Single storey extension to the rear of the property
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Residential Amenity
Policy Weight
Noise & Disturbance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 19 December 2023
by K Savage BA(Hons) MPlan MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 3 January 2024
Appeal Ref: APP/K2420/D/23/3330070
132 Stanley Road, Hinckley, Leicestershire LE10 0HT
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Stewart Lawrence Muscutt against the decision of Hinckley and
Bosworth Borough Council.
• The application Ref 23/00422/HOU, dated 29 April 2023, was refused by notice dated
7 September 2023.
• The development proposed is a single storey extension to the rear of the property.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Preliminary Matter
2. A new version of the National Planning Policy Framework (the Framework) was
published on 19 December 2023. The parts of the Framework most relevant to
the appeal have not substantively changed from the previous iteration.
Consequently, this update to national policy does not fundamentally alter the
main parties’ cases or prejudice their position at appeal, and it is not necessary
to seek further comments. References hereafter in the decision to the
Framework are to the December 2023 version.
Main Issue
3. The main issue is the effect of the proposal on the living conditions of
neighbouring occupants, with respect to light, enclosure and outlook.
Reasons
4. No 132 forms part of a short linear group of dwellings on Stanley Road with
deep rear gardens which fall slightly in level from the rear elevations. The
proposed extension would project some 8.2 metres from the rear wall
alongside the boundary with No 130. It would feature a monopitch roof falling
towards the interior of the site. As a result, the roof ridge of the extension
would stand at some 3.9 metres high at the boundary, above the bottom of the
rear first floor window.
5. The appeal site is presently separated from No 130 by a close boarded timber
fence leading from the rear wall for around 4 metres, and then a hedge which
runs to the outbuildings at the end of both gardens. The extension would
replace the fence and first section of the hedge. I saw the fence of be of a
standard height of around 1.8 metres, with the hedge around half a metre
taller in the vicinity of the proposed extension. At 3.9 metres, the extension
would represent a substantial increase in height in comparison to the existing
Appeal Decision APP/K2420/D/23/3330070
2
boundary treatment. Coupled with a depth of over 8 metres, the result would
be a structure of imposing size and bulk on the boundary.
6. The neighbouring occupant has two sheds directly alongside the position of the
proposed extension. However, neither one extends above the height of the
hedge and I saw at my visit that they are not of a height that restricts views to
the west from within No 130. As such, the additional height of the extension
would be wholly visible from the neighbouring dwelling at very close range. The
dwelling at No 130 is only some 1.8 metres from the common boundary and
although the plans before me do not show it, the depth of the extension means
it would almost certainly breach the 45 degree line rule set out in the Council’s
Good Design Guide Supplementary Planning Document 2019 (the GDG). The
combined height and depth would demonstrably restrict outlook to the west
and would have an enclosing effect on the rear ground floor windows and doors
which serve a living and dining area, and the adjacent patio area.
7. Moreover, as the extension would be located to the west of the rear elevation
and patio, it would limit evening sun and increase shadowing to these parts of
the neighbouring dwelling. Taken together, the proposal would result in loss of
outlook and sunlight, and increased sense of enclosure and overshadowing.
This would be detrimental to the living conditions of neighbouring occupants.
8. In reaching a view, I have had regard to matters raised by the appellant. I note
the described effects of the development at No 134 on the appellant’s own
living conditions; however, I am not provided with full particulars of that site’s
planning history so as to understand the Council’s considerations in granting
permission for extensions, such as what existed beforehand. In any event, the
assessment of the effect on living conditions is necessarily site specific and the
effects of one development will not always be identical to another, even when
neighbouring dwellings are involved, due to differences in the relative size,
position and relationship between buildings. Therefore, I do not consider the
development at No 134 to set a precedent for the appeal scheme, which I have
considered on its own merits.
9. I note that the roof shape is intended to reduce the need to access No 130 for
maintenance, and that the height of the extension reflects the high ceilings of
the existing dwelling and a desire to provide level access. However, the
evidence does not demonstrate clearly that the proposed design is the only
feasible means by which the dwelling could be extended, and so these are
considerations of very limited weight. The appellant has also referred to
frustrations in his discussions with the Council to find a suitable design for the
extension. Whilst I empathise with any difficulty the appellant has had, this is
not a determinative factor in my considerations, which are restricted to the
planning merits of the specific scheme determined by the Council and now
before me at appeal.
10. I have also noted other issues raised by the appellant in respect of noise and
disturbance caused by the neighbouring occupant; however, such claims are
not substantiated by evidence and therefore I afford very limited weight to
argued benefits in terms of reduction in noise levels which may result from the
presence of the proposed extension.
11. Taking all matters together, I find that the proposed extension, owing to its
height, depth and overall massing, would form an imposing and dominant
structure on the shared boundary with No 130, which would restrict outlook
Appeal Decision APP/K2420/D/23/3330070
3
and sunlight for neighbouring occupants and conversely increase
overshadowing and their sense of enclosure. This would conflict with Policy
DM10 of the Site Allocations and Development Management Policies
Development Plan Document (2016), which supports developments which,
among other things, would not have a significant adverse effect on the privacy
and amenity of nearby residents and occupiers of adjacent buildings, including
matters of lighting and visual intrusion.
12. There would also be conflict with the aforementioned guidance of the GDG and
with the aims of the Framework to create places with a high standard of
amenity for existing and future users.
Other Matters
13. Notwithstanding its size, the Council did not refuse permission on the basis of
the effect of the extension on the character and appearance of the area. The
property benefits from a significant depth of rear garden, within which the
extension would not appear disproportionate in depth relative to the main
dwelling or overall plot. As such, I have no reasons to conclude differently to
the Council on this issue, but whilst I acknowledge the proposed use of
matching materials, the extension would do no more than preserve the existing
character, and therefore would be a neutral factor overall.
14. The appellant refers to permitted development (PD) rights to extend detached
dwellings by up to 8 metres.1 However, it is also required that where the
enlarged part of the dwellinghouse would be within 2 metres of the boundary of
the curtilage of the dwellinghouse, the height of the eaves of the enlarged part
must not exceed 3 metres. As such, a PD compliant extension would not have
the same height on the shared boundary as the proposal before me, and thus
would not have the same degree of impact on neighbours. Critically, the right
to build to 8m depth is also subject to a prior approval process where the local
planning authority will consider the impact of the proposed development on the
amenity of any adjoining premises where objections are received. Given the
objections received in this case, I cannot be certain that a prior approval
application would be successful. Therefore, I afford limited weight to potential
development under PD as a fall-back position for the appellant.
Conclusion
15. For the reasons set out, the proposal would conflict with the development plan.
Benefits arising in this case would be limited in scale, such as any economic
output from the construction of the extension, or primarily private in nature,
namely the provision of additional level-accessed space for the appellant. These
and the other material considerations I have taken into account are not
sufficient to outweigh the identified development plan conflict.
16. Therefore, the appeal should be dismissed.
K Savage
INSPECTOR
1 The relevant provision is Schedule 2, Part 1, Class A, Paragraph A.1.(g) of the Town and Country Planning
(General Permitted Development) (England) Order 2015 (as amended).
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.