Summer house/ancillary residential accommodation in the back garden
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Trees & Landscape
Character & Appearance
Residential Amenity
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 30 October 2023
by Les Greenwood MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date:15.11.2023
Appeal Ref: APP/K3605/D/23/3328100
21 Tower Gardens, Claygate, Esher, Surrey KT10 0HB
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr Lee James Pendleton against the decision of Elmbridge
Borough Council.
• The application Ref 2023/0813, dated 17 March 2023, was refused by notice dated
5 July 2023.
• The development proposed is a summer house/ancillary residential accommodation in
the back garden.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Preliminary matter
2. The description of proposed development set out above is taken from the
application form rather than from the Council’s unilaterally altered description
as listed on its decision notice. I have made one alteration, omitting reference
to the retention of the building because retention is not an act of development.
The building was in place and in use for the accommodation of relatives at the
time of my site visit.
Main issue
3. The main issue is the effect of the proposal on the character and appearance of
the local area including consideration of the use of the building and its effect on
an existing oak tree.
Reasons
Character and appearance
4. 21 Tower Gardens is a detached house on a reasonably sized plot, in a modern
development of similar houses within a verdant setting including mature trees.
The appeal building is a single storey outbuilding, with a low mezzanine area,
set in a section of the rear garden that was already partitioned off by a brick
wall before the building was constructed. That section of garden is accessible
through a gate from the main garden and through another gate (closed off at
the time of my visit) from the street. The building provides an en suite
Appeal Decision APP/K3605/D/23/3328100
2
bedroom space with a small side kitchenette area including a sink, a
refrigerator and a few cupboards. At the time of my visit this side area
contained a couple of minor kitchen gadgets but did not have enough space for
a wider range of kitchen appliances. The overall amount of space within the
building is also somewhat restricted.
5. The Council’s concern about the use of the appeal building is that it is not
genuinely ancillary to the main house, partly based on evidence indicating that
the building has in the past been let as separate holiday accommodation. As
set out above, however, the application proposal is for a summer
house/ancillary residential accommodation. I see no reason in this case to
dispute this or set it aside. Although the building is in a separated area of
garden, it is within the overall property and planning unit, just as this area of
garden was within the planning unit before the appeal building was
constructed. The building does not provide a level of accommodation or
facilities that would normally indicate use as a separate dwelling and future use
could be controlled by a planning condition. The use of the building as ancillary
accommodation would not have any significant effect on local character.
6. This part of Tower Gardens is a cul-de-sac that bends around the garden of
No 21 so that the appeal building sits next to the street, where its upper
section is visible behind a timber fence and a recently planted row of evergreen
hedging. It is a modestly sized, low structure which does not block any
important views and has little visual impact. The spacious character and
appearance of the area is not significantly affected.
7. There is an oak tree, protected by a Tree Preservation Order (TPO), very close
to one side of the appeal building, which sits under its canopy and within its
rooting area. An arboricultural report submitted during the application process
confirms that the tree is an ‘early mature’ specimen with 40+ years of life
expectancy and a likely prospect of increasing in stem diameter and crown
spread over time. It notes that this is a high quality tree that appears to
remain in good condition despite some inevitable damage from the
development of the estate. The oak tree is undoubtedly an attractive specimen
that contributes substantially to the leafy character of the area. It could
continue to do so for a very long time.
8. The appellant’s arboricultural report considers that although the building is
positioned within the tree’s root protection area, it is not a significant constraint
on the tree’s health due to factors including the lack of underground footings,
the allowance for air to reach the soil and the lack of any guttering or drainage
to take rainwater away.
9. To my mind the arboricultural report does not adequately address the future
impact on the tree, however. Although water would drip through the decking
and off the roofs, the upper soil layers of the main area under the building
would likely become much drier. No indication is given of the extent of rooting
area already lost through development, but building over a large percentage of
the remaining rooting area appears to further and substantially reduce the
useful rooting area of the tree, potentially prejudicing its health and vitality.
There could also be pressure to prune lower branches in future as they grow
and the canopy expands. Finally, I also note that the tree’s trunk is positioned
very close to the building’s roof, so that as the tree continues to grow it could
Appeal Decision APP/K3605/D/23/3328100
3
easily come into direct contact with the roof, setting up another conflict that
would create pressure for tree works.
10. In summation on this issue, I find no harm from the proposed use of the
building or from its presence in the street scene. I do, however, consider that
there is insufficient evidence to show that the continuing presence of the
building would not unacceptably harm the TPO oak tree, undermining its
important contribution to Tower Gardens. For this reason, I conclude that the
proposal would unacceptably harm the character and appearance of the local
area. It conflicts with the shared aims of policies DM2, DM6 and DM10 of the
Elmbridge Local Plan Development Management Plan, policies CS11 and CS17
of the Elmbridge Core Strategy, the Supplementary Planning Documents
Design and Character and Companion Guide - Home Extensions and the
National Planning Policy Framework, to ensure high quality and sustainable
design that integrates sensitively with the townscape, avoiding damage to trees
that make a significant contribution to local character and the quality of the
urban environment.
Other matters
11. I have taken account of all other matters raised, including the comments of
neighbours. In particular, the appeal building is reasonably low and set far
enough away from neighbouring houses so that it would not be intrusive or
overbearing on their outlook. I understand that some users of the appeal
building have parked on street. This is, however, a quiet, private road with no
discernible pressure on the unrestricted on-street parking. I see no highway
safety issue arising.
12. I note that a lower outbuilding could be constructed here under permitted
development rights without the need for a planning application. Such a building
would, however, be restricted to uses incidental to the enjoyment of the
dwellinghouse. Incidental uses do not include primary accommodation such as
bedrooms, so such an outbuilding would be a much different development. I
give this possibility little weight as a fall-back position.
Conclusion
13. Although I find in favour of the proposal in some respects, my concerns
regarding the potential effects on the TPO tree, and thus on local character, are
sufficiently compelling for me to conclude that the appeal should not succeed.
Les Greenwood
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.