Single storey front, side and rear extension and to raise the roof to create another storey
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Extensions
Residential Amenity
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 11 July 2023
by K Townend BSc MA MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 17th August 2023
Appeal Ref: APP/X2410/D/23/3323172
24 Sedgefield Drive, Syston, Leicester LE7 1YU
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr Suren Pancholi against the decision of Charnwood Borough
Council.
• The application Ref P/23/0122/2, dated 1 February 2023, was refused by notice dated
29 March 2023.
• The development proposed is a single storey front, side and rear extension and to raise
the roof to create another storey.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Preliminary Matters
2. The declaration on the application form was not dated. However, both parties
have confirmed that the application was submitted on 1 February 2023.
3. The description of development in the banner heading above is taken from the
revised planning application form submitted with the Council’s evidence. The
amended description leaves out wording that is unnecessary to describe the
development which is the subject of this appeal. I have therefore used the
amended description of development in assessing the proposal.
4. From the evidence before me there is no dispute between the main parties as
to the acceptability of the single storey rear extension or the single storey front
extension. I shall therefore confine my detailed considerations to the proposed
upward extension, to raise the roof and create another storey, and the single
storey side extension.
5. Since receipt of the appeal submission the Council has issued a note advising of
an error within the officer report relating to the numbering of the neighbouring
properties. The officer report refers to 26 Sedgefield Drive being affected by
the proposal whereas the Council now advise that this should have read 22
Sedgefield Drive.
6. The appellant has been made aware of the Council’s note and confirmed that it
does not alter their appeal submission. Moreover, it is clear from the
description within the officer report that the wrong house number was referred
to in that 26 Sedgefield Drive is the adjoining property and 22 Sedgefield Drive
is separated by its own parking area, and that of the host dwelling. This was a
drafting error on the part of the Council; however, I do not consider that any
parties have been prejudiced by this change.
Appeal Decision APP/X2410/D/23/3323172
2
7. The Council, in their evidence, refer to the emerging Draft Charnwood Local
Plan, 2021-2037 (the Draft LP). Since the submission of the appeal the Council
has advised that the Examination has concluded and are due to carry out
further consultation prior to the receipt of the Inspector’s main modifications. I,
therefore, cannot be certain when the plan is likely to be adopted, if any
policies are to be modified, or if there are any unresolved objections. Moreover,
neither of the main parties rely on any emerging policies within their
submissions, nor did the Council refer to any emerging policies in their reasons
for refusal. Therefore, I attach limited weight to these emerging policies.
Main Issues
8. The main issues are the effect of the development on:
• The character and appearance of the area; and
• The living conditions of the occupants of 22 Sedgefield Drive (No. 22), with
particular regard to daylight and outlook.
Reasons
Character and appearance
9. The appeal property is one of a pair of semi-detached dwellings within a
residential estate. The design and scale of the houses on the estate and the
open green frontages creates a pleasant character to the area. The houses are
all pitched roofed and the general uniformity of the roofscape makes a positive
contribution to the character. There is no substantive evidence before me of
any other upwards extensions or dormer additions to roofs. Other dormers in
the area are part of the design of two storey dwellings and do not interrupt the
general uniformity of the roofscape.
10. The proposed raising of the roof to create an additional storey would extend
the appeal property significantly above the height of the existing roof. The
additional height would be noticeably unsymmetrical and unbalanced with the
adjoining dwelling, 26 Sedgefield Drive. The additional height would be
incongruous and prominent in the street scene, projecting above the general
roofscape and results in a top-heavy appearance to the appeal property that
would also dominate the existing dwelling. This would, therefore, result in harm
to the appearance of the pair of houses and the character of the area.
11. The two rear dormers are offset from the line of the windows on the first floor
of the appeal property and, therefore, do not respect the design or proportions
of the appeal property. However, these dormers are to the rear and not visually
intrusive in the street scene.
12. The front dormer, albeit pitched roof and set down from the ridge and in from
the sides, would be positioned centrally above the two windows at first floor.
The window within the dormer would also be wider than the first-floor windows
of the appeal property and of a similar scale to the ground floor window. As a
result of the position, scale, and design of the front dormer it would be an
overly dominant feature which would not respect or enhance the design of the
appeal property.
13. The front dormer would also introduce a new alien design feature, along with
the increase in the roof height, which is not prevalent in the existing estate and
Appeal Decision APP/X2410/D/23/3323172
3
would be out of keeping with the appearance of the existing housing. This
would have an adverse effect on the character and appearance of the area.
14. For the above reasons, I find that the proposal to raise the roof to create
another storey and the addition of a dormer to the front has an adverse effect
on the character and appearance of the area. It would, therefore, be contrary
to Policy CS2 of the Charnwood Local Plan Core Strategy, 2015 (CS) and
Policies EV/1 and H/17 of the Borough of Charnwood Local Plan Written
Statement, 2004 (the saved policies) which, taken together promote high
quality designs which respond positively to context, respect, enhance and are
compatible with the existing dwelling and the character of the area, having
regard to scale, massing, height and neighbouring buildings and seeks to
ensure development provides positive and attractive built frontages which are
not intrusive or incongruous.
15. I also find that it would be contrary to the guidance in the Charnwood Design
Supplementary Planning Document, 2020 (the Design SPD) which requires
extensions to dwellings to respect the basic shape, proportions and size of the
existing property, ensure that the main property is still the dominant building
with eaves lines lower than the existing house and advises that dormers should
be as small as possible with window styles to match the existing property.
16. The proposal would also conflict with DS5 of the Draft LP, which requires
development to make a positive contribution to Charnwood, respond to,
respect, and enhance, the local area and character, having regard to such
matters as scale, density, massing, and height. As such this policy does not
materially change the approach of the adopted development plan insofar as it
relates to this main issue.
17. Furthermore, the proposed development would not accord with the general
aims for good design and high-quality places as set out in paragraphs 126 and
130 of the National Planning Policy Framework (the Framework). Furthermore,
paragraph 134 of the Framework advises that development that is not well
designed should be refused.
Living conditions
18. 22 Sedgefield Drive (No. 22) has one window at ground floor and one window
at first floor in the side elevation facing towards the appeal property. From the
evidence before me the ground floor window is the only window serving the
kitchen. No. 22 is also on slightly lower ground.
19. The Design SPD provides advice on new development and on extending
existing dwellings. For house extensions the SPD advises that the 25-degree
guideline line should be used when an existing window directly faces an
extension, such as in this appeal.
20. The SPD also advises that where ground floor habitable room windows would
face a windowless single-storey flank wall a minimum separation distance of
9.5m should be provided. Though the SPD acknowledges that single storey
extensions with hipped roofs can be sited closer the separation distance would
be significantly below the guidance in the SPD.
21. Due to the proximity and depth, the single-storey extension would adversely
affect the only window to the kitchen of No. 22. The proposed extension would
bring the appeal property close to the boundary. Moreover, the proposed side
Appeal Decision APP/X2410/D/23/3323172
4
extension would be the full depth of the property, including the proposed front
and rear extensions, which would, therefore, extend beyond the front and rear
elevation of both the appeal property and No. 22. The proximity and scale of
the extension, albeit single storey with a hipped roof, would substantially
reduce the level of daylight available to this window and leave the habitable
kitchen with limited light. This, therefore, would result in harm to the living
conditions of the occupants of No. 22.
22. Furthermore, the depth and mass of the extension would result in the outlook
from the window for No. 22 being a, predominately, blank brick wall. Although
the views out of this window are already restricted by the appellant’s existing
dwelling there would currently be views over the fence and beyond the rear
elevation of the existing dwelling. Due to the scale and depth of the extension
the view out of this window would be substantially restricted. The reduction in
the gap between the two dwellings would lead to an unacceptable level of
overbearing effect which would result in harm to the living conditions of the
occupants of No. 22, contrary to the advice within the SPD.
23. For the above reasons I find that the scale and depth of the single storey side
extension would have a harmful effect on the living conditions of the occupants
of No. 22, with particular regard to daylight and outlook. This, therefore, would
be contrary to the requirements of Policies CS2 of the CS and Policies EV/1 and
H/17 of the saved policies which, taken together, seek to protect the living
conditions of people who live nearby, particularly having regard to dominance
of extensions and loss of light.
24. I also find that it would be contrary to the guidance in the SPD which seeks to
ensure the relationship between neighbouring buildings and land uses is
compatible and harmonious, seeks to ensure appropriate standards of daylight
and sunlight and that extensions are not over dominant to neighbouring
properties.
25. The proposal would also be contrary to the requirements of the National
Planning Policy Framework (the Framework), specifically paragraph 130 which
seeks to ensure a high standard amenity for existing and future users.
26. For the same reasons the proposal would also conflict with DS5 of the Draft LP
which, amongst other matters, seeks to protect the living conditions of
neighbouring properties and, in this regard, the policy does not materially
change the approach of the adopted development plan insofar as it relates to
this main issue.
Other Matters
27. The appellant has sought to argue that the additional floor, extending upwards,
and the single storey extension to the side could be erected as permitted
development. However, whether the extensions, including the upward
extension, would be permitted development is not before me and this is not a
matter for me to determine in the context of an appeal made under section 78
of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990.
28. Permitted development alterations do not need to comply with adopted policy
and may include alterations which Councils would not support through the
planning application process. For this reason, permitted development
Appeal Decision APP/X2410/D/23/3323172
5
alterations do not set a precedent for consideration of proposals which require
assessment against policy.
Conclusion
29. For the reasons given above I have found that, the proposed upwards
extension, front dormer and the single-storey side extension are contrary to
the development plan, as a whole, and the Framework. There are no other
material considerations that would indicate that the proposal should be
determined other than in accordance with the development plan. Therefore, the
appeal is dismissed.
K Townend
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.