Variation of planning approval 24/0979/OUT - Condition Numbers: U0185992 Materials, U0185993 Approved Drawings, U0185998 Restrictions on use of roof to allow for addition of a new flat rooflight above the ground floor boot room, to raise the parapet height of the single storey side return extension by 225mm, extension of the existing first floor terrace, updated landscape design, addition of new minimal frame sliding doors to garden room. To replace the approved drawings’ without complying with a condition attached to planning
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Heritage & Conservation
Character & Appearance
Policy Weight
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decisions
Site visit made on 9 December 2025
by Sylvia Leonard BA (Hons) BTP MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 22 January 2026
Appeal A Ref: 6000386
27 Baronsmead Road, Barnes, Richmond Upon Thames, London, SW13 9RR
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 (as amended)
against a refusal to grant planning permission under section 73 of the Town and Country Planning
Act 1990 (as amended) for the development of land without complying with a condition subject to
which a previous planning permission was granted.
• The appeal is made by Daniel Yates against the decision of the London Borough of Richmond Upon
Thames.
• The application Ref is PA25/1612.
• The application sought planning permission for ‘Variation of planning approval 24/0979/OUT -
Condition Numbers: U0185992 Materials, U0185993 Approved Drawings, U0185998 Restrictions on
use of roof to allow for addition of a new flat rooflight above the ground floor boot room, to raise the
parapet height of the single storey side return extension by 225mm, extension of the existing first
floor terrace, updated landscape design, addition of new minimal frame sliding doors to garden room .
To replace the approved drawings’ without complying with a condition attached to planning
permission Ref 25/0182/VRC, dated 18 March 2025.
• The condition in dispute is No. C4 which states that: The development hereby permitted shall be
carried out in accordance with the following approved plans and documents, where applicable:
A10_E00; A10_P00; and 23988_A10_LSLP received 17 April 2024; and
A10_P01 REV B; A10_E01 REV A; received 24 January 2025.
• The reason given for the condition is: To accord with the terms of the application, for the avoidance
of doubt and in the interests of proper planning.
Appeal B Ref: 6000387
27 Baronsmead Road, Barnes, Richmond Upon Thames, London, SW13 9RR
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 (as amended)
against a refusal to grant planning permission under section 73 of the Town and Country Planning
Act 1990 (as amended) for the development of land without complying with a condition subject to
which a previous planning permission was granted.
• The appeal is made by Daniel Yates against the decision of the London Borough of Richmond Upon
Thames.
• The application Ref is PA25/1617.
• The application sought planning permission for Variation of planning approval 24/0979/OUT -
Condition Numbers: U0185992 Materials, U0185993 Approved Drawings, U0185998 Restrictions on
use of roof to allow for addition of a new flat rooflight above the ground floor boot room, to raise the
parapet height of the single storey side return extension by 225mm, extension of the existing first
floor terrace, updated landscape design, addition of new minimal frame sliding doors to garden
room. To replace the approved drawings’ without complying with a condition attached to planning
permission Ref 25/0182/VRC, dated 18 March 2025.
• The condition in dispute is No. C4 which states that: The development hereby permitted shall be
carried out in accordance with the following approved plans and documents, where applicable:
A10_E00; A10_P00; and 23988_A10_LSLP received 17 April 2024; and
A10_P01 REV B; A10_E01 REV A; received 24 January 2025.
• The reason given for the condition is: To accord with the terms of the application, for the avoidance
of doubt and in the interests of proper planning.
Appeal Decisions 6000386 and 6000387
2
Decisions
1. Appeal A is dismissed.
2. Appeal B is dismissed.
Preliminary Matters
3. There are two appeals relating to similar proposals on the same site. The schemes
were refused on the same date and differ only in respect of the design of the
proposed rear mansard outrigger extension. I have dealt with each case on its
individual merits, but to avoid duplication, both appeals are considered together in
this decision, except where otherwise indicated.
4. The description of development on each decision notice states that the
applications comprise a variation of planning approval 24/0979/HOT. However, the
descriptions of development for both appeals in the banner heading above are
taken from the application forms and supporting letters submitted with each
planning application, as well as the appellant’s subsequent written confirmation
that both applications relate to a proposed variation of condition No.4 of
permission Ref 25/0182/VRC.
5. For clarity, approval Ref 25/0182/VRC granted a variation of an earlier permission
Ref 24/0979/HOT, dated 29 July 2024, for extension of the existing basement
including the addition of front and rear light wells; a single storey rear extension; a
part single/part two storey side extension; an extension to the roof; and
replacement railings.
6. As such, Appeals A and B each seek further cumulative changes to permission
Ref 24/0979/HOT, as amended by approval Ref 25/0182/VRC. Appeal A proposes
to increase the width of the rear mansard outrigger to the full width of the extended
dwelling and Appeal B proposes to extend its width by 2.1m.
7. The main parties have confirmed that the decision notice for 25/0182/VRC
contains a typographical error and that the listed approved plan ‘A10_EO1 Rev A’
should be ‘Proposed Elevations drawing Ref A10_P01 Rev A’. I have dealt with
both appeals accordingly.
8. Since the determination of the applications the subject of these appeals, the
Council has adopted the Richmond Upon Thames Local Plan ‘the best for our
borough’ 2024 to 2039 (7 October 2025) (the Local Plan). This supersedes the
previous London Borough of Richmond Upon Thames Local Plan (July 2018). The
main parties have had the opportunity to comment upon the implications of the
adoption of the Local Plan.
Main Issue
9. The main issue in the case of both appeals is the effect of the proposal on the
character and appearance of the host property and the wider surrounding area.
Reasons
10. The Council’s view is that an extension to the rear outrigger did not form part of the
original and subsequently amended approved schemes, and that, as such, it would
necessitate a change of development description, so that it cannot be considered
an amendment to the previously approved schemes.
Appeal Decisions 6000386 and 6000387
3
11. This accords with the Finney Judgment1 which established that an application
under s73 may not be used to obtain a permission that would require a variation to
the terms of the ‘operative’ part of the planning permission, which would include,
the description of the development for which the original permission was granted.
12. In considering this matter I have had regard to the MHCLG publication Permitted
Development Rights for Householders Technical Guidance (September 2019) (the
Technical Guidance) which confirms that houses will often have more than two
side elevation walls. Having regard to the illustrated example within the Technical
Guidance, I am satisfied that the side wall of the original outrigger would comprise
a wall forming a side elevation.
13. As such, the schemes the subject of both Appeal A and Appeal B would fall within
the original description of development which includes a ‘part single/part two
storey side extension and extension to the roof.’
14. The appeal property comprises a large semi-detached 3-storey period dwelling
with brick walls under a tiled pitched roof, which accommodates the second floor
living space. It lies in a prominent location on the corner of Baronsmead Road and
Ferry Road within an established residential area.
15. The appeal property makes a positive contribution to the Baronsmead Road
streetscape. It forms an integral part of a street scene comprising a row of similarly
designed pairs of attractive houses which front both sides of the street. These
result in a prevailing uniformity of built development comprising rows of semi-
detached houses of a similar height and scale, having consistent front and rear
building lines and being set within long rectangular-shaped plots arranged
perpendicularly to the road.
16. The dwellings, including the appeal property, collectively result in a cohesive
townscape, having regard to a prevalence of similar materials, roof forms and
architectural detailing. These include brick walls, timber sliding sash windows,
decorative headers and cills, square front-facing bay windows at ground and first
floor level and pairs of matching recessed front porches with decorative surrounds.
17. The roofscape is characterised by slate and tiled pitched roofs with prominent
front-facing feature gables, as well as decorative tile edging, potted brick chimney
stacks and parapets. The properties are positioned close to the road frontage with
small front gardens enclosed by low boundary walls, so that the design quality of
the houses is readily apparent in public views from the street.
18. The appeal property also has a visible presence within the Ferry Road streetscape
where its side and rear elevations, particularly the upper floors which rise above
the height of the side boundary wall, are visible in views from the public realm of
the street and from neighbouring properties.
19. Prior to the grant of approval Ref 24/0979/HOT, the property benefitted from a
single storey side conservatory addition and a three-storey rear out-rigger
projection incorporating a mansard-style roof accommodating the second floor
living accommodation as well as a first-floor side roof terrace.
20. The low height of the glazed roof conservatory and the set-back position of the
outrigger from the Ferry Road frontage meant that the architectural integrity of the
1 John Leslie Finney v Welsh Ministers & Carmarthenshire County Council, Energiekontor (Uk) Limited
Appeal Decisions 6000386 and 6000387
4
main part of the original dwelling continued to be appreciated in views from Ferry
Road. In particular, the combined width and height of the outrigger meant that it
did not obstruct the western-most rear elevation first and second floor windows
and it also enabled the original roof form of the property to be fully appreciated in
views from Ferry Road.
21. Extant permissions 24/0979/HOT and 25/0182/VRC result in the main dwelling
being extended so that it is closer to Ferry Road, whilst still maintaining the
character and architectural integrity of the original property and enabling it to still
be appreciated when viewed from the side and rear, as well as from Baronsmead
Road.
22. This is largely due to the unaltered width of the first and second floor elements of
the rear outrigger which means that this element of the building would remain
clearly subservient to the main dwelling and it would preserve views of much of the
main pitched roof form and some upper floor rear elevation fenestration, enabling
these features, together with the rear outrigger which is a common characteristic of
housing in the area, to be fully appreciated.
23. Both schemes the subject of Appeal A and Appeal B would provide a small
element of set-back of the resulting outrigger from the Ferry Road frontage.
However, by widening the rear outrigger to the extent proposed in both schemes,
both proposals would result in a rear two-storey addition which would be of a
combined height, width and scale which would be disproportionate to, and
overwhelm, the main pitched roof host dwelling as well as appearing unduly large
in relation to the rear elevation of the other half of the semi-detached pair.
24. The subsidiary rear outrigger feature would be lost due to the proposed scale of
the proposals. Moreover, both appeal schemes would obscure either the majority
of or all of the main building roof form and, in the case of the full width extension,
the rear elevation upper floor fenestration. Moreover, in the case of the narrower
Appeal B proposal, the visible rear elevation fenestration in the main house would
appear incongruously small and narrow in comparison with that which prevails on
the rest of the dwelling, including in relation to that proposed within the rear
elevation of the extension. In the case of the latter comparison, this serves to
emphasise the unduly large scale of the proposed outrigger in relation to the main
dwelling.
25. Accordingly, I find that both appeal schemes would add an excessively large and
visually over-dominant addition to the host property which would be at odds with,
and overwhelm its original form, as well as resulting in a detrimental erosion of
some of its defining architectural features.
26. There are other substantial corner properties within the locality which have
benefitted from large additions comprising a variety of architectural styles.
However, based on the evidence before me, none appear to be directly
comparable with the appeal schemes under consideration in respect of factors
including the extension designs and positions on the buildings, the character and
appearance of the original properties and their juxtaposition with their street
frontages. As such, these properties do not justify approval of either of the appeal
schemes before me.
27. Given the visibility of the proposals in views from the street and neighbouring
properties, there would also be material harm to the character and appearance of
Appeal Decisions 6000386 and 6000387
5
the wider area because of the detrimental impact on one of the dwellings which
makes a positive contribution to the prevailing pleasant street scene.
28. Whilst the Madrid Road Conservation Area abuts the rear boundary of the site, I
do not find harm to the setting and significance of the conservation area due to the
intervening long back garden, outbuilding and mature vegetation between the
appeal property and the rear gardens of the nearest properties within the
conservation area. Also, the significance of the setting of the conservation area
being surrounded by suburban residential development, some of which has been
extended would not be altered.
29. I acknowledge the appellant’s intention to achieve a very high Passivhaus
certification and the incorporation of many sustainable elements of design and
measures to enhance biodiversity. However, I am not persuaded based on the
evidence before, that these benefits, which are aims of other development plan
policies in any case, cannot be achieved by means of either of the extant
permissions.
30. For the above reasons, I therefore conclude that the schemes the subject of both
Appeal A and Appeal B would materially harm the character and appearance of
the host property and the wider surrounding area. As such they would be contrary
to Local Plan Policy 28 and the supporting House Extensions and External
Alterations Supplementary Planning Document (2015), which, amongst other
things, seek to ensure that new developments improve the quality and character of
buildings, spaces and the local area and that extensions do not over-dominate the
building’s original scale and character.
31. For similar reasons, the proposals would also be contrary to Chapter 12 of the
National Planning Policy Framework 2024 which seeks to achieve well-designed
places.
Conclusion
32. The developments the subjects of appeals A and B conflict with the development
plan taken as a whole and there are no material considerations, including the
Framework, to suggest the decisions should be made other than in accordance
with the development plan.
33. Therefore, for the reasons given above, I conclude that both Appeal A and
Appeal B should be dismissed.
S Leonard
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.