Side crown roof dormer extension with the addition of rooflights to the front, rear and side roof slopes
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Extensions
Character & Appearance
Residential Amenity
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 2 April 2026
by Elizabeth Lawrence BTP MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 13 April 2026
Appeal Ref: 6005472
1 Mossy Vale, Maidenhead, SL6 7RX
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 (as amended)
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr Daniel Cater against the decision of the Council to the Royal Borough of
Windsor and Maidenhead.
• The application Ref is 25/02708.
• The development proposed is described on the application form as the erection of a side crown roof
dormer extension with the addition of rooflights to the front, rear and side roof slopes.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issue
2. The main issue is the effect of the proposal on the character and appearance of the
host dwelling and the surrounding area.
Reasons
3. The appeal property is situated in a mixed residential area that is characterised by
a diverse range of predominantly two and two and half storey detached and semi-
detached houses of various ages and styles. Roof designs vary and include a
combination of hips, barn hips, gables, broken roof lines, and dormer windows.
This together with often generous sized plots and soft landscaping within the front
and rear gardens contributes to the informal and suburban character and
appearance of the locality.
4. The appeal property occupies a prominent position adjacent to the junction of Furze
Platt Road and Mossy Vale. It is one of three traditionally designed modern houses
that front onto Mossy Vale, and its side elevation is set back behind a side garden
that faces Furze Platt Road. The main roof of the appeal dwelling has barn hips to
the front and rear and the lower side wing similarly has a barn hip as well as a cat
slide roof facing Mossy Vale.
4. Elsewhere within Mossy Vale, there are dwellings with front roof projections along
with pitched and flat roofed front and side dormers of various sizes. Typically, they
sit materially lower than the main ridge lines and/or are set in from the sides of the
roof slopes. There are a number of larger rear dormers that project close to the
ridge line, although they are largely hidden from the street scene. As such, their
impact on the character and appearance of the host dwellings is limited from within
the public realm.
Appeal Decision 6005472
2
5. On the opposite side of Furze Platt Road is a row of substantial period houses with
a combination of pitched roof front dormer windows and more modest flat roofed
side dormers. They are set within deep roof slopes which include front gables,
multiple chimneys, and crested ridge lines. These roofs are visually well balanced,
ornate and attractive.
6. The appellant has referred to some recent planning approvals for dormer
extensions within Furze Platt Road, although no details of their siting, size and
design have been provided. In the absence of such details, I am unable to
compare them to the proposed dormer window, although they do demonstrate that,
in principle, dormer extensions are acceptable in the immediate area.
7. Various permitted development rights as set out in the Town and Country Planning
General Permitted Development (England) Order 1995 (As amended) were
removed when the appeal dwelling was permitted in 2011.1 Conditions 12 and 13
were imposed specifically to prevent overlooking and loss of privacy at first floor
level and are not directly relevant to the appeal proposal. Conversely, condition 14
effectively removes permitted development rights relating to any enlargements,
improvements or alterations to the dwellings or the construction of ancillary
outbuildings. The reason for this condition was to protect the amenities of adjacent
occupiers.
8. For this reason, the proposal requires planning permission and needs to be
assessed on its individual merits and in accordance with the prevailing planning
policies, having regard to all other material considerations. This includes the
existence of dormer windows in the local area, the wider availability of permitted
development rights and the reason for imposing condition 14 of the appeal referred
to above.
9. Together and amongst other things, Policy QP3 of the Borough Local Plan 2013 –
2033 (LP) and paragraph 135 of the National Planning Policy Framework 2024 (the
Framework), seek to ensure that new development is of high quality design. It
should respect and enhance the character of the environment paying particular
regard to urban grain, scale, bulk, massing, and materials. New development
should incorporate interesting frontages and design details to provide visual
interest.
10. The Borough Wide Design Guide 2020 (DG) is consistent with this. It explains that
changes to roofscapes can have a detrimental impact on character, especially
when visible from the street scene. DG Principle 10.5 advises that roof alterations
should be sympathetic and subservient to the design of the main building. They
should not undermine the visual amenities of the area. Dormer extensions should
be set back from the sides and ridgeline of the roof and not occupy more than half
the width and depth of the roof slope.
11. The proposed side dormer extension would project close to the main ridge line and
the upper part of the existing front and rear barn hips. Its shallow hipped crown
roof would sit above the ridge line of the side wing and the front and rear barn hip
eaves lines. It would appear disproportionately shallow, poorly proportioned and
disjointed when compared to the existing roof form. Due to their size and projection
beyond the windows in the existing side elevation, the proposed larger outer
1 Appeal reference: APP/T0355/A/11/2152605
Appeal Decision 6005472
3
windows would add to the perceived width and top heavy appearance of the
proposed dormer extension. Finally, due to their proximity to the ridge line and
depth, the cheeks of the dormer extension would appear top heavy and would
materially detract from the proportions of the roof in views from the street scene.
This is notwithstanding the use of slate tiles on the roof and walls of the proposed
dormer extension.
12. I appreciate that the proposed dormer extension would sit behind and be partially
screened by the existing two storey side wing. However, that wing sits at a
materially lower level and its lower eaves heights would emphasise the height of
the proposed dormer extension. Also, as indicated above the proposed dormer
extension would fail to respect or blend in with the character and appearance of the
existing side wing.
13. As a result of these factors, the proposed side dormer extension would materially
and unacceptably harm the character and appearance of the host dwelling and its
surroundings.
14. Conversely, the proposed rooflights are modest in size and form and in themselves
would not have a materially adverse impact on the character and appearance of the
dwelling and its surroundings. Whilst the proposed side facing roof light would face
towards 1a Mossy Vale, it would serve a bathroom and could be obscure glazed
and have restricted opening. This would prevent any loss of privacy for the
occupiers of No.1a and is a matter that could be dealt with by condition.
15. Overall, I find that the harm that would be caused by the proposed dormer
extension would clearly outweigh the absence of harm resulting from the proposed
roof lights; the benefits for the appellant and their family that would result from the
additional accommodation; and the other material considerations referred to in
paragraph 9 of this decision. Further, this harm is not a matter that could be
satisfactorily addressed through the imposition of conditions.
17. I conclude that the proposal would unacceptably harm the character and
appearance of the host dwelling and the surrounding area. Accordingly, it would
conflict with LP Policy QP3, paragraph 135 of the Framework and DG Principle
10.5.
Elizabeth Lawrence
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.