Retention of a caravan port
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Character & Appearance
Fallback Position
Green Belt Policy
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 9 April 2026
by Eleni Marshall BSc (hons) MSc FRICS FAAV MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date:15 April 2026
Appeal Ref: 6004932
21 Chartwell Grove, Mapperley, Nottinghamshire, NG3 5RD
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 against a refusal
to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by J Gell against Gedling Borough Council.
• The application Ref is 2025/0831.
• The development proposed is retention of a caravan port.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issues
2. The main issues are the impact of the proposal upon visual amenity, the character
of the area and the street scene.
Reasons
3. The appeal site is a detached residential dwelling located off Chartwell Grove with
off-street parking to the frontage of the site as well as benefitting from a garage to
the front of (as a projection off) the host dwelling. The appeal seeks permission for
retention of a caravan port which has been constructed to the front of the host
dwelling, adjacent to the existing garage, and which has been constructed in grey
timber with a flat roof at an overall height of in the region of three metres.
4. At the time of my site visit I noted that the area is characterised by garages which
are forward of their host dwellings, however, whilst garages are a characteristic
feature within the street scene, they are generally brick built with materials that are
more closely associated to/resemble their respective dwellings as well as having
pitched/hipped roofs. The flat roof, timber clad, building which is the subject of this
appeal is a direct contrast to other garages within the vicinity, and is not in-keeping
with the general character and appearance of the immediate locality. In addition to
this the appeal proposal would also result in two structures for housing vehicles to
the front of the dwelling which would be uncharacteristic.
5. The garages which serve dwellings within the locality do not appear dominant and
are visually appropriate within the street scene due to their consistent design and
choice of materials. The appeal proposal is a notably incongruous feature to which
is attention is drawn, as an alien feature with the street scene, very shortly after
turning left into Chartwell Grove (the second junction within Chartwell Grove itself,
not the junction with the B684). On this basis, I am of the opinion that the existing
garage structures, which are characteristic of the locality, are visually acceptable
however, the caravan port is not by virtue of its design, positioning and general
incompatibility with the character of the area. In addition to this the caravan port
Appeal Decision 6004932
2
roof exceeds the eave height of the host dwelling’s garage resulting in an awkward
visual contrast when viewed against the gable end of the existing garage.
6. I note from the appellant’s original planning statement, and their grounds of appeal,
that the caravan port has been constructed from timber and painted grey with that
colour bearing resemblance to the colour of the host dwelling’s mock Tudor
frontage. Despite this, I do not find that the choice of colour alone is in this case
sufficient to make the proposal acceptable in the context of the frontage of the
appeal site or the street scene itself. It is acknowledged that timber is a natural
material and that it has been painted to match the dwelling, but the overall design,
positioning and visual implications of the structure are inappropriate.
7. I note that the appellant makes reference, within their original planning statements,
to the fact the storage of the caravan on the property frontage does not require
planning permission. The ability to park a caravan, or large vehicles, on the
driveway of a property is acknowledged but, in this case, the outlined fallback
position would be visually more intrusive than the proposal to retain the caravan
port which has been constructed. I also acknowledge that there is no uniform
building line along Chartwell Grove, however, the proposal results in a caravan port
in front of the garage structure which overall further contributes to visual clutter and
inappropriate development in the context of the general estate setting.
8. The appellant is noted to have offered planting as well as having undertaken some
planting to date on site and whilst this is acknowledged, it should be kept in mind
that character and appearance are separate matters. Even if the proposed planting
were considered to make the proposal acceptable in terms of appearance, due to
screening or softening views within the street scene, this would not overcome the
fact that I find the flat roof, timber frame, structure, to be uncharacteristic. The
same applies to the appellant’s offer to replace the tree which is understood to
have been removed prior to construction – though its removal did not require
consent.
9. It is acknowledged that the proposal does not cause any adverse impact on
neighbouring amenity and does not give rise to any highway safety or parking
concerns meaning that the scope of the appeal is limited to that as stated within the
main issue defined above. Despite this, the proposal by reason of its scale, design
and siting, results in significant adverse impact on the visual amenity of the area as
well as being a development which is out of character with the area resulting in a
negative incongruous feature within the street scene.
10. The proposal is one which falls to be assessed against the Local Plan in
accordance with Section 38(6) of the Planning and Compulsory Purchase Act 2004.
Whilst the National Planning Policy Framework 2024 (the Framework) is a material
consideration it does not change the starting point for determination being the Local
Plan and I do not find that, under the Framework, harm must be significant. The
proposal is inconsistent with a basic requirement to contribute positively to an area.
In this case, for the reasons I have outlined, I find that the proposal is inappropriate
and poorly designed in the context of the appeal site and the character of the area
as well as the street scene of Chartwell Grove.
11. The proposal therefore fails to meet the objectives of Gedling Borough Council
Aligned Core Strategy Part 1 September 2014 Policy 10, which requires new
development to make a positive contribution to the public realm and sense of place
Appeal Decision 6004932
3
as well as requiring them to be assessed in terms of materials, architectural style
and detailing. The proposal would also fail to meet the objectives of Gedling
Borough Local Planning Document Part 2 July 2018 Policy LPD43 which requires
extensions or alterations to dwellings to be in keeping with the surrounding
character in terms of height, built form and generic design as well as being contrary
to paragraph 135, of the Framework, which requires decisions should ensure that
developments will function well, add to the overall quality of the area and are
sympathetic to local character and history.
Other Matters
12. The appellant references, within their appeal statement, that the Council did not
engage with the appellant or their agent throughout the planning process but,
despite this, I have considered the case based upon its own merits and for the
reasons set out I find the proposal to be inappropriate to an extent which is
sufficient to dismiss this appeal.
13. I note third party comments which have been received during the application
process. It is noted that it is stated that there are restrictive covenants on the site,
however, these are private legal matters and not planning matters and therefore
these do not fall within the scope of this appeal. The withdrawal of permitted
development rights for the site is of limited relevance due to the location of the
proposal, being forward of the principal elevation, being one which could not come
under permitted development in any case and is one which would require full
planning permission.
14. Removal of a tree, whilst acknowledged, is not one which required consent and
concern with regard to fire hazards are acknowledged but notwithstanding the fact
that this is not covered by planning policy I have no evidence to suggest that the
proposal would represent a fire hazard in any case.
15. Concern is noted to have been raised with regard to consultation; however, I have
no evidence to suggest that the consultation procedure has been undertaken in any
other way except in accordance with the relevant development management
procedure order. I have dealt with matters relating to design, build and general
character of the area in the context of the main issue above which responds to
many of the comments made within third party representations noted as part of the
submission and now this appeal.
Conclusion
16. For the reasons outlined above, and taking into account all other matters raised, I
conclude that the appeal should be dismissed.
Eleni Marshall
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.