Hip to gable roof extension, install dormer to rear with Juliet balcony to form habitable accommodation in the loftspace, erect single storey rear extension (part retrospective) Decision
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Extensions
Residential Amenity
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 17 August 2023
By Terrence Kemmann-Lane JP DipTP FRTPI MCMI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 14 September 2023
Appeal Ref: APP/D1590/D/23/3323206
60 Poynings Avenue, Southend-on-Sea, SS2 4RU
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr Marc Waldron against the decision of Southend-on-Sea City
Council.
• The application Ref 23/00436/FULH, dated 13 March 2023, was refused by notice dated
5 May 2023.
• The development proposed is hip to gable roof extension, install dormer to rear with
Juliet balcony to form habitable accommodation in the loftspace, erect single storey rear
extension (part retrospective)
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Preliminary matters
2. The application form described the proposed development as “Single storey
rear extension, loft conversion including rear dormer and insertion of roof lights
into front elevation”. The council changed this to the description used in the
heading above, which was also used on the appeal form. I have adopted it as it
more clearly identifies the development proposed.
3. The works are mostly complete, and therefore the proposal is in part
retrospective.
Main Issues
4. The main issues in this case are: i) the effect of the proposed development on
the character and appearance of the property, the streetscene and the area
more widely; and ii) the effect of the proposed dormer and single storey
extension on the outlook, sense of enclosure and living conditions of
neighbouring occupiers at Nos 58 and 62 Poynings Avenue.
Reasons
5. The appeal dwelling is a semi-detached bungalow sited within a residential
area. The surroundings include a variety of dwellings: two-storey, chalets and
bungalows of varying scale, form and design. Most dwellings have a traditional
hipped roof but gabled roofs are found in the wider locality.
Appeal Decision APP/D1590/D/23/3323206
2
The effect of the proposed development on the character and appearance of the
property, the streetscene and the area more widely
6. No objection in principle is raised by the council to a hip to gable roof
enlargement, and nor are the rooflghts in the front elevation controversial.
However, the appeal site is close to the junction with Arlington Road, being
separated by a single plot (No.62), and views of the rear of the appeal dwelling
are in the public domain. For that reason, the rear dormer would be
conspicuous from that road. The rear ground floor extension is evident to a
degree, and is likely to continue to be so with a reduced height.
7. In respect of this issue, it is the rear dormer, being entirely in view from the
public domain, that is the main element of concern. The dormer has a limited
set down from the roof ridge at 0.15m and occupies almost the entirety of the
width of the rear roof slope, with the façade of the dormer rising immediately
above the original line of the rear wall of the bungalow. The result is that the
dormer is visually dominant, lacks any sense of being subordinate to the
original bungalow, and so has a harmful effect on the character and
appearance of the property, and the streetscene.
8. On behalf of the appellant, I am provided with diagrams and calculations of the
volume of the hip to gable conversion and rear dormer. These purport to show
that these elements of the proposal meet the requirements of Class B –
additions etc to the roof of a dwellinghouse, of the Town and Country Planning
(General Permitted Development ) (England) Order 2015. As the planning
officer’s report notes, there has been no application for a certificate of
lawfulness, and it is not my role in dealing solely with an application for
planning permission, to determine whether an operation is lawful in order to
decide whether the appellant might be able to rely on permitted development
(PD) rights as a fallback. Nevertheless, from the information provided it would
appear that there is a fallback, so far as the roof alterations are concerned, and
in the circumstances of this case, it seems to me that there would be a real
prospect of the exercise of this PD right.
9. Since the roof alterations are the principal concern in respect of the effect on
character and appearance, in view of this fallback position, I am disinclined to
dismiss the appeal on this first issue.
The effect of the proposed dormer and single storey extension on the outlook,
sense of enclosure and living conditions of neighbouring occupiers at Nos 58 and
62 Poynings Avenue
10. I can deal briefly with the effect of the dormer in respect of neighbouring living
conditions, by stating that I do not consider that it would be overly dominant
and oppressive, resulting in a significantly harmful loss of outlook or an
unacceptable sense of enclosure. And in respect of the ‘Juliet balcony’, I
consider that this would cause no more overlooking or loss of privacy than a
normal first-floor window, serving a bedroom. It would be different if the
proposal was to use the roof of the rear extension as a balcony; but the Juliet
is effectively a balcony in name only.
11. However, taking account of the intention to reduce its height, the rear
extension is of significant size and scale, such that it would appear both
significantly out of keeping with the size and scale of the bungalow and would
impact on the attached neighbour to the west, No.58 Poynings Avenue. This
Appeal Decision APP/D1590/D/23/3323206
3
bungalow has not been extended to the rear, and appears to have rear
windows serving a habitable room as the only source of light and outlook. A
window in No.58 is situated close to the shared boundary with the application
site. I am supported in these assumptions by the fact that the plans of the
existing ground floor of the appeal dwelling, whilst handed, tend to confirm
this.
12. I therefore have come to the view that the rear extension by reason of its
position abutting the shared boundary and its excessive depth would appear as
an overly dominant and oppressive addition, resulting in a material loss of
outlook and an unacceptable sense of enclosure to the significant detriment of
the living conditions of the neighbouring occupiers at No.58.
13. The same considerations do not apply to the detached neighbour which is
orientated differently, and I have no information of the details of the
accommodation. Nevertheless, the extension would be at least somewhat
intrusive in the view from the garden.
14. For the appellant, reference is made to the PD rights for ‘larger single-storey
extensions’. These, extending beyond the rear of the original house by more
than 3 metres and less than 6 metres in the case of a house that is not
detached, are subject to a neighbour consultation scheme to assess the impact
of the proposed development on the amenity of their property. The
requirements of the neighbour consultation scheme are set out in paragraph
A.4 of Class A.
15. Paragraph A.4 specifies that householders wishing to build a larger extension
have to notify the local planning authority about the proposed extension and
the local planning authority must give adjoining neighbours notice of the
proposals and the opportunity to object. Works cannot commence until the
local planning authority notifies the householder that no prior approval is
required, or gives prior approval, or 42 days have passed without any decision
by the local planning authority.
16. With the roof of the rear extension as constructed lowered to that of the
existing eaves, and 2.95m above ground level, the height would be within
normal PD limits, and the length of the extension would be 4.35m, which
comes within the 6m limit for a semi-detached dwelling for a larger extension.
17. It is suggested that the appellant has subsequently consulted adjoining
neighbours and states that he has received confirmation verbally that their
principal concerns surrounded the loft conversion, specifically the thought that
the extension roof may be used as a form of balcony, have been met. The
appellant alleviated these concerns by confirming that there would only be a
Juliet balcony and no access would be available to the roof area, which could
be conditioned on any planning permission.
18. There are objections to this approach: i) an assurance of verbal acquiescence is
not satisfactory; ii) the statement goes against what has been submitted in
writing to the council that neighbours do object, although 1 neighbour finds the
appellant’s assurances are satisfactory; iii) it is the local planning authority, on
application by the householder, that should undertake the consultation, and
then make a decision, taking account of the responses received.
Appeal Decision APP/D1590/D/23/3323206
4
19. It is also suggested by the appellant that, in the event of the appeal failing, the
extension could be reduced to a depth of 3m (and with the height of roof
reduction) the development would be within PD rights and there would be no
further need to consult the council, but that reduction to 3m would not be of
significant benefit to the neighbours. However, it is my judgement that a
reduction of 1.35m would materially lessen the impact of the extension,
particularly on the attached neighbour.
Conclusions
20. As I have found at paragraphs 8 and 9, there would be a real prospect of the
appellant relying on PD rights with regard to the roof and dormer in the event
of the appeal failing. Since the roof alterations are the principal concern in
respect of the effect of on character and appearance, I am disinclined to
dismiss the appeal on that first issue.
21. The proposed rear extension is of significant size and scale and is materially
greater in depth than an extension which can be constructed on a semi-
detached dwelling as PD. The PD rights for ‘larger extensions’ cannot be relied
upon for the reasons that I have dealt with in paragraph 18 above, particularly
item iii).
22. The amended proposed rear extension would remain of significant size and
scale, taking account of the intention to reduce its height, such that it would
appear both significantly out of keeping with the size and scale of the bungalow
and would impact on the attached neighbour to the west, No.58 Poynings
Avenue, as I have observed in paragraphs 11 and 12.
23. If the appellant choses to reduce the depth of the extension to that permitted
without neighbour consultation, I consider that the effect would still be
deleterious to No.58, although obviously lessened, but that is not the proposal
before me.
24. For the reasons I have given, the appeal will be dismissed.
Terrence Kemmann-Lane
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.