Replacement of zinc roof from existing rear extension with a new pitched and tiled roof along with the erection of a new front porch
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Heritage & Conservation
Extensions
Conversion/Use
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 26 September 2023
by S M Holden BSc (Hons) MSc CEng MICE CTPP FCIHT MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 5th October 2023
Appeal Ref: APP/C1435/D/23/3317106
Stream Farm Stables, Dern Lane, Chiddingly, East Sussex BN8 6HG
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr Joe Wheatley against the decision of Wealden District Council.
• The application Ref WD/2022/2968/F, dated 14 November 2022, was refused by notice
dated 16 February 2023.
• The development proposed is replacement of zinc roof from existing rear extension with
a new pitched and tiled roof along with the erection of a new front porch.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Preliminary Matters
2. The description of the proposal on the application form was given as: ‘demolition of
existing extension and erection of new extension and front porch’. However, the
proposal was amended during the Council’s consideration of the application and the
agreed description of development, which was on the Council’s decision notice and
the appeal form, is set out in the above banner heading. I have determined the
appeal based on this description and the associated amended plans.
3. There is a dispute between the parties as to whether the appeal building is
curtilage listed. The appellant referred to two applications at Stream Farm Stables
for which listed building consent was not required. However, these relate to the
garage1 and not the appeal building, which was granted planning permission and
listed building consent for conversion from former stables to a dwelling in 20062.
4. In 20123 the Council considered proposals for a detached garage and a single
storey extension to the rear of the dwelling to form a sunroom. I therefore
requested the documents relating the 2006 conversion and the 2012 proposal to
assist in my assessment of the appeal proposal. The officer report dealing with the
planning application for the garage and extension stated that both were
acceptable. However, the planning permission only imposed conditions relating to
the garage. A second report related to the application for listed building consent for
the extension. It considered that proposal in more detail, also concluding that it
was acceptable. Listed building consent was granted subject to a series of
conditions. Both these decisions were issued on 23 July 2012.
5. Based on the above, I find Stream Farm Stables to be a curtilage listed building.
Therefore, alterations to it require planning permission and listed building consent.
However, as no application for listed building consent was submitted, this appeal
only deals with the application for planning permission.
1 WD/2013/1434 and WD/2017/2432
2 WD/2006/2623/F & WD/2006/2624/LB
3 WD/2012/0971/F & WD/2012/0972/LB
Appeal Decision APP/C1435/D/23/3317106
2
Main Issue
6. The main issue is whether the proposal would preserve Stream Farm Stables, a
curtilage listed building to Stream Farmhouse, a Grade II listed building, its setting
or any features of special architectural or historic interest that it possesses.
Reasons
Significance
7. Stream Farmhouse is thought to date from the 17th century or possibly earlier. The
listing description states that it is mostly painted brick at ground floor level with
first floor tile hanging and a tiled roof. Other features include casement windows
and a later addition on its eastern elevation. It was listed in 1952 when the land in
its ownership also included several outbuildings, one of which continues to provide
stabling, garaging and storage for the host property. Stream Farm Stables co-joins
this building along the shared boundary which now separates the land ownerships.
This cluster of outbuildings buildings were previously functionally linked to the
farmhouse.
8. The subsequent separation of land ownerships and the conversion of the stables to
create a small independent dwelling has weakened the connections between
Stream Farmhouse and this part of its former outbuildings. Even though no
heritage statement was submitted with the application, it is apparent from the
planning history that the significance of the converted stables derives primarily
from their simple form, utilitarian appearance and the materials used in their
construction and secondly, from their historic, functional relationship with the listed
farmhouse.
9. The dwelling was formed from the conversion of the single-storey disused stables
and a small two-storey barn with a store to the side under a catslide roof. These
two buildings are at right angles to each other but were separate. The conversion
was made possible by the construction of a small lobby that linked the two at the
rear. The side store has become the kitchen with its large doors replaced by
windows.
10. The listed building consent granted in 2012 replaced the small lobby linking the
two buildings with a glazed sunroom. This extends part way across the rear
elevation of the former barn and has a flat roof. The extension has a lightweight
appearance and its materials, including hardwood posts and leadwork were subject
to a series of stringent conditions. Its contemporary design and translucent
appearance contrasts with the original buildings. The flat roof (which the plans
indicated would be rolled lead, not zinc) enabled the pitched roof of the former
stable block to be undisturbed. In addition, the brick elevation of the barn with its
small central window continued to be the dominant features of the rear of the
dwelling. This ensured that the significance of the building as historic outbuildings
to Stream Farmhouse has been preserved.
11. At the front of the house the original relationship between the two buildings has
been retained with the large gable of the barn and its catslide roof being
prominent. The stable element, with its much smaller gable, is set back. Its front
elevation, which includes the entrance to the house, aligns with the rear elevation
of the barn. This unusual arrangement also helps to preserve the significance of
the originally separate barn and stables which have been combined to form the
dwelling. This is especially important now that the functional links between the
outbuildings and Stream Farmhouse have been diminished with the separation of
the land into different ownerships.
Appeal Decision APP/C1435/D/23/3317106
3
Assessment
12. The existing flat roof on the sunroom is leaking and the proposal seeks to replace
the rolled lead with a mono-pitched, tiled roof. This would give the extension a
more traditional appearance. However, it would diminish the distinction between its
lightweight contemporary design and the original building. The approval of the
extension granted in 2012 was based on these specific aspects of the design, which
ensured the significance of the original buildings was retained. The use of the flat
roof also ensured that the pitched roof of the stables was not altered. By contrast,
the current proposal would disrupt this roof resulting in an awkward arrangement
between different pitches. It is not clear from the submitted details how the
interface between the two roofs would be achieved and altered rainwater goods
would be provided. Whilst I appreciate that maintaining a flat roof may be more
challenging than one that is pitched and tiled, that is not a justification replacing it
with one that would fail to preserve the significance of the original building.
13. The proposed porch would occupy the full width of the site between the existing
barn wall and the boundary fence with Stream Farmhouse. Its depth would also
project some distance along the original barn wall. Consequently, its overall
footprint would be disproportionate to the converted buildings. The shape of its
gable roof would detract from the gable of the original stables and the introduction
of mock timbering would be a contrived approach to integrating it with the existing
building. The scale and design of the porch have not been based on an
understanding of the significance of the original modest and utilitarian
outbuildings. Neither would the porch reflect the lightweight appearance of the
contemporary rear extension which was found to be acceptable. It would therefore
not be a sympathetic addition to the property’s front elevation.
14. Taking account of all the above, I conclude that the proposed alterations, whether
consider individually or collectively, would fail to preserve the special architectural
and historic interest of the curtilage listed building, associated with Stream
Farmhouse, a Grade II listed building. This would be contrary to the Planning
(Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990, which requires me to have
special regard to the desirability of preserving the building or its setting or any
features of special architectural or historic interest which it possesses.
15. In terms of the National Planning Policy Framework, I consider this harm may be
quantified as less than substantial. However, this assessment still amounts to a
significant objection which I am required to weigh against the public benefits of the
proposal in accordance with paragraph 202 of the Framework. In this case the
alterations would only be of benefit to the occupants of the house. They are not
public benefits which can be weighed against the identified harm.
16. This leads me to conclude that the proposal is unacceptable. It would conflict with
Spatial Planning Objective SPO2 of the Wealden Local Plan Core Strategy, 2013,
which seeks to protect the intrinsic quality of the district’s historic environment. It
would also fail to comply with the advice of the Framework in which states heritage
assets should be conserved in a manner appropriate to their significance.
Conclusion
17. For these reasons, I conclude that the appeal should be dismissed.
S M Holden
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.