Installation of Air Source Heat Pumps
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Noise & Disturbance
Heritage & Conservation
Policy Weight
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 17 June 2024
by Tom Bristow BA MSc MRTPI AssocRICS
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 17 September 2024
Appeal Ref: APP/V1260/D/24/3337213
85 Mudeford, Christchurch BH23 3NJ
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 as
amended (the ‘1990 Act’) against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Nicolas Roach against the decision of Bournemouth Christchurch
and Poole Council (‘BCP’).
• The application is ref. 8/23/0306/HOU.
• The development proposed is described on the application form as the ‘installation of Air
Source Heat Pumps’.
Decision
1. The appeal is allowed and planning permission is granted for 2 air source heat
pumps (‘ASHPs’) at 85 Mudeford, Christchurch BH23 3NJ in accordance with
the terms of application ref. 8/23/0306/HOU, subject to the conditions below.
Preliminary matters
Statutory context
2. The development relates to grade II listed Mudeford House, no. 85.1
Neighbouring no. 87, to the east in the direction of Christchurch Quay, is grade
II listed Mude Cottage.2 Both are within the Mudeford Quay Conservation Area
(‘MQCA’), focussed principally around the Quay and stretch of coastline by it. I
have therefore approached the appeals in the context of sections 66(1) and
72(1) of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990 as
amended (the ‘LBCA Act’).
3. Section 66(1) of LBCA Act requires that I pay special regard to the desirability
of preserving listed buildings, their settings, or any features of special
architectural or historic interest they possess. Similarly, section 72(1) of the
LBCA Act sets out how special attention shall be paid to the desirability of
preserving or enhancing the character and appearance of conservation areas.
4. The appeal is under section 78 of the 1990 Act, which relates to planning
appeals (rather than section 20 of the LBCA Act which relates to works for
which listed building consent is sought). As reflected by the comments of BCP
Urban Design and Conservation of 5 June 2023, ‘it is unclear whether the
installation of the two ASHPs would necessitate any changes to the existing
structures (for example, the introduction of additional pipework and/ or internal
units)’.
1 List entry no. 1110091.
2 List entry no. 1324666.
Appeal Decision APP/V1260/D/24/3337213
2
5. For clarity, however, no alterations to the historic fabric of the listed building
are shown or described in the information before me. I was unable to discern
any effect in that regard during my site visit. If listed building consent were to
be required for associated works, that would be a matter for the appellant and
BCP to address as necessary.
6. Notwithstanding an extensive history of alterations and additions to the listed
building, there appears to have been no parallel application for listed building
consent along with planning application ref. 8/23/0306/HOU. BCP’s decision
notice of 14 December 2023 in respect of application ref. 8/23/0306/HOU,
moreover, focusses squarely on the implications of the scheme to the setting of
nos. 85 and 87.
Policy context
7. Section 38(6) of the Planning and Compulsory Purchase Act 2004 as amended
requires that proposals are determined in accordance with the development
plan unless material considerations indicate otherwise. On 1 April 2019 the
former Councils of Bournemouth, Christchurch and Poole combined to form a
single Authority. Existing development plan documents of former authorities
remain. In this instance the development plan includes policies of the
Christchurch and East Dorset Local Plan: Part 1- Core Strategy (adopted 28
April 2014, the ‘CS’), and ‘saved’ policies of the Borough of Christchurch Local
Plan (adopted originally in March 2001, the ‘LP’).
8. I have had regard to all relevant material considerations including the National
Planning Policy Framework (updated 20 December 2023, the ‘NPPF’), the
Planning Practice Guidance (‘PPG’), Historic England’s guidance on ‘Heat Pumps
in Historic Buildings’ (published 26 May 2023), and the Mudeford Quay
Conservation Area Appraisal (published 2008, the ‘MQCAA’). I understand that
a review of the CS is underway, as is work towards a neighbourhood plan
(albeit that both are yet at relatively early stages).
The development
9. Notwithstanding the description of development reproduced in the banner
heading above, BCP’s decision notice of 14 December 2023 describes the
development for which permission is sought as ‘retrospective application for
Installation of 2no. Air Source Heat Pumps (AMENDED DESCRIPTION/PLANS)’.
The application form, dated 2 May 2023, states that the installation of ASHPs
was started without permission on 1 August 2022.
10. The expansive plot of Mudeford House cuts to the rear of the plot of Mude
Cottage, increasing in width towards the water’s edge (rather than being
rectilinear). The plot of no. 89 is separated from that of no. 85 by the plot of
no. 87. That interrelationship is shown on plan no. ‘20-1074-LOC’. Given the
arrangement of plots here, no. 89 is therefore close to the location of the
ASHPs. For comprehensiveness, no. 89A is to the east of Mude Cottage and
north of no. 89 (appearing, relatively, a more recent property).
11. There is a representation of 30 May 2023 on behalf of the occupant of no. 89,
prepared by Dan Roycroft of Atlas Planning Group. That indicates that heat
pumps were installed in ‘April/ May 2022’, and appends a Noise Impact
Appeal Decision APP/V1260/D/24/3337213
3
Assessment of September 2022.3 There are representations before me in
relation to Mude Cottage, no. 89A, and also no. 10 Hamilton Close, endorsing
the representation of the occupant of no. 89.
12. The scheme has, however, been amended. It may well, therefore, be that the
difference in dates given for the commencement of development above relates
to the initial installation of heat pumps and their subsequent alteration. I
understand that the original scheme was, around November 2023, amended to
address BCP’s concerns over noise (unwanted sound). In this decision, for
brevity, I refer to the ‘original’ and ‘amended’ scheme in that context.
13. It is the amended scheme before me. As clarified by the appellant at appeal in
response to my request, the plans illustrating the amended scheme are ‘20-
1074-LOC’, dated June/21, a ‘Location and Block Plan’, and ‘23.011-HGP-01-
22-DR-A-2001’, dated ‘FEB 23’, entitled ‘Pool Plant Room Details’.
14. Confusingly, however, the reference number and date of the latter plan are the
same as that illustrating the original scheme. Practically that poses a potential
problem in respect of conditions were the appeal to be allowed.4 In the
eventuality that permission were to be allowed, securing adherence to the
amended plan could also be interpreted as applying to the original scheme.
15. Following that logic, with reference to NPPF paragraph 56, a condition in that
respect would, notwithstanding that the scheme is retrospective, be imprecise.
That would in turn bring into question whether permission could in actually be
granted in the eventuality the scheme is acceptable. Consequently, at my
request, a plan has been provided with a unique reference, plan no. 23.011-
HGP-01-22-DR-A-2001 REVISION C, dated July 2024. That, along with the
location plan referenced previously, now reflect the amended scheme.
Noise, relevant evidence
16. BCP’s decision notice does not refer to noise. The associated officer report sets
out, with reference to the appellant’s evidence, that noise levels ‘were deemed
not to be excessive to the detriment of neighbouring properties living
conditions’. That draws from the views of BCP Environmental Health (received
30 October 2023, the ‘EH assessment’).
17. The dates on which the scheme was implemented, revised and assessed are,
however, complex. The appellant’s evidence in respect of noise includes a Noise
Impact Assessment of 25 September 2023, marked as ‘Revision P01’ (the
‘NIAR’).5 There is also a Noise Impact Assessment of 27 April 2023 (the ‘NIA’).6
The NIA is, however, marked as ‘Revision P02’. That suggests that it is an
update to the NIAR of 25 September 2023. It is not. The ‘Revision P01’ NIAR
was, befuddlingly, produced after the ‘Revision P02’ NIA.
18. There is also a ‘Project Note’ of 22 June 2023 prepared on behalf of the
appellant which addresses points made in the assessment commissioned by the
3 Impact Acoustics, ref. IMP7262-1
4 Notwithstanding article 7(1)(c) of the Town and Country Planning (Development Management Procedure)
(England) Order 2015 as amended.
5 Vanguardia, ref. 0055609-VAN-RP-0002, Revision P01.
6 Vanguardia, ref. 0055609-0820-0-VAN-RP-01-02, Revision P02.
Appeal Decision APP/V1260/D/24/3337213
4
occupant of no. 89 referenced above.7 There is also a review of the foregoing
by Clarke Saunders Acoustics of 10 August 2023.8 Nevertheless, only the NIAR
of 25 September 2023, marked as ‘Revision P01’ relates to the amended
scheme (anything beforehand to the original scheme).9
Noise, evidence availability
19. Via correspondence of 1 July 2024 BCP set out how, in the light of the
amended scheme a site notice ‘was erected on 19 September 2023 (amended
description/ plans) allowing for further comments up to 4 October 2023’. That
appears, incidentally, to conflict with the deadline for further comments given
in BCP’s officer report (11 October 2023).
20. Nevertheless in their correspondence of 1 July 2024, BCP explain how the NIAR
‘was made public on 25 September 2023’. If that is correct, individuals would
have had had some 10 days to comment on it. Via that correspondence BCP
also attached a response of 4 October 2023 to the foregoing opportunity for
further comments (again by Dan Roycroft). In brief that response remains
critical of the substantiation behind the scheme in terms of noise.
21. As expressed in correspondence of 9 July 2024 at appeal, BCP were of the view
that the foregoing procedure was sufficient to enable me to determine the
appeal without prejudice to any party (including with reference the EH
assessment). I disagreed, notably as the response of 4 October 2023
referenced in the preceding paragraph asks: ‘where is the updated Noise
Impact Assessment which takes into account the inaccuracies we have already
highlighted in previous reps, and the new ASHP installed?’.
22. The latter appears to be a reference to the NIAR, which BCP say was then
available. In that context, in the interests of fairness, openness and
impartiality, I could not be certain that my proceeding to determine the appeal
would have been following suitable opportunity for public scrutiny.
23. I therefore asked BCP to re-consult to ensure that there had been fair
opportunity for comment (both on the NIAR and plan no. 23.011-HGP-01-22-
DR-A-2001 REVISION C). Via correspondence of 13 August 2024, BCP informed
me of the intention to consult on Monday 18 August 2024. BCP prepared a
notice of consultation dated 28 August 2024, with the consultation period
running to 11 September 2024. I understand re-consultation took place on 19
August 2024.10
24. Via correspondence of 13 September 2024, BCP set out that no further
representations had been received. In short, on the information now before
me, I am satisfied that no party would be prejudiced by my proceeding to
determine the appeal.
7 Vanguardia, ref. 0055609-0820-0-VAN-PN-01-00, Revision R00.
8 Ref. AS13185.230807.L1.
9 As is inherent in some of the information contained within those documents, and as confirmed by the Council and
appellant at appeal.
10 BCP correspondence of 13 August 2024.
Appeal Decision APP/V1260/D/24/3337213
5
Main issues
25. The main issues are the effect of the development in respect of (i) the living
conditions of those nearby in respect of noise, and (ii) in respect of historic
significance.
Reasons
Noise
26. Notwithstanding the foregoing context, the absence of further representations
in respect of the NIAR does not indicate that neighbours support the amended
scheme. More broadly the existence or absence of objections is not a
bellwether as to a scheme’s acceptability.
27. Turning to the assess the noise implications of the scheme, the NIAR is stated
to be prepared with reference to relevant British Standards
4142:2014+A1:2019 and 8233:2014.11 In essence it reiterates some of the
foregoing, in that following complains former ASHPs have been replaced by a
‘single, quieter model, and a new directional duct system has been constructed
on the roof of the plant room.’ That is incorrect.
28. There is not now a single unit but instead 2. The NIAR also refers to ‘Air
Handling Units’ (‘AHUs’), but nowhere to ASHPs. The appellant has furthermore
submitted a data sheet in respect of a ‘Flotide PX30/32’ unit. Dan Roycroft’s
correspondence of 4 October 2023 includes a photograph of packaging on site,
presumably taken at the time the amended scheme was being undertaken, of
an LG ARUM220LTE6. That is a different unit, inevitably with a different sound
profile.
29. The NIAR, however, sets out that it assessed the amended scheme. In
response to my request of 1 July 2023 the appellant confirmed on 3 July 2024
that two ASHP were installed at the time the NIAR was undertaken. BCP do not
say otherwise. Moreover, as I understand it ASHPs are a species of the genus
AHU. To address Dan Roycroft’s observation, the Flotide PX30/32 appears to
serves the swimming pool, another ASHP within louvred housing serving the
rest of the property (which may be an LG ARUM220LTE6 or not).
30. There are, however, further ambiguities in the NIAR. The background noise
level was assessed by the parking to no. 85 (the blue dot on NIAR figure 3).
The noise level was monitored close to the south-western corner of the plot of
no. 87, no. 87 annotated as the ‘complainant’s property’ (the red dot on NIAR
figure 3). Given the nature of plots here described above, the red dot is not the
closest location to no. 89 within the plot of no. 85. I presume the reference to
no.87 being the complainant’s property should instead be to no. 89.
31. Furthermore NIAR Figure B-3 is a photograph of the ‘new directional ducting on
roof of plantroom’ being constructed. However that does not tally with the size
or location of the enclosure shown on plan no. 23.011-HGP-01-22-DR-A-2001
REVISION C or what I saw on site in that respect, particularly as the housing
shown on the plans, and that which is in place, does not abut the a wall of the
swimming pool building.
11 Respectively ‘Methods for Rating and Assessing Industrial and Commercial Sound’, and ‘Guidance on sound
insulation and noise reduction for buildings’.
Appeal Decision APP/V1260/D/24/3337213
6
32. Whilst the foregoing make assessing the implications of the development
challenging, they are not in critical to the integrity of the NIAR. Both the red
and the blue dots are consistent with those locations in the earlier NIA (thereby
enabling a relative assessment of the amended scheme compared to the
original). I saw that the distance between the location of the ASHPs and the
red dot is comparable to the distance between them and the nearest elevation
of no.89 (with the nature of intervening buildings and boundary features being
comparable also, if not more substantial, in relation to the interaction between
the plot of nos. 85 and 89).
33. Figure B-3 to the NIAR inevitably relates to a scheme under construction, and I
have assessed the development on the basis of plan no. 23.011-HGP-01-22-
DR-A-2001 REVISION C. BCP do not contend that there is any divergence
between what has been installed or constructed and that which is shown on the
foregoing plan. Therefore for the purposes of this decision ‘the development’
reads as shorthand for both the amended scheme shown on that and as it
stands. Again, were there to be any divergence between the two, that would be
a matter for the main parties to address as necessary.
34. Turning to the findings of the NIAR, the modal background level at the blue
dot, expressed in terms of LA90, 15mins, was found to be 37dB both during the
day and night (the latter being 23:00 to 07:00). Therefore at 15 minute
intervals, for 90% of the time, sound levels exceeded 37db. Rationally,
however, the NIAR applied a sensitivity test to that.
35. That sensitivity test is, in summary, as the modal figure referenced above may
not account for intervals of lower levels of sound. During the night, the 25th
percentile, i.e. which sound is above 75% of the time, was found to be 25dB.
The effects of the amended scheme are presented relative both to nighttime
levels of 37dB and 25dB in order for effects to be accurately gauged.
36. In a comparable way to traditional means of heating properties, ASHPs work
periodically or intermittently. The NIAR presents the results of assessment as if
ASHPs were, however, operational continuously (something of a ‘worst case’
scenario). Similarly ASHPs work with different degrees of effort. With that in
mind the ‘peak’ mode of operation would generate a sound level of 49dB, the
‘typical’ mode 44dB, and the ‘night mode’ 44dB.12
37. The foregoing figures are, however, at or near source. In terms of the
assessment position, namely the red dot at NIA figure 3, the calculated specific
sound level would be lesser (40, 39 and 23dB respectively), with reference to
British Standard 4145:2014+A1 2019. If ‘façade correction’ is applied to
account for sound reflecting from facades nearby, the foregoing figures might
be adjusted downwards further still (by some 3dB).13
38. In that context there would be little, if any, meaningful difference resulting
from the operation of the ASHPs as assessed relative to the prevailing
background level (setting aside any attenuation from partially open windows at
neighbouring properties). That, incidentally, compares favourably to the
12 NIAR, table 4-2.
13 Ibid.
Appeal Decision APP/V1260/D/24/3337213
7
original scheme, which returned daytime sound levels of 46dB LAeq, 1 hour and
nighttime, 47dB LAeq, 15 minutes, noting that British Standard 4142:2014 sets out
that a 5dB difference, sound being graded logarithmically, would be an
indication of the potential for adverse effect.14
39. There is, however, another angle to noise in this instance (setting aside any
previous conditions which applied to development on site in that respect). In
certain circumstances certain ASHP are permitted development by virtue of
Schedule 2, Part 14, Class G of the Town and Country Planning (General
Permitted Development) (England) Order 2015 as amended (the ‘GPDO’), in
that specific planning is not required for their installation.
40. If installed pursuant to those GPDO provisions, ASHP must accord with the
Microgeneration Certification Scheme planning standards (‘MCS’). Although
those GPDO provisions do not apply to listed buildings and allow for only a
single ASHP, it is relevant to note that the MCS planning standards limit sound
or noise generated by ASHP to 42dB(A) at neighbouring properties.
41. Practically adherence to the findings of the NIAR as above or MCS planning
standards, whichever is the lesser, could be secured via condition were the
scheme acceptable as a whole. Consequently, summarising the foregoing and
subject to such a condition, the development would not conflict with the
relevant provisions of CS policy ME5 or NPPF paragraph 13.f) which, in
summary, seek to ensure that development integrates appropriately with
neighbouring living conditions including in respect of noise.15
42. By consequence of the foregoing reasoning relative to background conditions,
logically there would no conflict with criterion 5 to saved LP policy BE4 in
respect of the prevailing nature of the MCA in respect of sound or noise.
Heritage
43. It is difficult to get a precise fix on BCP’s position in respect of heritage. Their
decision notice attributes harm flowing from the ‘location of the heat pump, the
utilitarian design of the proposed enclosure and the introduction of additional
units within the enclosure, resulting in a negative visual impact’. As above,
however there are only 2 heat pumps, one housed in the enclosure shown on
plan no. 23.011-HGP-01-22-DR-A-2001 REVISION C and the other beath the
boardwalk to the rear of the swimming pool. The development is expressly for
only 2 ASHPs, not more.
44. The Urban Design and Conservation officer’s response to application ref.
8/23/0306/HOU also sets out that: the concealment of the ASHPs in a plant
room to minimise their visual and noise impact could be acceptable and in line
with Historic England’s Installing Heat Pumps in Historic Buildings guidance.’ It
appears, therefore, that the kernel of BCP’s objection relates to the details of
the enclosure itself. As noted earlier, there is no indication that what has been
built diverges from the plans (and therefore references to what has been done
or to the plans is effectively one and the same). For 4 principal reasons, I am
conversely of the view that no heritage harm results from the development.
14 Noting that the lack of tonality of the amended scheme is noted in NIAR paragraph 5.1.
15 Noting criterion 5 to saved LP policy BE 4 sets out how noise should not detract from character and appearance.
Appeal Decision APP/V1260/D/24/3337213
8
45. In the abstract ‘utilitarian’ additions to a listed building such as Mudeford
House, a grand neoclassical early nineteenth century property,16 might be
incongruous. Although less grand, Mude Cottage is also of refined design
(including on account of hood mouldings around windows within its principal
elevation). As with other historic properties nearby, both represent something
of a late Georgian and early Victorian affluent seaside expansion here. It is a
truism, however, that historic buildings need to evolve somewhat.
46. Set against that context, in one sense the enclosure is designed for function (to
attenuate sound and to shield one ASHP from the elements). However, firstly,
it cannot fairly be described as utilitarian accorded its ordinary meaning of
useful or practical rather than attractive. Any element of the built environment
is, after all, to serve some form of purpose. The enclosure is principally of
timber, with a louvred design, and finished white consistent with walls by it.
Unlike many housings for plant and equipment it is neither of standardised nor
principally functional aesthetic, but has rather been crafted to fit its particular
context. In materials, understated design, and finish it is consistent and
unobtrusive in its surroundings.
47. Secondly the enclosure is, all told, a very modest structure.17 At its highest it
reaches to around the level of the boundary wall with no. 87, and far lower
than buildings either side of it (to which I will return). As aptly noted in the
MQCAA, Mudeford House is ‘on a grand scale’. Physically both ASHPs and the
enclosure to one, might fairly be characterised as almost de minimis additions
relative to the original form of Mudeford House and its expansive plot (or
indeed relative to the form and plot of Mude Cottage).
48. More broadly, and thirdly, the MQCAA notes how the area hereabouts is
characterised by the prevalence of substantial brick boundary walls and
established, mature planting.18 That creates a strong sense of enclosure and
intimacy, in contrast to the comparative openness across the water towards the
Quay. That character is clearly reflected in the plots of nos. 85, 87, 89 and
89A. Whilst significance and visibility are different concepts, there is no
meaningful intervisibility between the ASHPs or enclosure and original elements
of either nos. 85 or 87. The development is largely concealed. The
development is of such limited extent so as not to be appreciable in any longer-
distance views either (if there would be any visibility whatsoever).
49. Fourth, plan no. 23.011-HGP-01-22-DR-A-2001 REVISION C shows how the
enclosure is sandwiched between an existing ‘swimming pool building’ and
‘summer house’. The former is substantial and projects to the rear of the
historic form of no. 85, set close to the boundary with no. 87. BCP’s officer
report lists 14 applications for either listed building consent or planning
permission related to Mudeford House dating back to 2002. Of those, the
swimming pool relates, to some extent, to 4.19 The summer house, also far
16 The driveway wall to which contains a plaque referring to John Brian Keane Lieutenant General, commander in
chief in Jamaica 1833, and in Bombay, Cabul in 1840. Whilst there is no evidence as to any associative connection
in that respect, in era and architectural style, historic elements of Mudeford House are consistent with conspicuous
architectural display and preferences of that era.
17 Noting, for comprehensiveness, that the ASHP serving the swimming pool is barely perceptible (being set
beneath a boardwalk and essentially occluded from view by domestic planting).
18 Page 25.
19 8/21/0677/HOU and 8/21/0678/LB, both approved 20 December 2021, 8/11/0261 and 8/11/0262, both
approved 30 August 2011.
Appeal Decision APP/V1260/D/24/3337213
9
taller and more substantial than any aspect of the development, relates to
planning permission secured in 2019.20
50. There is no indication in the evidence before me, aside from in respect of the
development at issue in this appeal, that anything at the appeal site
unauthorised or subject to enforcement (whether investigation or action). The
ASHPs are next to substantial elements of Mudeford House constructed in
recent years, rather than there being any appreciable visual relationship to the
historic fabric or appearance of the property.
51. Summarising the foregoing, the development is appropriately designed,
modest, enclosed and relates to substantial recent elements of the property.
There is no meaningful effect on elements of the historic environment, or in
respect of the special interest or significance of nos. 85, 87 or the MQCA more
broadly (touched upon throughout this main issue insofar as relevant to this
appeal). In summary what BCP have described in their decision notice is
change, whereas in my view that change is not detrimental.
52. I therefore conclude that the development accords with the expectations of
statute referenced above and the relevant provisions of CS polies HE1 and HE2,
of LP policies BE4 and BE15, and of NPPF paragraphs 195 and 205. In summary
all the foregoing seek to ensure that development integrates acceptably with
historic character appearance, significance and integrity.
53. It is consequently unnecessary to consider whether any public benefits of the
scheme either exist or would outweigh any harm (the appellant noting that the
scheme stems from the motivation to move towards a more sustainable form of
energy usage at Mudeford House). It is also unnecessary to consider whether
alternative approaches could have achieved comparable benefits.
Conclusion
54. Having considered the development plan as a whole along with all other
relevant material considerations, I conclude that the appeal should be allowed
subject to the conditions below.
Conditions
55. As the application is retrospective it is unnecessary to require commencement
in line with section 91 of the 1990 Act. It is nonetheless necessary to impose
condition 1 securing compliance with the approved plans in the interests of
certainty and so as to ensure that the development remains as assessed
above.21 Following on from my reasoning in paragraph 41 of this decision, I
have also imposed condition 2 to avoid undue effects to the living conditions of
those nearby in respect of noise.22 In imposing conditions I have had regard to
the relevant provisions of the NPPF, PPG and of statute to ensure that all are
appropriate.
Tom Bristow
INSPECTOR
20 8/18/3032/HOU, approved 30 April 2019.
21 Thereby obviating the need for BCP’s proposed second condition.
22 Thereby obviating the need for BCP’s proposed third conditions.
Appeal Decision APP/V1260/D/24/3337213
10
SCHEDULE OF CONDITIONS
1) The development hereby permitted shall accord with the following approved
plans: ‘20-1074-LOC’, dated June/21, the Location and Block Plan, and 23.011-
HGP-01-22-DR-A-2001 REVISION C, dated July 2024, entitled ‘Pool Plant Room
Details’.
2) The development hereby permitted shall operate so as to function with no
greater level of sound generation or effects than established via the Noise
Impact Assessment of 25 September 2023 prepared by Vanguardia, ref.
0055609-VAN-RP-0002, Revision P01, or 42dB(A) at the nearest sensitive
receptor in line with the Microgeneration Installation Standard (MCS 020, Issue
1.3), whichever is the lesser.
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.