New two storey side extension, single storey front extension, replacement of front boundary treatment and relocation of off-street parking space
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Heritage & Conservation
Residential Amenity
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 9 May 2023
by Eleni Randle BSc (hons) MSc FRICS FAAV MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 19 May 2023.
Appeal Ref: APP/H5390/D/23/3315429
4 Steventon Road, Hammersmith & Fulham, London, W12 0SL
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mrs Sian Thomas against the decision of the London Borough of
Hammersmith & Fulham.
• The application Ref 2022/00791/FUL dated 17 March 2022, was refused by notice dated
4 November 2022.
• The development proposed is new two storey side extension, single storey front
extension, replacement of front boundary treatment and relocation of off-street parking
space.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issues
2. The main issues are the impact of the proposal upon i) the character and
appearance of the host property, appeal site and nearby Old Oak and Wormholt
Conservation Area and ii) neighbouring residential amenity with specific regard
to increased sense of enclosure, loss of privacy and overlooking.
Reasons
Character and appearance
3. The appeal site is an infill property to the rear of 81 Sedgeford Road (no. 81).
Steventon Road borders the Old Oak and Wormholt Conservation area (CA)
and is a tree-lined residential street with primarily traditional semi-detached
brick and pitched roof properties on the edge of the CA. The properties on the
opposite side of Steventon Road are traditional, uniform, semi-detached
properties, with parking to the front and have notable set back from the edge
of the pavement which is wider than that on the side of the appeal site.
Section 72 of the Planning (Listed Buildings in Conservation Areas) Act 1990
requires that special attention shall be paid to the desirability of preserving and
enhancing the character and appearance of the CA.
4. The appeal site is already a more unusually designed property, however, the
use of more traditional materials which are in-keeping with the general area as
well as the overall modest massing (appropriate to the infill plot itself) means
that it does not particularly stand out or result in a negative contrast to the
character or appearance to the surrounding area.
5. There are multiple elements to the appeal proposal which includes the erection
of a two-storey side extension with the installation of a copper-clad lantern
Appeal Decision APP/H5390/D/23/3315429
2
skylight, erection of a single storey front extension at ground floor level,
replacement of a front wall with white metal railings and replacement access
with a new sliding gate, removal of an existing shed and formation of a
relocated parking bay with a dropped kerb, installation of a black aluminium
window to replace the existing circular window to the front elevation at first
floor level and the installation of a new door to replace the existing door with
windows to the rear elevation at ground level.
6. The Council’s refusal reason does not raise any objection to the proposed
removal of the shed and the formation of the replacement parking space,
subject to conditions, or other alterations to fenestration and I have no
evidence to conclude differently on those elements. The loss of the existing
brick front boundary would, I find, be of potential detriment to the overall
appeal site, however, it would not be a refusal reason in isolation and a
condition regarding replacement boundary treatment materials could have
been applied had the proposal been found acceptable in other regards. The
main issue, within the first refusal reason, is concerned with increased
massing, over development of the appeal site as well as the proposed materials
being out of context with the surrounding properties.
7. The existing dwelling is modest which is as a result of it being built within an
infill plot. Such plots are, typically as a result of their nature, more constrained
in terms of site area. The existing dwelling has a gross internal area of
52.7sq./m and, as a result of the proposed extensions, would be increased to
86 sq./m. This increase in floor area would equate to the extensions adding in
the region of 60% to the current host dwelling. The two-storey side extension
would continue the at existing roof height of the host dwelling and would not,
in any way, read as a subservient addition which would be detrimental to the
character and appearance of the host dwelling and the appeal site.
8. If it was not for the proposed contrasting materials the proposal would not be
able to be differentiated from the original host dwelling and its legibility, and
existing character, would be lost. The proposals would, therefore, add
considerable scale and massing and would dominate the parent building in
scale. In addition, a comparison between the existing and proposed site plans
show that the proposals would, combined with the relocated parking space,
result in the vast majority of the site being occupied by built form, or car
parking, which further reduces general area around the property and amenity
space for the appeal site. I find that the level of the development proposed is
indicative of overdevelopment and proposes a property which would be overall
too large for the site upon which it stands.
9. As previously outlined, the appeal site is surrounded by properties which are
primarily traditional semi-detached brick and pitched roof properties. I found,
at the time of my site visit, that the properties are visually consistent and
generally uniform in both character and appearance. The appellant’s statement
of case accepts that pre-cast concrete and/or stone is not a material that is
utilised locally. Whilst this should not result in proposals automatically being
unacceptable it does mean that it is, in this case, harder to successfully
integrate them within the character and appearance of the area.
10. Had the area, in general, been a wider mix of materials, it may have been
possible to introduce more contemporary materials due to a less uniformity.
This is, however, not the case with this proposal where more traditional
Appeal Decision APP/H5390/D/23/3315429
3
materials including vertical hanging tile, painted render and pebbledash are
typical of surrounding properties. Whilst the proposals do seek to reference
the general horizontal arrangement of materials within the area, the overall
combination of basket weave texture and plain face pigmented concrete are too
large a contrast within the uniformity of the area.
11. The proposed materials, in particular use of pre-cast concrete, which would be
dark grey coloured, and basket weaved pattern would be a complete contrast
to any material used within the vicinity of the appeal site and would form a
clear contrast to the both the character (the qualities which distinguish the
area) and appearance (the outward, visible qualities) of the area. Overall,
whilst I can appreciate the desire to create a more contemporary style
property, the proposal would, in this case, contrast too heavily with the
surrounding area which, when combined with the overall proposed increase in
massing and height, would create a dominant, inappropriate, and alien form of
development within this area.
12. I find that the combined bulk, scale and massing as well as the materials
proposed would, within the street scene of Steventon Road, visually detract
from the properties on the opposite side of the road which stand within the CA.
I find that this would, therefore, have less than substantial harm upon this
setting of the CA. In accordance with paragraph 119 of the National Planning
Policy Framework 2021, when considering the impact of the proposed
development on the significance of a designated heritage asset, great weight
should be given to the assets conservation. For the reasons outlined above, I
find the proposal would result in less than substantial harm to the setting of the
CA which falls to be considered against the public benefits of the proposal. The
proposal is for extensions to a private dwelling, and I have no evidence of
public benefits flowing from the proposal before me to outweigh the less than
substantial harm which I have identified to the setting of the CA.
13. The proposal would be contrary to London Plan 2021 (LDN) Policy HC1, which
requires that development proposals affecting heritage assets, and their
settings, should conserve their significance, by being sympathetic to the assets
significance and appreciation within their surroundings. The proposal would
also be contrary to Hammersmith and Fulham Local Plan 2018 (LP) Policy DC1,
which requires that development within the Borough should create a high-
quality urban environment that respects and enhances its townscape context
and heritage assets. The proposal would also be contrary LP Policy DC4 which
requires a high standard of design in all alterations and extensions to existing
buildings which should be comparable to the scale and character of the existing
development, neighbouring properties and their setting as well as being
subservient and should never dominate the parent building in bulk, scale,
materials or design.
14. The proposal would also be contrary to LP Policy DC8, which seeks to conserve
the significance of the Borough’s historic environment by protecting, restoring,
and enhancing its heritage assets. These assets include CAs. Applications
should conserve the setting of, make a positive contribution to, or reveal the
significance of the heritage asset and particular regard is to be given to matters
of scale, height, massing, alignment, materials, and use.
Appeal Decision APP/H5390/D/23/3315429
4
Residential Amenity
15. To the East of the appeal site is no. 81. The property itself is less than 20
metres from the appeal property and faces the proposed two storey side
extension. At the time of my site visit, and from the submitted plans, I note
that the appeal property currently benefits from a single-storey side element
which, when viewed from the neighbouring property, would only equate to
around half of the depth of the appeal property. This is clearly visible within
the existing drawings (side elevation). This existing side element of the appeal
property has an eave height which is only marginally in excess of the boundary
fencing and has a hipped roof, meaning that the ridge height slopes upwards
away from no. 81. The existing side element is a modest element of the host
dwelling which is limited in overall bulk, scale and massing.
16. The appeal proposal, by comparison, seeks to replace this element with a two-
storey side extension. As a result of the proposed front extension and taking
into account the proposed curved wall to the front of the extension, the
proposal would result in two-storey development which would match the
existing ridge height of the main bulk of the existing host dwelling. This would
result in a large increase to bulk, scale and massing to the side of the host
property given that it would both double the height, and depth, of development
to the side of the host property. This would be a strongly contrasting proposal
compared to the existing development in overall scale as well as materials.
The proposal would result in views of a substantial pre-cast concrete/pre-cast
concrete with weave pattern wall, from no. 81 and the associated garden
space, which I consider to be both oppressive and un-neighbourly in terms of
the residential amenity of neighbouring occupiers as a result of overall massing
and height.
17. I note that there are proposed new windows at first floor level. One window,
serving the wardrobe, is noted to be frameless frosted glass. This would be the
main window which could potentially offer direct views over the neighbouring
garden at no. 81, but I find that frosted glass would, in this case, prevent
implications with regard to privacy and overlooking. Whilst the curved
bedroom window at first floor level would be overlooking the revised parking
space, it would still offer potential views at close, elevated, proximity into
amenity space of no. 81. I find that this would have a detrimental impact on
the amenity of no. 81 due to loss of privacy and overlooking, which would
further contribute to the increased sense of enclosure as a result of overall
massing and height.
18. I note that the appellant considers the existing eastern wall to be oppressive
view from neighbouring gardens due to its unforgiving and featureless expanse
of brickwork. Whilst the current wall does not offer interest from a design
point of view, the overall refusal reason is not based upon design in relation to
impact upon neighbours. In this case, the increased bulk, scale, and massing
would result in significant additions to which are highlighted within paragraph
6.9 of the appellant’s statement of case. The building would, ultimately, result
in substantially larger built form being only around 8.2 metres away from no.
81. The increased sense of enclosure would be particularly notable from within
the amenity area of the neighbouring property.
19. The proposal would be contrary to LP Policy HO11, which states that proposals
for extensions will be only considered acceptable where it can be demonstrated
Appeal Decision APP/H5390/D/23/3315429
5
that there is no detrimental impact on privacy enjoyed by neighbours in
adjoining properties, outlook from windows and adjoining properties and
openness between properties.
Other Matters
20. Comments regarding the handling of the application itself, with regard to the
Case Officer and Team Leader, and general delays within the application
process are noted to be frustrating. They are, however, outside the scope of
this appeal, which I Have determined on its own merits.
21. The appellant has made reference to application reference 2019/01306/FUL (14
Old Oak Road). The proposal is stated to relate to the demolition of a detached
house and garage and the erection of a replacement three-storey building
comprising of six self-contained residential flats. The approved elevation
provided, only shows distances between the properties in question which,
whilst they may be comparable, does not offer any further information as to
the location of overall amenity space or land use around the properties,
windows or similar, which officers would have taken into account in the
determination of that application and the application of the policies in question.
22. As a result of the very limited information provided relating to 14 Old Oak Road
and the application referenced there, I am unable to draw any meaningful
conclusions between the two proposals, as insufficient information has been
provided to allow an understanding of the site context and the relationship
between the properties in question. This would be key to understanding
impacts. Each case must be considered on its own merits, and I have
considered it on this basis.
23. The nationally described Space Standards (NDSS) are applicable to internal
space within new dwellings. It sets out requirement for the gross internal
(floor) area of new dwellings at a defined level of occupancy. The NDSS are
not, therefore, designed to be applicable to house extensions. Even if I had
accepted the argument that the existing house should be considered
unacceptably small and poor quality, sub-standard accommodation, the
proposed extension would increase the floor area to a level which then exceeds
NDSS which, whilst it may improve the accommodation for occupants of the
appeal site, would still be to the detriment of neighbouring properties for the
reasons outlined above.
Conclusion
24. For the reasons outlined above, and taking account all other matters raised, I
conclude that the appeal should be dismissed.
Eleni Randle
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.