Loft conversion with front rooflights, hip to gable and rear dormer (resubmission following refusal 5/2022/1392)
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Extensions
Heritage & Conservation
Residential Amenity
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 10 October 2023
by Eleni Randle BSc (hons) MSc FRICS FAAV MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 26 October 2023
Appeal Ref: APP/B1930/D/23/3327438
60 Oster Street, St Albans, Hertfordshire, AL3 5JL
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr N Ryan against the decision of St Albans City & District
Council.
• The application Ref 5/23/0403 dated 23 February 2023, was refused by notice dated
19 May 2023.
• The development proposed is loft conversion with front rooflights, hip to gable and rear
dormer (resubmission following refusal 5/2022/1392).
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Procedural Matters
2. Since the determination of the application, and the submission of this appeal, a
revised National Planning Policy Framework 2023 (the Framework) was
adopted on 5 September 2023. The refusal reason generically references the
Framework however, it is not considered that this impacts upon the
determination of this appeal given the main changes to the Framework.
3. This appeal is accompanied by an application for costs. This is the subject of a
separate decision.
Main Issue
4. The main issue is the impact of the proposal upon the Locally Listed Building
and Conservation Area.
Reasons
5. The appeal site is a locally listed, end of terrace, two-storey dwelling which
stands within the St Albans Conservation Area (CA). Section 72 of the Planning
(Listed Buildings in Conservation Areas) Act 1990 requires that special
attention shall be paid to the desirability of preserving and enhancing the
character and appearance of the CA. Preserving and enhancing can also be
taken to mean doing no harm. Designation, as a locally listed building (a non-
designated heritage asset) reflects the positive contribution that such
properties make to the heritage value of the overall CA.
6. There are several elements to the appeal proposal including a hip to gable
conversion, a rear roof slope dormer and the insertion of two rooflights. The
Council’s delegated report confirms that the hip to gable loft conversion would
not be out of character with the area and that whilst it would add bulk to the
Appeal Decision APP/B1930/D/23/3327438
2
dwelling, it is considered acceptable. No concern is raised in relation to the
front rooflights. Based upon the evidence before me, and my site visit, I have
no reason to conclude differently on this element. The refusal reason is specific
in its reference to, and basis being upon, the proposed rear dormer. For the
avoidance of doubt this appeal will focus upon the proposed rear dormer in the
context of the main issue outlined above.
7. The appellant makes reference to a list of other permissions stated to have
been granted for rear dormer roof extensions across Folly Avenue, Cannon
Street, Ladysmith Road, Normandy Road and Kimberley Road but no further
information as to these decisions (with the exception of 56 Oster Street (no.
56) discussed below) have been provided. It is not, therefore, possible to
attribute much weight to these within the determination of the appeal. I have
no further evidence before me as to size or design of the rear dormers which
were approved in the context of their host dwellings or surroundings to be able
to draw any comparisons. Such decisions do suggest that the principle of a
dormer window could be acceptable within the CA, but that it would come down
to the specific design, bulk and massing of the proposed dormer in the context
of the host dwelling and the surrounding area within the CA.
8. I also note, from my site visit and the appellant’s submissions, varying roof
extensions to the rear of houses fronting Folly Avenue. Despite this I do not
find those dwellings to have the same general uniformity, in terms of general
height and proportions, as the straight terraced row on Oster Street within
which the appeal site stands. In this case the site context includes the
roofscape of the wider terraced row which, with the exception of no. 56, is
largely uninterrupted. The houses on the other side of Oster Street are of
differing design, some with dormers, but each case should be considered on its
own merits.
9. At the time of my site visit I also walked down Cannon Street and round to
Folly Avenue and found that the proposed rear dormer would not be readily
visible within public views. The proposal, however, be highly visible from
within private properties to the rear, and side, along Cannon Street and Folly
Avenue. Limited public views of the proposal would assist to limit the
proposals impact upon the appearance of the wider CA and features noted
within the character area assessment would be left generally unaffected by the
proposal. Despite this, this does not overcome potentially harmful impact to
the character of the host dwelling itself. It should be kept clearly in mind that
appearance is the outward visible qualities whereas character is the sum of all
the qualities which distinguish an area.
10. The dormer would have a flat roof form and would occupy around half of the
roof slope, in terms of width, when considering the overall roof slope that
would result from the hip to gable extension. Whilst the proposal has been
reduced from a previously refused scheme, I find that there would still be very
limited set down from the ridge or set up from the eave. The proposed dormer
would not leave the original building form predominant as it would cover the
majority of the original roof plane. In this case I find that the flat roof design
combined with the hip to gable extension would overall appear out of scale,
and incongruous, in terms of overall additions to the locally listed building.
11. The proposed window within the dormer, whilst it does take design cues from
the existing windows, does not relate well to the location of the windows in the
Appeal Decision APP/B1930/D/23/3327438
3
rear elevation. Taking into account the host dwelling, and the proposed hip to
gable extension, the host dwelling (without the dormer) would overall present
as symmetric. The width of the dormer is slightly wider than the centre point
of the outrigger which overall I find would appear awkward in the context of
the host dwelling and disrupt the symmetry. These proportions exacerbate the
bulk of the proposed dormer as a result of overall design and relationship with
the host dwelling and other elements of the appeal proposal. The proposal
would be a bulky and incongruous addition and would further disrupt the
roofline at the rear of the terrace which, as previously noted, largely retains its
original form as a row. The Framework supports that great weight should be
given to conservation of heritage assets and I consider that the proposal before
me would result in less than substantial harm to the character of the CA and
the host building as a locally listed building.
12. I acknowledge the permission granted at 56 Oster Street (no. 56), however,
whilst the appellant has submitted the decision notice and approved plans,
there is no copy of the Council’s delegated report (or committee report if
applicable) which would explain the Council’s reasoning for approval of that
proposal compared to that which is within the appeal before me. Consistency
within decision making is key to maintaining public confidence in the planning
system and the permission at no. 56 is a material consideration, however, this
does not override all other considerations or harm to the CA. I do not find that
the permission noted at no. 56 outweighs the harm that would arise from the
proposal before me and indeed I find that the proposal at no. 56 is harmful to
the CA as a result of interrupting the roofscape of the largely unaltered terrace
row and that it’s replication in terms of design should be avoided.
13. I note reference to appeals at 14 Liverpool Street, however, I find that the
approved proposals at 14 Liverpool Street (for which plans have been provided
with the Inspector’s decision letter) resulted in a high proportion of the original
roof slope being perceptible as a result of the proposals. In that case, whilst
there was minimal set down from the ridge, there was notable set up from the
eaves and overall, the proposal did not dominate the roof slope but appeared
as a proportionate addition sat over, and related to, the proportions of the
outrigger below it.
14. Overall, I acknowledge that dormer windows are not uncharacteristic within the
wider CA, and that the impact of the proposal upon the appearance of the CA
would be limited from within the street scene. Despite this, in terms of the
character of the non-designated heritage asset, the host building itself, and the
row within which the appeal site stands I find that the proposal would dominate
the roofscape and appear as a disproportionate addition which is sufficient to
warrant refusal.
15. In accordance with the Framework, paragraph 202, where a development
proposal would lead to less than substantial harm, this harm should be weighed
against the public benefits of the proposal including, where appropriate,
securing its optimal viable use. The proposal is for alterations to a single
residential dwelling and the appellant’s comments regarding need for the
proposal to create a family home is noted. Despite this, the proposal would
result in entirely private benefits, and I have no evidence before me to support
that the proposal would result in any public benefits to outweigh the great
weight which should be given to the less than substantial harm which has been
identified.
Appeal Decision APP/B1930/D/23/3327438
4
16. The proposal would be contrary to St Albans District Local Plan Review 1994
(LP) Policy 69 which requires that development shall take account of the scale
and character of its surroundings, LP Policy 72 which requires compatibility with
original buildings particularly in CAs, LP Policy 85 which seeks to ensure
extensions normally leave the original form predominant, and LP Policy 87
which reconfirms that permission would not be granted for alterations of
extensions unless LP Policy 85 is complied with.
Other Matters
17. I note that there are third party comments relating to the proposal, one being
in support of the proposal and one objection on the ground of privacy. The
Council raise no refusal reason based upon loss of privacy and given the
separation distance, and existing relationship between the appeal site and the
property to the rear, I find no reason to conclude differently on this matter.
Conclusion
18. For the reasons outlined above, and taking account all other matters raised, I
conclude that the appeal should be dismissed.
Eleni Randle
INSPECTOR
£
Costs decision section
Costs Decision
Site visit made on 10 October 2023
by Eleni Randle BSc (hons) MSc FRICS FAAV MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 26 October 2023
Costs application in relation to APP/B1930/D/23/3327438
60 Oster Street, St Albans, Hertfordshire, AL3 5JL
• The application is made under the Town and Country Planning Act 1990, sections 78,
322 and Schedule 6, and the Local Government Act 1972, section 250(5).
• The application is made by Mr N Ryan for a full award of costs against St Albans City &
District Council.
• The appeal was against the refusal of planning permission for loft conversion with front
rooflights, hip to gable and rear dormer (resubmission following refusal 5/2022/1392).
Decision
1. The application for a full award of costs is refused.
Reasons
2. The Planning Practice Guidance (PPG) advises that costs may be awarded
against a party who has behaved unreasonably and thereby caused the party
applying for costs to incur unnecessary or wasted expense in the appeal
process. The PPG makes it clear that a Local Planning Authority (LPA) is at risk
of an award of costs if it fails to produce evidence to substantiate each reason
for refusal on appeal and/or makes vague, generalised, or inaccurate
assertations about a proposal’s impact which are unsupported by any objective
analysis.
3. The appeal followed the refusal of permission on 19 May 2023 for an
application made on 23 February 2023 for a loft conversion with front
rooflights, hip to gable and rear dormer (resubmission following refusal
5/2022/1392). There was a single reason for refusal which was concerned with
the impact of the proposals upon the Locally Listed Building and Conservation
Area. My decision, which accompanies this costs decision, agreed with the
LPA’s decision, and dismissed the appeal. The appellant’s application for a full
award of costs is made on the basis that they consider the LPA’s decision
making to be inconsistent as a result of failure to take account of other
approvals, with particular reference to one within the same terraced row.
4. The LPA’s report, though it does not name it specifically as 56 Oster Street
(no.56), does acknowledge that there had been recent approval of a rear
dormer on the terrace that the appeal site is part of. I find that the LPA did,
therefore, take into account the presence of this dormer (and dormer windows
existing within the vicinity of the site) within their overall assessment but
concluded that, aside from this example, the roofscape of the terraced row is
uniform and largely unaltered. The level of assessment could potentially have
been improved, given the proximity of the dormer window in question, and its
inclusion in the appellant’s documents, but overall, I find that it was taken into
account as a material consideration in the determination of the proposal.
Costs Decision APP/B1930/D/23/3327438
2
5. I acknowledge that there was no explanation as to the approval of the proposal
at no. 56 as a nearby comparison to the appeal proposal before me, however,
similarly within the appeal documents before me no copy of the delegated
report for no. 56 has been submitted. Such document would assist in
understanding the assessment for that proposal, and overall approach from the
LPA, to understand any inconsistencies as claimed.
6. In a similar vein the then applicant did submit a number of examples of other
dormer window approvals as a list. Whilst the LPA did not go through these at
length, or on a case-by-case basis, I do not find that approvals in a much wider
area would have overruled the requirement to pay special attention to the
desirability of preserving or enhancing the character or appearance of a
Conservation Area in exercising planning functions. Ultimately each case
should be considered on its own merits against the Local Plan and taking into
account the host dwelling and site context each time.
7. Even if the LPA had taken a more robust approach to consideration of, and
made specific response to, the examples listed by the appellant I do not find,
on this occasion, that it would have resulted in a different outcome - the
proposal would still be at appeal. The refusal reason was largely based upon
impact to the Locally Listed Building itself which, in turn, would not enhance
the character of the Conservation Area. The refusal reason was clear that by
reason of its proportions, design and bulk, together with the use of a flat roof
design, would appear as a bulky, dominant and out of scale addition to the
Locally Listed Building…and would fail to respect the character of the host
dwelling.
8. The above point was, I find, supported by a sufficiently robust assessment as
to set back, set in, symmetry and overall relationship with the host dwelling
itself as well as overall design within the context of the host dwelling. Such
matters were considered in the context of Local Plan policies seeking to ensure
that dormer windows do not dominate the roof and are overall appropriately
designed for the host dwelling and its surroundings.
9. I find that there was reasonable basis for the stance with regard to the
application of the relevant policies which were utilised for the refusal reason. It
can be seen from my decision that I agreed with the LPA and that there were
sufficient grounds to refuse the appeal as a result of my findings for the refusal
reason. As a result, it reasonably follows that I cannot agree the LPA has acted
unreasonably in this case, nor has their behaviour resulted in unnecessary cost
coming to appeal or that the actual refusal given by the LPA was unreasonable.
Conclusion
10. I do not therefore find that unreasonable behaviour resulting in unnecessary or
wasted expense, as described in the Planning Practice Guidance, has been
demonstrated and a full award of costs is unjustified.
Eleni Randle
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.