Demolition of an existing boundary fence, erection of boundary wall, fence and retaining wall
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Flood Risk
Highways & Transport
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 1 April 2026
by S McIntyre BSc (Hons), CEng, MICE, MCIHT
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 27th May 2026
Appeal Ref: 6004672
37 Addison Gardens, Surbiton, Kingston Upon Thames KT5 8DJ
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 (as amended)
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr Apostolos Sarafeidis against the decision of the Council of the Royal
Borough of Kingston Upon Thames.
• The application Ref is 25/02727/HOU.
• The development proposed is the demolition of an existing boundary fence, erection of boundary
wall, fence and retaining wall.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Preliminary Matters
2. The description of development proposed on the planning application form is
extremely lengthy and includes detail and narrative that does not relate to the
operative part of the development. The description of development on the Council’s
decision notice was amended to that shown in the banner heading. This is clearer
and more accurate than the description on the application form and this amended
version was used by the appellant in their appeal form. I have therefore determined
the appeal on the basis of the amended description.
3. Reference to “retrospective” in the description of the development proposed is not a
form of development, therefore I have removed the reference to this in the banner
heading above. While works have commenced on site, I have determined the
appeal on the basis of the plans submitted with the planning application.
Main Issues
4. The main issues are:
i. the effect of the development on the character and appearance of the area;
ii. the effect of the development on highway safety; and
iii. whether sufficient information has been provided to demonstrate that the
development would not adversely affect 35 Addison Gardens (No 35) with
regards to surface water flooding.
Appeal Decision 6004672
2
Reasons
Character and Appearance
5. In the vicinity of the appeal site, Addison Gardens is a residential street
predominantly of two-storey terraced houses. The terraces are set back from the
road with open front gardens or parking areas. Front boundary treatments, where
provided, are typically low post and rail wooden fences. There is some hedging to
the front boundary of the appeal site and No 35.
6. The front gardens on Addison Gardens provide an open separation between the
road and dwellings which creates a spacious appearance to the street scene. The
existing layout plan for the appeal site shows the site before work had taken place.
It indicates a typical open frontage with a front boundary of either hedge or low
timber post and rail fence that would likely have made a positive contribution to the
character of the area, in keeping with its neighbours.
7. The appeal proposal includes a brick/block wall, with intermittent pillars to the front
of the appeal site and along the edge of the front garden along Addison Gardens.
The height to the top of the pillars is approximately 2.35m. The height of the wall
between pillars has not been provided but the plans indicate that the wall would be
approximately half the height of the pillars.
8. While some hedging would be retained at the front of the site the brick/block wall
fronting the appeal site is a solid visual barrier that restricts views into and through
the frontage of the appeal site, adversely affecting the open and spacious feel of
the site and Addison Gardens. The form and materials of the proposal are not
characteristic of boundary treatments in the area and appear prominent and
incongruous in the street scene. The submitted plans do not confirm the material of
the wall. The wall as constructed comprises grey blocks and buff mortar. These
materials contrast negatively with the red brick that is the prevalent facing material
of dwellings in Addison Gardens. Even if the wall were constructed of red brick, it
would remain incongruous in the area.
9. The appellant contends that, with regard to boundary frontages, the wider area
does not exhibit a consistency of form, and that the appeal proposal represents an
enhancement of the visual amenities of the locality. As noted above I have
observed consistency in the area within which the appeal sits with regard to open
frontages.
10. Overall, I conclude that the development harms the character and appearance of
the area and is therefore in conflict with Policy D3 of the London Plan 2021 and
Policy DM10 of the Royal Borough of Kingston Upon Thames Local Development
Framework Core Strategy (The Core Strategy). These policies require development
to respond to, and contribute to, the existing character and distinctiveness of a
place and have particular regard to the contribution that private front gardens make
to the Borough’s suburban character and distinctive local context.
Highway Safety
11. The officer’s report includes reference to a consultation response from the highway
officer which includes a requirement that a driver leaving the site can see anything
over 0.6m, primarily to prevent injury to children. This guidance is set out within the
Council’s Vehicular Crossover Policy and Application Pack (VCPAP, 2024).
Appeal Decision 6004672
3
12. The appellant states that there are numerous vehicular accesses along Addison
Gardens, including an existing access at the site, and that highway users are
conscious of their existence and have to exercise a degree of caution. The primary
concern of the highway officer, and VCPAP, relates to visibility to small children,
and it would be inappropriate to rely on small children exercising caution when
walking on a footway approaching an access.
13. The appellant also notes that the dwelling generates a small number of vehicular
movements and the cul-de-sac position of the site is such that vehicle movements
and speeds on Addison Gardens in the vicinity of the access are low. This may be
true but the requirement for a driver to be able to see an approaching child
pedestrian is not related to vehicle numbers or speeds.
14. No visibility splay details have been submitted for the vehicular access, however
there is a 2.35m high pillar immediately adjacent to the access and the adjacent
wall would be in excess of 1m in height. Appropriate visibility splays are therefore
not proposed, and consequently the development would have an adverse effect on
highway safety.
15. A potential condition noted in the LPA questionnaire regarding visibility splays is
acknowledged. However, this does not include a requirement for the splay to be
free of obstruction from a height of 0.6m. For this reason, I am not of the view that it
would satisfactorily address the safety concern.
16. I conclude that the proposal results in unacceptable impacts on highway safety, in
conflict with Policy DM10 of the Core Strategy, which requires development not to
have an unacceptable impact on highway safety. Policy DM9 of the Core Strategy,
which relates to requirements for Transport Assessments, parking provision and
car club and electric vehicle infrastructure was referenced in the Council’s reason
for refusal. However, by reason of the nature of development, this is not directly
relevant to the scheme before me and was not determinative to this appeal.
Surface Water Flooding
17. The ground levels in the rear garden have been raised to reduce the gradient of the
ground and retaining walls varying in height between approximately 0.67m and
1.14m are shown on the submitted plans. No details have been submitted by the
appellant to demonstrate that the increased ground levels in the garden would not
result in increased risk of surface water flooding to No 35.
18. The appellant considers that this can be addressed by a condition requiring
submission of drainage details and, if necessary, any required mitigation measures.
However, given that the works to the rear garden have been completed and in the
absence of certainty that there is a deliverable drainage solution, such a condition
is not appropriate.
19. Overall, I conclude that insufficient information has been provided to demonstrate
that the development would not adversely affect No 35 Addison Gardens with
regards to surface water flooding. The proposal is therefore in conflict with Policy
SI13 of the London Plan 2021 and Policies CS1 and DM4 of the Core Strategy
which require development to take account of increased flood risk and manage
surface water run-off.
Appeal Decision 6004672
4
Other Matters
20. I acknowledge the appellant’s argument that the works have taken place in order to
strengthen the security and privacy of their property. However, there is no
substantive evidence before me to demonstrate that the scheme before me is the
only way to achieve that. This matter has not led me to an alternative conclusion on
the main issues.
Conclusion
21. The proposal conflicts with the development plan and the material considerations
do not indicate that the appeal should be decided other than in accordance with it.
Therefore, the appeal should be dismissed.
S McIntyre
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.