Demolition of single storey elements and outbuildings, erection of two storey and single storey extensions with erection of detached garage ’ without complying with conditions attached to planning permission Ref 38/24/0371, dated 12/02/2025
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Heritage & Conservation
Trees & Landscape
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 7 April 2026
by O Marigold BSc DipTP MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 27 April 2026
Appeal Ref: 6004576
Westerkirk, Manor Road, Staplegrove, Taunton TA2 6AP
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 (as amended)
against a refusal to grant planning permission under section 73 of the Town and Country Planning
Act 1990 (as amended) for the development of land without complying with conditions subject to
which a previous planning permission was granted.
• The appeal is made by Mr John Eaton against the decision of Somerset Council.
• The application Ref is 38/25/0336.
• The application sought planning permission for ‘demolition of single storey elements and
outbuildings, erection of two storey and single storey extensions with erection of detached garage ’
without complying with conditions attached to planning permission Ref 38/24/0371, dated
12/02/2025.
• The conditions in dispute are Nos 2, 4 and 12 which state that:
Condition 2: The development hereby permitted shall be carried out in accordance with the
following approved plans:
(A4) DrNo 01 Location Plan
(A4) DrNo 02 Existing Block Plan
(A1) DrNo 03 Existing Site Survey
(A1) DrNo 04 Existing Ground Floor Plan, First Floor Plan & Elevations
(A3) DrNo 16 Existing Plan & Elevations
(A2) DrNo 17 Existing Plan & Elevations Veterinary Building
(A1) DrNo 3008RS-01 Topographical Survey
(A1) DrNo 30 Rev C Proposed Ground Floor Plan & First Floor Plan
(A1) DrNo 31 Rev C Proposed Elevations SK09
(A3) DrNo 32 Proposed Garage Plans & Elevations
(A3) DrNo 33 Proposed Entrance Way Plan & Elevations
(A1) DrNo 3008RS-01 Topographical Survey
(A1) Dr No 34 Rev A Proposed Site Plan SK09
(A4) DrNo 35 Proposed Block Plan SK09
Condition 4: Works will not commence until:
(a) Construction operatives have been inducted by a licensed bat ecologist to make them aware of
the possible presence of bats, their legal protection and of working practices to avoid harming bats.
Written confirmation of the induction will be submitted to the Local Planning Authority by the licensed
bat ecologist within one week of the toolbox talk.
(b) Mature trees and the coach house within the site boundary are suitable to install bat boxes for
temporary roosting. To provide a suitable alternative roosting location, to accommodate any
discovered bat(s), will be hung on a suitable tree or building on or adjacent to the site at a minimum
height of 4 metres as directed by a licensed bat ecologist. Any such box will be maintained in -situ
thereafter. Photographs showing their installation will be submitted to the Local Planning Authority .
(c) Works potentially affecting bats will then proceed under the supervision of the licensed bat
ecologist. A licensed bat worker will attend the site on the day of any and all roof removal and the
removal of the boards at the windows. The licensed bat worker will give a toolbox talk to the
contractors on the site regarding the legal protection afforded to bats, bat biology, the contractor's
responsibilities and any conditions set out within the licence and this report. The contractors will be
continually aware of bats and the potential for them to be present during the works. Prior to any work
taking place an internal survey will take place looking for bats within the loft spaces. Should a bat be
present within any areas the bat worker wearing gloves will capture the bat and move the bat
Appeal Decision 6004576
2
to a pre-installed bat box located on the coach house and mature trees. The bat licensed ecologist
will supervise the 'soft' dismantling of the roof and any features such as ridge, soffits, lead flashing,
felt, mortar and the wooden boards at the windows where appropriate. Soft dismantling will be
undertaken by hand and hand tools only, each tile will be removed gently pulled away from the roof
to avoid crushing and careful ridge removal and thorough check within the ridge line will be
undertaken by hand. Other features will be removed carefully and inspected for the presence of bats
and/or bat evidence. Should any bats be present the licensed bat worker will relocate the bat to an
existing bat box. Once the features suitable to support roosting bats have been dismantled then
works can continue unsupervised. Should a bat be discovered at any other time then works will
cease and the licensed bat ecologist contacted for advice. All contractors are strictly forbidden from
handling bats.
(d) To retain suitable roosting features post development loft space will be segregated off from the
main roof to support bats and a sign will be erected on the boxed off loft space advertising the
presence of a bat roost. 10 bat access points will be installed to provide access for crevice dwelling
bats a combination of under tiles and between wood panelling. Wherever bats will be able to access
type I bituminous roofing felt will be used (or approved breathable felt i.e. TLX bat safe). As the tiles
will be laid directly onto battens a natural gap will be made between the felt and tile by the batten.
Two ridge access points will be installed at the southeastern ridge to provide direct access into the
roof void. Any external lighting required as part of the new scheme will be motion triggered, hooded
and directional. No new external lighting will be allowed within 5m of the replacement bat access
points and must illuminate any access points. Site boundaries must not be illuminated by >0.5 lux. As
a significant number of bats have been recorded within the site two post-monitoring surveys will be
required to check mitigation measured conditioned within this report and obtained license is
implemented. In order to ensure the above has been undertaken in accordance with the strategy
either a written statement and or photographs of the mitigation measures will be required to be
submitted to the Local Planning Authority.
Condition 12: Before development commences (including site clearance and any other preparatory
works) a scheme for the protection of trees to be retained shall be submitted to and approved in
writing by the Local Planning Authority. Such a scheme shall include a plan sh owing the location of
the protective fencing, and shall specify the type of protective fencing, all in accordance with BS
5837:2012. Such fencing shall be erected prior to commencement of any other site operations and at
least two working days' notice shall be given to the Local Planning Authority that it has been erected.
It shall be maintained and retained for the full duration of works or until such time as agreed in writing
with the Local Planning Authority. No activities whatsoever shall take place within the protected
areas without the prior written agreement of the Local Planning Authority.
• The reasons given for the conditions are:
Condition 2: For the avoidance of doubt and in the interests of proper planning.
Condition 4: A pre-commencement condition is required to ensure the strict protection of European
protected species and in accordance with policy CP8 of the Taunton Deane Core Strategy.
Condition 12: To ensure the enhancement of the development by the retention of existing trees and
natural features during the construction phase.
Decision
1. The appeal is allowed and planning permission is granted for demolition of single
storey elements and outbuildings, erection of two storey and single storey
extensions with erection of detached garage at Westerkirk, Manor Road,
Staplegrove, Taunton TA2 6AP in accordance with the terms of the application,
Ref 38/25/0336, without complying with conditions 1 to 13 attached to planning
permission Ref 38/24/0371, dated 12/02/2025, but instead subject to the
conditions at the Schedule at the end of this decision.
Background and Main Issues
2. Planning permission was granted in 2025 to alter and extend the dwelling at
Westerkirk, and to erect a detached garage. The appellant now seeks to vary
conditions 2 (approved plans), 4 (bat mitigation) and 12 (tree protection) of that
permission, in particular to make elevational changes to the approved proposal.
These would involve the addition of full-height glazing to part of the new extension,
Appeal Decision 6004576
3
and the removal of hanging tiles and some of the render on the existing dwelling. It
is also proposed to vary the bat and tree protection conditions to reflect
subsequent approvals.
3. The main issues are:
• the effect of the proposed changes on the character and appearance of the
area, including the Staplegrove Conservation Area (CA), within which the
site lies, and its effect on Kibby’s, its coach house and stables, which are
Grade II listed, and
• whether conditions 4 and 12 should be amended in respect of trees and
bats.
Reasons
Character and Appearance
4. Section 72 of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990
(the Act) requires that I pay special attention to the desirability of preserving or
enhancing the character or appearance of the CA. Section 66(1) of the same Act
requires that I have special regard to the desirability of preserving the listed
buildings and their settings, or any features of special architectural or historic
interest.
5. The Staplegrove CA covers part of what was historically a rural village, and retains
this feel despite the expansion of Taunton over time. The CA has a mix of
architectural designs, including properties of Arts-and-Crafts, Victorian and
vernacular types and detailing. Relevant to this appeal, the significance of the CA
is the attractive, traditional and semi-rural appearance of its buildings and street
scenes.
6. The dwelling at Westerkirk is adjacent to Kibby’s, including its associated coach
house and stables. Kibby’s consists of a former farmhouse with 17th century
origins. It has architectural interest because of its design, construction and
craftsmanship as a farmhouse. Its detached stable block building is divided
between Kibby’s and the appeal site. It also has architectural interest and aesthetic
value as well as providing a surviving connection between Kibby’s and Westerkirk,
with group value. Applicable to this appeal, the significance of the listed buildings
is their age and setting as part of the semi-rural, historic core of Staplegrove.
7. The appeal dwelling is a large, detached house dating from the early 20th century.
Its design has been influenced by the Arts-and-Crafts style, including having wide
gables and tall chimneys. It was historically accessed from Staplegrove Road, but
this is now taken from Manor Road. The property has an attractive design and
adds to the setting of the listed buildings. As such, it makes a positive contribution
to the CA and constitutes a Non-Designated Heritage Asset.
8. As now proposed, one of the elevations of the Garden Room would have a fully
glazed area extending to the apex of the gable roof, whereas the approved version
has solid walling. I do not doubt that Arts-and-Crafts houses often feature gable
windows, full-height bays and tall, A-shaped roofs, with an emphasis on light,
space and air. Examples nationally include focal-point gables with generous
glazing to help frame landscape views. Some Arts-and-Crafts properties in
Somerset undoubtedly have garden elevations with glazing to provide a ‘living
Appeal Decision 6004576
4
front’. Even so, no specific local instances of a glazing pattern similar to the
proposal have been identified.
9. In respect of the appeal site, a connection to the garden, as well as light to the
Garden Room, would already be provided by the approved bi-fold doors. This part
of the building would not be particularly bulky and so its form does not provide a
justification for the proposed glazing. Westerkirk has a tall full-height staircase
window, but this retains solid wall to the roof and so does not appear unusual. In
contrast, by extending the glazing as proposed, the affected elevation would
appear overtly modern. As such, it would look out of place with the more traditional
appearance of the rest of the house, including the approved extension.
10. It is also proposed to remove hanging tiles on the dwelling, and replace them with
render. The tiles may well not be an original feature, and at the time of my visit had
been temporarily taken off. Nevertheless, hanging tiles give something of a rural,
cottage-like feel to the dwelling. Weathered tiles would be less intrusive than
render in wider views, such as from a nearby footpath. The permanent removal of
the hanging tiles would therefore detract from the appearance of the building.
11. The proposal includes the removal of render, primarily on what was historically the
main elevation. This removal had also taken place at the time of my visit, and has
revealed a stone wall, brick quoins, window details, and a crest. These details may
have originally been intended to be exposed. Removal of the render may prolong
the life of the masonry and avoid damp. I understand that urgent repairs to the
walls are necessary, though works have commenced in any case.
12. Nonetheless, the removal of the render from some sections of the dwelling, and its
introduction on others, would give the impression of this part of the building as
forming separate elements. This would give the south western elevation a
disjointed appearance, undermining the visual cohesion of the building as a whole.
Accordingly, I conclude that this change would also have a negative effect on the
design of the property.
13. Other elements of the works would be acceptable such as changes to the porch.
The development would result in the conservation and enhancement of what is
said to be a dilapidated building, damaged by vacancy, dampness and fire. It
would also involve the removal of collapsed buildings and the replacement of
columns at the entrance. However, these benefits would also flow from the
previously approved scheme. As such, they do not provide a good reason to justify
the harmful effects that I have identified above.
14. Consequently, the proposed changes would have negative effects on the
attractive, traditional and semi-rural appearance of the building as an NDHA and
on the CA as a whole. It would similarly detract from the setting and significance of
Kibby’s and its associated Coach House and Stables, as part of the semi-rural,
historic core of Staplegrove. Having regard to the advice of the Planning Practice
Guidance1 (PPG), I take this view despite the limited publicly obtainable views of
parts of the property.
15. For the reasons given, the proposed amendments would harm the character and
appearance of the area, including the NDHA, CA and adjacent listed buildings. On
this basis, the proposal would conflict with policies CP8 and DM1 of the Taunton
1 Paragraph: 013, Reference ID: 18a-013-20140306
Appeal Decision 6004576
5
Deane Core Strategy, adopted September 2012. These require development to
conserve and enhance the historic environment, and to not unacceptably harm the
character or appearance of a building.
16. For the same reasons, the proposal would not comply with the Act. In accordance
with the National Planning Policy Framework (the Framework), I give great weight
to the harm to the designated heritage assets and their significance. In the
language of the Framework, the proposal would result in less than substantial
harm. That said, no additional public benefits beyond those considered above
have been identified. The balances of Framework paragraphs 215 and 216 do not
therefore indicate approval. It follows that I shall not change the approved plans
relevant to this issue referred to in condition 2.
Trees and Bats
17. In addition to the changes to the building, the appellant also seeks to vary
conditions 4 and 12. The amendment in respect of condition 4 seeks to remove the
requirement to provide photographs of the bat boxes installed for temporary
roosting. Condition 12 is proposed to be amended by omitting the need for
submission of a scheme for the protection of trees. Instead, it would refer to the
scheme that has already been approved by the Council.
18. The proposed changes would not undermine the extent of protection afforded to
these matters. The Council does not object to the changes, and I see little reason
to disagree. Conditions 4 and 12 can therefore be amended in respect of trees and
bats, and to that limited extent the appeal is successful.
Other Matter
19. The site falls within the nutrient catchment area of the Somerset Levels and Moors
Ramsar Site. However, the Council considers that nutrient neutrality would not be
changed by the proposal, and I take the same view. As a result, it is not necessary
for me to consider any likely significant effects on the integrity of the Ramsar Site,
or to undertake an Appropriate Assessment as part of this appeal.
Conditions
20. The PPG makes clear that decision notices for the granting of planning permission
under section 73 should restate conditions previously imposed which continue to
have effect. Even so, work has commenced on site. As such, some conditions
originally imposed need to be amended. The Council has provided a list of revised
conditions. I have assessed and amended these based on the advice of the PPG,
and having sought comments from the Council and the appellant. For clarity, I
have used the same condition numbers as those previously used.
21. As development has already begun, the permission should start from the date of
my decision. I shall impose a condition confirming this. Condition 2, requiring
adherence to the approved plans, is necessary for certainty. I have amended this
condition only to the extent of the numbering of the topographical plans, to be
consistent with the other plans.
22. The other conditions remain for the same reasons as originally proposed, albeit re-
worded in accordance with the PPG and to reflect that work has commenced,
including in respect of conditions 4 and 12. However, I have deleted conditions 6
Appeal Decision 6004576
6
and 7. This is because any effects on birds and reptiles relevant to these
conditions will already have occurred now that work has started.
Conclusion
23. For the reasons given above, I conclude that the appeal should succeed, but only
in respect of the matters I refer to above. I will grant a new planning permission
subject to the conditions in the Schedule below.
O Marigold
INSPECTOR
Appeal Decision 6004576
7
Schedule of Conditions
1) Notwithstanding the time limits given to implement planning permission as
prescribed by Sections 91 and 92 of the Town and Country Planning Act
1990 (as amended), this permission (being granted under section 73A of the
Act in respect of development being carried out) shall have effect from the
date of this decision.
2) The development hereby permitted shall be carried out in accordance with
the following approved plans:
(A4) DrNo 01 Location Plan,
(A4) DrNo 02 Existing Block Plan,
(A1) DrNo 03 Existing Site Survey,
(A1) DrNo 04 Existing Ground Floor Plan, First Floor Plan & Elevations,
(A3) DrNo 16 Existing Plan & Elevations,
(A2) DrNo 17 Existing Plan & Elevations Veterinary Building,
(A1) DrNo 18 Rev A Proposed Demolition Plan
(A1) DrNo 30 Rev C Proposed Ground Floor Plan & First Floor Plan,
(A1) DrNo 31 Rev C Proposed Elevations SK09
(A3) DrNo 32 Proposed Garage Plans & Elevations
(A3) DrNo 33 Proposed Entrance Way Plan & Elevations
(A1) DrNo 34 Rev A Proposed Site Plan SK09
(A4) DrNo 35 Proposed Block Plan SK09
3) Works to any of the buildings shall cease within one month of the date of this
decision unless the Local Planning Authority has been provided with either
(a) a copy of the licence issued by Natural England pursuant to Regulation
55 of The Conservation of Habitats and Species Regulations 2017
authorising the development to go ahead; or (b) a statement in writing from a
licensed bat ecologist to the effect that he/she considers that the specified
development does not require a licence. Works shall not recommence until
these details have been provided.
4) (i) No internal works to the dwelling shall take place until an internal survey
for bats within the loft spaces has taken place. Should a bat be present within
any loft areas, a licensed bat ecologist shall capture the bat and move it to
the bat box located on the coach house and mature trees. The bat licensed
ecologist will supervise the 'soft' dismantling of the roof and any features
such as ridge, soffits, lead flashing, felt, mortar and the wooden boards at the
windows where appropriate. Soft dismantling will be undertaken by hand and
hand tools only, each tile will be removed gently pulled away from the roof to
avoid crushing, and careful ridge removal and a thorough check within the
ridge line will be undertaken by hand. Other features shall be carefully and
inspected for the presence of bats and/or bat evidence. Should any bats be
present, the licensed bat worker shall relocate the bat to an existing bat box.
Once the features suitable to support roosting bats have been dismantled
then works can continue unsupervised. Should a bat be discovered at any
other time then works shall cease and the licensed bat ecologist contacted
Appeal Decision 6004576
8
for advice. Anyone who is not a licensed bat ecologist is strictly forbidden
from handling bats.
(ii) The development hereby approved shall not be occupied until:
• The loft space has been segregated off from the main roof to support
bats, and a sign erected on the boxed off loft space advertising the
presence of a bat roost,
• 10 bat access points have been installed and a breathable felt used.
• Two ridge access points have been installed at the southeastern ridge
to provide direct access into the roof void.
• details of two post-monitoring surveys, and a written statement and/or
photographs of the mitigation measures, have been submitted to and
approved in writing by the Local Planning Authority.
The approved bat boxes for temporary roosting shall be maintained in-situ
thereafter.
5) No external lighting shall be installed within the site unless it is in accordance
with details that have first been submitted to and approved in writing by the
Local Planning Authority.
6) Deleted.
7) Deleted.
8) The development hereby approved shall not be occupied until the following
features have been submitted to and approved in writing by the Local
Planning Authority and the approved details have been installed:
• Two bird boxes around the site boundaries or on buildings.
• One bee brick.
• One log pile on the southern boundary.
9) Notwithstanding the provisions of the Town and Country Planning (General
Permitted Development) Order 2015 (or any order revoking and re-enacting
that Order), the use of the garage thereby permitted as part of this
development shall not be used other than for parking and for no other use.
10) The development hereby approved shall not be occupied until space for the
parking and turning of four vehicles within the site has been laid out, drained
and surfaced, in accordance with details that shall first have been submitted
to and approved in writing by the Local Planning Authority, and such area(s)
shall not thereafter be used for any purpose other than the parking and
turning of vehicles associated with the development.
11) Notwithstanding the provisions of the Town and Country Planning (General
Permitted Development) (England) Order 2015, or any order revoking and re-
enacting that Order, with or without modifications, no vehicular access gates
shall be erected at any time unless they are set back a minimum distance of
6 metres behind the highway boundary and hung so as to open inwards only.
12) Works to any of the buildings shall cease within one month of the date of this
decision and shall not commence until protective tree fencing has been
erected and the scheme for the protection of trees to be retained has been
Appeal Decision 6004576
9
implemented, in accordance with the Tree Protection Details approved by the
Local Planning Authority on 20th May 2025. The fencing and scheme shall
be maintained and retained for the full duration of works. No construction
activities shall take place within the protected areas.
13) The development hereby approved shall not be occupied until a scheme of
landscaping has been submitted to and approved in writing by the Local
Planning Authority. The scheme shall include details of all existing trees and
hedgerows on the land and those to be retained. All planting, seeding or
turfing comprised in the approved details of landscaping shall be carried out
in the first planting and seeding seasons following the occupation of the
building. Any trees or plants which within a period of five years from the
completion of the development die, are removed or become seriously
damaged or diseased shall be replaced in the next planting season with
others of similar size and species.
End of Conditions
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.