Retrospective application to erect a single storey garden annexe
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Character & Appearance
Policy Weight
Extensions
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 17 October 2023 by R Dickson BSc (Hons) MSc MRTPI
Decision by John Morrison BA (Hons) MSc MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 13 December 2023
Appeal Ref: APP/V1260/D/23/3324654
54 Broadway Lane, Bournemouth BH8 0AA
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr & Mrs Rocco & Iryna Saverio Ruggeri & Niavezhyna against
the decision of Bournemouth Christchurch and Poole Council.
• The application Ref 7-2023-2261-G, dated 17 April 2023, was refused by notice dated 9
June 2023.
• The development is described as a “retrospective application to erect a single storey
garden annexe”.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Appeal Procedure
2. The site visit was undertaken by a representative of the Inspector whose
recommendation is set out below and to which the Inspector has had regard
before deciding the appeal.
Preliminary Matters
3. At the time of the site visit, the development appeared to have been completed
in accordance with the submitted plans. I have proceeded on the basis that
retrospective planning permission is sought through the appeal.
Main Issue
4. The main issue is the principle of the proposed development with specific
regard to its effect on the character and appearance of the area.
Reasons for the Recommendation
5. The appeal building is a substantial structure in the rear garden of No 54. The
accommodation comprises an open plan kitchen and living space, a shower and
WC, a dining room, an office and a double bedroom. It has a front door that
addresses the plot’s driveway. It has windows facing Chesildene Drive as well
as the driveway and the rear of the plot. The elevation that faces No 54’s
garden is a solid wall with roof lights.
6. The Council’s Residential Extensions: A Design Guide for Householders (Design
Guide) sets out, amongst other things, what is reasonable for the purposes of
an annexe. It explains that, if they are to be detached buildings, they must
remain subservient to the existing property and be of a suitable scale for its
purpose. Over large buildings will not be considered acceptable and creating an
independent dwelling within the curtilage of an existing house is rarely viewed
Appeal Decision APP/V1260/D/23/3324654
2
favourably. It goes on to say that if permission is granted for an annexe,
conditions will be imposed to ensure that the structure is not used as an
independent home.
7. Putting the intentions of the appellant briefly aside, and on its face, the
proposed annexe is a large building in terms of its floor area and overall height.
It has the facilities to be able to be occupied fully independently of No 54. I
appreciate that a bathroom and kitchen would not necessarily a dwelling make
but in the case of the appeal scheme, and applying fact and degree principles,
the provision of accommodation and facilities within the proposed annexe
would go beyond even that. Taking into account also how the building
addresses its own frontage which can be accessed entirely separate from No
54, one could easily park a vehicle in front of it and it has been designed and
built to face entirely away from what one would, if it were to be annexed
accommodation, reasonably assume to be a communal private garden space.
8. It is the appellant’s intention to use the annexe for domestic storage and in
connection with painting and hobby craft. It is also to provide accommodation
for guests when gatherings occur. There is no mention in the evidence as to
the accommodation being provided for a family member or how specifically it
would function with some reliance on the host dwelling. There could be space
for storage, but it is not shown on the plans. In addition, I remain to be
convinced that accommodation for guests would require, by association, its
own dining, living and food preparation facilities.
9. The appellant seems amenable to the use of a condition to restrict the
occupation of the building if it were to be accepted as an annexe. Be that as it
may, I am unsure as to how one could be enforced with the above in mind and
equally how it could be complied with when the accommodation provided would
not require any reliance on the host dwelling.
10. The prevailing character of the immediate area is low-rise buildings, in the form
of bungalows and dormer bungalows. There are two storey dwellings further
afield. Generally speaking, there is a designed and evolved hierarchy to
buildings in the area. Larger primary uses face their road frontage and
outbuildings are to the side and rear and exist as subservient
ancillary/incidental structures performing uses as such. This results in a
discernible open and spacious feel to gardens specifically which, along with the
above, contributes positively to the character and appearance of the area.
11. The siting of this substantial building which would present and exist in
character terms as a primary one (a dwelling for all intents and purpose) takes
up a significant proportion of No 54s curtilage. It has a crowding and cramping
effect, competing for visual and character dominance with No 54. Its
appearance, design and function would be as an independent unit of
accommodation somewhat squeezed between No 54 and the closest dwelling
on Chesildene Drive, unacceptably reducing the area’s established speciousness
and eroding the defined hierarchy by being disproportionate in both land take
and height to No 54. The prominent location of the building alongside
Chesildene Drive, coupled with its scale and lack of screening, makes it highly
visible and thus exacerbates the above effects. Furthermore, the materials
used are not a common feature of the area. This means that it is not as readily
absorbed into the street scene in a way that a smaller and similarly constructed
outbuilding would be.
Appeal Decision APP/V1260/D/23/3324654
3
12. There are other outbuildings of substance in the wider area. The appellant has
provided some examples. Some are used as annexes albeit I am not aware of
their individual circumstances. Notwithstanding, they do tend to be within
larger gardens and are proportionately much smaller than their host. I note the
pitched roof garage example cited albeit this is clearly a garage and as such an
incidental outbuilding which sits alongside and set back from its dwelling. These
examples do not therefore justify the appeal scheme.
13. With this and the above in mind, the principle of the development would not be
acceptable, and it has an unacceptably harmful effect on the character and
appearance of the area. This would be contrary to the Council’s Design Guide
on annexed accommodation specifically which would, consequently, lead to
conflict with Policy CS41 of the Bournemouth Local Plan: Core Strategy 2012
(LP). This seeks, amongst other things, to ensure that new developments and
spaces are well designed and of a high quality. It goes on to say that
development should, through its scale, density, layout, siting, character and
appearance be designed to respect the site and its surroundings.
Conclusion and Recommendation
14. For the reasons given above, the appeal scheme conflicts with the development
plan and there are no material considerations worthy of sufficient weight that
would indicate a decision other than in accordance therewith. I therefore
recommend the appeal be dismissed.
R Dickson
APPEAL PLANNING OFFICER
Inspector’s Decision
15. Whilst proposed as an annexe, and as has been explained above, the
development presents as one capable of independent occupation and thus
function as a dwelling with there being justifiable concerns over whether a
condition to restrict its occupation would pass the required tests. That being so,
it may be the case that the development could have, both in isolation and
along with other plans and projects, an adverse effect on the integrity of the
Dorset Heathlands Special Protection Area, Ramsar Site and Dorset Heaths
Special Area of Conservation.
16. In the event any development were to be permitted, an Appropriate
Assessment would be required to determine any such effects and whether, in
accordance with the Council’s Strategic Access Management and Monitoring
measures, any contributions would be required from the appellant to address
any mitigation. To not do so would be contrary to, amongst other regulations,
Policy CS33 of the LP. Since the appeal is dismissed however, this matter will
not be taken any further.
17. I have considered all the submitted evidence and my representative’s report
and on that basis the appeal is dismissed.
John Morrison
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.