Erection of a new 2-bay cart shed
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Green Belt Policy
Heritage & Conservation
Trees & Landscape
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 2 February 2024
by K E Down MA(Oxon) MSc MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date:27th February 2024
Appeal Ref: APP/J1915/D/23/3330627
Tollgate House, Amwell Hill, Great Amwell, Hertfordshire, SG12 9QZ
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Ross Newham against the decision of East Hertfordshire District
Council.
• The application Ref 3/23/1239/HH, dated 26 June 2023, was refused by notice dated 23
August 2023.
• The development proposed is erection of a new 2-bay cart shed.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Preliminary Matter
2. Since the application was determined, a revised National Planning Policy
Framework (Framework) was published on 19 December 2023. However, as any
policies that are material to this decision have not fundamentally changed, I am
satisfied that this has not prejudiced any party. I have had regard to the latest
version of the Framework and new paragraph numbers in reaching my decision.
Main Issues
3. There are four main issues. Firstly, whether the proposed outbuilding would
amount to inappropriate development in the Green Belt, having regard to the
National Planning Policy Framework (the Framework) and any relevant
development plan policies; secondly, the effect of the proposed outbuilding on
the openness of the Green Belt; thirdly, the effect of the outbuilding on the
character and appearance of the area with regard to trees and the setting of the
Grade II listed building; and fourthly, if the proposed outbuilding would amount
to inappropriate development, whether the harm, by reason of
inappropriateness and any other harm is clearly outweighed by other
considerations, such as to amount to the very special circumstances necessary
to justify the development.
Appeal Decision APP/J1915/D/23/3330627
2
Reasons
Whether inappropriate development in the Green Belt
4. Amwell Hill (A1170) is a busy road that lies within the Green Belt. There is
sporadic development on both sides of the highway. The appeal site is accessed
via a gated entrance off Amwell Hill. It comprises a Grade II Listed dwelling set
on a large and steeply sloping plot. The dwelling is on high land with the site
entrance and site of the proposed cart shed on the lowest part of the site, some
55m away. Despite the presence of other buildings, including dwellings, in the
vicinity the site is not within a defined settlement and the character of the area
is that of open countryside.
5. The proposed cart shed would have two bays and a roughly square footprint. It
would have a pitched, tiled roof. It would be located immediately to the
northwest of the site entrance and under the canopy of a large tree. The
existing drive would be extended to provide access to the cart shed. This would
come within a short distance of the tree trunk.
6. Policy GBR1 of the East Herts District Local Plan (LP), 2018, states that planning
applications within the Green Belt will be considered in line with the provisions
of the Framework. The Framework states that inappropriate development is, by
definition, harmful to the Green Belt and should not be approved except in very
special circumstances. Paragraph 154 states that the construction of new
buildings should be regarded as inappropriate except in a number of
circumstances, such as the extension or alteration of a building provided that it
does not result in disproportionate additions over and above the size of the
original building.
7. Although the proposed building is not a conventional extension, the High Court
has ruled [Warwick DC v SSLUHC, Mr J Storer & Mrs A Lowe [2022] EWHC 2145
(Admin)] that for the purpose of Green Belt assessment an outbuilding should
not be assumed not to be an extension simply because it is not physically
attached to the host building. Whether a detached structure would amount to
an extension of the existing building is a matter of fact and degree. Factors that
may be relevant include whether, in the case of a residential outbuilding, it
would be a “normal domestic adjunct”, its purpose, its relationship with the
original building and its size.
8. In this case the cart shed in itself would not be excessive in size. However, it is
clear from the evidence that a number of other planning permissions have been
granted for the extension of the original dwelling. It is not therefore clear
whether the cart shed, in conjunction with other extensions, would amount to a
disproportionate addition over and above the size of the original dwelling.
Moreover, although its use may be for the parking of domestic vehicles, this is
not clear from the evidence and there is an existing garage at the site, closer to
the dwelling. Finally, the outbuilding would be a significant distance from the
original dwelling. The functional relationship between the original dwelling and
the proposed cart shed is thus not proven and the significant separation
distance reinforces my view that, on the basis of the evidence, it could not
reasonably be considered as an extension to the original dwelling. The
Appeal Decision APP/J1915/D/23/3330627
3
exceptions set out in paragraph 154 of the Framework do not therefore apply in
this case.
9. It is concluded on the first main issue that the proposed cart shed would
amount to inappropriate development in the Green Belt. The Framework advises
that substantial weight should be given to any harm to the Green Belt, including
that by reason of inappropriateness.
Openness of the Green Belt
10.The Framework states that the essential characteristics of Green Belts are their
openness and permanence. The proposed cart shed would be a modest
structure on a currently undeveloped site resulting in harm to the spatial
openness of the Green Belt. However, it would be largely hidden from beyond
the appeal site and domestic in scale and would result in limited harm to the
visual openness of the Green Belt.
11.It is concluded on the second main issue that the proposed outbuilding would
lead to some minor harm to the openness of the Green Belt.
Character and appearance
12.Tollgate House is a Grade II listed building constructed in the seventeenth
century forming a small house. Its significance largely derives from its
architectural and historic interest as an early example of domestic rural
architecture contributing to an understanding of its significance in the
countryside.
13.The proposed cart shed would be located close to several mature trees which
contribute to the setting of the listed building and to the wider, wooded setting
of Amwell Hill. In addition, they have amenity and biodiversity value. In
particular, the building would lie within the root zone and under the canopy of
one particularly large and prominent tree which is visible from the street and
makes a significant contribution to the character and appearance of the appeal
site. The proximity of the proposed cart shed and the extended driveway to the
trees means that there is clear potential for harm to either or both the root zone
and canopy during construction or in the longer term. No evidence has been
submitted regarding the trees, their ability to withstand development in close
proximity or any details of the proposed foundations or paving that might
ameliorate potential harm.
14.It is suggested that planning conditions could be used to require an
arboricultural assessment prior to development. However, I have no evidence
that suitable methods could be employed to protect the trees, given their
proximity to the proposed building. In consequence, there is no certainty that
there would not be material harm to or potential loss of trees and hence no
certainty that the setting of the listed building and the character and
appearance of the wider area or biodiversity would be preserved.
15.The harm I have found to the setting of the listed building is less than
substantial but nevertheless of considerable importance and weight. There
would be minor economic benefits from the purchase and installation of the
materials for the structure. However, these would be insufficient to outweigh
the considerable importance and weight I attach to the harm I have identified.
Appeal Decision APP/J1915/D/23/3330627
4
16.I therefore conclude on the third main issue that the proposed outbuilding
would have a potentially harmful effect on the character and appearance of the
area with particular regard to trees and the setting of Tollgate House a Grade II
listed building. In consequence, it would conflict with LP Policies HA1, HA7, NE3,
DES3 and DES4. Taken together and amongst other things these expect new
development to preserve and where appropriate enhance the historic
environment including the setting of listed buildings, not to result in the loss of
or significant damage to trees and to retain, protect and enhance existing
landscape features which are of amenity and/or biodiversity value.
Other considerations
17.The appellant draws my attention to the design and overall scale, mass and
bulk of the proposed cart shed and to its siting and use that he says would be
incidental to the enjoyment of the dwelling. In addition, the appellant would be
willing to enhance soft landscaping through the provision and implementation of
a landscaping scheme. These matters, it is suggested, might amount to the
very special circumstances necessary to justify the proposal.
18.However, all development, both inside and outside the Green Belt, should be of
a high quality design and of a size and in a location that does not materially
harm the existing surroundings. Moreover, the provision of enhanced
landscaping is frequently necessary. I do not therefore find that these matters
could be afforded more than limited weight.
19.It is therefore concluded on the fourth main issue that the other considerations
drawn to my attention would be insufficient clearly to outweigh the harm that
would be caused to the Green Belt by reason of inappropriateness and harm to
the openness, which carries substantial weight, and the potential harm to the
character and appearance of the wider area, the setting of the listed building
and to biodiversity. The very special circumstances necessary to justify the
development do not therefore exist and the proposed outbuilding would conflict
with LP Policy GBR1 and national policy set out in the Framework.
20.For the reasons set out above and having regard to all other matters raised, I
conclude that the appeal should be dismissed.
K E Down
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.