Described in the appellants’ appeal statement as ‘Retention of the existing first-floor extension (measuring 8.19m width x 3.00m depth x 2.44m height), replacement of the existing temporary flat roof with a permanent flat roof made from sustainable materials, and removal of the parapet (measuring 450mm above the roof height) currently in situ. Removal of the planned ‘crown’ roof and replacement with a flat roof
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Residential Amenity
Character & Appearance
Extensions
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 29 April 2025
by Alison Fish BA (Hons) Dip TP MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 14TH July 2025
Appeal Ref: 6000109
217 Edgwarebury Lane, Edgware HA8 8QJ
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 (as amended)
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Nayeem and Jimal Noor against the decision of the Council of the London
Borough of Barnet.
• The application Ref is 24/0424/RCU.
• The development proposed is described in the appellants’ appeal statement as ‘Retention of the
existing first-floor extension (measuring 8.19m width x 3.00m depth x 2.44m height), replacement of
the existing temporary flat roof with a permanent flat roof made from sustainable materials, and
removal of the parapet (measuring 450mm above the roof height) currently in situ. Removal of the
planned ‘crown’ roof and replacement with a flat roof’.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Applications for costs
2. An application for costs was made by the appellants against the Council of the
London Borough of Barnet. This application is the subject of a separate Decision.
Preliminary Matters
3. I have used the description set out in the appellants’ appeal statement1 as it more
succinctly and accurately describes the appeal proposal than the one provided on
the planning application form and the Council’s decision notice.
4. The Council adopted the Barnet Local Plan 2021-2036 (LP) on 4 March 2025. This
replaces the previous Local Plan referred to in the Council’s reasons for refusal.
Both parties have been given an opportunity to comment on the implications of this
for the appeal and I have taken those comments into account.
5. I have been provided with copies of Policies CDH01, CDH05 and HOU04 of the LP
which are relevant to the appeal. The Council have also provided a copy of Policies
GSS01 and CDH04 of the LP which relate to proposals for new homes and tall
buildings. As the appeal proposal relates to a domestic extension, these policies
are not relevant to the proposal before me.
Background and Main Issues
6. The appeal property benefits from a flat roof dormer extension to the roof and a flat
roof single storey ground floor extension. Both extensions are to the rear and
1 Paragraphs 13 and 14 of the Appeal Statement dated 24 January 2025
Appeal Decision 6000109
2
extend the full width of the property. There is an extant planning permission2 (‘the
EPP’) for an extension at first floor level which would extend across approximately
two thirds of the rear of the property and would have a crown roof.
7. This appeal relates to a first floor flat roof extension which has already been built.
The appeal proposals seek to retain the extension but with a reduction to the height
of the parapet around the roof of the extension.
8. Therefore, the main issues in this appeal are the effect of the first floor extension
with the proposed alteration to the parapet on:
• The character and appearance of the host dwelling and the surrounding
area;
• The living conditions of the neighbouring occupier at 219 Edgewarebury
Lane with respect to outlook; and
• If harm is found, whether material considerations, including any fallback
position and the occupiers’ personal circumstances, justifies a decision
otherwise than in accordance with the development plan.
Reasons
Character and Appearance
9. The appeal property is located in a predominantly residential area consisting of
largely detached and semi-detached dwellings located in good size plots. Although
the design, size and materials of construction vary along Edgewarebury Lane, brick
and rendered elevations under hipped roofs, as seen on the host dwelling, are the
prevailing character.
10. The first floor extension extends across the whole of the rear elevation of the
property. Even with a reduction in height of 450mm to the parapet, the extension
would be a bulky and dominant addition to the property. Whilst the red brick
construction matches the main house and the use of brick generally in the area, the
flat roof is at odds with the original character of the building.
11. Located to the rear of the property, the first floor, flat roof extension is not visible
from the street. It is nonetheless visible from the neighbouring properties.
Paragraph 14.26 of the SPD3 states that flat roofs on two storey rear extensions
are not normally acceptable because they do not relate sympathetically to the
house. In this instance, the height, bulk, design and siting of the extension even
taking account of the reduction to the parapet, would result in an incongruous form
of development and would add to the proliferation of flat roofs to the rear of the
property. The appeal proposal would not be in keeping with the prevailing character
of the area.
12. I have been referred to other developments at numbers 215 and 247
Edgewarebury Lane and I note that the Inspector refers to these in the previous
appeal4. I have also been advised that flat roof extensions are commonplace in the
area. However, substantive evidence such as plans and drawings are not before
2 LPA Ref: 22/0298/HSE First floor rear extension with crown roof. New side window to south and north elevations. Roof light to
existing side north roof slope. Skylights over existing flat roof dormer roof.
3 Local Plan Supplementary Planning Document: Residential Design Guidance October 2016
4 Appeal Ref: APP/N5090/C/23/3314767 and 3314768
Appeal Decision 6000109
3
me and therefore, I am unable to draw any direct comparisons with the appeal
proposal.
13. The proposal would be contrary to Policy D3 of The London Plan, adopted March
2021 (TLP) which requires that development is of an appropriate form which
positively responds to a site’s context and local distinctiveness. The proposal would
also be contrary to Policies CDH01 and CDH05 of the LP which promote high
quality design which responds to local character, complements the character of and
is subordinate to the existing building in terms of its size, scale and height and
incorporates a roof profile which is sympathetic to the existing property.
Living Conditions
14. The first floor extension is close to the boundary with the neighbouring property,
219 Edgewarebury Lane. The SPD says that two storey extensions which would
within 2m of a neighbouring property and project more than 3m will not normally be
acceptable. This does not in my view mean that all extensions which project 3m or
less, as in the case of the appeal proposal, would be acceptable. Each case must
be decided on its own merits taking into account the specifics of the relationship
between the two properties.
15. The proximity of the extension to the boundary with No. 219 and its extent of
projection means that even with the proposed alteration, it would have an imposing
presence, from inside the neighbouring property and from its rear patio area. This
would result in a harmful sense of enclosure and a loss of outlook for the occupiers
of No. 219. This would be at odds with Paragraphs 14.23 and 14.24 of the SPD
which seeks to ensure that two storey rear extensions do not lead to a loss of
outlook or have an unacceptable sense of enclosure to the neighbouring property.
16. Prior to the works being carried out, there was a tree between the appeal site and
No. 219. However, the impact of the tree on the living conditions of the occupiers of
the neighbouring property would be materially different to the impact of built
development, not least because of a tree’s organic form. Given the scale, height
and proximity of the proposal to the boundary, additional planting would not
effectively screen the development or negate the harm. A condition requiring the
appellants to pay for or provide a tree on the neighbours’ land, on land outside their
control, would not be enforceable.
17. The proposal would be contrary to Policy D3 of TLP which seeks to deliver
appropriate outlook and Policies CDH01 and CDH05 of the LP which requires that
an acceptable outlook is maintained for adjoining occupiers.
Other Considerations
18. The EPP represents a viable fallback position. However, in that case, the first floor
extension would be set well back from the boundary with No. 219 and would not
have the same enclosing impact as the proposal before me. In addition, it would be
smaller and have a crown roof. It would therefore appear subservient to the host
dwelling and preserve the character and appearance of the area. Given that the
fallback position would be less harmful than the proposal before me, it carries very
limited weight in favour of the appeal proposal.
Appeal Decision 6000109
4
19. Whilst the flat roof area provides a location for solar panels, there is no substantive
evidence before me that this would be the only appropriate location for solar panels
on the property. This carries very limited weight in favour of the proposal.
20. The lack of harm in respect of overlooking, daylight and sunlight to the
neighbouring property and amenity space provision is what is expected of all
development in order to be acceptable and are therefore neutral in my assessment.
21. My attention has been drawn to Policy HOU04 of the LP which relates to specialist
housing. Insofar as is relevant to this appeal, the policy seeks to provide vulnerable
residents with a housing choice by supporting proposals for people to live
independently in locations which are accessible by public transport. The first floor
extension includes an en-suite bedroom for a family member who requires
adaptations. However, Policy HOU04 of the LP goes on to say that proposals
should also demonstrate that they will not have a harmful impact on the character
and amenities of the surrounding area. Given my findings on the main issues
above, the proposal would not comply with Policy HOU04 of the LP in this respect.
22. Both appellants plan to marry in the near future at which point, their wives would
also move into the property. The appeal proposal would result in four en-suite
bedrooms and one bedroom with access to a separate bathroom. This would
provide sufficient accommodation for the 8 adults comprising the appellants’ family.
23. One of the en-suite bedrooms is currently occupied by Mrs Noor, the appellants’
elderly grandmother. She has medical conditions which result in mobility issues
requiring a wheelchair. She requires assistance with showering, taking medication
and dressing. The family also assist Mrs Noor with domestic tasks, using the stairs
and transport to medical appointments. She requires a bedroom and bathroom of
sufficient size to manoeuvre a wheelchair and adaptations to the bathroom to
enable her to use the toilet and shower. Living with family members and having
appropriate adapted facilities are therefore fundamental to sustaining Mrs Noor at
home.
24. I saw on my site visit that the bedroom is at first floor level and had sufficient space
for a wheelchair to manoeuvre and the provision of a commode. In the en-suite I
saw that the toilet had a frame over it and there was a walk-in shower with a seat.
The Occupational Therapist has confirmed that the current bedroom and en-suite
meets the needs of Mrs Noor.
25. However, many of the adaptations I saw were freestanding items of equipment.
There was nothing to suggest that these adaptations could not be provided in other
en-suite bedrooms in the house.
26. The Council have suggested to the appellants that a ground floor bedroom and
bathroom could be provided within the property. This would remove the need for
Mrs Noor to negotiate the stairs. In addition, the Council have provided the
appellants with drawings indicating how the first floor of the property could be
reconfigured to provide an en-suite bedroom within the EPP.
27. Although a Council Building Inspector has not visited the property to assess their
feasibility, both suggestions are cogent, resulting in the required number of
bedrooms for the family’s needs. Whilst these options may require fundamental
structural alterations to the property which could come at a substantial cost, I have
no substantive evidence before me to demonstrate that this would be the case.
Appeal Decision 6000109
5
28. I appreciate that the appellants have made a significant investment in this
development and that they and their family have accommodation needs. However, I
am mindful of the advice contained in the Planning Practice Guidance that in
general planning is concerned with land use in the public interest. The development
brings about a permanent alteration to the building, whereas it is likely that the
family’s needs will change over the longer term.
29. For these reasons, I therefore find that the personal circumstances of the
appellants and their extended family are not sufficient to outweigh the conflict with
the development plan arising from the harm to the character and appearance of the
area and the living conditions of the neighbouring occupiers.
Other Matters
30. Given that there is already a degree of mutual overlooking of rear gardens, the first
floor extension would not result in additional overlooking to an unacceptable extent
and a condition could prevent the use of the flat roof for anything other than
maintenance purposes. The submitted Daylight and Sunlight Report5 demonstrates
that the proposed development sufficiently safeguards the daylight and sunlight to
the neighbouring property and its garden.
Planning Balance
31. The appeal scheme would be harmful to the character and appearance of the area
and to the living conditions of the neighbouring occupiers and thereby conflict with
the development plan. I have considered whether conditions could be used to
overcome the harm and have set out above why, in this instance, they would not.
32. Dismissing the appeal would interfere with the appellants’ and their family’s rights
to peaceful enjoyment of their possessions, and to a private and family life and
home, under Article 1 of the First Protocol and Article 8 as set out under the Human
Rights Act 1998. However, those are qualified rights; interference with them in this
instance would accord with the law and be in pursuance of a well-established and
legitimate aim: the protection of the character and appearance of the area and the
living conditions of neighbouring occupiers. Accordingly, it is proportionate and
necessary to refuse to grant planning permission. There will be no violation of the
appellants’ or their family’s human rights. The protection of the public interest
cannot be achieved by means that are less interfering with their rights.
33. I have had due regard to the Public Sector Equality Duty (PSED) contained
in section 149 of the Equality Act 2010, which sets out the need to
eliminate unlawful discrimination, harassment and victimisation, and to
advance equality of opportunity and foster good relations between people
who share a protected characteristic and people who do not share it. These
characteristics include age, disability and race. I acknowledge that members of the
appellants’ family share one or more of these protected characteristics for the
purposes of the PSED.
34. In considering the requirements of the PSED, a refusal of permission would not
amount to unlawful discrimination. Allowing the appeal when the proposal would
result in the harm I have identified, would undermine relations between people who
do and do not share a protected characteristic. This supports my view that the need
5 Dated 17 November 2022 by Right of Light Consulting
Appeal Decision 6000109
6
for the appeal proposal does not outweigh the harm to the character and
appearance of the area and the living conditions of the neighbouring occupier.
Conclusion
35. The proposed development would be contrary to the development plan and there
are no material considerations that outweigh this conflict. Consequently, with
reference to Section 38(6) of the Planning and Compulsory Purchase Act 2004,
the appeal is dismissed.
Alison Fish
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.