Excavation of single storey basement, formation of rear lightwell with walk on rooflight and associated alterations
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Flood Risk
Residential Amenity
Highways & Transport
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 9 April 2024
By Terrence Kemmann-Lane JP DipTP FRTPI MCMI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 23 April 2024
Appeal Ref: APP/K5600/D/23/3333904
4 Child's Street, London, SW5 9RY
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Dr Helmi Ismail against the decision of the Council of the Royal
Borough of Kensington and Chelsea.
• The application Ref PP/23/04146, dated 22 June 2023, was refused by notice dated
5 September 2023.
• The development proposed is excavation of single storey basement, formation of rear
lightwell with walk on rooflight and associated alterations.
Decision
1. The appeal is allowed and planning permission is granted for excavation of
single storey basement, formation of rear lightwell with walk on rooflight and
associated alterations at 4 Child's Street, London, SW5 9RY in accordance with
the terms of the application, Ref PP/23/04146, dated 22 June 2023, subject to
the conditions set out in the schedule at the end of this decision.
Application for costs
2. An application for costs was made by Dr Helmi Ismail against Council of the
Royal Borough of Kensington and Chelsea. This application is the subject of a
separate Decision.
Preliminary matters
3. I am aware that since their decision, the Councils New Local Plan Review has
progressed to Regulation 18 as of March 2022. There is not substantive
reference to policies in the new plan, the officer’s report stating that it has
limited weight at the present stage. I have decided the appeal on the basis of
the policies put before me.
4. There have been 2 previous appeals for developments that were near identical
to the current proposal. I have been supplied with copies of the Inspector’s
decision on both cases1. The main issues were similar in both the previous
appeals as in the case here (with an additional sewer flooding issue in the first
of them). However, I have determined this appeal on the basis of the evidence
put before me.
1 Appeal reference 3252281 of December 2020, and appeal reference 3302060 of November 2022.
Appeal Decision APP/K5600/D/23/3333904
2
Main Issues
5. The main issues in this case are i) the effect of the proposal on the residents,
businesses and users of Child's Street and Earls Court Road, and ii) the effect
of the proposal on the integrity on the appeal building and nearby buildings and
infrastructure, in particular No.5 Child’s Street.
Reasons
6. The appeal property is a three-storey terraced dwelling dating from the 1950’s
situated on the northern side of the street and has a single parking space to
the front. The property is part of a group of three terraced houses, which were
built during the 1950s, to replace Victorian terraced properties which were
damaged during WWII. Number 4 is directly attached to No.5 which, with its
neighbours to the west, is part of the original Victorian terrace.
7. No.4 Child’s Street is situated 35 metres from the junction with Earl’s Court
Road. Child’s Street is a single width residential road with no turning available
at the end. Earl’s Court Road is a one-way street, with commercial frontages,
mainly shops, pubs and cafes. About 10 metres to the north of the junction of
Child’s Street and Earl’s Court Road is a loading bay limited to 20 minutes
waiting time.
Disruption to users of the highways
8. Of the policies mentioned in the refusal reasons, it is Policy CL7k that is most
relevant in respect of this issue. This reads (The council will require all
basement development to): k. ensure that traffic and construction activity do
not cause unacceptable harm to pedestrian, cycle, vehicular and road safety;
adversely affect bus or other transport operations (e.g., cycle hire),
significantly increase traffic congestion, nor place unreasonable inconvenience
on the day to day life of those living, working and visiting nearby.
9. In addition, the council’s Basements Supplementary Planning Document of April
2016 provides detailed guidance relating to the implementation of policy CL7.
This requires a draft Construction Traffic Management Plan (CTMP), to be
submitted, demonstrating how the traffic associated with the construction
phase will be managed.
10. The following is a brief and partial summary of the draft CTMP, since the parties
are fully familiar with it. It states that no construction vehicles would enter
Child’s Street. All lorries would use the public loading bay located a short
distance to the north of the junction of Earle’s Court Road and Child’s Street.
The loading time for the loading bay is restricted to 20 minutes. Transport for
London has confirmed that the loading bay may be used for the purpose of
removing the spoil.
11. The CTMP estimates a build time of 32 weeks with the excavation phase (the
most intensive phase) limited to 12 weeks, and that the timings of the
movements would be restricted to between 0930 to 1630 hours (outside
morning and evening peak hours) Monday to Friday, with no more than 3
vehicles using the loading bay per day during the excavation phase to remove
excavated spoil (an average of 2 vehicles per day is expected). Each loading
session during the excavation phase would involve up to 6 pallet truck
movements along Child’s Street in any one loading session (3 each way) to
load a 7.5t tipper.
Appeal Decision APP/K5600/D/23/3333904
3
12. The electric pallet truck would take about 30 seconds in each direction: no
more than 3 minutes for each loading session (six 30 second intervals) when
the pallet truck was operational on Child’s Steet where potential obstruction
might occur. Materials would be delivered to site using the loading bay with no
more than 2 deliveries a day. Qualified traffic marshals would be used to hold
vehicles or pedestrians whilst the pallet truck was on the road or footpath, if a
conflict in movement was likely to occur. The pallet truck could move on the
pavement or the road, making it possible for cars and pedestrians to pass
whilst the movements were taking place.
13. The officer’s report makes clear that the view of the Inspector in the most
recent of the appeals is not accepted and sets out the reasons that the council
considers that the draft CTMP should not be accepted. Again, both parties will
be familiar with this section of the report, which deals with the nature of Child’s
Street as a very narrow cul-de-sac and the nature of Earl’s Court Road as one
of the busiest highways in the Royal borough, and its status as a red route.
Doubt is cast on the assessment of the operation of removing spoil and delivery
of materials, a lack of contingency plans, a lack of clarity over some matters,
and that violation of the 20-minute waiting time would be unenforceable.
14. I conclude that the submitted draft CTMP does indicate that a satisfactory
scheme could be submitted as a consequence of a condition requiring it, to
ensure that the construction of the appeal development could be undertaken
without harmful disruption to the users of the highway and footpaths, including
residents and nearby businesses on Earl’s Court Road.
15. In my experience there is frequently a temptation for delivery vehicles to
overstay 20-minute loading restrictions, but threat of parking enforcement is
generally effective, or otherwise it would be evident that congestion and
inconvenience would be commonplace. Furthermore, I cannot see that the
vehicles involved in the appeal development would be in any different position
to those delivering to local business premises and houses, when confronted
with full occupation of the loading bay. I have not been presented with any
evidence of such situations occurring with harmful consequences.
16. On balance I am satisfied that the first main issue can be overcome with the
imposition of a suitable condition. The appeal scheme would not cause
unacceptable harm to pedestrian, cycle, vehicular and road safety nor place
unreasonable inconvenience on those living, working and visiting nearby.
The structural integrity on the appeal building and nearby buildings.
17. Local plan policy CL7 requires, among other matters, that basement
development be designed to safeguard the structural stability of the existing
building and nearby buildings. Item m. of this policy requires development to
“be designed to safeguard the structural stability of the existing building,
nearby buildings and other infrastructure including London Underground
tunnels and the highway.” The council’s Basements Supplementary Planning
Document (SPD) adopted April 2016, also seeks further assurance in respect to
structural stability through the provision of a Construction Method Statement
(CMS) to ensure the construction of basements can be undertaken safely.
18. The Planning Practice Guidance (PPG) states that the planning system has an
important role in considering land stability by minimising the risk and effects of
land stability on property, infrastructure and the public and helping ensure that
Appeal Decision APP/K5600/D/23/3333904
4
development does not occur in unstable locations or without appropriate
precautions.
19. The appeal documentation includes a CMS that has been written by a firm of
structural engineers, that has been signed off by the engineer from whom the
practice gets its name. He is a chartered engineer, being a member of the
Institution of Structural Engineers. Thus, I have no concerns about the
adequacy of the professional input, or doubts that it can be relied on for the
purpose of satisfying me that the CMS is a sound basis for making a decision
about the structural soundness of the proposal. I would add that the
development of new basement accommodation to existing buildings appears to
have been a frequent undertaking in London for some years; hence no doubt
the reason for the council’s adoption of the SPD.
20. In coming to a conclusion of this issue, I have taken into account that the
adjoining dwelling is Victorian, as noted in paragraph 6 above. Therefore, the
foundations of No.5 will be of that time. That fact is clearly well known to the
authors of the CMS, and the method of carrying out the proposed development
will have taken that into account.
21. In light of the above considerations, I am satisfied that the CMS satisfies the
policy requirement of policy CL7 and the SPD, and that the proposal can be
undertaken safely and should not endanger the integrity on the appeal building
or nearby buildings and infrastructure, in particular, No.5 Child’s Street. I also
note that other regimes, such as the Building Regulations and the Party Wall
etc Act 1996 would be further safeguards preventing harmful works from
progressing. I am satisfied that a comprehensive Construction Method
Statement and professional supervision could be secured by condition and
there would be no conflict with LP Policy CL7(m).
Conclusions
22. For the reasons that I have set out above I am satisfied that the reasons for
refusal have ben overcome. Therefore, I will allow the appeal.
Conditions
23. The statutory condition that provides a time limit on the start of development
must be imposed. In addition, the council has suggested a number of
conditions in the event that the appeal is upheld. I have considered these in
the light of Planning Practice Guidance (PPG). For clarity and to ensure
compliance with the PPG, I have amended some of the text. I consider that the
conditions should be imposed for the following reasons: condition 2 is to ensure
that the appearance of the development permitted integrates with the existing
in a visually satisfactory manner; condition 3 is required for certainty and
avoidance of doubt as to the development permitted; condition 4 is to minimise
the impact of construction works upon users of the highway and nearby
residents living conditions; condition 5 is to ensure that the engineering and
construction of the development is properly supervised in the interests of
highway safety and nearby residents’ living conditions; conditions 6 and 7 are
to mitigate the impact of construction work upon the living conditions of
neighbouring occupiers; condition 8 is to reduce flood risk and to contribute to
sustainability.
Appeal Decision APP/K5600/D/23/3333904
5
24. Conditions 4 to 8 are pre-commencement conditions, because clearly the
matters they deal with must be agreed before any construction can start, as
compliance with the requirements of the condition at a later time would result
in unacceptable harm during the development contrary to the policies of the
Development Plan, which the conditions are designed to avoid. Section
100ZA(5) of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 requires that, if the
Inspector is minded to grant planning permission subject to pre-
commencement condition(s) he/she may only do so with the written agreement
of the appellant to the terms of the condition(s). In this case the appellant’s
agent has clearly stated on the appellant’s behalf that the conditions are
acceptable.
Terrence Kemmann-Lane
INSPECTOR
Appeal Decision APP/K5600/D/23/3333904
6
Schedule of Conditions
1) The development hereby permitted shall begin not later than 3 years
from the date of this decision.
2) The materials to be used in the construction of the external surfaces of
the development hereby permitted shall match those used in the existing
building.
3) The development hereby permitted shall be carried out in accordance
with the approved plans.
4) No development shall commence until a Construction Traffic Management
Plan has been submitted to and approved in writing by the local planning
authority. The statement should include:
a) routeing of demolition, excavation and construction vehicles, including
a response to existing or known projected major building works at other
sites in the vicinity and local works in the highway;
b) access arrangements to the site;
c) the estimated number and type of vehicles per day/week;
d) details of any vehicle holding area;
e) details of the vehicle call up procedure;
f) estimates for the number and type of parking suspensions that will be
required;
g) details of any diversion or other disruption to the public highway
during preparation, demolition, excavation and construction work
associated with the development;
h) work programme and/or timescale for each phase of preparation,
demolition, excavation and construction work associated with the
development;
i) details of measures to protect pedestrians and other highway users
from construction activities on the highway; and
j) where works cannot be contained wholly within the site a plan should
be submitted showing the site layout on the highway including extent of
hoarding, position of nearby trees in the highway or adjacent gardens,
pedestrian routes, parking bay suspensions and remaining road width for
vehicle movements.
The development shall be carried out in accordance with the approved
Construction Traffic Management Plan.
A one-page summary of the requirements of the approved CTMP shall be
affixed to the frontage of the site for the duration of the works at a
location where it can be read by members of the public.
5) No development shall commence until a) Chartered Civil Engineer (MICE)
or Chartered Structural Engineer (MI Struct.E) has been appointed for the
duration of building works and their appointment confirmed in writing to
the Local Planning Authority, and b) the name, and contact details of the
person supervising engineering and construction on site for the duration
of building works have been confirmed in writing to the Local Planning
Authority. In the event that either the Appointed Engineer or Appointed
Supervisor cease to perform that role for whatever reason before the
construction works are completed, those works shall cease until a
replacement chartered engineer of the afore-described qualification or
replacement supervisor has been appointed to supervise their completion
Appeal Decision APP/K5600/D/23/3333904
7
and their appointment confirmed in writing to the Local Planning
Authority. At no time shall any construction work take place unless an
engineer and supervisor are at that time currently appointed and their
appointment has been notified to this Authority in accordance with this
condition.
6) No development shall commence until such time as the lead contractor,
for the site, is signed up to the Considerate Constructors Scheme and its
published Code of Considerate Practice, and the details of (i) the
membership, (ii) contact details, (iii) working hours as stipulated under
the Control of Pollution Act 1974, and (iv) Certificate of Compliance, are
clearly displayed on the site so that they can be easily read by passing
members of the public, and shall thereafter be maintained on display
throughout the duration of the works forming the subject of this
permission.
7) No development shall commence until:
a) An Appendix A Checklist and Site Construction Management Plan
(SCMP) for the development have both been submitted to, and approved
in writing, by the Council’s Construction Management Team, and then
b) Copies of the approved Checklist and Plan, and their written approval,
have been submitted to the local planning authority to be placed on the
property record.
The development shall be carried out in accordance with the Appendix A
Checklist and SCMP so approved, or in accordance with a subsequent
Checklist or SCMP as may be approved under this condition.
8) No development shall commence until a Sustainable Drainage Systems
Strategy (SDSS) with the following information is submitted to and
approved in writing by the Local Planning Authority:
a) A detailed analysis of surface water run-off and attenuation volume
(to demonstrate how the proposed measures will aim to comply with
Local Plan Policy CE2 (g), which is to achieve a reduction of 50% of
existing rates including climate change in the calculations and factoring
in all flows into the sewer system including groundwater or other flows).
b) Information about the proposed SDSS types, their location,
attenuation capacity, specification, structural integrity, construction,
operation, access, and maintenance. (More sustainable green SDSS
should be favoured over attenuation tanks).
c) Section/profile drawings of the SDSS, if relevant (green roofs, blue
roofs, sub-base attenuation, permeable paving, planters, species, etc.).
d) Drainage plans to show clearly how surface water run-off will be
conveyed to the SDSS and any connections to the sewer system if
necessary. During construction of the development hereby permitted the
approved Sustainable Drainage System (SDSS) and Flood Risk measures
shall be fully implemented and maintained thereafter.
End of Schedule
£
Costs decision section
Costs Decision
Site visit made on 9 April 2024
by Terrence Kemmann-Lane JP DipTP FRTPI MCMI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 23 April 2024
Costs application in relation to Appeal Ref: APP/K5600/D/23/3333904
4 Child's Street, London, SW5 9RY
• The application is made under the Town and Country Planning Act 1990, sections 78,
322 and Schedule 6, and the Local Government Act 1972, section 250(5).
• The application is made by Dr Helmi Ismail for a full award of costs against the Council
of the Royal Borough of Kensington and Chelsea.
• The appeal was against the refusal of planning permission for excavation of single
storey basement, formation of rear lightwell with walk on rooflight and associated
alterations.
Decision
1. The application for an award of costs is allowed in the terms set out below.
Reasons
2. The Planning Practice Guidance advises that costs may be awarded against a
party who has behaved unreasonably and thereby caused the party applying
for costs to incur unnecessary or wasted expense in the appeal process.
The Application
3. There have been 2 previous refusals for the development dealt with in this
appeal. Both appeals failed for technical reasons relating to documentation. In
the second of these appeals (APP/K5600/D22/3302060), the Inspector found
that the submitted Construction Traffic Management Plan (CTMP) was
satisfactory, and that the measures set out in it would ensure minimal
disruption or inconvenience to those living and working nearby and that any
violation of the 20-minute loading restriction could be controlled by parking
enforcement, and a condition could deal with the matter.
4. However, the appeal failed because the submitted Construction Management
Statement (CMS) was not signed by a suitably qualified Chartered Engineer. On
the basis of a precautionary approach, the Inspector concluded that it would be
inappropriate to deal with the matter by a condition. The CMS submitted with
the current appeal is signed by a member of the Institution of Structural
Engineers, thereby overcoming that deficiency.
5. Following that appeal decision, the council wrote a letter, dated 29th November
2022, addressed to the Planning Inspectorate, stating that it respectfully
disagrees with the Inspectors assessment of the CTMP. This letter was
published on the application portal during the consultation period, before the
neighbour consultation period had expired. The decision to publish the letter,
Costs Decision APP/K5600/D/23/3333904
2
which was not copied to the appellant, and may have influenced the objections
made by local residents and fettered the ability of the council to consider the
application on its individual merits, and in the light of the previous Inspector’s
decision.
6. The behaviour of the council to not accept the findings of the previous
Inspector, and the revised document submitted on this occasion, and its failure
to add anything new, is considered unreasonable. This has led to the appellant
incurring unnecessary or wasted expense in the appeal process. A full award of
costs is therefore sought.
The Rebuttal
7. No rebuttal has been offered by the council.
Conclusions
8. The previous Inspector’s decision referred to by the appellant was clear, that it
was likely that a condition could be applied with reference to the CTMP, had it
not been for the issue of a signed CMS. In the absence of a signature by a
Chartered Civil Engineer (MICE) or a Chartered Structural Engineer on the
CMS, a precautionary approach was taken. It is also clear from the letter that
the council wrote to the Planning Inspectorate that the council did not accept
these judgements. The council has therefore put forward the same arguments
as previously.
9. Looking at the matter afresh, I have come to similar conclusions to the
previous Inspector, but now with the assurance that the CMS has been signed
off by Chartered Structural Engineer. Both the CMS and the CTMP are
persuasive that the development can take place without unreasonable
disruption to residents of Childs’ Street or businesses on Earls Court Road or
highway users of both roads, and without harm to the structural integrity on
the appeal building and, in particular, No.5 Child’s Street. In the absence of
fresh evidence to the contrary, the costs claim is made out.
10. I therefore find that unreasonable behaviour resulting in unnecessary or
wasted expense, as described in the Planning Practice Guidance, has been
demonstrated and that a full award of costs is justified.
Costs Order
11. In exercise of the powers under section 250(5) of the Local Government Act
1972 and Schedule 6 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 as amended,
and all other enabling powers in that behalf, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED that the
Council of the Royal Borough of Kensington and Chelsea shall pay to Dr Helmi
Ismail the costs of the appeal proceedings described in the heading of this
decision; such costs to be assessed in the Senior Courts Costs Office if not
agreed.
12. The applicant is now invited to submit to the Council of the Royal Borough of
Kensington and Chelsea, to whom a copy of this decision has been sent, details
of those costs with a view to reaching agreement as to the amount.
Terrence Kemmann-Lane
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.