Single storey rear extension with lantern roof
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Residential Amenity
Extensions
Trees & Landscape
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 25 February 2026
by Eleni Marshall BSc (hons) MSc FRICS FAAV MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 02 March 2026
Appeal Ref: 6003582
8 Hall Lane, Pelsall, Walsall, WS3 4JQ
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 against a refusal
to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Ms Aulfat Bi against Walsall Metropolitan Borough Council.
• The application Ref is 25/0835.
• The development proposed is single storey rear extension with lantern roof.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Procedural Matters
2. I have utilised the Council’s description of the proposal as I find it describes the
proposal more concisely.
3. The existing plans (EMP.101.7) do not appear to accurately reflect the existing built
form on site given that the conservatory, as built, appears to project further than the
current kitchen window which can be gauged by the presence of an external door,
to the conservatory, at a right angle to the kitchen window. This is not on the plans.
Main Issue
4. The main issue is the impact of the proposal upon neighbouring residential amenity
with regard to outlook, overbearing scale and unacceptable impact.
Reasons
5. The appeal site is a semi-detached residential dwelling which already benefits from
extensions including, as confirmed by the appellant, a double storey side extension
and an existing single storey rear extension. Based upon the plans before me
(EMP.101.7 – existing plans and EMP.101.8 – proposed plans) it is evident that the
proposed extension would, cumulatively with the existing extensions, extend in the
region of 6 metres from the original rear elevation wall of the host dwelling. I do,
however, note the presence of the party wall between the appeal site and its
attached dwelling, the existing extensions and their as-built depth.
6. Despite this, I do not find that the wall, and the existing conservatories, result in an
enclosed baseline condition with enclosed outlook by its nature. The joint party
wall extends in the region of 4 metres between the properties; the proposal would
continue and exceed this notably. Assessing the proposals in the context of the
existing extension, and wall, I find that the proposal could not be considered
incremental and would be unacceptable, resulting harmful impact to the residential
amenity of 6 Hall Lane (no. 6) with regard to outlook and overbearing scale.
Appeal Decision 6003582
2
7. I note the appellant’s contention that the Council have taken the 45-degree
measurement from the rear of the adjacent conservatory rather than from a
habitable room of the main dwelling. I do not have any information as to the
connectivity, or use, of the conservatory in the context of the adjacent property but
even accepting the appellant’s argument that the conservatory is not classified as a
habitable room I still find that the proposal would be unacceptable as a result of
height and projection, from the appeal property in relation to impact upon no. 6.
8. 10 Hall Lane, (no. 10) has an external door and window in the side elevation facing
towards the appeal proposal. The window in question is linked to the kitchen and is
acknowledged to be a secondary window for the habitable room. It is outlined that
there is a connection to the dining room to the rear which would act as a primary
window which would remain unaffected in terms of light and overbearing impact.
There is no breach of the 45-degree code from the primary rear window further
supporting there would be no unacceptable loss of light or outlook as a result of this
guidance. Whilst the window facing towards the proposal is a secondary window,
the proposal would seek to increase the depth of the neighbouring property, from
the existing built form, by a further 4 metres (resulting in a cumulative total from the
original rear elevation of in the region of 6 metres) immediately along the shared
boundary with the appeal site already having been extended, at two storeys, to the
side towards no. 10. There would, therefore, be an extension and continuation of
built form within close proximity to the kitchen window at no. 10.
9. I acknowledge that the side elevation window is not the sole source of light to the
room in question and that there is a rear facing window, unaffected, by the
proposals but based upon the evidence before me it must be kept in mind that
overbearingness and impact as to light are separate matters. Whilst the impact
with regard to loss of light to the kitchen via the side facing window would be
acceptable, I find that the proposal would still result in an unacceptable overbearing
impact on the neighbouring amenity, as well as impact upon general outlook, due to
the bulk, scale and massing in such close proximity to the side facing window. I
find that the proposed single storey extension would, therefore, have an
overbearing and unacceptable impact upon no. 10.
10. I do not find the presence of a secondary window is sufficient to overcome concern
as to outlook or overbearingness in that regard. I do not find that the separation
highlighted by the appellant materially reduces enclosure or overbearing impact.
The proposal, cumulatively with the existing extensions, would be unacceptable
seeking to extend further, full width, off the already (side) extended appeal
property. It must be taken into account that in assessing extensions their
relationship individually, and cumulatively, in the context of the original dwelling,
and its relationship with adjacent properties, is of relevance. In this case,
cumulatively, the proposals would result in an overall rear projection of in the region
of 6 metres from the original rear wall, including utilisation of additional width as a
result of the existing side extension up to the shared boundary.
11. Whilst the area may be characterised by a variety of domestic extensions and rear
building lines, the main issue with the proposal is not the principle of an extension.
The issues I have identified, for the reasons outlined above, relate to actual impact
based upon the site context and relationship of the appeal site, and proposal, with
the dwellings either side with regard to the amenity of existing and future occupiers
of those properties.
Appeal Decision 6003582
3
12. The proposal would be contrary to Walsall Unitary Development Plan 2005 (saved
policies) GP2 which seeks to resist development which would have an
unacceptable adverse impact on the environment taking into account residential
amenity and ENV32 which seeks to avoid proposals which fail to properly take
account of the context or surroundings (in this case adjacent residential dwellings).
The proposal would be contrary to Black Country Core Strategy 2011 Policy CSP4
and Policy ENV3 which, in terms of overarching objectives, both seek to ensure
high quality design.
13. The proposal would also be contrary to paragraph 135 of the National Planning
Policy Framework 2024 which seeks to create places with a high standard of
amenity for existing and future users as well as being contrary to the Designing
Walsall Supplementary Planning Document for Urban Design 2008, Appendix D,
which advises that proposals must ensure that all occupants have a satisfactory
level of amenity.
Other Matters
14. Third party comments have been received from 10 Hall Lane along with
photographs which are stated to have been taken from the kitchen towards the
appeal site/location of the proposal. I have dealt with matters with regard to light
and outlook within the main issues of the decision letter above and I also note that
comment is raised with regard to disruption to existing planting and landscaping at
the neighbouring property. Landscaping and loss of planting would not, however,
be a material planning consideration but, either way, for the reasons outlined above
I have found that there is sufficient concern with regard to the impact of the
proposals on neighbouring amenity to dismiss this appeal.
Conclusion
15. For the reasons outlined above, and taking into account all other matters raised, I
conclude that the appeal should be dismissed.
Eleni Marshall
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.