None
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Heritage & Conservation
Character & Appearance
Policy Weight
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 16 February 2026
by F Harrison BA(Hons) MA MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 9th March 2026
Appeal Ref: 6002479
Alvin House, 9 South End, Hartlepool TS25 1DB
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 (as amended)
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Jim Borthwick against the decision of Hartlepool Borough Council.
• The application Ref is H/2025/0140.
• The development proposed is the erection of entrance porch and the erection of a fence
(part retrospective)
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Preliminary Matters
2. I observed that some elements of the proposal have been undertaken, which
appear to broadly accord with what is shown on the plans. However, as the
development at the site is not in its finished state, for clarity, I have determined the
appeal on the basis of the submitted plans
Main Issue
3. The main issue is the effect of the proposal on the character and appearance of
the surrounding area, bearing in mind it would be in the Seaton Carew
Conservation Area (SCCA) and adjacent to Grade II listed buildings.
Reasons
4. The appeal site accommodates an end of terrace property, set back from the road
by a deep front garden. Despite some differences in appearance including ridge
height and materiality, the short row of terraces are in general harmony with each
other owing to the similarity of the built form which creates a sense of balance that
contributes positively to the character and appearance of the area.
5. The site falls within the SCCA and there are Grade II listed buildings nearby.
Mindful of the statutory duty set out in sections 66(1) and 72(1) of the Planning
(Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990 (as amended) (the Act) I have
paid special attention to the desirability of preserving or enhancing the character or
appearance of the conservation area, and of preserving the listed buildings or their
setting or any features of special architectural or historic interest they possess.
6. From my observations and the SCCA Appraisal and Management Plan (2025) (the
Appraisal), the significance of the SCCA, insofar as it is relevant to this case, is
derived from the historic pattern of development defining how the settlement has
Appeal Decision 6002479
2
developed over time and includes the informal layout, position and vernacular form
of modest cottages associated with the settlement’s roots, including those on
South End. As part of a row of terraces on South End, the appeal site makes a
positive contribution to the SCCA.
7. 8 South End adjoining the appeal property is a Grade II listed building, included for
group value with No 7. Their special interest and significance stems from their
historic and architectural interest as early/mid eighteenth and nineteenth century
cottages with limestone rubble and clay pantile roofs. Nos 5 and 6 is also a Grade
II listed building, the special interest and significance of the pair of terraced houses
is derived in part from their architectural interest and their historic fabric. The
settings of the listed terraces comprise the streetscape within which they are
located, including the appeal site which has a visual relationship with the listed
buildings. As part of the short row of terraces the appeal site makes a positive
contribution to the listed buildings, even if the appeal property itself is not listed.
8. Irrespective of the mathematical proportion of the porch in relation to the elevation,
owing to the scale and massing of the projection the proposal would be a
prominent addition, unbalancing the character and appearance of the appeal
property and the row of terraces. The porch’s width would ensure that the ridge is
centralised as much as possible within the main elevation. Yet the bulky
proportions and significant projection from the main elevation, in relation to its
surroundings where there is an absence of porches, would result in the proposal
being a discordant feature in the street scene.
9. Despite the appeal property’s set back from the road and intervening vegetation,
the porch would be visible above the proposed boundary treatment on approach
from South End, Regal Close and in either direction from Tees Road. In these
views, the porch would stand out as being incongruous because it is not reflective
of the rest of the terraces and due to its prominent form. The proposal would not
be physically attached to the listed building at No 8, nor obscure views of it or the
wider terrace. However, such a prominent form of development would disrupt the
general harmony and rhythm of the heritage assets which are noted in the
Appraisal as key buildings within Character Area 2: South of the SCCA.
10. I observed the use of brick in the wider surrounding area, including at the bottom
of the rear extension at the appeal property, however it does not feature on the
main elevation of the properties on South End. While it would add a contrast to the
cream render at the appeal property, the limited visual connection with the rest of
the terrace means that it would draw the eye, exacerbating the proposal’s
incongruity. A condition could be imposed to secure the use of render to match the
existing property however this would not overcome the harmful scale and massing.
11. Porches can fall under permitted development, are commonplace on smaller
period properties with narrow hallways and are not prohibited by the development
plan. Nevertheless, Policy HSG11 of the Hartlepool Local Plan (2018) (HLP)
requires extensions to be of a size, design and use materials that are sympathetic
to the existing dwelling and surrounding area and HLP Policy QP4 requires that
development positively enhances its location and setting. As explained above, that
would not be the case with the appeal scheme in this sensitive historic location.
12. The door to the appeal property would be on the side of the porch to reduce
exposure to the North Sea and reduce heat loss. A tall window would be located
Appeal Decision 6002479
3
centrally which provides a focal point, and it would not be readily discernible above
the boundary treatment that it was not a door. As such this detail in itself would not
be a detrimental component.
13. Overall, the proposal would appear out of place, detracting from the historic
environment and would not preserve or enhance the character or appearance of
the SCCA and would harm its significance as a whole. It follows that it would also
not preserve the setting of the listed buildings. The proposal would not therefore
meet the requirements of the Act or the provisions in the National Planning Policy
Framework (the Framework) regarding the conservation and enhancement of the
historic environment.
14. In coming to this conclusion, I have taken into account that the SCCA is identified
as a heritage asset at risk on Historic England’s register of sites that are most at
risk of being lost because of neglect, decay or inappropriate development. The
retention, protection and enhancement of heritage assets at risk is identified as a
priority for the Council under HLP Policy HE7.
15. Due to the scale and nature of the proposal relative to the designated heritage
assets, the degree of harm to the significance of the SCCA and the listed buildings
would be less than substantial, and towards the lower end of the spectrum.
Nevertheless, the Framework requires that great weight should be given to the
conservation of heritage assets, irrespective of the level of harm. Any harm to the
significance of a designated heritage asset should also require a clear and
convincing justification and be weighed against the public benefits.
16. The proposal would increase the accessibility of the property as the proposed
wider steps would be easier to traverse than the previous narrow steps. Even if a
scheme is not permissible under permitted development because of the required
height taking account of the difference of internal and external floor levels, it has
not been shown that the proposal is the only way to achieve the appellant’s aim for
greater accessibility and so this matter attracts limited weight.
17. The height of the proposed boundary treatment was reduced during the application
stage and the plans show a boundary treatment of a 1 metre timber fence with a
yew hedge which is not in dispute. I see no clear reason to disagree. However,
this, and any other policy compliance would be a neutral matter, weighing neither
for nor against the appeal scheme. The Council’s handling of the application has
not affected my consideration of the planning merits of the case.
18. Taking the above into consideration, the sum of the public benefits of the proposal
would not outweigh the harm to the significance of the designated heritage assets
that I have identified, and the considerable importance and weight this carries.
19. To conclude, the proposal would be unduly harmful to the character and
appearance of the surrounding area, failing to preserve the SCCA and the
adjacent Grade II listed buildings. It would be in conflict with HLP Policies HE1,
HE3, HE4, HE7, HSG11 and QP4 insofar as they require development within a
conservation area and the setting of a listed building to be of a high quality design
and conserve and/or enhance the historic environment and heritage assets at risk,
weighing any less than substantial harm against the public benefits.
Appeal Decision 6002479
4
Conclusion
20. My above findings bring the proposal into conflict with the development plan, read
as a whole. There are no material considerations that indicate a decision should
be made other than in accordance with it. Therefore, I conclude that the appeal
should be dismissed.
F Harrison
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.