Extensions and alterations to dwelling
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Green Belt Policy
Policy Weight
Trees & Landscape
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 8 April 2026 by F Bradford BA (Hons) MRTPI
Decision by John Morrison BA (Hons) MSc MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 17 July 2026
Appeal Ref: 6005883
Old Tallows, Orestan Lane, Effingham, Surrey KT24 5SN
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 (as amended)
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Bramwell against the decision of Guildford Borough Council.
• The application Ref is 25/P/01315.
• The development proposed is extensions and alterations to dwelling.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Appeal Procedure and Preliminary Matters
2. The site visit was undertaken by a representative of the Inspector whose
recommendation is set out below and to which the Inspector has had regard before
deciding the appeal scheme. The description of development in regard to which as
it is shown above is from the application form. The decision notice refers to the
works as a two storey rear extension. This is a more precise identification of the
proposals.
3. There is a discrepancy between the Site and Location Plans (1067-BP-101 Rev. 2
and 1068-LP-100 Rev. 2) with regard to the positioning of the outbuildings on the
site. On my site visit, I saw that the configuration depicted by the Location Plan is
that truest to the conditions thereon. I have proceeded on this basis.
Main Issues
4. The main issues are a) whether the proposal would be inappropriate development
in the Green Belt; b) its effect on the openness of the Green Belt; c) whether it
would be acceptable with regard to ground conditions and pollution; and d) whether
any harm by reason of inappropriateness, and any other harm, would be clearly
outweighed by other considerations, so as to amount to the very special
circumstances required to justify the proposal.
Reasons for the Recommendation
Inappropriate Development
5. The National Planning Policy Framework (the Framework) establishes that
development in the Green Belt is inappropriate unless one of the specified
exceptions applies. The main parties make their cases in respect of paragraph 154
c) of the Framework which specifically allows for the extension or alteration of a
building, provided that it does not result in disproportionate additions over and
Appeal Decision 6005883
2
above the size of the original building. Policy P2 of the Guildford Borough Local
Plan: Strategy and Sites 2015 – 2034 (Local Plan) is consistent with the Framework
in its overall approach to development in the Green Belt. The Green Belt
Supplementary Planning Document (2023) (the SPD) provides guidance thereon.
6. The appeal site formerly hosted a factory building. The dwelling with the associated
stable block as they exist on the appeal site were erected following a planning
permission granted in 1999 (reference 99/P/01527). This approval does not
explicitly refer to the scheme as a replacement building. Indeed, under the current
iteration of the Framework this would not be so since it refers to replacement
buildings having, in the first instance, to be in the same use. This permission
however was not granted under those controls. It comfortably pre dated even the
first iteration of the Framework in 2012.
7. I am unsure as to what was explicitly set out by national Green Belt policy at the
time, but it would not be reasonable to make a judgement on if the existing dwelling
is a replacement or not based on what the national policy position is now. The 1999
scheme was conditioned to ensure the existing buildings were demolished, which
suggests it was at least predicated on something being removed and something
else erected in its place. Notwithstanding the description of development, and in an
ordinary understanding of something being replaced, this would thus fit.
8. For the Framework, the original building for Green Belt purposes is a building as it
existed on 1 July 1948 or, if constructed after then, as it was built originally. Local
Plan Policy P2 sets out similar, explaining (with specific regard to extensions or
alterations) the original building shall mean either the building as it existed on 1 July
1948; or if no building existed on 1 July 1948, then the first building as it was
originally built after this date.
9. The definition of original building for the Framework does not expressly deal with
replacements. It might therefore be reasonable to conclude that the original building
in such a case would be the replacement itself, as originally built, and that should
form the baseline against which subsequent extensions and alterations should be
measured. However, and in this case, the development plan contains more detailed
policies relating to establishing what the original might be. I have set out that there
is no reason to not consider what is currently on site a replacement.
10. The dwelling did not exist in 1948, evidently neither did the factory, which was
erected sometime after when it received planning permission in 1958. It is therefore
the second part of P2 that is relevant. This refers to a situation if no building existed
on 1 July 1948, then the first building as it was originally built after this date. Which
was the factory. I cannot see that the stance of SP2 is inconsistent with the
Framework. It travels in the same direction and simply provides more detail. With
this and the above in mind, I can only conclude that the factory is the original
building. This is not a universal finding, but on the specific merits of the case and
taking into account the primacy of the development plan.
11. In purely floor area (land take) terms, and taking the appellant’s lower figures, the
space taken up by the dwelling, its stable and the proposed extension would be
less than the factory. That said, a judgement of disproportionality may not rest
entirely on land take. Or even floor space which can be repeated over more than
one floor above another. I have no definitive floor space figures, or even volume for
either the dwelling or the factory. Volume may give a clearer picture of the physical
Appeal Decision 6005883
3
presence of built form in its entirety. Even then, a qualitative assessment of the
growth of a building is equally relevant, taking into account the aims of Green Belt
policy to protect openness which is as much concerned with bult form taking up
physical space in the three dimensional sense as it is land in the sprawling sense.
12. In the absence of knowing what the physical presence of the former factory was, in
terms of its own height and bulk/mass/design, I cannot draw a sufficiently accurate
comparison between it and the resulting dwelling at appeal. Particularly given that I
also do not have a clear indication of the volume of what may be later sheds
adjacent the stable block which may or may not include a greenhouse that was
granted planning permission in 2012. Outbuildings can be considered extensions
for the purposes of Green Belt policy, as normal domestic adjuncts depending on
their scale, location and use. So they may need to be taken account of in the
cumulative. As well as not having a clear enough indication of the substance of the
proposals at appeal beyond their land take, which would constitute a lengthy
projection to the building arranged over two storeys with a pitched roof.
13. All matters considered therefore, I cannot be satisfied that the appeal scheme,
including any later extensions/alterations that have gone before and since the
original, would not amount to disproportionate additions over and above the original
building. Such that I cannot be sufficiently certain that the proposals would not be
inappropriate development in the Green Belt, for the purposes of both P2 of the
Local Plan and, by association, the Framework. Inappropriate development is
harmful to the Green Belt by definition.
Openness
14. The fundamental aim of Green Belt policy is to prevent urban sprawl by keeping
land permanently open with the essential characteristics being their openness and
permanence. Openness has both visual and spatial aspects. The latter can be
taken to mean the absence of built form.
15. The appeal site is located behind the frontage developments of Calvert Road and
Orestan Lane and is largely obscured by vegetation and trees from the public
realm. Due to the siting of the proposed development to the rear of the property, it
is unlikely that it would be obvious to the private occupiers of these frontage
developments. However, the proposal would occupy a greater footprint than the
existing dwelling, and for the reasons above, would substantially increase its overall
bulk and mass which, from a spatial perspective, would significantly and
unavoidably reduce the openness of the Green Belt. This harm would be in addition
to that caused by the scheme’s inappropriateness and result in further conflict with
the aforementioned aims of the development plan and the Framework.
Ground Conditions and Pollution
16. The appeal site contains areas known to have been used for the landfill of Class A
(non-putrescible waste) although no Site Risk Assessment (SRA), as required by
Policy P8 of the Local Plan, was submitted within the original application. However,
I am satisfied that in the event this appeal was to succeed this could be secured via
a pre-commencement condition which would allow the Council to review the SRA
and ultimately satisfy the requirements of Policy P8 and the Framework. Taking into
account the scale, nature and location of the proposed works. Amongst other
things, Policy 8 exists to protect human health and the environment and promote
the safe development of contaminated land.
Appeal Decision 6005883
4
Other Considerations
17. I have agreed that the land take of the eventual dwelling for the purposes of this
appeal would be lesser than the factory. This, there is little doubt historically
speaking and in those terms in isolation, fitted with an improvement in the historic
effect of built form on the Green Belt. I have however also set out why the
assessment of these effects, in particular regard to the nature, design, mass and
scale of the proposed works, goes further than the land it would take up.
18. Whilst the transition of the appeal site from an industrial to residential may have
delivered environmental and character benefits to the area, this was achieved
through a previous application. The proposals would not materially further these
existing benefits to the extent that I could afford them any more than limited weight.
Conclusion and Recommendation
19. I cannot be satisfied that the appeal scheme would not be inappropriate
development in the Green Belt. It would reduce its openness. These matters attract
substantial weight. The other considerations would collectively attract limited
weight. Those issues on which I have found no harm would be neutral and not
weigh in favour of the proposals. As such, the potential harms to the Green Belt
would not be clearly outweighed. Consequently, the very special circumstances
necessary to justify the proposed development in this situation do not exist.
20. Since the appeal scheme would conflict with the development plan and material
considerations, including the Framework, do not indicate a decision other than in
accordance, I recommend that the appeal should be dismissed.
F Bradford
APPEAL PLANNING OFFICER
Inspector’s Decision
21. I have considered all the submitted evidence and my representative’s report and on
that basis the appeal is dismissed.
John Morrison
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.