Part demolition of existing building, demolition of rear sheds, fenestration alterations, two-storey rear extension, one-storey upwards extension to existing dwelling
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Heritage & Conservation
Character & Appearance
Policy Weight
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 18 March 2026
by G Sibley MPLAN MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 22 May 2026
Appeal Ref: 6004701
1A Evelyn Road, Richmond, Surrey TW9 2TF
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 (as amended)
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Matthew Goslett against the decision of Richmond Upon Thames London
Borough Council.
• The application Ref is PA25/3255.
• The development proposed is part demolition of existing building, demolition of rear sheds,
fenestration alterations, two-storey rear extension, one-storey upwards extension to existing
dwelling.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Preliminary Matter
2. The appeal site is located within the Kew Foot Road Conservation Area (CA) and
section 72(1) of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990
(the Act) requires special attention to be paid to the desirability of preserving or
enhancing the character or appearance of that area.
Main Issue
3. The main issue relevant to this appeal is the effect of the proposal on the character
and appearance of the area, including the CA.
Reasons
Significance
4. The Kew Foot Road No. 36 Conservation Area (CA) Study identifies that the
special interest of the CA derives in part from terraces of attractive residential
development of varied types and architectural styles, occupying the spaces
between the two principal road frontages. Old, narrow alleys lead off the main
roads, and the area is densely developed.
5. This dense urban fabric incorporates a mix of grand Georgian terraces, large
detached and semi-detached townhouses, and small Victorian artisans’ cottages.
The diversity of building types and scales contributes significantly to the character
and interest of the CA.
6. Side roads are predominantly characterised by two-storey terraced or
semi-detached houses with shallow-pitched slate roofs, which are generally
unencumbered by roof extensions. Yellow stock brick is the prevailing material,
Appeal Decision 6004701
2
often complemented by red brick detailing, which establishes a consistent and
recognisable material palette.
7. While development along Evelyn Road differs to some extent from other parts of
the CA, it retains a number of consistent features. These include flat-fronted
elevations and the use of stock brick with red brick string courses, decorative
detailing and headers.
8. Original windows and chimney stacks are also identified as significant elements.
Collectively, these features make a positive contribution to the character and
appearance of the area and underpin the overall significance of the CA.
9. The appeal property comprises a single-storey building characterised by rounded
windows and a rounded door to the front elevation. It is constructed of yellow stock
brick and is finished with a tiled side-gabled roof. The appeal site also contains a
single-storey, flat-roofed garage with a large metal door fronting Evelyn Road, with
the main appeal building set back slightly from the garage frontage.
10. As a single-storey building, the appeal property is somewhat unusual within Evelyn
Road and the wider CA. However, along Evelyn Road there is a mix of two-,
three- and four-storey properties, such that the scale of development varies.
11. The materials used in the construction of the appeal building are consistent with
those found elsewhere in the CA and contribute positively to its character.
Properties along the road are typically set back behind narrow brick-walled front
gardens or open basements, whereas the appeal site has an open frontage. While
this differs from the prevailing pattern, there is some variation in setback distances
along the street.
12. Detailing to windows and doors varies, but some form of architectural detailing is a
common and unifying feature of the housing in the road. Although the rounded
windows and door are unusual, they do incorporate surrounding detailing,
contributing to this unifying characteristic. The flat fronted nature of the building
also reflects a consistent feature of the area.
13. By contrast, the single-storey flat-roofed garage is uncommon within the street
scene and the wider CA, and its materials are not characteristic of those typically
used. Consequently, the garage does not incorporate features that contribute
positively to the significance of the CA and thus does not preserve the character or
appearance of it.
14. Notwithstanding its smaller scale and open frontage, the appeal building itself
incorporates features that contribute positively to the significance of the CA and
therefore preserves its character and appearance.
The effect of the proposal
15. The proposed development would take the form of a two-storey building with a
split-level roof. This would comprise a slate-finished gabled roof, incorporating
parapet walls to either side over part of the structure, with a flat roof over the
remaining section.
16. The building would present a varied frontage, with approximately half of the
dwelling projecting significantly forward of the remainder. Whilst there are
examples of side extensions and additions to properties in the area, these are
Appeal Decision 6004701
3
typically modest in scale and clearly subordinate to the host building, as seen at 1
Evelyn Road. In this case, the two sections of the extended dwelling would be of
broadly equal width, such that neither would appear subservient to the other. The
generally consistent building line and flat-fronted nature of properties are important
contributors to the character of the area, and the proposed design would conflict
with these established characteristics, further distinguishing the development from
the prevailing pattern within the CA.
17. Stucco quoins are proposed and whilst these are a feature of a group of semi-
detached properties on Evelyn Road, they are typically employed to demarcate the
junction between separate buildings. The design and placement of the quoins and
the setback between the two sides of the house would give rise to the appearance
of two distinct buildings rather than a single cohesive dwelling, an effect that is
compounded by the contrasting roof forms.
18. The proposed windows would incorporate decorative surrounds that reflect those
found on nearby properties. Although a Juliet balcony is proposed, balconies are
present on the frontage of the building opposite. Given its modest proportions and
the use of open metal railings, the Juliet balcony would not appear incongruous
within the street scene.
19. The flat-roofed side of the house would incorporate large, perforated doors,
together with a zinc canopy above, intended to provide a covered refuse storage
area. Both the doors and canopy would project a notable distance beyond the front
elevation. Additionally, whilst canopies are a common feature above shopfronts on
Kew Foot Road, these are clearly associated with commercial premises, whereas
the appeal proposal is distinctly residential in character. As such, the design of the
refuse store and canopy would fail to preserve the simple, flat-fronted elevations
that typify residential properties along Evelyn Road and elsewhere within the CA.
20. Whilst buildings of architectural merit at 1-11 Evelyn Road do not feature Juliet
balconies, the appeal site is separated from these by 1B Evelyn Road, a single-
storey property. Given this separation, and the differences in architectural
approach, it is evident that the proposal does not seek to directly replicate these
buildings. However, the side elevation door, positioned beneath a first-floor ledge,
would represent an unusual feature within the context of the wider street. The
form, extent and detailing of the glazing associated with this entrance would not
reflect the character of covered entrances elsewhere in the locality. These
elements would further distinguish the dwelling from others along the road and
within the CA. Front elevations in the area are generally simple in composition,
typically comprising a recessed front door and larger windows with decorative
surrounds. By contrast, the design and arrangement of features in this part of the
proposal would result in an unduly busy frontage, appearing discordant with the
prevailing character of surrounding development. Moreover, the absence of
chimneys within the design further emphasises the overall lack of consistency and
architectural coherence.
21. The surrounding development is predominantly terraced or arranged in closely
spaced pairs of semi-detached dwellings. Consequently, gaps within the street
scene are uncommon and do not form a defining feature. Although the existing
appeal site, together with the adjoining single-storey building and garages, creates
a gap above ground floor level between development on Kew Foot Road and the
larger buildings along this part of Evelyn Road, this openness does not necessarily
Appeal Decision 6004701
4
contribute towards the significance of the CA. In particular, the character of Evelyn
Road is defined by the relatively close spacing and larger scale of its buildings.
Therefore, the infilling of this gap at first-floor level would not, in itself, result in
harm to the character or appearance of Evelyn Road or the wider CA.
22. The scheme would require the demolition of the flat roofed garage next to the host
dwelling and as such it would involve the removal a building that does not preserve
the character and appearance of the CA. The sheds located to the rear of the
appeal property are limited in scale and domestic in appearance and are screened
by the dwelling. Taking these factors into account their demolition would have a
neutral effect on the character and appearance of the CA.
23. In summary, the proposal incorporates certain elements that reflect the character
and appearance of other properties within the CA, including the use of materials
and decorative detailing to some window surrounds. In addition, given the variation
in building scale and alignment along Evelyn Road, the two-storey scale of the
proposal would not appear inherently out of character. However, the relationship
between the two constituent parts of the building would appear awkward, and
when combined with the inclusion of features such as the projecting zinc canopy
over the refuse store and the differing roof form, the overall design appears
disjointed and lacks architectural coherence. This lack of coherence is particularly
evident at ground floor level on the flat-roofed element.
24. Furthermore, whilst the existing site does not feature a frontage brick wall, none is
proposed as part of the development. This omission would further differentiate the
proposal from the prevailing character of the street, notwithstanding the inclusion
of a low wall between the appeal site and the neighbouring garage. Consequently,
the proposed development would include features that cause harm to the
significance of the CA as a whole and whilst the removal of the flat roofed garage
would remove a building that does not preserve the character and appearance of
the CA, the extended dwelling as proposed would fail to preserve the significance
of it.
Heritage Balance
25. Paragraph 212 of the National Planning Policy Framework (the Framework)
advises that, when considering the impact of development on the significance of
designated heritage assets, great weight should be given to their conservation.
Paragraph 213 goes on to say that any harm to, or loss of, the significance of a
designated heritage asset from development should require clear and convincing
justification.
26. In this case, the proposal relates to an extension to a single dwelling within the CA.
The harm identified would be less than substantial in Framework terms and in this
context, I give great weight to the harm I have identified. Having regard to the
statutory duty under the Act, considerable importance and weight must be
attached to the desirability of preserving or enhancing the character or appearance
of the CA. In these circumstances, paragraph 215 of the Framework advises that
this harm should be weighed against the public benefits of the proposal.
27. The proposal would result in the demolition of the existing garage, which does not
preserve the character and appearance of the CA. Its removal would therefore
represent only a modest benefit. However, the existing dwelling on the site
preserves the character and appearance of the CA, and its loss would not
Appeal Decision 6004701
5
constitute a public benefit. Furthermore, its replacement with a building that fails to
preserve the character or appearance of the CA would weigh against the proposal.
28. The extended dwelling would screen views of the large ventilation system for a
restaurant that operates on Kew Foot Road. The utilitarian appearance of this
ventilation system is uncommon within the area and the screening of this would
provide a limited public benefit to the character and appearance of the CA.
29. There would be short term and long-term economic benefits that would arise from
the construction of the scheme. The appellant would also contribute towards the
social aspect of the area, and the scheme would deliver a wheelchair accessible
home. The proposal would also provide soft landscaping around the property.
30. The scale of development across the wider CA varies considerably and views of
taller properties from side roads is not uncommon. Consequently, the screening
the proposed two storey property would provide of 147 Kew Road would not be a
benefit to the character or appearance of the CA.
31. The proposal would also allow for the appellant to live in the property that would be
designed to support them, but this would be a private benefit of the scheme and is
considered in greater detail later in this decision.
32. Taking all matters into account, the modest public benefits of the proposal would
not outweigh that harm to the heritage asset. Consequently, clear and convincing
justification has not been provided to justify the harm to the significance of the
heritage asset.
33. Therefore, for the reasons given above, the proposed development would fail to
preserve the character or appearance of the CA, and I give this harm considerable
importance and weight in the planning balance. Accordingly, the proposal would
conflict with Policies 28 and 29 of the Richmond upon Thames Local Plan. These
seek, amongst other matters, for development to conserve and where possible
take opportunities to make a positive contribution to, the historic environment of
the borough.
Other Matter
34. Whilst the Council could have sought amendments during the determination of the
application, the appeal process should not be used to evolve a scheme. I have
thus had regard to the merits of the scheme before me. The process is confined to
determining the proposal as submitted, not iterating alternative schemes. Where
the harm is inherent to the proposal’s overall design approach rather than a
discrete element, neither conditions nor the appeal process provides an
appropriate mechanism to resolve it.
Planning Balance and Conclusion
35. I have found that the harm to the significance of the designated heritage asset
would not be outweighed by the public benefits of the proposal. This would lead to
a conflict with relevant development plan policies. While there are other policies
with which the proposal would comply, the objectives of the development plan
must be read as a whole and the conflicts I have identified result in a conflict with
the development plan when it is considered as a whole.
Appeal Decision 6004701
6
36. The scheme would lead to economic, social and environmental benefits to which I
attach modest weight in favour of the development. However, I consider these
benefits would be outweighed by the adverse impacts. As a result, no material
considerations have been shown to carry sufficient weight to indicate that a
decision should be taken other than in accordance with the development plan and
this signifies that the appeal should be dismissed.
37. The extended dwelling would provide accommodation for the appellant, who has
additional care needs arising from a health condition. As such, the appellant is a
person with a protected characteristic (disability) for the purposes of the Equality
Act 2010.
38. I have had due regard to the Public Sector Equality Duty (PSED) set out in section
149 of the Equality Act 2010. This requires decision-makers to have regard to the
need to eliminate discrimination, advance equality of opportunity, and foster good
relations between persons who share a protected characteristic and those who do
not. I have had these matters in mind throughout my assessment.
39. The evidence indicates that the appellant uses a wheelchair and requires
accommodation specifically designed to meet their needs, including provision for a
live-in carer. The proposal would extend the dwelling to meet those requirements
and would therefore contribute positively towards addressing the appellant’s
needs.
40. I attach significant weight to these considerations. However, the evidence before
me does not demonstrate that the appellant’s needs could not reasonably be met
through alternative means, including through a differently designed scheme that
would preserve the character and appearance of the CA. In particular, many of the
identified concerns relate to the external design of the building, rather than the
internal layout required to meet accessibility needs. As such, it has not been
shown that the specific form of development proposed is the only means of
achieving those objectives.
41. I have also considered the provisions of the Human Rights Act 1998, in particular
Article 8 and Article 1 of the First Protocol. Dismissing the appeal would interfere
with the appellant’s interests in respect of their home and private life. However,
these are qualified rights, and any interference must be weighed against the public
interest.
42. In this case, the interference would be lawful and in pursuit of a legitimate aim,
namely the preservation of the character and appearance of the CA. Given that the
appellant’s needs could potentially be met in a less harmful manner, I am satisfied
that the decision to dismiss the appeal would be proportionate. There will be no
violation of the individual or their family’s human rights. The protection of the public
interest cannot be achieved by means that are less interfering with their rights.
43. Accordingly, having had due regard to the PSED, I conclude that the identified
harm is not outweighed by the benefits of the proposal, including those arising
from meeting the appellant’s needs.
44. The development would conflict with the development plan and the material
considerations, including the Framework, do not indicate that a decision should be
made other than in accordance with it. Therefore, for the reasons given above, I
conclude that the appeal should be dismissed.
Appeal Decision 6004701
7
G Sibley
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.