Combined Appeal
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Residential Amenity
Extensions
Green Belt Policy
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 20 April 2026
by A.Graham BA(hons) MAued IHBC
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date:06 May 2026
Appeal Ref: 6004588
2 Blakely Court, Raby Mere, Wirral CH63 0ND
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 against a refusal
to grant outline planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr Paul Gordon against the decision of Wirral Council.
• The application Ref is: APPH/25/01390.
• The application is for demolition of existing front porch, storage and balcony, construction of a front
extension, a new front dormer, a single and a two storey rear extension with a roof lantern and
skylights respectively, with alterations to the main roof to add new rooflights to the rear, and external
wall fenestrations.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Procedural Matters
2. This appeal is subject to a costs decision which is the subject of a separate
decision notice.
3. The neighbouring property at number 4 Blakely Court has presented several
matters that relate to a potential dispute over the boundary between the two
properties and the manner in which these are shown on the proposed plans. Whilst
I note these concerns and whilst I saw on my site visit the proximity to the
boundary, it is not within my gift to make judgement upon issues of a civil matter
such as these and I would expect any such dispute to be addressed outside of this
decision. As such I have determined the appeal accordingly.
Main Issue
4. The main issue is the effect of the proposal upon the living conditions of
neighbours.
Reasons
5. The appeal property is a detached house located within a modest, tree lined cul de
sac of several similarly designed houses, many of which contain long, low catslide
type roofs, stylised chimneys and a mix of render, stone and brick materials.
6. The appeal property itself is a good example of architecture or the houses on the
street whereby its extended roof covers a double height living room space and a
balcony faces the front at first floor level. To the rear there is nearing completion a
single storey flat roof extension that would contain a kitchen/dining area.
Appeal Decision Appeal Ref: 6004588
2
7. The scheme before me seeks permission for two elements. To the front the
proposal would extend the ground floor of the property to create a store and office
with utility space behind. This would be housed beneath a lean too roof and would
extend the property to be in line with the existing ground floor front elevation
serving the living room. It would also remove the existing first floor balcony in this
location. Above the extended hallway and front door would rise a partial gable
fronted dormer upward extension that would house a fourth bedroom.
8. To the rear the proposal seeks permission for a first floor bedroom extension over
the existing ground floor kitchen. This extension would terminate in a rear facing
gable and would bring the rear elevation to around the same rear building line of
that of the neighbour at number 4 Blakely Court. This rear gable end would be
located close to the neighbour’s boundary and I understand that a previously
proposed Juliet style balcony has been substituted for an area of glazing with
opening casements.
9. To the north of the appeal site is another suburban street, Raby Drive. Occupying a
corner plot here is number 65 Raby Drive which is a two storey detached house
that has previously been extended to the rear with a flat roof extension. This
property is sited on a noticeably lower plot than that of the appeal site due to the
general lay of the land here. There are several windows and patio doors opening
onto what is a modest rear garden with a side terrace running along the initial
length of Blakely Court.
10. When the appeal property is viewed from number 65, particularly from the rear
kitchen/dining room window, the prominence of the end gable of the house is
obvious. This feature stands on a higher level but is fairly narrow, as such its
impact is relatively limited although it does create a dominance over the central
parts of the house. Also obvious from this point of view is the first floor balcony
whose railings can clearly be seen rising above the garden fence of number 65 and
upon which an occupant of the appeal property could stand or sit were they to feel
so inclined.
11. The proposed extension would remove this balcony and extend the ground floor
level towards the front of the appeal property. This would remove any chance of
direct overlooking and the extension would be accommodated beneath a pitched
lean too roof which would extend from around the cill level of the first floor front
bedroom windows. Apart from the initial rise in height to the top of the roof slope,
the effect of this ground floor extension would be minimal when viewed from
number 65 and would offer a considerable enhancement with regards privacy.
12. The first floor element would be set in from the gable end of the appeal property by
almost 4 metres. It would then extend upwards from just shy of the extended front
of the property to form a large dormer type extension that would terminate in a
gable roof form. This would raise the structure in line with the existing eaves of the
property before a pitch roof would slope away to a height slightly lower than the
existing ridge of the main house. This single extension is larger than those
individual extensions of the previously proposed extension whereby two smaller
dormer windows were proposed that were more modest and set further in from the
front elevation.
Appeal Decision Appeal Ref: 6004588
3
13. When seen from the rear garden and the rear kitchen of number 65 this extension
would infill a noticeable area of openness and would obscure parts of the sky. It
would undoubtably result in more mass of development here that would be on the
verge of being over dominant in any normal scenario even though it almost meets
the guidance within the Council’s guidance on house extensions in having a around
a 12m distance between the extension and the neighbouring property. With the
predominant vista being upwards towards the appeal site however, due to the lay of
the land, the effect is amplified and would appear much more harmful from the
aspect from number 65.
14. This is a finely balanced judgement and although I consider some design
modifications would likely be able to overcome these issues, it is not within my gift
to determine such potential changes here. As such, based on the scheme before
me, I must conclude that the effect upon the living conditions of those living at
number 65 Raby Drive would still be significant and that the loss of openness and
dominance of the proposed extension would make this development, on balance,
unacceptable.
15. Coming to the extension to the rear, this would itself have a slight effect upon
residents at number 65 Raby Drive but to a much more limited amount due to the
distance involved. As such I find no harm with regards this extension in this
respect. The proposal would however include a bedroom window upon its gable
which would be much further forward than the existing window is currently located.
As a result, it would bring the potential for overlooking of the neighbour’s garden at
number 4 Blackely Court into focus.
16. Although I note that the Council have not raised issue with this since the Juliet type
balcony was removed from the revised scheme, nevertheless it would still introduce
a first floor window here very close to the common boundary between the two
properties and the neighbour has raised specific concerns about this. In assessing
this important matter, I do not consider there would be much scope for overlooking
into the neighbour’s conservatory, however, there would be opportunity to overlook
into the garden area from an oblique angle very close to the boundary from this
proposed window and this would introduce a level of overlooking that does not
currently exist.
17. Once again, this is a finely balanced issue and although it would not be possible for
a person occupying the bedroom to sit on a balcony of sorts, the proposed window
here would still offer a clear view of the neighbour’s private garden to the detriment
of their living conditions.
18. Although I note the Appellant’s suggestion of a split decision in this case, I am
unable to offer this due to this potentially harmful introduction. And, whilst I consider
a modest design change or perhaps attached external screen could be capable of
mitigating such an impact, I am unable to condition such a matter in this regard.
19. Moreover, I saw on my site visit that the boundary fence was set in from the edge
of the existing rear extension which appeared to show a boundary that was not
immediately clear. As such I would not be confident in allowing this rear element,
even with conditions, subject to the uncertainty around the boundary issue as
outlined above.
Appeal Decision Appeal Ref: 6004588
4
20. Therefore, whilst I consider there would be ways to mitigate the harms that I have
found with this scheme, ultimately the proposal before me would still cause such
harm so as to bring the scheme into conflict with policies WD5 and WD23 of the
Wirral Local Plan1 as well as guidance contained within SPG11, all of which reflect
the Framework in its aims to achieve good design that does not cause harm to the
living conditions of neighbours.
Conclusion
21. For the reasons given above, whilst taking into account all other matters raised, I
must dismiss this appeal.
A Graham
INSPECTOR
1 Wirral Local Plan 2022-2040 adopted 31 March 2025.
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.