Proposed development is demolition of bay and outside WC and construction of single storey rear extension and internal reconfiguration
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Heritage & Conservation
Character & Appearance
Trees & Landscape
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 13 March 2024
by P B Jarvis BSc (Hons) DipTP MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 10 April 2024
Appeal Ref: APP/B5480/D/23/3333874
6 Meadway, Romford, RM2 5NU
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by KMDS Designs against the decision of the Council of the London
Borough of Havering.
• The application Ref P1441.23, dated 18 September 2023, was refused by notice dated
14 November 2023.
• The proposed development is demolition of bay and outside WC and construction of
single storey rear extension and internal reconfiguration.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Procedural Matter
2. Since the appeal was lodged an updated National Planning Policy Framework
(the Framework) has been published. However, the relevant parts have not
materially changed therefore I have not sought further comments from the
parties. I have referred to the updated paragraphs of the Framework in my
decision below.
Main Issue
3. The main issue is the impact on the character and appearance of the host
building and the Gidea Park Conservation Area.
Reasons
4. The appeal site comprises a characterful detached two-storey dwelling set on
an extensive long, narrow plot. It is one of the original cottages of the 1911
Exhibition Houses which fall within the Gidea Park Conservation Area.
Meadway is residential in character though the wider area is also characterised
by areas of open space including the Raphael Park Tennis Club at the western
end of Meadway and golf course at its eastern end.
Significance of the heritage asset
5. The Gidea Park Conservation Area (CA) seeks to preserve the special
architectural and historical interest of the Gidea Park Estate formed of the
1910/11 and 1934 Gidea Park Exhibitions and includes the surviving fragments
of the Gidea Hall landscaping. Its’ special interest is described in the Gidea
Park Conservation Area Character Appraisal and Management Proposals SPD
(CAMP) which, amongst other things, describes the area as having a unique
character of the originally designed Garden Suburb mainly comprising of a
Appeal Decision APP/B5480/D/23/3333874
2
delightful variety of individual ‘exhibition’ houses but also including shopping
centres; mature gardens, trees and boundary hedges form an integral part of
the area’s character with some exceptional trees, notably one outside No 10
Parkway. Overall, the distinctive houses combine with mature landscape to
create a suburban residential area of unique history and character.
6. The dwelling on the appeal site and all houses along Parkway, with one
exception, are original 1910/11 ‘exhibition houses’ many of which were
designed by influential architects of the Arts & Crafts movement. These
exhibition houses formed the core of the suburb and were of different designs
but of good quality materials and vernacular details and provide a succession of
picturesque views with varied and complex rooflines and detailed features. The
CAMP (Map 3: character analysis) identifies the dwelling on the appeal site as a
‘building making a positive contribution to the area’ falling within the category
of ‘key buildings’. The Council confirms that it is a non-designated heritage
asset for the purposes of Framework paragraph 209.
7. The site lies within the northern part of the CA which the CAMP describes as
having relatively generous plots. Meadway is identified as having smaller
cottage units, balanced by broad verges and, together with the other nearby
roads developed for the exhibition, described as the most architecturally
distinguished in the CA. The area also contains evidence of the previous
historic use and occupation including the ponds which lie at the southern end of
the appeal site.
8. The dwelling on the appeal site is unaltered from its original form with white
roughcast walls and plain tiled pitched roof over a front projecting gable end
and ‘catslide’ roof to the side. It also contains the original window frames
including bay window to the rear. The site therefore maintains many of its
original features and appearance and makes a significant contribution to its
significance and that of the conservation area.
Effect of the proposal on significance
9. The proposed rear extension would be of flat roofed design with parapet edge
and finished in brick elevations and would extend across almost the whole
width of the rear elevation of the dwelling, involving the removal of the original
bay window. Whilst it would be modest in scale and of subservient size, it
would introduce a building form at odds with the distinctive character and
appearance of the existing cottage. The roof form and use of brick facing
materials would introduce particularly incongruous features that would contrast
starkly with the form and finish of the original ‘exhibition’ cottage.
10. The Appellant suggests that the simple design is intended to deliberately
contrast with the original historic building and avoids impacting on the upper
parts of the rear elevations which a pitched roof extension could not achieve as
it would involve obscuring the upper floor windows and low eaves. It is also
suggested that the stepped design would add interest and its modest size and
siting would result in it having little impact on the wider area.
11. Whilst I would agree that the extension would be of modest size and would
ensure that the spacious nature of the wider area would not be significantly
affected, it would result in the loss of the important original rear bay window
feature. Furthermore, I am not convinced that a smaller pitched roof addition
would necessarily result in the loss of important features at the upper level
Appeal Decision APP/B5480/D/23/3333874
3
albeit would have to ‘tie in’ with the existing gable end and catslide roof. I
note that the Appellant is willing to accept a condition to ensure a roughcast
finish to match the existing dwelling, but the overall design would still be
unacceptable for the reasons given above.
12. Overall, I find that the proposal would have an adverse effect on the character
and appearance of the host dwelling, a non-designated heritage asset, and the
significance of the CA of which it is an important and integral part. This would
result in conflict with Policies 26 and 28 of the Haringey Local Plan 2016-2031
(2021) which promote high quality design through, amongst other things,
supporting development that respects and complements the distinctive
qualities, identity, character and features of the site and local area, responding
to distinctive local building forms, and well-designed development in
conservation areas which preserves, enhances or better reveals the character
and appearance of the area and its significance.
13. It would also fail to satisfy the guidance in the Council’s Heritage SPD (2011)
which aims to ensure appropriate protection, enhancement and management of
Havering’s heritage assets by enabling sensitive responses.
Planning balance
14. As a result of my findings above, I conclude that there would be less than
substantial harm arising in the context of paragraph 208 of the Framework.
This also states that such harm should be weighed against the public benefits
of the proposal. The additional accommodation sought is mainly to provide
enhanced accommodated for the Appellant’s family. Whilst these are
essentially private benefits, I recognise that the proposal would result in a
larger dwelling that could be available as part of the wider local supply. In
addition, there would be limited economic benefits arising as suggested by the
Appellant. However, these benefits are of limited weight and do not outweigh
the harm to the significance of the heritage asset to which considerable weight
must be given.
15. Framework paragraph 209 is also relevant which states that the effect of an
application on a non-designated heritage asset should be taken into account
and a balanced judgement will be required having regard to the scale of harm
and its significance. For the reasons set out above, I consider that the
proposal would detract from the significance of the non-designated heritage
asset and there are no factors which outweigh that harm.
16. In respect of other policies of the Framework, the proposal would not accord
with its objectives to achieve good design and development that is sympathetic
to local character including the surrounding built environment.
17. I have been referred to an appeal decision relating to rear single storey
extensions to a nearby property within the conservation area, no. 18 Parkway1.
Whilst the Inspector in that case found the proposal to be acceptable, there are
clear differences to the scheme before me, not least that the dwelling had
undergone a number of alterations and extensions, some of which would be
replaced by that proposed.
18. I find that the proposal does not accord with the development plan and there
are no material considerations that indicate a decision otherwise.
1 APP/B5480/D/22/3301769 dated 24 October 2022
Appeal Decision APP/B5480/D/23/3333874
4
Conclusions
19. I therefore conclude that this appeal should be dismissed.
P B Jarvis
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.