New vehicular highway access with dropped kerb and gated drive to house. This is to allow disabled vehicles to enter the site and park
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Heritage & Conservation
Trees & Landscape
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 13 March 2024
by D Cleary MTCP MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date:11.04.2024
Appeal Ref: APP/E3715/D/24/3337670
7 Newbold Road, Rugby, Warwickshire CV21 2LQ
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr C Hinde against the decision of Rugby Borough Council.
• The application Ref: R23/0902, dated 4 September 2023, was refused by notice dated 6
November 2023.
• The development proposed is described as a new vehicular highway access with
dropped kerb and gated drive to house. This is to allow disabled vehicles to enter the
site and park.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Procedural Matters
2. In response to reasons for refusal 1 and 4, which relate to trees, the appeal
has been supported by an Arboricultural Report1 (the AR). This is new
information not previously seen by the Council. As a householder appeal, the
Council are deprived of the opportunity to comment on matters raised. I have
therefore invited, and received, comments from the Council on the content of
the AR. In response to those comments made by the Council, additional
comments have been received from the appellant. I have had regard to all
comments received in reaching my decision.
3. Since the decision was made by the Council, a revised version of the National
Planning Policy Framework (the Framework) was published (19 December
2023). This does not materially change the planning policy context in respect of
the main issue.
Main Issues
4. The main issues are the effect of the development on: the character and
appearance of the area; the setting of a Listed Building (The Lawn); protected
trees; and, highway safety.
Reasons
Character and Appearance (and setting of The Lawn)
5. The appeal dwelling is a large detached dwelling which is located close to
Rugby town centre. The site lies on Newbold Road, which a classified road, and
1 Apex Environmental – Arboricultural Report BS5837:2012, dated 08/12/2023
Appeal Decision: APP/E3715/D/24/3337670
2
one of the main arterial routes into Rugby. The surrounding area includes a mix
of land uses and buildings of varying scale, form and character. The front
garden of the appeal site is well vegetated and includes a number of mature
trees, some of which are covered by TPO2. Brick walls define the front and side
boundaries of the appeal site. On this side of Newbold Road, low level front
boundary walls, positioned at the back of the pavement, continue towards
Oliver Street. Together, the walls create a strong visual edge along this part of
Newbold Road.
6. The appeal site lies close to a Grade II listed building, known as The Lawn.
Newbold Road, various buildings, hard surfaced areas, and soft landscaping,
separate the appeal site from The Lawn. The appeal site can be considered to
fall within its wider setting. Section 66(1) of the Planning (Listed Buildings and
Conservation Areas) Act 1990 (LBCA Act) requires me to have special regard to
the desirability of preserving listed buildings, or their setting, or any feature of
special architectural or historic interest which they possess.
7. The proposed access would result in the removal of part of the front boundary
wall. This would be positioned close to the adjacent vehicular access, and
would be separated by the retained pedestrian access to the appeal site only.
The close proximity of the vehicular accesses would cumulatively result in a
wide visual break in the wall. This would disrupt the rhythm and continuity of
the hardedge boundary fronting Newbold Road on this close approach to the
town centre. The retained pedestrian access would appear as an isolated
narrow front boundary flanked by the two wider vehicular accesses. Given its
narrow width, this would appear visually at odds with the longer lengths of wall
either side of the vehicular accesses. The proposed removal of the wall would
therefore have a harmful effect on the overall character and appearance of the
street.
8. With regard to the effect on the setting of The Lawn, the intervening
development and separation distance means that there is limited intervisibility
between the appeal site and the listed building. Furthermore, Newbold Road,
with its high traffic flow, acts as a visual buffer which dissects the visual
relationship. Given this context, and the limited scale of the proposal, the
development would not inadvertently draw attention away from the listed
building in a manner which would be harmful to its setting.
9. Therefore, while I have found that the removal of the wall has a negative effect
on the character and appearance of the area, more generally, I do not consider
that the development would be harmful to the setting of The Lawn.
10. For the above reasons development would have a negative effect on the
character and appearance of the area. The proposals would conflict with Policy
SDC1 of the Rugby Borough Council Local Plan 2019 (the LP) and guidance
contained within the Framework. These, amongst other things, require
development to achieve high quality, inclusive and sustainable design, which
responds to character of the area. However, I find no conflict with this Policy
with regard the effect of the development on the setting of The Lawn.
2 Tree Preservation Order No.237 – 3-7 Newbold Road, Rugby
Appeal Decision: APP/E3715/D/24/3337670
3
Trees
11. A horse chestnut tree, covered by the TPO, is located to the front of the
property (hereafter referred to as T1). T1 is large and prominent, and I
consider it to have significant visual value. Development which would
compromise its retention now, or in the future, could have a negative effect on
the overall character and appearance of the area.
12. There is some dispute between the parties over the extent of the root
protection area (RPA) for T1, and consequently the level of incursion that would
arise from the development. The AR provides a nominal RPA to take account of
the urban context and site characteristics. This considers that the root system
is likely to be affected by the roadside boundary wall and the appeal dwelling.
The suggested RPA therefore spreads into the land to the north and south of
the appeal site. The side boundaries of the appeal site include brick walls
although I am unclear whether the foundations of these would have affected
the root system and, therefore, the extent of the suggested RPA. Furthermore,
much of the land to the south of the appeal site is covered by hard surfaced
areas, while there are also areas of existing hard surfacing within the site.
13. The AR suggests that the proposals would result in a 14% incursion into the
RPA. However, I have been provided with no clear calculations on how much of
the land within the nominal RPA is surfaced and the extent of land which
remains unsurfaced. The scheme includes the surfacing of a large area of the
garden for parking and turning. These works would cover much of the existing
garden area. The AR indicates that this would be carried out using no-dig
construction techniques. While such techniques can be used in certain
circumstances, in this instance, there is too much uncertainty over the extent
of the RPA and the proportions which remain unsurfaced. Therefore, I cannot
definitively conclude on the extent of incursion into the RPA and whether this
would be within acceptable tolerances3.
14. The land level behind the front boundary wall, around T1, is higher than the
public highway. From my observations on site, this change in levels is not
insignificant. The access and driveway would all fall within the RPA of T1 and, if
excavation is required, has the potential to affect the root system. I also note
that the driveway would also be flanked by walls and pillars which may require
foundations. The AR indicates that these works would be carried out under
arboricultural supervision, although there is little specific detail of what works
would actually be carried out in this area. Crucially, I have not been provided
with any existing or proposed land level data to show what changes in land
levels will be required to provide level access from the highway. Given the
change in levels such information would be essential to inform the extent of
works necessary. Furthermore, there is also little information with regard to the
foundation construction for the proposed walls and gate pillars that may be
required. In the absence of such information, I cannot be satisfied that there
would be no detrimental effect on T1 in this regard.
15. In addition, the submitted plans do not detail of how level access would be
provided from the parking area to the dwelling. There is no indication of a path
linking the parking area to existing hard surfaced areas. Noting the
3 Within BS5837:2012 recommendations of 20% existing unsurfaced land in the RPA
Appeal Decision: APP/E3715/D/24/3337670
4
requirement is to provide for disabled parking, delivering appropriate and level
access may result in further additional works within the RPA.
16. A further pine tree has been identified as being covered by the TPO4. This tree
is scheduled for retention. The evidence suggests that some incursion into the
RPA of this tree would arise, albeit this does not appear to result in any
significant incursion. Subject to appropriate measures the effect on this tree is
likely to be acceptable.
17. For the above reasons, from the evidence before me, I have insufficient
information to be satisfied that the development could be carried out without
having an unacceptable effect on trees. The proposals therefore conflict with
Policies SDC1 and SDC2 of the LP, and guidance contained within the
Framework. Together, these require development to respond to character of
the area, integrating landscape and environmental factors, and to ensure that
important site features are retained.
18. However, I do not find conflict with LP Policy NE1 which appears to relate to
matters regarding biodiversity sites and geodiversity.
Highway Safety
19. Vehicular access would be provided off Newbold Road which is a classified road,
and, at the time of my site visit, I observed a constant flow of traffic in both
directions. The access would be in close proximity to a roundabout and a
pedestrian crossing.
20. The access would be flanked by pillars which are taller than the retained
boundary wall. The pillars are of such a height where visibility, on exiting the
site, would be largely obscured. Due to the narrow width of the access, the
pillars would initially be very prominent in the driver’s sightline. I acknowledge
that, once past the pillars, the pavement may be of a width which could allow
for some visibility of oncoming traffic from the roundabout. However, the
submitted plan showing sight lines5 does not appear to correctly show the “x”
and “y” distances from the proposed access and, therefore, I am unclear as to
what visibility can actually be achieved. Notwithstanding this, the proposals do
not provide for any pedestrian visibility splays. On exiting the site, immediate
views of the pavement would be obscured by the height of the pillars.
Therefore, the access would have the potential to result in conflict between
vehicles and users of the pavement, leading to highway safety concerns.
21. The Highways Officer has advised that the width of the access is below
standard and that the position of the gates are too close to the highway. I
concur that the width of the access does appear to be narrow. I have no swept
path detail to show that a vehicle can comfortably enter the site. Given the
narrow width of the access, on entering the site, any misjudgement would
require realignment and additional manoeuvres. This would have to take place
within the limits of the public highway and has the potential to result in conflict
with vehicles and other users of the highway.
4 T6 in the AR
5 Plan Ref: 23.045.06 – Proposed Site Lines
Appeal Decision: APP/E3715/D/24/3337670
5
22. The positioning of the gates would be set back from the edge of the pavement
within the site. I have not been presented with any evidence to demonstrate
that the gates would be positioned in accordance with the Councils standards
and, therefore, that a vehicle can pull clear off the limits of the highway
without overhanging the pavement. I acknowledge that the gates could be
electric, which the appellant would control. However, this does not account for
any visitors who may not be able to remotely control the gate. An overhang
onto the pavement would cause an obstruction to pedestrians, resulting in an
unacceptable conflict between users.
23. The plans show an existing dropped kerb for the access to the adjacent
property. From my observations on site, the extent of this dropped kerb
appears to encroach further in front of the appeal property than that shown on
the plans. Additionally, I have no information to demonstrate that the extent of
proposed dropped kerb would meet the Councils standards for the width of the
access proposed. Therefore, I concur with the Council, that there is insufficient
clarity on this point.
24. For the above reasons, I have insufficient information to be satisfied that the
proposed access can be provided without having a negative effect on highway
safety. Therefore, the development would conflict with Policy D1 of the LP and
guidance contained within the Framework. These require development to be
designed to mitigate against their transport impacts.
Other matters
25. It is understood that the site has no off-street parking, and that the appellant
currently use a nearby public car park. The proposal would provide parking for
a disabled driver and this is a ‘protected characteristics’ embraced by the public
sector equality duty under s149 of the Equality Act 2010. I am sympathetic to
these circumstances, and while it would be advantageous to provide more
convenient access, I can only attach moderate weight in favour of a
development which would improve the quality of life for its occupants. I
consider that this benefit does not outweigh the harm that the development
would cause in relation to the main issues which, cumulatively, are significant.
Therefore, it is proportionate and necessary to dismiss the appeal.
Conclusion
26. For the above reasons the appeal is dismissed.
D Cleary
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.