of the occupiers of Warley
House with particular reference to privacy;
• the effect of the proposal on the living conditions of current and future
occupiers of the appeal property with reference to outdoor amenity space.
Reasons
Character and appearance
3. The appeal concerns a two storey, end of terrace dwelling which forms part of a
modern mews development which I am informed was approved in 2015 as part of a
regeneration project for the Dover Court Estate. The terrace is of a contemporary
design, with brick ground floor elevations and dark zinc clad roofs. The terrace is
uniform in appearance and displays a strong sense of architectural rhythm, with
regular ground floor voids forming front courtyard amenity space, projecting window
surrounds and gaps at first floor level between adjoining properties.
4. The proposed extension would have a depth of about 2m and would infill part of the
existing front courtyard. It is designed with a flat roof to be used as a roof terrace,
with a front brick parapet of 1.62m, with an additional glass balustrade of 0.25m
Appeal Decision 6007240
2
above. A proposed 0.55m high obscure glass screen would be attached to the rear
parapet however this would not be visible from the Kelvedon Mews frontage.
5. The proposed front parapet would be of the same design, height and appearance
as the existing brick parapet but would effectively be positioned 2m further forward.
The proposed infill extension and associated parapet would retain a set back from
the main front elevation by about 1.2m, allowing the front courtyard wall and gates
to be retained.
6. Given the location of the appeal property at the end of the terrace, the visual effect
of the proposal on the architectural rhythm of the mews would be limited. The
proposed ground floor extension and associated parapet would reflect the original
design of the terrace and would be subservient in appearance due to its limited
scale and setback from the frontage. The proposed glass balustrade would be
transparent and lightweight in appearance and would not have any significant effect
on the visual appearance of the dwelling or wider terrace. Other than for the glass
balustrade, the proposal would be contained beneath the existing roofline and the
first-floor void, which is an important element establishing the rhythm of the mews,
would be preserved. Consequently, I am satisfied that the overall appearance,
symmetry and overall legibility of Kelvedon Mews would be respected and
preserved.
7. I therefore conclude on this issue that the proposal would not have a harmful effect
on the character and appearance of Kelvedon Mews. Thus, in this regard, the
proposal would comply with Policy D4 of the London Plan (2021) (LP) and Policy
PLAN1 of the Islington Local Plan Strategic and Development Management
Policies (2023) (SDMP). Together these policies require development to be of a
high quality and to deliver good design and make a positive contribution to local
character, legibility and distinctiveness.
Living conditions of the occupiers of Warley House
8. The original design of the Kelvedon Mews development ensures that no habitable
room windows or balconies face directly towards Warley House which is a large
flatted development immediately to the north of the site. The southern elevation of
Warley House faces the appeal property in close proximity and contains multiple
habitable room windows and balconies, with the ground floor units also benefitting
from rear gardens.
9. In assessing the proposal, the officer report refers to paragraph 1.67 of the SDMP
which states that a key aspect of contextual design is ensuring a minimum distance
of 18 metres between windows of habitable rooms, to protect privacy for residential
developments and existing residential properties. I acknowledge that this distance
specifically applies to the distance between habitable rooms and therefore is not
directly applicable to the appeal proposal. Nevertheless, the main text of Policy
PLAN1 of the SDMP to which paragraph 1.67 refers, requires that a good level of
amenity must be provided, including considerations such as overlooking and
privacy.
10. The existing rooflight would provide a barrier to accessing the edge of the parapet
and an obscured glass balustrade of 0.55m in height would be attached to the
existing rear parapet wall. These measures would help to restrict the ability of users
of the proposed roof terrace to look down into the rear gardens of Warley House.
However, as observed on my site visit, there would be an uninterrupted direct line
Appeal Decision 6007240
3
of sight from anyone stood on the roof terrace across to the upper-level windows
and balconies of Warley House. At a distance of only around 10 metres, the use of
the proposed roof terrace would result in a loss of privacy to occupiers of Warley
House, resulting in significant harm to their living conditions.
11. The appellants state that there is no planning condition, restriction or legal
impediment preventing the existing flat roof from being used as amenity space and
consider this to be a fallback position. However, the existing flat roof area is very
limited in its extent and is mostly taken up by the roof light. There is currently no
access onto the flat roof area which in my judgment would be difficult to access
from any existing openings and access via a ladder would involve climbing over the
existing parapet. Therefore, in my opinion the existing flat roof is unlikely to be used
frequently or for the same purposes as the proposed larger roof terrace. In these
circumstances, I do not consider a viable fallback position to exist. Furthermore,
given the access and size constraints of the existing flat roof and consequently its
likely infrequent use, mutual visibility between occupiers in Warley House and the
occupants of the appeal site would be highly likely to be worsened as a result of the
proposal.
12. I acknowledge that Warley House lies to the north of the appeal site and that users
seated on the roof terrace may be more likely to be orientated to face south.
However, the roof terrace would have the potential to be used for various forms of
social gatherings, where the privacy of the occupiers of Warley House would not be
guaranteed.
13. I also place limited weight on the appeal decision1 referred to by the appellant as it
does not appear to be directly comparable to the appeal proposal and that scheme
was clearly assessed by the Inspector according to the facts and circumstances
that related specifically to that particular case. In any event, I am required to
determine the appeal proposal on is own merits.
14. The appellant also provided an additional supporting document which refers to
other schemes in Islington, at Moray Mews and Block D of Dover Court Estate
redevelopment. Whilst noted, the layout of those developments and the spatial
separation distances involved, do not appear to me to be directly comparable to the
appeal scheme before me.
15. I therefore conclude that the proposed development would have a harmful effect on
the living conditions of the occupiers of Warley House with particular reference to
privacy. The proposed development is therefore contrary to Policy PLAN1 of the
SDMP insofar as it requires a good level of amenity to be provided.
Living conditions of current and future occupiers of the appeal property with reference
to outdoor amenity space
16. As with other dwellings in Kelvedon Mews, the appeal property benefits from a front
courtyard. Whilst the courtyard is relatively small at around 8.2sqm and is enclosed
on all sides, the slatted gate and the lattice section of brickwork on the front, south
facing elevation, allow light to penetrate the space. Whilst pedestrians and others
using Kelvedon Mews may be able to glimpse through the gate and open brick
work, the courtyard is nonetheless relatively private. I also observed at my site visit
that usage of Kelvedon Mews by pedestrians and cyclists was limited although I
1 Appeal ref: APP/K5600/W/23/3322802
Appeal Decision 6007240
4
appreciate that this might not always be the case during other times of the day.
However, having regard to all of the above considerations, I find that the existing
courtyard offers a good standard of privacy and outdoor amenity.
17. The proposed amount of usable amenity space on the roof terrace would broadly
equate in size to the existing courtyard. I acknowledge the advantages of the
proposal in that the terrace would receive more direct sunlight and would offer a
more open outlook compared with the existing courtyard.
18. However, given the lack of any meaningful screen to the rear, users of the
proposed roof terrace would be directly overlooked by occupiers of Warley House,
particularly from the habitable room windows and balconies at first floor level and
above. Taking into account the closeness of these windows and balconies and their
likely frequent usage, the level of overlooking that would be likely to occur would
result in the proposed roof terrace offering a poor level of privacy. Given the
difficulty accessing the existing flat roof area, I cannot accept that this is a situation
that already exists to any great extent and therefore the fallback position advanced
by the appellant does not, in my opinion, exist.
19. Whilst the current occupiers may be satisfied with the standard of amenity the
proposal would offer, as a matter of judgment, I consider that the roof terrace would
offer an inferior standard of amenity overall compared to the existing courtyard, due
to a lack of privacy. This leads me to conclude that the proposal would have a
harmful effect on the living conditions of existing and future occupiers of the
dwelling, with particular reference to outdoor amenity space.
20. The proposal is therefore contrary to Policy H5 of the SDMP. Amongst other things,
this policy requires residential development to provide good quality outdoor space
to ensure a good level of amenity with regard to daylight, sunlight, noise, enclosure,
overlooking, privacy and security. Where roofs are to be utilised, Policy H5 states
that proposals must demonstrate there are no adverse effects relating to noise,
overlooking and privacy of future residential occupiers as well as existing residents
adjacent to the site.
Conclusion
21. For the above reasons, and having regard to all other matters raised, I conclude
that the appeal should be dismissed.
J Davis
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.