Erection of new ancillary residential accommodation (Granny Annexe) in the grounds of Wighill following the demolition of two existing outbuildings (Poolhouse and Gardeners Outbuilding)
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Green Belt Policy
Heritage & Conservation
Trees & Landscape
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 29 April 2026
by H Miles BA (hons), MA, MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 22 May 2026
Appeal Ref: 6004895
Wighill, Old Malden Lane, Worcester Park, Surrey KT4 7PU
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 (as amended)
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr & Mrs Ian & Carla Botes against the decision of Royal Borough of
Kingston Upon Thames.
• The application Ref is 25/01929/HOU.
• The development proposed is erection of new ancillary residential accommodation (Granny Annexe)
in the grounds of Wighill following the demolition of two existing outbuildings (Poolhouse and
Gardeners Outbuilding).
Decision
1. The appeal is allowed and planning permission is granted for erection of new
ancillary residential accommodation (Granny Annexe) in the grounds of Wighill
following the demolition of two existing outbuildings (Poolhouse and Gardeners
outbuilding) at Wighill, Old Malden Lane, Worcester Park, Surrey KT4 7PU in
accordance with the terms of the application, Ref 25/01929/HOU, subject to the
conditions in the attached schedule.
Preliminary Matters
2. A Fire Strategy Report and Archaeological Desk Based Assessment have been
submitted with the appeal. These are new evidence not previously seen by the
LPA and interested parties at the application stage. Therefore, in the interests of
fairness and openness these documents will not form any part of this assessment
and I have not taken them into account.
Main Issues
3. The main issues are:
• Whether the proposal would be inappropriate development in Metropolitan
Open Land (MOL) having regard to the National Planning Policy Framework
2024 (the Framework) and any relevant development plan policies.
• The effect of the proposed development on archaeology.
• Whether the proposed development would achieve an acceptable standard of
fire safety.
Appeal Decision 6004895
2
Reasons
Whether inappropriate development
4. Policy G3 of the London Plan (2021) (LP) gives MOL protection equivalent to
Green Belt and requires that it is protected from inappropriate development in
accordance with national planning policy tests that apply to Green Belt. The
Framework states that inappropriate development is, by definition, harmful to the
Green Belt. Development in the Green Belt is inappropriate and thus should be
approved only if very special circumstances exist, unless it falls within one of the
exceptions in the Framework.
5. Of relevance to this appeal, paragraph 154d) of the Framework provides an
exception for the replacement of a building, provided the new building is in the
same use and not materially larger than the one it replaces.
6. The appeal scheme proposes a new building which would include two ensuite
bedrooms and generous living accommodation with a study, large
kitchen/living/dining room and separate utility, pantry and dog wash. However, to
access the annexe, occupiers would share the driveway and car parking area with
Wighill and then would travel using footpaths directly past the main house and
through the shared gardens. For privacy reasons, this access would be unsuitable
for unconnected occupiers. The gardens would be shared and no new segregating
features are proposed, although there is existing separation from the main house
due to the tennis courts and dense hedging alongside the pool as well as the
distance between the two buildings which the Council state would be a 114m
walking route. The proposed annexe would be inhabited by the appellants, with
their daughter and her family occupying Wighill. It is likely that there would be
space for live-in carers in the main house. Notwithstanding, the proposals before
me are for care to be provided for children in the main house and, in the future, for
elderly relatives in the proposed annexe and meals would be regularly shared.
Although the annexe would be large, it would nevertheless be clearly smaller than
and secondary to the generous accommodation at Wighill and the properties
would share utilities with no separate title formed.
7. I have considered the functional relationship, scale and extent of the proposal
following the caselaw put to me in Eagles v Minister for the Environment
Sustainability and Housing, Welsh Assembly Government and Torfaen County
Borough Council, (2009) EWHC 1028 and Phillip v Secretary of State for
Communities and Local Government and South Oxfordshire District Council [2008]
EWHC 3117. Also following Uttlesford DC v SSE & White [1992] JPL 171, whether
a separate use would be created as a matter of fact and degree. Although the
facilities in the annexe would provide for independent living, together matters
including the access arrangements, familial relationship, care provision and shared
gardens and utilities mean that there is a clear functional and physical connection
between the existing dwellinghouse and the accommodation as proposed.
8. Moreover, planning permission is sought on the basis that it would be part and
parcel of the main house and no proposal for a separate dwelling is before me. If
the structure is not built or used as proposed, or if there is a material change of
use in the future to create a separate dwelling, then a separate grant of planning
permission would be required, and the building would be at risk of enforcement
action if such permission is not granted. Features such as a change to the access
Appeal Decision 6004895
3
to the annexe, the formation of boundaries in the garden or a change to the
ownership, familial connection or care requirements of occupants could indicate
such a change. I have therefore considered the appeal on the basis that it would
be an annexe and part and parcel of the existing dwellinghouse use. Although the
wording in the description of development is not sufficiently clear a suitably worded
condition could be used to secure this use.
9. The buildings proposed to be demolished are a pool house and gardeners store
which are incidental to the main dwelling. Therefore, both the new building and the
buildings to be demolished would be part of the residential use of Wighill. As such,
they are in the same use.
10. The pool building is a single storey flat roofed structure with three rooms and a
generous eaves height. It has a volume of 378cu.m. The gardeners outbuilding is
a modest single storey flat roofed outbuilding with a volume of 93cu.m. These
buildings have a combined footprint of 138sq.m.
11. The proposed annexe would be a chalet bungalow style. It would have a hipped,
pitched roof and generous gables clearly evidencing the first floor accommodation
and would be taller than the existing buildings at 5.9m. However, the pitched roof
would minimise the bulk at first floor. I am provided with different figures from the
main parties as to its volume which would be between 471-411cu.m and they
agree it would have a footprint of 144sqm, although this is disputed by interested
parties. Based on the evidence before me I find that the proposed building would
be similar to the volume and footprint of the buildings to be demolished.
12. The appeal scheme would extend development into the open part of the garden
area and compared to the pool house its orientation would be wider in views from
the north. However, the replacement of two separate buildings would consolidate
the built form on this site. Nevertheless, the consideration of whether the
replacement building would be materially larger is primarily an objective one by
reference to size. Whilst the annexe would be taller, even taking all the above into
account, its comparable footprint and volume lead me to conclude that overall it
would not be materially larger than the ones it replaces.
13. A Grampian condition is proposed which would secure the demolition of these
buildings, and this is suitably robust and enforceable to ensure that these works
take place. As such a planning obligation would not be required. Given the
importance of the demolition and size of the replacement building to the protection
of MOL, it would be necessary to remove permitted development (PD) rights for
outbuildings and all extensions in order to ensure that they were not replaced or
the proposed annexe extended without considering the effect on MOL. This is a
clear justification as to why these rights should be removed and this could be
secured by condition.
14. The impact on openness is implicitly taken into account in the exception under
paragraph 154d). Therefore, there is no requirement to assess the impact of the
development on the openness of the Green Belt. Furthermore, as it is not
inappropriate development under paragraph 154d) there is no need to consider
any other exceptions or whether very special circumstances exist.
15. Therefore, the appeal scheme would not be inappropriate development in the
terms of the Framework and would consequently be in accordance with Policy G3
of the LP, the aims of which are set out above.
Appeal Decision 6004895
4
16. Policy DM5 of the Kingston Core Strategy (2012) (CS) mainly relates to sites
adjacent to MOL, and open space needs. Therefore, the policy set out above is
more relevant to this main issue.
Archaeology
17. The site is within an Area of Archaeological Significance. Given this location
specific designation, it is likely that archaeological remains could be present which
have heritage significance due to their age and scarcity. A desk based assessment
was not submitted with the planning application and therefore it is not possible to
rule out the likelihood of archaeological remains on the appeal site.
18. The development would be on open garden land which is unlikely to have been
disturbed in connection with the other buildings on the site and groundworks would
be required for foundations for the proposed annexe. However, householder
development would not generally require an assessment and the extent of the
building is modest.
19. The appellant has suggested a condition which would secure the submission of an
assessment prior to any work taking place. A condition could also ensure that a
scheme of mitigation was submitted. Such works would be required to take place
before the development is implemented and therefore a pre commencement
condition would be necessary. This would prevent any work until a scheme which
appropriately identifies, records and/or preserves and mitigates the effects has
been agreed. Based on the evidence and given the scale of the development there
is a prospect of these documents being agreed within the time limit. Therefore, in
the circumstances of this case, a condition would be an appropriate response to
ensure that the development preserves the heritage significance of archaeological
remains.
20. Therefore, there would be an acceptable effect on archaeology. Consequently, the
proposed development would be in accordance with Policy HC1 of the LP and
Policy DM12 of the CS. Together these seek to preserve or enhance heritage
assets and avoid or minimise harm to assets of archaeological significance.
Fire Safety
21. A fire safety statement was submitted with the application, although this does not
provide detail of either adequate access for fire appliances or on-site sprinkler
systems. However, although the site is in MOL, there is little to suggest that
appropriate access which would not be inappropriate development or harm
openness could not be provided on this large site. Nor that sprinkler systems could
not be provided. A condition requiring that such detail is agreed has been
suggested. In these circumstances this would be an appropriate way to secure
these details.
22. Therefore, the proposed development would achieve an acceptable standard of
fire safety. Consequently, it would be in accordance with Policy D12 of the LP
which requires that development achieves the highest standards of fire safety.
Appeal Decision 6004895
5
Other Matters
23. The Biodiversity Net Gain condition does not apply to development which is the
subject of a householder application. For the reasons above the development
before me is for development within the curtilage of a dwellinghouse for a purpose
incidental to the enjoyment of the dwellinghouse. Therefore, this exemption would
apply.
24. As set out above this appeal does not seek permission for a separate dwelling.
Consequently, the increase in the number of people living at the property over and
above what could currently be accommodated is minimal and I do not have detail
that this limited increase would have an unacceptable effect on traffic or foul
drainage. In addition, any light from the annexe would be mainly concentrated
within the existing domestic garden where external lighting is not unexpected.
Furthermore, I am not presented with evidence that the specific considerations in
this case would be likely to arise elsewhere and therefore, that this decision would
lead to a notable increase in residential annexes.
Conditions
25. I have considered the suggested conditions against the tests in the Framework
and the advice in the Planning Practice Guidance. I have made amendments in
order to comply with these documents and to ensure that conditions would not
unnecessarily delay the delivery of development.
26. The standard implementation condition is attached and in the interests of certainty
a condition to define the plans with which the scheme should accord. A Tree
Survey, Arboricultural Impact Assessment & Method Statement were submitted
with the application. The Councils trees and landscape consultee has not required
further information and I have no reason to think that these documents are
inadequate, therefore a further report is not required, but a condition ensuring
compliance is attached in the interests of character and appearance. Compliance
with the Preliminary Ecological Appraisal is required for biodiversity.
27. A condition requiring matching materials is needed in the interests of character
and appearance and is proportionate in this case. A specification of tree planting is
necessary for the same reason and this includes a requirement for maintenance
for 5 years. However, the site is within an existing domestic garden and the
evidence does not satisfy me that a full landscaping scheme is necessary.
28. Conditions requiring an archaeological statement and safeguarding measures, a
fire statement, demolition, the use of the building as an annexe, and removal of
specified PD rights are attached for the reasons set out above. However, I have
not been provided with a clear justification as to why PD rights for boundary
treatment, hardstanding or access ways should be removed and as such these
classes are not included in the condition. Given the importance of the fire
statement to this case and the site specific circumstances full details of fire safety
are needed. Conditions relating to Biodiversity Net Gain and associated Habitat
Management and Monitoring Plans are not required as previously set out.
Appeal Decision 6004895
6
Conclusion
29. For the reasons given above the appeal should be allowed.
H Miles
INSPECTOR
Schedule of Conditions
1) The development hereby permitted shall begin not later than three years from
the date of this decision.
2) The development hereby permitted shall be carried out in accordance with
drawing nos: 2407-PL-110 Existing Elevations, 2407-PL-111 Existing
Elevations, 2407 PL-100 Existing Plans, 2407 PL-250 - Proposed Floor
Plans, 2407 PL-000 - Location Plan, 2407 PL-200 - Proposed Site Plan, 2407
PL-201 - Proposed Block Plan, 2407 PL-251 - Proposed Roof Plan, 2407 PL-
260 - Proposed Elevations, 2407 PL-261 - Proposed Elevations 2, 2407 PL-
270 - Proposed Sections, 2407 PL-300 - Proposed 3D Visuals, 2407-PL-100
Existing Site Plan.
3) No development including demolition shall take place until:
i) A Desk-Based Archaeological Assessment has been carried out in
accordance with a specification and timetable that shall first have been
submitted to and approved in writing by the local planning authority; and
ii) Safeguarding measures to ensure the preservation in situ of important
archaeological remains and/or further archaeological investigation and
recording identified in the archaeological assessment have been
undertaken in accordance with a specification and timetable that shall
first have been submitted to and approved in writing by the local
planning authority
iii) Any historic or archaeological features not previously identified which
are revealed when carrying out the development hereby permitted shall
be retained in-situ and reported to the local planning authority in writing
within 2 working days of their being revealed. Works shall be
immediately halted in the area/part of the building affected until
provision has been made for the retention and/or recording in
accordance with details that shall first have been submitted to and
approved in writing by the local planning authority. Work shall continue
in accordance with the approved details of retention and/or recording.
4) No development above ground level shall take place until a full specification
of all proposed tree planting including replacement tree planting at a
minimum ratio of 2:1 for any trees removed has been submitted to and
approved in writing by the local planning authority. The specification shall
include the quantity, size, species, and positions or density of all trees to be
planted, how they will be planted and protected and the proposed time of
planting. The tree planting shall be carried out in accordance with the
approved specification.
If, within a period of 5 years from the date of planting, the tree (or any tree
planted in replacement for it) is removed, uprooted, destroyed or dies or
Appeal Decision 6004895
7
becomes seriously damaged or defective, another tree of the same size and
species as that originally planted shall be planted at the same place within
the first planting season following the removal, uprooting, destruction or
death of the original tree.
5) No development above ground level (excluding demolition), shall take place
until the buildings to be removed as shown on site plan drawing number 2407
PL-200 have been demolished. Prior to the first occupation of the dwelling
hereby approved, all building waste and other materials arising from the
demolition shall be removed from the site.
6) No development above ground level shall take place until a Fire Safety
Strategy has been submitted to and approved in writing by the local planning
authority. The Fire Safety Strategy shall demonstrate how the development
will achieve the highest standards of fire safety and shall include the following
details:
i) suitably positioned outside space for fire appliances/ an evacuation
assembly point;
ii) appropriate fire alarm systems;
iii) passive and active fire safety measures;
iv) appropriate construction details to minimise the risk of fire spread;
v) provision of suitable and convenient means of escape/ an evacuation
strategy;
vi) provision of suitable access and equipment for firefighting which is
appropriate for the size and use of the development.
The development shall be carried out in accordance with the approved Fire
Safety Strategy prior to occupation, and thereafter retained.
The required Fire Safety Strategy shall reference the London Plan Guidance
for Fire Safety (February 2022) where applicable. A Reasonable Exception
Statement shall be submitted where the Applicant considers parts of or all of
Policy D12(A) of the London Plan 2021 to not be relevant.
7) The external materials of the outbuilding and hardstanding hereby permitted
shall match those used in the existing dwelling.
8) The building hereby permitted shall be used solely as an annexe which is
part and parcel of the residential use of the dwelling known as Wighill and
shall not be occupied, sold, leased or otherwise used as a separate or
independent dwelling.
9) Notwithstanding the provisions of the Town and Country Planning (General
Permitted Development) (England) Order 2015 (or any order revoking and re-
enacting that Order with or without modification), no development permitted
by virtue of Classes A, AA, B, D and E of Part 1 of Schedule 2 to the Order
shall be undertaken.
10) The development hereby permitted shall be carried out in accordance with
the Trees and Construction BS5837:2012 Tree Survey, Arboricultural Impact
Assessment & Method Statement ref 22017.25/A2_AIA, dated July 2025.
11) The development hereby permitted shall be carried out in accordance with
the recommendations in the Preliminary Ecological Appraisal Ref: ECO64
dated 25/03/2025.
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.