Removal of existing conservatory and replace with one and half storey extension (renewal of H16-1143-07) and proposed carport (retrospective)
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Character & Appearance
Residential Amenity
Policy Weight
Inspector’s Reasoning
1
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 20 February 2024
by J Somers BSocSci (Planning) MA (HEC) MRTPI IHBC
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State.
Decision date:12.03.2024
Appeal Ref: APP/A2525/D/23/3334715
75 Bourne Road, Spalding, Lincolnshire PE11 1JR
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr D Roberts against the decision of South Holland District
Council.
• The application Ref H16-0727-23, dated 10 August 2023, was refused by notice dated
10 October 2023.
• The development proposed is described as ‘Removal of existing conservatory and
replace with one and half storey extension (renewal of H16-1143-07) and proposed
carport (retrospective).’
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed insofar as it relates to the carport.
2. The appeal is allowed insofar as it relates to the removal of existing
conservatory and replace with one and half storey extension; and planning
permission is granted for the Removal of existing conservatory and replace
with one and half storey extension at 75 Bourne Road, Spalding, Lincolnshire
PE11 1JR in accordance with the terms of the application, Ref H16-0727-23,
dated 10 August 2023, so far as relevant to that part of the development
hereby permitted and subject to the following conditions:
1) The one and a half storey extension hereby permitted shall be maintained in
accordance with the approved plans, unless further planning consent is
obtained from the Local Planning Authority:
• ‘Proposed Visuals,’ Drg No, 3289-07, Undated, Drawn by Remway Design
Ltd;
• ‘Proposed Floor Layout,’ Drg No, 3289-06, Undated, Drawn by Remway
Design Ltd;
• ‘Proposed Elevations,’ Drg No, 3289-05, Undated, Drawn by Remway Design
Ltd;
• ‘Proposed Block Plan,’ Drg No, 3289-04, Undated, Drawn by Remway Design
Ltd;
Preliminary Matters
3. The demolition of the existing conservatory and the erection of one and a half
storey extension was seen to be appropriate and in accordance with the
Development Plan as seen within the Planning Officer’s Report. I note that the
one and a half storey extension also does not feature within the Council’s
reasons for refusal, and that the only concern between both parties concerns
Appeal Decision: APP/A2525/D/23/3334715
2
the erection of the carport. I have no reason to dispute the Council’s opinion on
the one and a half storey extension, and as such agree that the one and a half
storey extension is in accordance with the policies of the Development Plan. As
such, I will not deal with this development any further, but focus on the matter
in contention concerning the car port.
4. Upon visiting the site, the carport frame had been erected and as such is
retrospective. As such, I have made my decision on this basis. It is also noted
that Reasons for Refusal No.2 and 3 relate to the same issue regarding design,
character and appearance. Consequently, I will deal with both reasons for
refusal together under the same matter.
Main Issues
5. Taking the above into account, the main issues are the effect of the carport
upon:
• The existing building and the character and appearance of the greater
locality; and
• The living conditions of No.73C/D Bourne Road, with particular consideration
to access to light.
Reasons
Character and Appearance
6. The appeal site lies to the south of Bourne Road which contains a number of
different periods of dwellings, with evidence of semi-detached Victorian
dwellings located close to the footpath, and later infill development during the
twentieth and twenty-first century which tends to have a greater setback from
the footpath. There is some evidence of vegetation to front gardens and from
glimpses between properties to vegetation in rear gardens, unfortunately much
of this side of the road is dominated by hard paving and vehicular parking
which presents a poor appearance to the street. The opposite side of road is
somewhat the opposite, with dwellings having a larger setback and where
vegetation is allowed to dominate giving a much more leafy feel to the street
scene. This leads further along the road which contains a hedgerow to the road
edge with mature trees behind which adds positively to the local
distinctiveness, character and appearance of the locality. .
7. The appeal site is experienced as part of the greater collection of infill buildings
and spaces within the street scene and contains a one and a half storey
dwelling of brown brick and gable fronting the street. The appeal dwelling has a
relatively large setback from the footpath at the front boundary, with the front
garden being completely hardstanding which compared to dwellings with large
setbacks opposite, presents a poor appearance to the character and
appearance of the street scene. This appearance is accentuated by the parking
of vehicles to the front garden area which adds further clutter and negative
aspects to the character, local distinctiveness and appearance of the area.
8. When considering development, the South East Lincolnshire Local Plan (LP)
Policies 2 and 3 are design led policies which seek that proposals consider size,
scale layout, relationship wo other land uses; creating a sense of place,
massing of neighbouring buildings and the surrounding area, amongst others.
Appeal Decision: APP/A2525/D/23/3334715
3
Additionally the National Planning Policy Framework (the Framework)
paragraph 135 seeks that applications adopt a design led approach and that
developments are sympathetic to local character, including the surrounding
environment.
9. Typically a car parking building such as a garage or carport would be a smaller
subservient component to the main dwelling and as shown in the surrounding
area where garages are small and subservient structures, and which are
typically located to the side and rear of the dwelling, with the main frontage of
the building, despite the setback, being the dominant form within the street
scene.
10. The carport as constructed is very large and takes up much of the front garden
area and would be unlike anything in the surrounding area. The carport would
be unusual in its size, location, and dominance within the street scene which
accentuates the poor appearance and clutter already experienced as a result of
the hard standing and vehicular parking area. Whilst I agree that the use of
timber is an appropriate material for such a carport, this does not overcome
the dominant form and appearance of the car port which does not reinforce the
positive character, appearance and local distinctiveness of the area.
11. Taking the above into account, and in conclusion of this matter, the carport
would be harmful to the local distinctiveness, character and appearance of the
area, and be contrary to LP policies 2 and 3 and additionally the Framework
Paragraph 135.
Living Conditions
12. No.73 C/D is an apartment that is set forward within the plot compared to the
appeal site. Unusually, the main and only window to the Kitchen/diner of the
neighbouring property is within the front garden area of the appeal site and
requires this third party land for its access to natural light. The carport,
although having open sides, the roof does cause a significant amount of
overshadowing and loss of light to this window of the neighbouring property,
which is its only window.
13. I can appreciate the appellant’s comments that there is already a deal of harm
caused to the living conditions of this window as a result of cars parking right
in front of it which likely cause, noise, fumes and blockage of some light. The
appellant has presented a fallback position that they could erect a wall under
the GPDO along the boundary of their site which would in-effect block out all
light to the neighbouring window. Additionally, it has been put forward by the
appellant that they are willing to accept the removal of permitted development
rights for the erection of a wall should I allow this appeal and which the
Appellant seeks me to consider as a material consideration to this scheme.
There is no evidence that the Appellant would construct such a wall which
would not serve any other purpose except to annoy the neighbour, and whilst I
agree this scenario would be more detrimental than the current proposal in
terms of overshadowing, and that the removal of permitted development rights
would remove the threat of the appellant constructing a wall, it does not
provide sufficient justification to depart from the policies of the Development
Plan. Furthermore, the issue of living conditions is not the only matter which
the development is contrary to when considered against the Development Plan,
and hence this potential fallback position has little weight in my determination.
Whilst I also appreciate that there already exists an amount of harm caused to
Appeal Decision: APP/A2525/D/23/3334715
4
this neighbouring window by the parking of vehicles by the appellant, this does
not provide justification that the existing harm is acceptable, or that it is
appropriate to cause further harm.
14. Taking the above into account and in conclusion of this matter, the proposal
would be detrimental to the living conditions of the neighbouring resident from
a significant loss of light. The scheme is therefore contrary to LP Policy 2 and 3
which seeks that development not cause harm to the amenity of existing and
neighbouring occupiers.
Conclusion and Conditions
15.For the reasons given above, I conclude that the appeal should succeed in
relation to one and half storey extension. However, in relation to the carport,
the appeal should be dismissed. As the car port is both physically and
functionally severable, I consider a split decision would be a logical outcome.
16.In respect of the appeal being allowed, the Council has issued a list of
recommended conditions which I have considered against the Framework and
the National Planning Practice Guidance which advises that conditions should
only be imposed where they are necessary, relevant to planning and to the
development to be permitted, enforceable, precise and reasonable in all other
respects.
17.Suggested condition 1 is an approved plans condition, which is a standard
conditions which is necessary and for the avoidance of doubt as this provides
certainty to the scheme which has been approved. A time limit condition in this
respect is not required due to the development being retrospective.
J Somers
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.