Described as; ‘Retrospective application for works carried out to, add pillars with metal railings between to front boundary wall, stone face side wall between front and rear garden and construction of raised timber deck
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Heritage & Conservation
Residential Amenity
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 30 May 2023
by N Teasdale BA (Hons) DipTP MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 19 June 2023
Appeal Ref: APP/P2935/D/23/3317959
Woodstock, Mill Lane, Haltwhistle, Northumberland NE49 9LW
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant full planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr Terry Christie against the decision of Northumberland County
Council.
• The application Ref 22/03696/FUL, dated 6 October 2022, was refused by notice dated
21 December 2022.
• The development proposed is described as; ‘Retrospective application for works carried
out to, add pillars with metal railings between to front boundary wall, stone face side
wall between front and rear garden and construction of raised timber deck’.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Procedural Matters
2. The proposed development has already been completed. The appeal
scheme has therefore been assessed on a retrospective basis.
3. During the course of the determination of the original application the
appellant submitted a revised plan to the Council. However, this was
submitted close to the end of the determination period and the Council has
confirmed that the plan did not overcome its concerns. Consequently, the
Council based its decision on the plans originally submitted. Third parties do
not appear to have had the chance to comment on the revised plan and
could therefore be prejudiced by my acceptance of it. It may also have
implications for the historic environment. Accordingly, I too have
determined this appeal on the basis of the plans originally submitted.
Main Issues
4. The main issues are the effect of the proposed development on;
• The character and appearance of the site, including whether it would
preserve or enhance the character or appearance of the Haltwhistle
Conservation Area (CA); and
• The living conditions of existing occupiers of Mill Lane House to the south
in relation to privacy.
Appeal Decision APP/P2935/D/23/3317959
2
Reasons
Character and appearance
5. The appeal site accommodates a property known as ‘Woodstock’, a two-
storey detached dwelling set in a relatively large plot. While accessed via a
private road towards the edge of the village, the site nonetheless falls
within the CA. I therefore have a statutory duty under Section 72(1) of the
Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990 to pay special
attention to the desirability of preserving or enhancing the character or
appearance of the CA. Moreover, the National Planning Policy Framework
(the Framework) advises that great weight must be given to the
conservation of designated heritage assets and any harm which is less than
substantial must be weighed against the public benefit of the proposal.
6. The significance of the CA is derived from a number of factors. These
include the fact that the town forms one of a group of Anglian or pre-
Norman settlements and accommodates many buildings of historic and
architectural quality (mainly at its historic core). In accordance with the
Haltwhistle Conservation Area Appraisal (HCAA), the site falls within Area 2:
Castle Hill / Fair Hill. This area is described as being almost sub-urban in
character, with detached houses dotted along its length. It is also
characterised by routes having many changes of direction and level which
provide diverse views within and beyond the area. The HCAA is clear that
boundary and retaining walls play an important part in the local character.
7. Woodstock is located on the western side of Mill Lane. It is set back from
the carriageway at a notably elevated level. Consequently, the site is highly
visually prominent from public vantage points. Prior to alteration by the
appeal scheme, relevant boundary treatment appears to have comprised a
large section of relatively low-level stone wall mostly situated immediately
adjacent to the carriageway. This wall did not significantly exceed the
ground level of the adjacent carriageway. It was also stepped down in
height at its vehicular entrance, which had an open aspect. Similar to
nearby means of enclosure, previous boundary treatment would therefore
have been unobtrusive at this prominent site.
8. Amongst other works, the appeal scheme has added stone pillars
interspersed with sections of decorative metal railing to the existing stone
wall, together with a sizable metal gate at the site’s entrance incorporating
similar decorative features.
9. The proposal has significantly increased the overall height and bulk of the
enclosure. It is now notably taller and more ‘solid’ in appearance compared
to nearby boundary treatment and has eroded the open aspect at the site’s
entrance. Consequently, the new boundary treatment has resulted in the
introduction of an unduly dominant and intrusive feature at this visually
prominent site, to the detriment of the appearance of this part of the
streetscene.
10. Unlike nearby means of enclosure, the design of the new boundary
treatment incorporates lion detailing. Not only does this reinforce the
proposal’s discordant relationship with nearby development, but it also
Appeal Decision APP/P2935/D/23/3317959
3
gives the wall an imposing, ‘fortress like’, appearance that further draws
the eye to its excessive scale.
11. Furthermore, a painted rendered wall located to the side of the property
between the front and rear garden area has been replaced with a stone clad
wall. This is taller than its former and appears as a section of castle turret,
facilitated by the false windows and door, lion detailing and stepped pillars.
Despite the wall utilising the same stone as the original house and
boundary walls, its presence is highly visible in the street scene. The overall
design/architecture serves as a homage to the demolished Musgrove Tower,
which once sat behind the site. Whilst incorporating hints of former
architecture in the area can be appropriate, the side wall as a result of its
overall scale and prominent features means that it stands out as a visually
prominent anomaly in this particular street scene and wider context.
12. A raised deck has been constructed to the rear of the property to maximise
views of the wider area. Given the topography of the land and its overall
positioning in relation to the main dwelling, a proportion of the structure
along with its staircase is exposed and clearly visible from Mill Lane,
towering above the side wall element. As a result of its raised height and
positioning, it appears as an awkwardly placed, prominent and contrived
addition in this setting.
13. My attention has been drawn to other boundary treatments in the locality
including the use of railings. However, whilst materials may be similar,
these are generally smaller and less imposing and prominent than the
appeal site. As a result, they are not directly comparable.
14. Although considerable, the harm is localised and is less than substantial
within the meaning of the Framework. I recognise that railings and gates
have been erected to improve safety given the level difference from the
road as well as security. I also note maintenance problems with the
previous rendered wall. Nevertheless, there is no evidence before me to
suggest that such matters could not be achieved by a scheme that would be
less harmful to the CA. Overall, it has not been demonstrated that there are
sufficient public benefits to outweigh the less than substantial harm to the
CA that I have identified.
15. For the above reasons, I conclude that the development unacceptably
harms the character and appearance of the site and fails to preserve the
character or appearance of the CA.
16. It therefore conflicts with Policies QOP 1, QOP 2, HOU 9, ENV 1, ENV 7 and
ENV 9 of the Northumberland Local Plan 2016-2036, 2022 (NLP). Amongst
other things, these seek to ensure that development respects, complements
and does not have an unacceptable adverse impact on the style and
character of the existing dwelling and its setting and that proposals
conserve and enhance the significance, quality and integrity of
Northumberland’s heritage assets and their settings. The proposal is also
contrary to the advice of the Framework which seeks to conserve heritage
assets in a manner appropriate to their significance.
Appeal Decision APP/P2935/D/23/3317959
4
Living conditions
17. As discussed, a raised deck has been constructed to the rear of the property
which sits above a close boarded timber fence which separates the appeal
site from the neighbouring property, Mill Lane House which lies to the
south. The decking is located within close proximity of the garden area of
the neighbouring property and this, together with the raised position of the
decking allows for direct views from the decking to the neighbouring garden
area resulting in an undue loss of privacy for the occupiers of Mill Lane
House The appellant agrees that the raised deck is unacceptable in that it
results in direct views of a neighbour’s private rear garden. This in turn
reduces the usability and quality of the outside space.
18. Several substantial trees may have been located in the garden of the
adjacent property which would have helped conceal the decking. However,
these have been removed and I must determine the appeal based on the
current context of the site.
19. For the above reasons, I conclude that the development harms the living
conditions of existing occupiers of Mill Lane House in relation to privacy. The
development therefore conflicts with Policies QOP 2 and HOU 9 of the NLP
which together, amongst other matters, requires such development to not
have a significant adverse impact on the amenity of adjoining properties in
terms of structural proximity and unacceptable loss of privacy. The
development is also contrary to the aspirations of the Framework relating to
achieving well-designed places.
Other Matters
20. I am aware of frustrations regarding communication with the Council during
the application process and note that the appellant has requested site visits
to take place onsite. However, this does not affect my findings on the main
issues nor does the lack of comments received from the Council’s
Conservation Officer or the lack of listed buildings nearby.
Conclusion
21. The development conflicts with the development plan when considered as a
whole. There are no material considerations, either individually or in
combination including the provisions of the Framework, that outweighs the
identified harm and associated plan conflict. I conclude that the appeal
should therefore be dismissed.
N Teasdale
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.