Rebuild brick piers each side of driveway. New timber gate
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Heritage & Conservation
Highways & Transport
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
https://www.gov.uk/planning -inspectorate
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 16 June 2026
by Edward Dade BA (Hons) MSc MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 26th June 2026
Appeal Ref: 6006235
12 Manor House, Yarmouth Road, Thorpe St Andrew, Norfolk NR7 0EF
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 (as amended)
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr Jeremy Clarke against the decision of the Broads Authority.
• The application Ref is BA/2025/0313/HOUSEH.
• The development proposed is rebuild brick piers each side of driveway. New timber gate.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issues
2. The main issue in this appeal is the effect of the proposal on highway safety.
Reasons
3. The appeal property is a dwelling served by an existing, open and ungated
driveway access to the A1242 Yarmouth Road. Photographs from the late 19 th
century and from 1955 show the appeal site was formerly served by a gated
entrance, positioned flush with the highway boundary until at least the 1980s.
Therefore, whilst historically the access was gated, in recent decades it has been
open to the highway.
4. The proposal would not alter the position, width or geometry of the access, and the
proposed siting of the brick piers and gate would reflect the position of the historic
gate and would abut the back of the pavement. However, entrance gates are not a
characteristic feature of the street scene, since most of the accesses along
Yarmouth Road either do not have a gate or gates are set back from the highway.
5. There is no record of any incident relating to the former gates and t he appellant
suggests the strategic function of Yarmouth Road has evolved since the opening
of the Norwich Southern Bypass in 1992. However, Yarmouth Road is an urban
route toward Norwich’s city centre which Norfolk County Council, the local highway
authority (LHA), classifies as a principal road within its route hierarchy, linking
primary destinations and carrying high traffic volumes.
6. Since the proposed gate would sit flush with the pavement, there would be no
place of refuge for a vehicle to wait off the public highway. Therefore, the proposal
would require vehicles to stop in the highway while the gates are operated.
7. The carriageway of Yarmouth Road is relatively narrow. A vehicle waiting in the
carriageway would cause other vehicles to either stop or move into the opposite
Appeal Decision 6006235
https://www.gov.uk/planning -inspectorate 2
lane and into the path of oncoming vehicles. Therefore, the proposal would
obstruct the free flow of vehicular traffi c.
8. Similarly, the pavement is narrow, and a vehicle stopped on the pavement
awaiting the operation of the gates would obstruct and inconvenience pedestrians.
9. As a busy urban route, the flow of traffic would be routinely interrupted, such as
from buses serving bus stops, pedestrians crossing the street, vehicles slowing to
enter or egress from accesses and side roads or to pass cyclists. In addition,
Yarmouth Road is served by traffic calming measures. However, this does not
justify development that would encourage highway users to take risky overtaking
manoeuvres of stopped vehicles.
10. On-street parking is not prohibited in the vicinity of the appeal site. However, the
carriageway width and a bend in the road inhibits long distance visibility.
Therefore, despite the absence of parking controls, it does not automatically follow
that a vehicle stopped in the carriageway is without risk to highway safety.
11. The appellant suggests the proposed gate would be electronically operated,
capable of advance activation and rapid opening, and would operate on a timed or
dawn-to-dusk basis, remaining open during the day and closing primarily at night.
However, in winter months peak traffic may occur after dark, and therefore I
cannot be certain that the gate would only be operated at times of reduced tra ffic
volume. Moreover, conditions relating to the time periods at which the gate may
remain open or closed, or the speed of the gate’s mechanical operation could not
be reasonably enforced for the lifetime of the development.
12. The appellant indicates that permission has been granted for substantial
residential development which would generate daily vehicle movements onto
Yarmouth Road. A new apartment block has been constructed opposite the site
which appears to have an ungated access, and I have been provided no evidence
to suggest the development would harm highway safety.
13. The appellant has drawn my attention to other appeal decisions for driveway gates
close to the highway. However, I have not been provided substantive details of the
characteristics of the related highways, and therefore I cannot be certain the
highway conditions in the cited appeal decisions are comparable to the proposal.
14. The appeal property is served by an existing vehicular access which would
continue to be lawfully used by vehicles irrespective of my dismissal of the appeal.
In addition, recent renovation works to the appeal property amalgamated two
former dwellings into one, thereby reducing the intensity of the access to serve a
single dwelling. However, the open access to the site is of lesser risk to highway
safety than the proposed gates which would require vehicles to stop in the
highway. Therefore, the proposal would not be justified by the presence of the
existing ungated access.
15. The LHA is a statutory consultee with an advisory role in the decision-making
process, and therefore I have ha d regard to the advice of the LHA in my decision.
For the reasons set out above, the proposal would harm highway safety.
16. The proposal would therefore conflict with Policy DM23 of the Broads Local Plan
which requires proposals be assessed in terms of their impact upon the highway
network, including in respect of highway safety.
Appeal Decision 6006235
https://www.gov.uk/planning -inspectorate 3
Other Matters
Historic environment
17. Sections 66(1) and 72(1) of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation
Areas) Act 1990 require I have special regard to the desirability of preserving listed
buildings or their settings or any features of special architectural or historic interest
which they possess, and require I pay special attention to the desirability of
preserving or enhancing the character or appearance of th e conservation area.
18. The appeal site contains Grade II listed building, Manor House and annexe which
dates from the m id-17th century with later additions and alterations, constructed of
brick with plain tiled, gabled roof with ridge stacks at intervals, and large external
stepped chimney stack.
19. The appeal property is attached to neighbouring Grade II* listed building, Walpole
House, which dates from the 17 th century, with a slate roof and of red and burnt
brick, and colour washed to the north, with quoins at the corners. Grade II listed
Manor Cottage abuts the site, and is a house constructed in approximately 1840 of
painted brick with two sash windows and a hipped, black glazed pantile roof. It has
two storeys, but one to north owing to slope of ground. The significance of the
listed buildings is derived from their special architectural and historic interest.
20. The site is within the Thorpe St Andrew Conservation Area (CA) which
encompasses the area of a historic settlement which stretches along Yarmouth
Road. The CA’s character is defined by its concentration of historic buildings and
relationship with the river.
21. No historic fabric would be lost through implementation of the proposal. The
proposed piers and gate would reflect the historic siting of the former gate and
would be constructed of brick and timber, and subject to approval of materials,
would be capable of achieving an appearance which is sensitive and compatible
with surrounding heritage assets.
22. The effect of the proposal on the significance of the listed buildings and character
and appearance of the area is not in dispute between the main parties, and I have
identified no conflict myself. I have had regard to the advice of the Authority’s
Historic Environment Manager who considers the proposed works are appropriate
and in keeping with the character of the area and the setting of the designated
heritage assets and raises no objection from a heritage or design perspective. In
addition, a separate Listed Building Consent (LBC) application has been approved
by the Authority and relates solely to the effect of the works on the special
architectural and historic interest of the listed buildings, their setting, and the
character and appearance of the CA.
23. For these reasons, I am satisfied the proposal would comply with the s66(1) and
s72(1) and would preserve the listed buildings and the character and appearance
of the CA.
Crime and antisocial behaviour (ASB)
24. The appellant asserts the proposal is required to protect the property from crime
and ASB, with instances of drug dealing, urination and defecation, and a vehicle
break-in having occurred on the site. The appellant asserts the proposed siting of
the gate flush with the highway boundary would be justified since the inclusion of
Appeal Decision 6006235
https://www.gov.uk/planning -inspectorate 4
any setback from the highway edge would leave a concealed space with
opportunity for crime and ASB to occur.
25. Section 17 of the Crime and Disorder Act 1998 places a statutory duty on decision
makers to consider crime prevention. This duty is embedded in paragraphs 96 and
135 of the National Planning Policy Framework which require development be safe
and that crime and disorder and fear of crime do not undermine quality of life .
26. The appellant confirms the presence of CCTV on the site and police involvement
in previous crime and ASB. However, the proposal does not demonstrate that all
alternative preventative measures have been exhausted by the relevant agencies.
Whilst I am satisfied the proposal would represent a public benefit through
reducing opportunity for crime and ASB by restricting access to the site, this would
not outweigh the harm to highway safety for users of a principal A-road.
Best interests of the child
27. A neighbouring property has an access door which opens directly onto the
driveway and is occupied by a young family. The appellant asserts the gate would
reduce the risk of a child accessing the highway.
28. Article 3(1) of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child provides
that in all actions concerning children undertaken by public bodies, the best
interests of the child shall be a primary consideration. Even if I were to consider
enclosure of the site necessary to ensure the safety of children, this would not in
itself justify the siting of the gate in the proposed location since the LHA suggest it
would support a gate set back from the highway . Therefore, the evidence before
me does not suggest that dismissal of the appeal would have an adverse impact
on children, and such concerns would not justify the highway safety risk.
Conclusion
29. The proposal would conflict with the development plan as a whole and there are no
other considerations which outweigh this finding. Therefore, for the reasons given
the appeal should be dismissed.
Edward Dade
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.