Erection of front and rear dormer extensions at first floor level. Erection of porch to front entrance and a single-storey garden office to the rear. PV to proposed garden office, proposed dormers and existing garage
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Heritage & Conservation
Extensions
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 31 July 2023
by L Wilson BA (Hons) MA MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 17 August 2023
Appeal Ref: APP/C4235/D/23/3317447
Werneth Hall, Cowlishaw Road, Romiley, Stockport SK6 4NU
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Professor Karen Kirkby against the decision of Stockport
Metropolitan Borough Council.
• The application Ref DC/086755, dated 7 October 2022, was refused by notice dated
7 December 2022.
• The development proposed was originally described as erection of front and rear dormer
extensions at first floor level. Erection of porch to front entrance and a single-storey
garden office to the rear. PV to proposed garden office, proposed dormers and existing
garage.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issue
2. The appeal site is located within the Green Belt. Based on the information
presented, the scheme would not be inappropriate development in the Green
Belt as it would comply with Policies GBA1.2 and GBA1.5 of the Stockport
Unitary Development Plan Review (2006) (UDP), and chapter 13 of the National
Planning Policy Framework (the Framework). This position is agreed by the
main parties.
3. Therefore, the main issue is the effect of the proposed development on the
character and appearance of the host property and surrounding area, bearing
in mind the special attention that should be paid to the desirability of
preserving the setting of the nearby Grade II listed building.
Reasons
4. Pictures show that Werneth Hall was previously a two-storey building with a
white lime wash/ render to the stonework and had an outrigger. The footprint
and roofscape of the building have changed over the years, and around 2005
extensive refurbishment was carried out to the building which resulted in an
additional storey being added.
5. Werneth Hall is now a three-storey dwelling with a single-storey side extension.
The dwelling is constructed of stone with a slate roof. It has a large driveway
leading to a detached double garage, and a terraced garden to the rear. The
existing extension includes a corner window which is typically a more modern
detail.
6. Werneth Hall is not listed but is included in the Greater Manchester Historic
Environment Record. It has been drawn to my attention that there are
Appeal Decision APP/C4235/D/23/3317447
2
inaccuracies in the entry, and Werneth Hall is not identified within Stockport’s
Historic Environment Database. Having said that, the Council has identified
Werneth Hall as a non-designated heritage asset, and this is not disputed
within the appellant’s Heritage Statement. The building has a degree of
architectural and historical significance. Architecturally, the building displays
typical characteristic features of a large, period farm house from this area, with
its plain and functional form and traditional use of local stone and slate.
7. Werneth Hall forms part of a small group of dwellings, believed to be a former
farmstead, which comprises terraced cottages and a detached dwelling.
Although these buildings (including Werneth Hall) have been altered over the
years, they maintain a strong collective uniformity which have a traditional
character and appearance. The wider surrounding area is characterised by
agricultural land use.
8. Adjacent to the appeal site is Werneth Old Hall Barn which is a Grade II listed
building, known as Werneth Hall Farm. The evidence before me highlights that
it was built around the early 1800s, is constructed of coursed rubble with a
stone slate roof. The building was previously a barn which was renovated and
refurbished to form a dwelling. The original significance of the building has
been altered through its conversion and physical changes, but it maintains
heritage value. As the proposal relates to the setting of a listed building, I have
had special regard to section 66(1) of the Planning (Listed Buildings and
Conservation Areas) Act 1990 (the Act).
9. Werneth Hall Farm is situated to the side of the appeal site and has a separate
entrance. Its side elevation faces towards Werneth Hall. The double garage of
Werneth Hall sits between the two dwellings. There is a low wall and railings
along the boundary. As a result, there are clear views between Werneth Hall
Farm and Werneth Hall. There is a strong relationship between the buildings
due to their physical proximity, siting within the same view, material
similarities and associated former uses. For these reasons, Werneth Hall makes
a positive contribution to the setting and significance of the listed building.
10. The ridgeline, footprint and materials (including silvered timber and grey roof)
of the extension have been designed to be lightweight and respect the existing
building as well as nearby buildings. I have taken into account SPAB and
Historic England guidance, and recognise that contemporary materials and
design can successfully complement historic buildings.
11. There is a barn immediately opposite Werneth Hall, which I understand has a
lapsed planning permission for the conversion to a 4-bedroom home1. I do not
have full details of that permission but there are some similarities in the design
to the scheme before me. Nonetheless, that proposal maintained an
uncluttered roof with no dormers, and in any case I have considered the appeal
proposal on its own merits.
12. The appellant sets out that there are numerous examples of properties with
dormer extensions and gables with large areas of glazing in the local area.
However, I did not observe such features in the locality. The former farmstead
buildings also do not contain such features.
1 DC/046188
Appeal Decision APP/C4235/D/23/3317447
3
13. The proposed development would result in substantial dormers to the existing
extension. It would include large sliding doors, a glass-balustraded Juliet
balcony to the front and a glass-balustraded external balcony to the rear.
Dormer windows are not characteristic of the host dwelling, or nearby
buildings. The roof of Werneth Hall and adjacent dwellings are characterised by
simple, uncluttered roof forms which contribute to their historic and
architectural character.
14. I observed on my site visit that only very limited views of the development
would be visible from public vantage points because of the siting of nearby
buildings and vegetation. Nonetheless, glimpsed views would be possible from
parts of Cowlishaw Road and longer distance views across the valley.
15. The dormers would not respect the former farmstead buildings distinctive
character and roofscape because they would be visually discordant and
incongruous features as a result of their scale, massing and design. The
substantial dormers with large openings and contemporary design would not be
sympathetic or respectful to the historic form of the host building or adjacent
buildings. The development would result in an intrusive feature that would
draw the eye and detract from the ability to appreciate the listed building.
Consequently, the proposed development would adversely affect the visual
amenity of the area. For these reasons, I find that the proposal would fail to
preserve the special interest of the listed building and significance of the non-
designated heritage asset.
16. I have considered the Council’s argument that the grant of planning permission
would set a precedent for other similar developments. Each application and
appeal must be determined on its individual merits. A generalised concern of
this nature would not justify withholding permission or result in additional
harm.
17. In relation to the listed building, paragraph 199 of the Framework advises that
when considering the impact of development on the significance of a
designated heritage asset, great weight should be given to the asset’s
conservation. Paragraph 200 goes on to advise that any harm to, or loss of, the
significance of a designated heritage asset (from its alteration or destruction,
or from development within its setting), should require clear and convincing
justification. This is also reflected in Policy SIE-3 of the Stockport Metropolitan
Borough Council Local Development Framework: Core Strategy DPD (2011)
(CS).
18. The level of harm would be at the low end of the spectrum of less than
substantial harm. This is due to the scale of the development, Werneth Hall
and the other former farmstead buildings have been altered over the years,
relationship between the host building and listed building, and very limited
public views of Werneth Hall. Nonetheless, mindful of my statutory duties, this
is a matter to which I attach considerable importance and weight. Under such
circumstances, paragraph 202 of the Framework advises that this harm should
be weighed against the public benefits of the proposal.
19. In relation to Werneth Hall, paragraph 203 of the Framework states that the
effect of an application on the significance of a non-designated heritage asset
should be taken into account in determining the application. In weighing
applications that directly or indirectly affect non-designated heritage assets, a
Appeal Decision APP/C4235/D/23/3317447
4
balanced judgement will be required having regard to the scale of any harm or
loss and the significance of the heritage asset.
20. The appellant sets out environmental, economic and social benefits, specifically
that they aim to minimise the Lifetime Carbon of the property and provide
energy security. I fully acknowledge and understand the intentions of the
appellant to reduce the energy demand of the house, address fossil fuel
dependency, contribute towards local retrofit targets and decarbonisation
goals. However, given the small scale of the development, the benefits would
not be sufficient to outweigh the harm that I have identified.
21. Given the above and in the absence of any defined significant public benefit, I
conclude that, on balance, the proposed development would not preserve the
setting of the Grade II listed building and would fail to preserve the special
historic interest of the heritage asset. Furthermore, the scheme would cause
harm to the significance of the non-designated heritage asset and character
and appearance of the surrounding area.
22. Consequently, the proposal would fail to satisfy the requirements of the Act,
paragraphs 202 and 203 of the Framework and conflict with Policy SIE-3 of the
CS that seek, among other things, to protect the historic environment. Whilst
not listed within the reason for refusal but identified as a conflict in the officer’s
report and the appellant has referred to them, the development would also
conflict with Policy SIE-1 of the CS and Policy CDH1.8 of the UDP. These seek,
amongst other things, to ensure developments consider the site’s
characteristics and context to ensure that extensions complement the existing
dwelling and do not adversely affect the character of the street scene. As a
result, the proposal would not be in accordance with the development plan.
23. Even if I had found that Werneth Hall is not a non-designated heritage asset,
that would not outweigh the harm I have found in relation to the listed
building, the former farmstead buildings, and visual amenity of the area.
Other Matters
24. I acknowledge the other matters highlighted by the appellant, including that
they wish to enhance the building’s visual and physical connection to the
surrounding landscape and garden, as well as improvements in accessibility to
ensure their home is suitable in older age. In addition, frustrations with the
Council, no objections from neighbours, compromises, and pre-application
advice. Nonetheless, the other matters raised do not outweigh the harm I have
found.
Conclusion
25. For the reasons given above, having considered the development plan as a
whole, the approach in the Framework, and all other material considerations,
the appeal does not succeed.
L Wilson
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.