Retrospective garage
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Green Belt Policy
Policy Weight
Fallback Position
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 17 April 2024
by D Szymanski BSc (Hons) MA MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 26th April 2024
Appeal Ref: APP/M1595/D/23/3330818
Alcott, Oxford Road, Horndon on the Hill, Thurrock SS17 8PX
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Ms Gloria Ward against the decision of Thurrock Borough
Council.
• The application Ref 23/00735/HHA, dated 20 June 2023, was refused by notice dated
7 August 2023.
• The development proposed is described as retrospective garage.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Procedural Matters
2. Since the appeal was lodged the revised National Planning Policy Framework
(2023) (the Framework) was published on 19 December 2023. In the context
of the main issues in this appeal, the Framework’s policies have not materially
changed, so there is no requirement for me to seek submissions on this latest
version, and I am satisfied no party would be prejudiced by this approach. The
numbering below reflects the revised Framework.
3. The application form confirms that the application is retrospective, and the
development has been carried out, which reflects what I saw on my site visit.
Main Issues
4. The main issues are:
• whether or not the development is inappropriate development in the Green
Belt;
• the effect of the development upon the openness of the Green Belt; and,
• if the development is inappropriate development, whether the harm by
reason of inappropriateness, and any other harm, is clearly outweighed by
other considerations, and if so, would this amount to the very special
circumstances required to justify the development.
Appeal Decision APP/M1595/D/23/3330818
2
Reasons
Inappropriate development
5. The appeal site comprises a detached dwelling and its plot in the Green Belt,
constructed under a consent1 to replace a previous dwelling. The Council’s
approach is that, though detached, the function and relationship of the appeal
garage and dwelling is such that the garage is regarded as an extension or
alteration to the dwelling. The appellant has not argued this incorrect and from
what I saw and the evidence before me I see no reason to disagree.
6. Paragraph 142 of the Framework states the fundamental aim of Green Belt
policy is to prevent urban sprawl by keeping land permanently open.
Paragraph 152 states that inappropriate development is by definition harmful
to the Green Belt and should not be approved except in very special
circumstances. Policy PMD6 of the Thurrock Core Strategy and Policies for the
Management of Development (as amended) (2015) (the TCS) states
permission will only be granted for new development in the Green Belt,
provided it meets the requirements of the Framework, other policies in the
TCS, and listed policy criteria for Green Belt exceptions.
7. The construction of new buildings should be regarded as inappropriate in the
Green Belt, subject to certain exceptions. An exception at paragraph 154c) is
the extension or alteration of a building provided it does not result in
disproportionate additions over and above the size of the original building.
PMD6 sets out what is considered disproportionate additions, and what is the
original building.
8. Though in the first part of its definition the policy text of PMD6 defines the
original building in a similar way to the Framework, the policy text also
specifically states that any building which is itself a replacement, will not be
considered the original. Proposals for further extension or replacement of that
replacement will be judged by reference to the original building which preceded
it. Criteria 1) states disproportionate means no larger than two reasonably
sized rooms or any equivalent amount. This allowance is worked out by
dividing habitable room floorspace by the number of habitable rooms, then
multiplying it by two.
9. The delegated report states the total of the previous dwelling, its two-room
extension allowance under Policy PMD6, the garage and an outbuilding
combined was approximately 199.6 sqm. The replacement current dwelling is
approximately 198.7 sqm in floorspace, so it has already used all but 0.9 sqm
of the two reasonably sized rooms allowance. This appeal garage seeks to
retain approximately 33.4 sqm of floorspace. Though the garage might be
regarded as compliant with part 1 of the policy read in isolation, it is a detailed
policy, and its wording must be read as a whole.
10. No other exceptions have been advanced to me. Condition 4 of the previous
consent required the removal of the previous garage, prior to construction of
the dwelling. There is nothing before me to suggest garage demolition did not
take place as required, so on that basis, though the appeal garage is in a
similar location, it could not be regarded as a replacement building under
Framework paragraph 154d) or Part 2) of Policy PMD6 of the TCS.
1 Permission Ref. 16/00925/FUL.
Appeal Decision APP/M1595/D/23/3330818
3
11. Based upon its definition of disproportionate additions and the original building,
the footprint and scale of the development does not meet the exception under
Policy PMD6. Therefore, it constitutes inappropriate development in the Green
Belt under Policy PMD6, which is by definition harmful to the Green Belt.
Openness
12. The garage provides a single parking space and allows some further storage, so
represents a significantly sized pitched roof building standing away from the
host dwelling, adding a new building on what was previously driveway space.
Were the stone driveway considered as operational development the new
garage might not be considered to have an adverse effect upon the spatial
openness of the Green Belt.
13. However, by virtue of being significantly above the level of the driveway it
inherently diminishes and has a marked adverse effect upon the visual
openness of the Green Belt in this location. As well as being visible from within
parts of the appeal site, the effects upon visual openness are visible from some
rural land and buildings due south of the site, from the north from parts of Oak
Cottage and St Benedict’s, and to a very limited degree from the Old Chapel.
Therefore, the development has an adverse effect upon the openness of the
Green Belt, at odds with a fundamental aim of Green Belt policy.
Other Considerations
14. The appellant is of the view that the appeal scheme is not inappropriate
development in the Green Belt if the Framework’s definition of the original
building is applied. At Annexe 2, it defines the original building as being as it
existed on 1 July 1948 or, if constructed after, as it was built originally.
15. Though initially adopted in 2011, the TCS focussed review and its examination
was undertaken to ensure compliance with the Framework when published in
20122. By referring to Framework compliance, Policy PMD6 clearly takes into
account the 2012 Framework. There is nothing before me to lead me to
conclude relevant Framework Green Belt policies materially differed to what
they do now, or that the TCS, its examination and adoption was unsound.
16. While development plan policies should be consistent with the Framework, I am
not convinced this means they must be exactly the same. Policy PMD6 follows
the broad approach of the Framework and adds to it, by seeking to prevent
incremental development creep in the Green Belt by inappropriate development
over time in respect of replaced buildings. Therefore, it has a clear rationale
having regard to the aims of Green Belt policy and I see no reason to reduce
the weight attributed to it. The absence of conflict with the exception in the
Framework as a material consideration, attracts moderate weight.
17. Permission Ref. 16/00925/FUL is subject to a condition withdrawing permitted
development rights under Classes A, B, C and E of Part 1 of the GPDO3,
imposed having regard to Green Belt openness. There is nothing before me to
lead me to the view that conditions withdrawing permitted development rights
are untypical in newer replacement dwellings in the Green Belt.
2 Page 3 of the Thurrock Core Strategy and Policies for the Management of Development Focussed Review
(January 2015).
3 The Town and Country Planning (General Permitted Development) (England) Order 2015.
Appeal Decision APP/M1595/D/23/3330818
4
18. This appeal is not one to remove the condition. Whether or not the condition
could be regarded as inflexible to changing circumstances, unreasonable,
unnecessary, or lacking clear justification, this appeal garage still requires
express permission and that is the development before me. However, based
upon the submitted evidence, insofar as it relates to this development, the
condition has a clear rationale having regard to Policy PMD6. It does not stop
all development taking place but requires that express consent is first obtained
from the Council. While beneficial for car, paraphernalia storage and security,
the substantive evidence does not lead me to the view the garage is essential
for the habitation of the dwelling. These matters carry moderate weight.
19. That the appellant was not made aware of the condition when purchasing the
property is unfortunate and that they did not wilfully breach the planning
conditions is noted. However, such factors cannot attract weight in favour of
allowing this appeal based upon the main issues in this case. I also cannot
conclude the appellant has been treated unfairly by the Council’s decision.
20. At my visit I noted premises I was referred to off Robinson Road and some
detached garages at dwellings on Oxford Road within the Green Belt, such as
the Old Chapel, St Benedict’s and Hillview permitted historically. I am provided
with very little detail of the circumstances of the proposals, or the policies in
force at the time of their consent. These were permitted some time ago,
predating the TCS and Framework, so I attribute them only moderate weight.
21. The garage is well-designed, does not result in harm to the character and
appearance of the area, is of a sufficient size for car parking, retains sufficient
parking for, and access to the dwelling. These are neutral matters in the
balance. Were I to have taken the view the garage would not result in harmful
living conditions to neighbouring occupiers this would also be a neutral matter.
Green Belt Balance and Conclusion
22. Policy PMD6 of the TCS seeks to protect the open character of the Green Belt in
accordance with the provisions of the Framework. Paragraph 153 of the
Framework explains that substantial weight should be given to any identified
harm to the Green Belt.
23. The development is inappropriate development in the Green Belt as defined by
Policy PMD6 of the TCS, and effects the openness of the Green Belt. The other
considerations set out by the appellant attract moderate weight. However,
they do not clearly outweigh the harm identified to the Green Belt, which
carries substantial weight, so as to amount to the very special circumstances
necessary to justify the development. Therefore, the development conflicts
with Policy PMD6 of the TCS, and the Framework, read as a whole.
24. The development is contrary to the development plan read as a whole, and the
National Planning Policy Framework, and there are no considerations advanced,
including the policies of the Framework, which outweigh this finding.
Accordingly, for the reasons given, the appeal should not succeed.
Dan Szymanski
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.