Alterations including erection of a side and rear roof extension to main roof slope and an extension above two-storey rear addition; erection of a single-storey side extension; erection of a rear/side ground floor extension
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Heritage & Conservation
Extensions
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
1
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 8 August 2023
by J Somers BSocSci (Planning) MA (HEC) MRTPI IHBC
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 31st August 2023
Appeal Ref: APP/H5960/D/23/3323426
59 Salcott Road, Wandsworth SW11 6DQ
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr Rupert Green against the decision of the London Borough of
Wandsworth.
• The application Ref 2022/4081, dated 4 October 2022, was refused by notice dated
18 April 2023.
• The development proposed is described as alterations including erection of a side and
rear roof extension to main roof slope and an extension above two-storey rear addition;
erection of a single-storey side extension; erection of a rear/side ground floor
extension.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed insofar as it relates to the erection of a side and rear
roof extension to main roof slope and an extension above two-storey rear
addition.
2. The appeal is allowed insofar as it relates to the erection of a single-storey side
extension and erection of a rear/side ground floor extension, and front
rooflight; and planning permission is granted for erection of a single-storey side
extension and erection of a rear/side ground floor extension, and front rooflight
at 59 Salcott Road, Wandsworth SW11 6DQ in accordance with the terms of
the application, Ref 2022/4081, dated 4 October 2022, so far as relevant to
that part of the development hereby permitted and subject to the conditions
shown in the Annex to this letter.
Application for Costs
3. An application for costs which is made by Mr Rupert Green against the London
Borough of Wandsworth. This application is the subject of a separate decision.
Preliminary Matters
4. I have taken the description of the development from the Council’s Decision
Notice as this describes the different elements of the scheme in more detail. It
is also noted that this description has also been used on the appellant’s appeal
form.
5. The Council in their Planning Officer Report state that the proposed single-
storey side extension and rear/side ground floor extension, and front rooflight
would be appropriate and in accordance with the Development Plan Policies. I
have no reason to dispute this opinion, and given that these elements are both
functionally and physically severable from the roof extensions, a split decision
is considered a suitable outcome. I acknowledge that the alteration to the roof
of the rear wing was deemed acceptable by the Council, however this does not
Appeal Decision: APP/H5960/D/23/3323426
2
appear to be physically severable from the rear main roof extension. Given the
only matter in dispute refers to alteration to the main roof, this will be the
focus of this letter.
6. It is noted that the Reasons for Refusal from the Council’s Decision Notice cited
Policies DMS1, DMS8 and DMS9 of the Wandsworth Development Management
Policies 2016 (DMPD). During the appeal process, the Wandsworth Local Plan
(LP) has been examined, and then has been adopted by the Council on 19 July
2023 which supersedes the policies of the DMPD. The reasons for refusal also
state the ‘publication version’ policies of the Local Plan, which are now fully
adopted and carry full weight. I have therefore only referred to the adopted
policies of the LP in this decision.
Main Issues
7. The main issue is the effect of the proposed alterations to the main roof of the
existing building and the character and appearance of the locality; with special
regard to the Wandsworth Common Conservation Area (CA).
Reasons
8. Section 72(1) of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act
1990 (PLBCA), in respect of development affecting conservation areas, states
that special attention shall be paid to the desirability of preserving or
enhancing the character and/or appearance of the area.
9. The appeal site is located along Salcott Road, which forms a number of streets
in the locality that contains formally laid out speculative housing around the
Common which appears to date from the late nineteenth century. The streets
contain a mix of dwelling types situated in groups which may respond to the
range of speculative builders, with common forms being groups of terraces,
and groups of semi-detached dwellings. Despite different building types, the
dwellings maintain similar setbacks from the street, similar materials, and high
ornamentation in their design with many of the dwellings having corbelled
eaves, decorative stone fenestration surrounds, the use of cream and gault
bricks, and large chimney stacks that dominate the roofline.
10. The spaces and visual gaps in and around dwellings and to the first floor level
in between properties enables glimpses to the tops of trees in rear gardens to
be experienced and is a positive characteristic of the area alongside street
trees and vegetated front gardens. Whilst there are limited examples of roof
and side alterations which enclose the visual gaps and remove positive
architectural features and present a poor appearance to the street scene; the
original roof forms dominate and form part of the qualities that make up the
local character and distinctiveness of the locality.
11. The appeal site appears to have been one of the characteristic semi-detached
dwellings which have been constructed in a group of 3 pairs of semi-detached
dwellings between No’s 57-65 (odd) where the appeal site lies to the centre
pair. Each of the pair of dwellings maintains similar design characteristics with
cream brick, hipped roof with central parapet, corbelled eaves, large chimney
stacks and large canted bay window to ground floor. Gaps are present between
the pairs of semi-detached properties, except between No’s 61 and 63 where a
narrow dwelling has been erected within the gap. Whilst I acknowledge
comments from the appellant’s Statement of Case (SoC) that the small infill
Appeal Decision: APP/H5960/D/23/3323426
3
development to the gap in-effect makes the appeal site a terrace, the form and
appearance of the pairs of semi-detached dwellings and roof forms do allow the
historic proportions and designs of semi-detached forms to dominate and many
of the remaining features are architecturally authentic to their historic origins
as semi-detached properties. Whilst one could view the properties as either
semi-detached or terraced, it does not change how extensions and alterations
are assessed in terms of the characteristics and proportions of the existing
dwellings, and the need for alterations to respond to the character of the
building and the surrounding context.
12. In undertaking extensions and alterations to the roof of an existing dwelling,
the Wandsworth LP Policy LP1 sets a number of design principles such as
ensuring a design-led approach where new development ensures a high level of
physical integration with their surroundings; ensure that scale and massing
contributes to local spatial character; does not harm the amenity of occupiers
and users; and is sympathetic to local characteristics, amongst others. LP
Policy LP3 is related to the historic environment and seeks that proposals
sustain, preserve and wherever possible, enhance the significance, appearance,
character, function and setting of heritage assets. LP Policy LP5 applies
specifically to residential extensions and seeks that development respects
and/or complements the form, setting, period and detailing of the host
building, is in keeping wit the with the character of the locality and the style of
the existing building, amongst others. The design policies are supplemented by
the Wandsworth Housing Supplementary Planning Document (SPD) which
provides further guidance with regards to roof extensions such as rooves being
an important feature of the urban scene and ensuring the extension is
proportionate to the roof, with emphasis on preserving original features such as
the pitch and chimneys of the roof.
13. The proposal would be situated towards the centre of the side of the hip of the
roof and would have a mansard form that wraps around to the rear pitch,
removing much of the pitch of the roof, along with the characteristic chimney
stack, both elements of which are positive characteristics of this particular
dwelling and within the group of three pairs of semi-detached dwellings. Whilst
I appreciate that zinc is a high quality product, its use for the entire extension
would present a dominant appearance to the roof form which would not provide
subservience, and would draw attention away from the historic characteristics
of the roof of the dwelling which are important for reinforcing the qualities of
local character and distinctiveness. Whilst I acknowledge that design elements
such as dropping the ridge and incorporating a setback to the centre of the roof
have been employed to reduce visual bulk, these design elements are
unsuccessful. The erosion of much of the pitch of the roof together with the
wrap around mansard nature of the alteration, and loss of chimney stack would
create a poor relationship to the existing building and how it is experienced
within the locality.
14. I note comments in the appellant’s SoC that because the extension has low
visibility from a public realm and is predominantly located to the rear that it
would therefore cause no harm to the character and appearance of the CA. The
duty provided under s72 of the PLBCA does not make any differentiation
between whether the development is within the public or private realm, and an
assessment of harm is not limited to tangible aspects such as views and should
also incorporate intangible aspects. As such it is not appropriate to discount the
contribution to the significance of the rear of the buildings to the CA, which as
Appeal Decision: APP/H5960/D/23/3323426
4
described contribute to the significance of the CA, the status, and architectural
authenticity and integrity of the existing building. Whilst I agree with the
appellant that the front façade and plan form of the pairs of semi-detached
dwellings may have been altered from the development of No.61a which fills
the gap between the properties, the hipped roof forms along with their
chimneys remain as a dominant component of the historic pairs of semi-
detached dwellings, particularly with the infill having a parapet roof that sits
under the eaves and being subservient of the adjoining pitched roof forms.
15. I also acknowledge extensions1 found in the surrounding area where large side
and roof extensions have been permitted within the Wandsworth Common CA.
What is evident in these applications, are that the applications are considered
on their merits and in the officer reports that have been submitted in relation
to these applications, that officers at the time gave consideration to the
significance and the character and appearance of the area where such
extensions had become common place in these neighbouring streets. Along
Salcott Road, such extensions are not characteristics of this locality, where
consideration has been given to maintaining the architectural integrity and
authenticity of historic roof forms and positive characteristics such as roof pitch
and chimney stacks. As such the presence of extensions elsewhere does not
provide adequate justification to the proposal for the appeal site.
16. In conclusion of this matter, the proposed alteration to the main roof of the
existing dwelling would not be a suitable architectural approach which in turn
would cause harm to the character and appearance of the existing dwelling and
cause harm to the surrounding locality. The alterations would therefore be
contrary to LP Policies LP1, LP3 and LP5, which is supported by the SPD, as
described previously.
17. Taking the above into account, and whilst serious, the proposed first floor rear
extension was found to cause ‘less than substantial harm’ to the significance of
the CA within the meaning of the term in paragraph 202 of the National
Planning Policy Framework (the Framework). Paragraph 200 of the Framework
states that any harm to, or loss of, the significance of a designated heritage
asset requires clear and convincing justification. Paragraph 202 of the
Framework requires that, where a proposal would lead to less than substantial
harm, the harm should be weighed against the public benefits of the proposal.
18. The appellant has not outlined any public benefits of the scheme. However, to
me, the benefits of the scheme would deliver larger residential accommodation
for the existing dwelling, as well as result in short term employment
opportunities in the construction of the extension; all of which are important
planning policy objectives. However, these benefits may also be present in a
more appropriately designed scheme. That said, these benefits would not
justify the harm I have identified.
19. I therefore find that the public benefits would not outweigh the harm caused to
the significance of the CA. The scheme therefore conflicts with the Framework,
which directs, at paragraph 199, ‘that great weight should be given to the
asset’s conservation … irrespective of whether any potential harm amounts to
substantial harm, total loss or less than substantial harm to their significance’.
1 App Ref 2014/7236: 60 Bennerley Road; App Ref 2022/0334: 5 Belleview Road; App Ref 2022/4801: 49
Wakehurst Road; App Ref 2019/4775 43 Wakehurst Road
Appeal Decision: APP/H5960/D/23/3323426
5
20. In conclusion on this matter, I consider the proposed development would cause
less than substantial harm to the significance of the CA. It has not been shown
that public benefits would outweigh this harm and so the proposal would
conflict with the development plan.
Conclusion and Conditions
21. For the reasons given above, I conclude that the appeal should succeed in
relation to the rear and side single storey extensions and the roof light to the
front roof plane. However, in relation to the alterations to the main roof, the
appeal should be dismissed.
22. I have had regard to the context of the Framework and the National Planning
Practice Guidance which advises that conditions should only be imposed where
they are necessary, relevant to planning and to the development to be
permitted, enforceable, precise and reasonable in all other respects. The
Council has forwarded a list of proposed conditions should the appeal be
allowed.
23. In respect of the side and rear ground floor extension and roof light, it is
necessary to have the standard conditions of the standard time limit for the
avoidance of doubt; and the extension to be constructed in accordance with the
approved plans is also necessary as this provides certainty to the scheme
which has been approved. Condition 3 seeks to approve materials, which is a
necessary condition and meets the tests of conditions to achieve a suitable
external appearance with the conservation area. The condition allows
demolition to take place beforehand, and would therefore not be a pre-
commencement condition requiring pre-authorisation by the appellant.
Condition 4 seeks that the flat roof of the ground floor extensions are not
utilised for sitting out, which is necessary and meets the test of conditions and
seeks to avoid any harm caused to the living conditions of surrounding
occupiers. Condition 5 seeks a suitable conservation rooflight that finishes flush
with the existing roof plane which is necessary and meets the test of
conditions.
J Somers
INSPECTOR
Appeal Decision: APP/H5960/D/23/3323426
6
ANNEX: Schedule of Conditions
1) The proposed single-storey side extension and rear/side ground floor extension
hereby permitted shall begin not later than three [3] years from the date of
this decision.
2) The proposed single-storey side extension and rear/side ground floor extension
and front roof light shall be constructed in accordance with approved plans:
• ‘Proposed Roof Plan and Site Layout,’ Drawing No. 514/101 Rev A, Dated
June 2022;
• ‘Proposed Ground Floor Plan,’ Drawing No. 514/103, Dated June 2022;
• ‘Proposed Roof Plan and Site Layout,’ Drawing No. 514/101 Rev A, Dated
June 2022;
• ‘Proposed Front Elevation,’ Drawing No. 514/106 Rev A, Dated June 2022;
• ‘Proposed Rear Elevation,’ Drawing No. 514/107 Rev A, Dated June 2022;
• ‘Proposed Side Elevation,’ Drawing No. 514/108 Rev A, Dated June 2022;
3) Prior to commencement of above ground works (excluding demolition), details
and samples of materials proposed to be used on all external surfaces of the
development hereby permitted shall be submitted to and approved in writing
by the local planning authority. The development shall be carried out in
accordance with the approved materials and thereafter so retained.
4) The roof area of the development hereby permitted shall not be used as a
balcony, roof garden or similar amenity area and furthermore, no balustrades,
railings or other means of enclosure or means of permanent access shall be
erected on this area.
5) The rooflights hereby permitted, shall be of a conservation area specification
i.e. in-line and flush within the roof pitch that they would be located.
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.