First floor rear extension over existing orangery, enclosing of existing open porch and changes to the fenestration
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Green Belt Policy
Ecology & Biodiversity
Fallback Position
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 5 September 2023
by J Moore BA (Hons) BPl MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 10 October 2023
Appeal Ref: APP/Y3615/D/23/3315131
Springfold House, Shophouse Lane, Albury, Guildford GU5 9EQ
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr & Mrs M Jacklin against the decision of Guildford Borough
Council.
• The application Ref 22/P/00619, dated 4 April 2022, was refused by notice dated
11 October 2022.
• The development proposed is first floor rear extension over existing orangery, enclosing
of existing open porch and changes to the fenestration.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Background and Main Issues
2. From the evidence before me, the Council raises no objection to the proposed
changes to the fenestration beyond those resulting from the proposed first floor
extension and the enclosure of the existing porch, and I find no reason to
disagree. Therefore, the main issues are:
• whether the proposed development would be inappropriate development in
the Green Belt having regard to the National Planning Policy Framework
(the Framework) and any relevant development plan policies;
• the effect of the proposal on the openness of the Green Belt;
• the effect of the proposal upon biodiversity and protected species; and
• whether the harm by reason of inappropriateness, and any other harm,
would be clearly outweighed by other considerations so as to amount to the
very special circumstances required to justify the proposal.
Reasons
3. The appeal site lies within the Metropolitan Green Belt, and it is within the
Surrey Hills Area of Outstanding Natural Beauty (AONB) and within an Area of
Great Landscape Value (AGLV). The host property is sited within a large plot,
largely screened by vegetation to its boundaries, and the proposal would be
largely screened from the public realm.
Inappropriate Development
4. The Framework identifies that the fundamental aim of Green Belt policy is to
prevent urban sprawl by keeping land permanently open. It goes on to state
that inappropriate development is, by definition, harmful to the Green Belt and
Appeal Decision APP/Y3615/D/23/3315131
2
should not be approved except in very special circumstances; and that the
construction of new buildings within the Green Belt is inappropriate
development.
5. There are however a limited number of exceptions to this, as set out in the
Framework, including that at paragraph 149 c) which refers to the extension or
alteration of a building provided that it does not result in disproportionate
additions over and above the size of the original building1. Policy P2 of the
Guildford borough Local Plan: strategy and sites 2015-2034, April 2019 (LP)
broadly conforms to the Framework in this regard. The Framework does not
provide a definition of ‘disproportionate additions’ and neither does Policy P2.
Therefore, an assessment of whether a proposal would amount to a
disproportionate addition is a matter of planning judgement.
6. From the evidence before me, the original building benefits from previous
extensions and additions. By itself, the proposal would be a modest addition of
about 11.9m2 to the existing dwelling.
7. The main parties have provided different calculations of the original footprint of
the dwelling, together with the existing and proposed footprint. The Council
calculates an increase of about 71.2% and the appellant calculates an increase
of about 62%. Regardless of the differences between the main parties, an
increase of 62% would be a significant uplift. From the evidence before me and
my own observations, the proposed development would result in a significant
increase to the volume of the original dwelling, due to the creation of further
bulk and mass, including that arising from an enlarged roof to incorporate the
first-floor extension. Therefore, the proposal would result in a disproportionate
addition over and above the size of the original building in terms of both
footprint and volume.
8. The appellant states that the Council has granted permission for extensions
with an increased footprint of as much as 77%. However, I do not have details
of the circumstances that led to that example being accepted and so I cannot
be sure that it is directly comparable to the case before me, including in
respect of national and local planning policy.
9. I therefore conclude that the proposed development would result in
inappropriate development in the Green Belt, and it conflicts with Policy P2 of
the LP and the Framework.
Openness
10. Openness is an essential characteristic of the Green Belt, and it has a spatial
aspect as well as a visual aspect. ‘Open’ can mean the absence of development
in spatial terms, and it follows that openness can be harmed even when
development is not readily visible from the public realm.
11. The proposed enclosure of the existing open porch would have very little
impact upon openness in both spatial and visual terms due to its scale and
siting. The proposed first floor rear extension would be above the existing
orangery. It would have a flat roof crown and be integrated into the existing
rear roof slope. While it would not result in an increase to the overall depth and
width of the existing dwelling, it would result in an increase in the volume of
1 The Framework defines ‘original building’ as the building as it existed on 1 July 1948, or if it was constructed
after that date, as it was built originally.
Appeal Decision APP/Y3615/D/23/3315131
3
built form to its rear corner, thus resulting in a reduction in openness in spatial
terms. Due to the limited views from the public realm, it would not result in a
significant visual intrusion.
12. I therefore conclude that the proposed development would fail to preserve the
openness of the Green Belt, even though limited in visual terms. It conflicts
with Policy P2 of the LP and the fundamental aims of the Framework.
Biodiversity & protected species
13. Circular 06/2005 (ODPM) sets out that it is essential that the presence or
otherwise of protected species and the extent to which they may be affected by
a proposal is established before planning permission is granted, otherwise all
relevant material considerations may not have been addressed in making the
decision. In this case, Surrey Wildlife Trust (SWT) advises that records indicate
bat presence within the area and that the proposed development may affect
structures that may provide suitable roosting, foraging and commuting habitat
for bats. Furthermore, SWT advises that there is a reasonable likelihood of the
species being present and affected by the development. In such circumstances,
the circular is clear that a survey for protected species is required.
14. Paragraph 176 of the Framework refers to the conservation and enhancement
of wildlife as an important consideration in AONBs. Paragraph 174 sets out that
planning decisions should contribute to and enhance the natural and local
environment by minimising impacts on and providing net gains for biodiversity.
15. In the absence of compelling evidence to demonstrate that there is no
reasonable likelihood of protected species being present on or near the appeal
site, nor whether there is a risk that they may be adversely affected by the
proposal, and if so, what mitigation measures would be appropriate, I cannot
rule out potential harm to biodiversity and protected species. Under these
circumstances, I am not content to leave such matters to a condition.
16. The proposed development conflicts with Policy NE4 of the LP, which seeks to
ensure that development does not adversely affect protected species, and their
habitats. It conflicts with paragraphs 174 and 176 of the Framework, and it
fails to comply with the provisions of the Wildlife and Countryside Act (1981)
(as amended) and the Conservation of Habitats and Species Regulations
(2017) (as amended). I attach significant weight to this conflict.
Other considerations
17. The main parties agree that the design of the proposal would have no adverse
impacts upon the character and appearance of the area, or upon the amenity of
neighbouring occupiers, and I find no reason to disagree. Due to its scale,
design and siting, the proposed development would conserve the landscape
and scenic beauty of the AONB and would have no adverse impact upon the
AGLV. However, the absence of harm in such matters is a neutral factor in my
assessment, carrying neither positive nor negative weight, as is the absence of
any objections from neighbours or the Parish Council.
18. The Council’s report upon the planning application sets out a potential fallback
position with regard to the exercise of permitted development rights under the
GPDO2. The report briefly sets out a scenario to demolish the existing orangery
2 The Town and Country Planning (General Permitted Development) (England) Order 2015 (as amended).
Appeal Decision APP/Y3615/D/23/3315131
4
and erect a two-storey extension that would effectively co-join the existing
orangery with the proposed first floor extension. The report goes on to consider
that the appeal scheme includes alterations to the roof, which could result in an
increase in roof volume above that permitted by the GPDO.
19. Consequently, it is by no means certain that such a scheme would meet the
requirements of the GPDO for both Class A (which covers the enlargement of a
dwellinghouse) and Class C (which covers any alterations to the roof) in order
to be permitted development. In the absence of any compelling evidence
before me to demonstrate that a potential fallback position exists and that it
would be a realistic prospect, I cannot be certain that it would be more harmful
than the appeal scheme. Therefore, the potential fallback position is afforded
very limited weight, and does not form a case for very special circumstances
that might outweigh any harm arising from the proposal.
20. The proposal would result in an improvement to the amenities of the occupiers
of the host property, to which I attach limited weight. The appellant contends
that an extension to the existing dwelling would be less harmful to the
environment, in terms of CO2 emissions, landfill, noise and impacts upon
surrounding nature, rather than a scheme for a replacement dwelling. There is
no substantive evidence before me to demonstrate this. Furthermore, a
proposal for a replacement dwelling is not before me and I have considered the
appeal scheme on its own merits. Consequently, this matter is a neutral factor
in my assessment, carrying neither positive nor negative weight.
Green Belt Balance and Conclusion
21. The proposal would represent inappropriate development in the Green Belt,
which is, by definition, harmful to the Green Belt, and should not be approved
except in very special circumstances. In addition, openness is an essential
characteristic of the Green Belt, so a reduction in openness would also be
harmful, even if to a limited extent. I am also required to give substantial
weight to any harm to the Green Belt.
22. In this case, it is clear that the limited benefit arising from the proposal would
not outweigh the substantial and significant harms I have identified, and the
very special circumstances necessary to justify the proposal do not exist.
23. For the reasons above, I conclude that the appeal should be dismissed.
J Moore
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.