Demolition of an existing single storey garage outbuilding and its replacement with a single storey annex building for residential accommodation ancillary to the main house alongside associated landscaping
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Character & Appearance
Residential Amenity
Green Belt Policy
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 8 May 2024
by R Gee BA (Hons) Dip TP PGCert UD MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 22 May 2024
Appeal Ref: APP/K2230/D/23/3324637
49 Gouge Avenue, Northfleet, Gravesend, Kent DA11 8DP
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 (as
amended) against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr Matthews against the decision of Gravesham Borough
Council.
• The application Ref is 20230243.
• The development proposed is described as demolition of an existing single storey
garage outbuilding and its replacement with a single storey annex building for
residential accommodation ancillary to the main house alongside associated
landscaping.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Preliminary Matters
2. Since the submission of the appeal a revised National Planning Policy
Framework (the Framework) was published in December 2023. Those parts of
the Framework most relevant to this appeal have not been amended. As a
result, I have not sought further submissions on the revised Framework, and I
am satisfied that no party’s interests have been prejudiced by taking this
approach.
Main Issues
3. The main issues are:
i) the effect of the proposal on the character and appearance of the area;
ii) whether the proposal would provide acceptable living conditions for
future occupiers, including whether or not it would be considered a safe
place to live;
iii) whether or not the proposed development would constitute a separate
dwelling; and
iv) the effects of the proposal on the integrity of the North Kent Special
Protection Area and Ramsar, including the Thames Estuary and Marshes.
Appeal Decision APP/K2230/D/23/3324637
2
Reasons
Character and appearance
4. The appeal site lies within a predominantly residential area. There is uniformity
in the pattern of development in the locality which generally consists of
dwellings that front the highway with elongated rear gardens. No 49 Gouge
Avenue, however, is a detached two-storey dwelling located at the end of a
long terrace of dwellings with a long rear garden of irregular shape to its north-
eastern extent. A large, detached garage is currently in situ, accessed via an
unmade access road which serves a significant number of garages.
5. The proposed would have a greater prominence than the existing garage on
site, including by reason of its increased height. The introduction of a sizeable
building to the rear of the site, whether an annex or an independent dwelling,
would contrast with the existing pattern of development along Gouge Avenue
and Coulton Avenue. While the proposal would make efficient use of land the
proposal would represent a piecemeal development of a large garden that
would be at odds with the existing pattern of development in the locality.
6. The proposed building would be a visual enhancement when compared to the
existing garage and an appropriate palette of materials could be secured by a
suitably worded condition. However, this would not overcome the harms I have
identified.
7. While I am satisfied that the proposal would accord with Policy CS02 of the
Gravesham Local Plan Core Strategy 2014 (Core Strategy) insofar as it
prioritises development in urban areas as a sustainable location for
development it would fail to have regard to the character and the area.
8. For the reasons stated, I conclude that the proposal would have a harmful
effect on the character and appearance of the area. It would therefore conflict
with Policies CS15 and CS19 of the Core Strategy. Among other matters, these
seek well designed new developments and to protect the character of the area.
I also find conflict with the Framework which seeks to ensure that new
development is, amongst other things, locally distinctive and reinforces the
local character of the area.
Living Conditions
9. Parking would be retained adjacent to the building, accessed via the unmade
track to the east of the site which extends from Coulton Avenue. Given the
presence of an existing gated pedestrian access from the track it would be
highly unlikely that the future occupiers would access the building via Gouge
Avenue. Accordingly, future occupiers would likely access the property from an
unlit, unmade access track which would be poor in terms of creating well-
designed places.
10. While the appellant submits that the proposal would improve natural
surveillance there would be no openings facing towards the track and
movements associated with the rear access would be for short periods of time.
The proposal would therefore have a limited positive effect on such matters.
11. If I were minded to allow the appeal a condition could be imposed to ensure
the provision of external lighting. However, this would not overcome the harms
I have identified.
Appeal Decision APP/K2230/D/23/3324637
3
12. In conclusion on this matter, I am not satisfied that the proposal would provide
acceptable living conditions for future occupiers. Accordingly, I find conflict with
Policy CS19 of the Core Strategy, which, among others, seeks to create a safe
and secure environment.
Whether a separate dwelling
13. The Council has alleged that the proposal would be tantamount to a self-
contained independent residential unit. The proposed development has been
applied for as an extension and the householder application form submitted.
The appellants submissions indicates that the building has been designed to
meet the appellant’s requirement for guest accommodation and home office
working.
14. The proposed building would be positioned approximately 25m from the main
dwelling. The plans indicate that the existing fence would be removed so that
there would be no subdivision of the land. Irrespective of whether the proposal
is considered as a dwelling or annex, the proposal would be sizeable and
includes a range of facilities (e.g. kitchen, utility, living/dining area, bedroom
and bathroom), which is indicative of a building which could be occupied for
extensive periods of time (throughout the day and night). Furthermore, owing
to the access and parking arrangements, including the retention of a pedestrian
gateway it is highly likely that future occupiers would access the building via
the unmade track rather than entering via Gouge Avenue. Accordingly, the
proposed building would be independently accessible from the main house. For
these reasons the proposal would be capable of supporting independent
occupation.
15. Case law, including Uttlesford DC v SSE & White [1992], has held that, even if
the accommodation provides the capability for independent day-to-day living, it
would not necessarily become a separate planning unit from the main dwelling.
That is a matter of fact and degree. An appropriately worded condition could
restrict the occupancy and plot severance.
16. Even if the development could be used as a separate dwelling, such a proposal
is not before me. If the structure is not built or used as proposed, or if there is
a material change of use in the future to create a separate dwelling, then a
separate grant of planning permission would be required, and the building
would be at risk of enforcement action if such permission is not granted.
17. Accordingly, based on the evidence before me, the proposed development
would not constitute a separate dwelling, I find no conflict with Policy CS02 of
the Core Strategy which is concerned with the scale and distribution of
development.
18. The Council cites paragraphs 149 and 150 of the 2021 version of the
Framework in their reason for refusal. However, as these paragraphs relate to
Green Belt, they are not determinative to this appeal.
Thames Estuary and Marshes Ramsar site and Special Protection Area (SPA)
19. I am advised that the appeal site lies within the Thames Estuary and Marshes
Ramsar site and SPA. The area is internationally important for nature
conservation as the area is wetland and supports important numbers of
wintering birds and migrating birds.
Appeal Decision APP/K2230/D/23/3324637
4
20. The Council imposes a tariff on all new dwellings within the 6km zone to
provide contributions toward the Strategic Access Management and Monitoring
Strategy (SAMMS) to mitigate the effects of recreational disturbance and
protect the integrity of European sites.
21. There is dispute between the parties as to whether the proposal is required to
pay the financial contribution in accordance with the SAMMS Mitigation
Contribution Agreement Tariff. However, the appellant has expressed
willingness to make a financial contribution in accordance with the SAMMS.
22. Although no evidence has been provided to indicate payment has been made,
or that a Unilateral Undertaking or a S106 Agreement has been submitted, as I
am dismissing the appeal for other substantive reasons there has been no need
to pursue this matter. Furthermore, even if such a document had been
provided, it would not have altered my Decision.
Other Matters
23. I note the appellants desire for accommodation for their use and enjoyment,
including, homeworking, and for use by friends and family. However, from the
evidence before me, I am not persuaded that this cannot be met by a less
harmful scheme.
24. I note the thermal performance of the proposed building in accordance with
Building Regulations. However, this is a neutral matter.
25. I note the evolution of the proposal from previously refused schemes. However,
I have considered the appeal proposal on its own merits, based on the
evidence before me.
Conclusion
26. The proposal would conflict with the development plan as a whole and there
are no material considerations, including the Framework, which would indicate
a decision other than in accordance with it. The appeal is therefore dismissed.
R Gee
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.