Conversion of loft level to create an ensuite bedroom, including the addition of 2 no. rooflights, installation of internal staircase and alterations to roof purlins
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Heritage & Conservation
Policy Weight
Conversion/Use
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 12 May 2026
by V Simpson BSc (Hons) MSc MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 2 June 2026
Appeal A Ref: 6004170
Lamyatt Lodge, Portway Hill, Lamyatt, Shepton Mallet BA4 6NP
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 (as amended)
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by George Hallam against the decision of Somerset Council.
• The application Ref is 2024/1948/HSE.
• The development proposed is the conversion of loft level to create an ensuite bedroom, including the
addition of 2 no. rooflights, installation of internal staircase and alterations to roof purlins.
Appeal B Ref: 6004169
Lamyatt Lodge, Portway Hill, Lamyatt, Shepton Mallet BA4 6NP
• The appeal is made under section 20 of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act
1990 (as amended) against a refusal to grant listed building consent.
• The appeal is made by George Hallam against the decision of Somerset Council.
• The application Ref is 2024/1949/LBC.
• The development proposed is the conversion of loft level to create an ensuite bedroom, including the
addition of 2 no. rooflights, installation of internal staircase and alterations to roof purlins.
Decisions
Appeal A
1. The appeal is dismissed
Appeal B
2. The appeal is dismissed
Preliminary Matters
3. The appeal site contains the Grade II Listed building known as Lamyatt Lodge1
(the Listed Building). Consequently, in reaching my decision, I have exercised my
statutory duties under sections 66(1) and 16(2) of the Planning (Listed Buildings
and Conservation Areas) Act 1990 – as amended (the Act).
4. The appeals relate to the same site and the same scheme. Unless stated
otherwise, and despite the differences in the planning permission and listed
building consent regimes, I have dealt with both appeals together. This is to avoid
unnecessary repetition.
5. The description of the scheme on the application form included reference to
alterations to roof purlins. However, prior to the Council’s determination of the
applications, amended plans were submitted – which are subject of these appeals.
1 Official list entry number 1274169
Appeal Decisions 6004170 and 6004169
2
These plans indicate that existing purlins are to be retained. Therefore, and
notwithstanding the description of the proposals in the banner above, these
appeals are dealt with on the basis that the works and development do not include
alterations to the roof purlins.
6. I understand that planning permission and listed building consent2 have been
granted for works and development which include the formation of an en-suite to
bedroom 2. Moreover, while onsite I noted that the works associated with the
formation of the en-suite to bedroom 2 were well advanced. However, the ceiling
of this en-suite was observed to be substantially higher than that of the associated
bedroom. The height of the en-suite appears to have been secured by the removal
of parts of the first-floor ceiling and ceiling joists above it. An effect of which has
been to raise the floor level of that part of the attic that is above this en-suite.
Although this raised floor level does not appear to be reflected in the existing plans
or details submitted in support of these appeals, I proceed to determine the
appeals based on the scheme indicated on the submitted plans.
Main Issue
7. The main issue is whether the development and works would preserve the Grade
II Listed Building or its setting or any features of special architectural or historic
interest which it possesses.
Reasons
Significance
8. According to the associated official list entry, the Listed Building comprises an
early 19th century house, with a large lower height wing to the rear. However, in
light of the content of the heritage statement and the heritage appeal statement, I
accept that much of the large rubble stone rear wing of the property is likely to
have been built as a farmhouse in the 18th century, and that the formal Georgian
frontage is an addition dating from the early part of the 19th Century. While the
house has been subject to later alterations and additions - which have included a
secondary and higher roof structure to parts of the rear wing, much of the historic
fabric, including parts of the early roof structure – which is an important structural
feature of the early farmhouse, and sections of early internal walls remain in-situ.
9. Having regard to the above, the significance of the Listed Building is mainly
derived from its architectural and historic interests, as a good example of a house
that has grown in size and stature over time. Important contributors in these
respects are the legibility of the 2 main stages of its historic development, and the
distinctive design, form and materials associated with each. It is also from its
surviving historic fabric and the remaining early plan form of parts of the house.
10. On the basis that at least part of the Listed Building comprises a historic former
farmhouse, it also gains some significance from the agricultural land that forms
part of its setting.
Effects of the works and development
11. It is imperative that proposals are accompanied by drawings and specifications of
sufficient detail to illustrate and/or describe the proposed works and development.
2 Application references: 2023/1737/FUL and 2023/1738/LBC
Appeal Decisions 6004170 and 6004169
3
This is to avoid any uncertainty over what is proposed, and to allow a robust
assessment of any consequent effects. This is especially important given the
building’s Grade II Listed status – a designated heritage asset of national
importance.
12. However, the full extent and nature of the works and development that would be
required to provide the attic bedroom and associated en-suite cannot be
ascertained from the submitted plans and supporting information – which includes
a structural methodology statement. That being the case, and even if the physical
alterations that would be undertaken would relate to only a small proportion of the
Listed Building, it has not been possible to comprehensively assess the effect of all
the works and development on its significance.
13. Nevertheless, the installation of the proposed rooflights would require sections of
both early and later rafters to be cut out. Furthermore, the insertion and
subsequent use of the staircase between the first floor and the attic bedroom
would require the removal of a portion of historic internal wall. Such operations
would lead to a harmful and irreversible loss of parts of the historic fabric of the
building that contribute positively to its significance as a designated heritage asset.
The subdivision of the en-suite bathroom would also further erode the historic plan
form of the Listed Building.
14. Even if works and developments have previously been authorised that have
sanctioned the loss of sections of the building’s historic fabric, this does not justify
the further loss and associated harm that would be caused by the implementation
of the proposed scheme.
15. I accept that the profile of the existing roofs would be unchanged by the
implementation of the scheme, and note the presence of an existing rooflight
within the same side of the roof as the proposed roof-lights. However, even if the
proposed rooflights would not be readily visible from publicly accessible land, they
would disrupt and harmfully clutter a section of roof that broadly reflects the
distinctive and simple vernacular character of the early farmhouse within the Listed
Building.
16. The works and development subject of these appeals relate only to the house at
Lamyatt Lodge. Consequently, the contribution that the setting makes to the
significance of this Listed Building would be preserved. Nevertheless, and
irrespective of any additional works and development that may be required to form
the en-suite bedroom and to install 2 no. rooflights and an internal staircase, the
previously identified operations would harmfully erode the integrity and
significance of this designated heritage asset.
Public benefits / heritage balance
17. In line with paragraph 212 of the National Planning Policy Framework (the
Framework), I give great weight to the conservation of the Listed Building.
18. The previously identified works and development relate to a small proportion of the
whole Listed Building. That being the case, the associated harm that would be
caused to the significance of the Listed Building would be to the lower end of the
scale of less than substantial. Nevertheless, this finding of harm carries
considerable importance and weight.
Appeal Decisions 6004170 and 6004169
4
19. Paragraph 215 of the Framework indicates that where a development will lead to
less than substantial harm to the significance of a designated heritage asset, this
harm should be weighed against the benefits of the proposal, including where
appropriate, securing its optimum viable use.
20. From the evidence before me, I cannot be certain that the retained trusses and
purlins would be better revealed as part of the interior of the proposed bedroom.
Therefore, any associated public benefit cannot be assured.
21. Without the enlargement of the house, the scheme would enable the formation of
an additional bedroom with an en-suite. However, the house is already large, and I
do not doubt that it provides adequate living conditions. Consequently, the benefit
to the appellant and to future occupiers from the enlargement and/or the
enhancement of the living accommodation would mainly be a private benefit rather
than a public benefit - as set out in the Government’s Planning Practice
Guidance3.
22. Economic benefits would arise during the implementation of the scheme. However,
if the works and development were not undertaken, I do not anticipate the
cessation of the use of the house or that maintenance to it would cease.
23. Because of the modest scale of the scheme, the previously identified public
benefits would be small, and very little weight is attributed to them. Overall, the
public benefits would not outweigh the harm that would be caused to the
significance of the Listed Building.
24. For the reasons given, the development and works would preserve the setting of
the Grade II Listed Building. However, they would not preserve the building itself or
any features of special architectural or historic interest which it possesses.
Consequently, the scheme would fail to satisfy the requirements of the Act, and
the provisions of the Framework that seek to conserve and enhance the historic
environment. It would also conflict with policies DP1, DP3 and DP7 of the Local
Plan4. Collectively and amongst other things, these policies seek to ensure that
schemes preserve the significance of heritage assets, and contribute positively to
the maintenance and enhancement of local identity. Where this would not occur,
they require any related harm to be balanced against the wider benefits that would
arise from the proposal.
Other Matters
25. It is understood that the appeal site is within the catchment area for the Somerset
Levels and Moors Ramsar site (the Ramsar site). However, given my findings on
the main issue, further consideration of the effect of the scheme on the Ramsar
site would serve little purpose.
26. The Railings on Roadside to Frontage of Lamyatt Lodge are also Grade II Listed5
(the Railings). The significance of this heritage asset is mainly derived from its
historic and architectural interest. However, it also gains some significance from its
group value with Lamyatt Lodge, and from the contribution the house at Lamyatt
Lodge makes to its setting. The main parties agree that the appeal scheme would
not affect the significance of the Railings, and I have no reason to find otherwise.
3 Paragraph: 020 Reference ID: 18a-020-20190723
4 Mendip District Council – Mendip District Local Plan 2006-2029 Part 1: Strategy and Policies – adopted December 2014
5 Official list entry number: 1059185
Appeal Decisions 6004170 and 6004169
5
That being the case, the setting of the Railings would be preserved, and its
significance would not be harmed by the proposed works and development.
However, this is a neutral consideration.
Conclusion
27. The development subject of appeal A would conflict with the development plan as
a whole, and there are no material considerations, either individually or in
combination, that outweigh the identified harm and associated development plan
conflict. I therefore conclude that this appeal should be dismissed.
28. Moreover, and for the reasons previously given, I also conclude that appeal B
should be dismissed.
V Simpson
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.