Replacement roof extension
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Green Belt Policy
Policy Weight
Trees & Landscape
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 1 August 2023
by Benjamin Clarke BA (Hons.) MSc MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 21st August 2023
Appeal Ref: APP/A1910/D/22/3313973
Lower Farm End, Luton Road, Markyate, Hertfordshire AL3 8PZ
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr Toby Wright against the decision of Dacorum Borough
Council.
• The application Ref 22/01347/FHA, dated 19 June 2022, was refused by notice dated 10
October 2022.
• The development proposed is a replacement roof extension.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Applications for costs
2. An application for an award of costs was made by Mr Toby Wright against
Dacorum Borough Council. This is the subject of a separate decision.
Main Issues
3. The main issues relevant to this appeal are:
• whether the proposed development is inappropriate in the Green Belt;
• the effects of the development upon the openness of the Green Belt; and
• if the development is inappropriate, whether the harm by reason of
inappropriateness, and any other harm, is clearly outweighed by other
considerations, so as to amount to the very special circumstances
necessary to justify the development.
Reasons
Whether inappropriate development
4. The appeal site is located in the Green Belt. In considering this appeal, I have
been directed towards Policy CS5 of the Dacorum Core Strategy (2013) (the
Core Strategy). Amongst other matters, this seeks to ensure that small-scale
developments will be permitted in the Green Belt, such as limited extensions to
existing buildings. In addition, the National Planning Policy Framework (the
Framework) regards the erection of new buildings in the Green Belt as
generally being inappropriate. There are some exceptions to this which are
listed in paragraph 149 of the Framework.
5. The proposed development can be described as the extension of an existing
dwelling. The Framework is clear that the extension or alteration of a building
Appeal Decision APP/A1910/D/22/3313973
2
might not be inappropriate, provided that it does not result in disproportionate
additions over and above the size of the original building.
6. In this instance, the evidence before me indicates that the original building is
the bungalow as currently constructed. This building has a relatively limited
footprint, in addition to relatively low roof ridge and eaves heights. The
proposed development would result in an increase in the height of the dwelling
in order to create larger rooms in the roof. The development would also include
the creation of new dormer windows.
7. Although the proposed development would not result in an increase in the
footprint of the dwelling. However, this is not the only means by which the size
of an extension can be assessed. In this case, the proposed development would
result in a significantly larger dwelling. This is because, as part of the
development, there would be a notable increase in the height of the eaves and
the overall height of the dwelling.
8. In addition, the proposed development would also include the insertion of two,
large, dormers on two different elevations of the proposed development. These
would have a height comparable to the overall height of the proposed
development. This means that the development would create a dwelling that
would result in a significantly greater height, mass and bulk than the existing
dwelling. The proposed development would therefore result in the creation of a
disproportionate addition.
9. My attention has been drawn to Policy 22 of the Dacorum Borough Local Plan.
Although not cited in the Council’s reason for refusal, this policy suggests that
a 30% increase in the floorspace of a dwelling. Although the proposed
development might not result in an increase in excess of this figure, this is only
one of the factors that must be assessed under this policy.
10. Therefore, the fact that the floorspace increase may not be in excess of the
prescribed figure, it does not mean that the policy has been complied with.
Therefore, given that the proposed extension would not be compact, this policy
has been breached. In addition, this is only one of the considerations to which I
have been directed.
11. Therefore, irrespective of whether an existing outbuilding should be counted as
an extension of the original dwelling, the proposed development would be a
disproportionate addition to the original building.
12. In considering this appeal, I have been directed towards the provisions of class
AA of the General Permitted Development Order (the GPDO). This allows for
the erection of additional stories on domestic dwellings. However, from the
evidence before me, it is clear that for this provision to be enacted, it is
necessary to first apply to the relevant local planning authority for a form of
approval.
13. It is not clear from the evidence that has been submitted that if an extension
were to be proposed under the provisions of Class A of the GPDO that such
permission would be forthcoming. In result, I cannot be certain that an
extension would be constructed under this mechanism. This means that I can
only give it a limited amount of weight and it does not overcome my previous
concerns.
Appeal Decision APP/A1910/D/22/3313973
3
14. I therefore conclude that the proposal would be an inappropriate development
within the Green Belt. The development, in this regard, would conflict with
Policy CS5 of the Core Strategy and the Framework.
Effect on openness
15. The appeal site consists of a domestic dwelling surrounded by a relatively large
garden. There are several mature trees near to the front and side boundaries
of the appeal site. The wider area is predominantly rural in nature. In
consequence, the appeal site and surrounding area has an open and more
verdant character.
16. The proposed developments would result in a notable increase in the overall
level of built form. This would comprise the increase in floor space in addition
to the greater height and massing of the new dwelling. In result of this, the
proposed development would result in an erosion of the spatial sense of
openness that is an intrinsic feature of the Green Belt.
17. In addition, the proposed development would be visible from some vantage
points to the rear of the site. In addition, there would be some limited and
glimpsed views from the highway. This means that the development would also
erode the visual sense of openness in the Green Belt. In addition, the appeal
site is currently screened by planting and trees. This reduces the level of
prominence of the appeal site.
18. However, should some of these trees and planting be removed such as through
ill-health, the development would become more prominent. This would lead to
a further erosion of the visual sense of the openness of the Green Belt. In
result, the proposed development has the potential to be experienced by a
notable number of people. Therefore, the proposal would result in an erosion of
the visual sense of the Green Belt's openness.
19. In result, the proposed development would create a more urbanising form of
development which would conflict with the general purposes of including land
within the Green Belt given that it would erode the predominantly open
character of the vicinity of the appeal site.
20. These adverse effects would occur even though the appellant’s dwelling and
other buildings in the surrounding area feature some space in between them.
21. I therefore conclude that the proposed development would have an adverse
effect upon the Green Belt sense of openness. The development, in this regard,
would conflict with Policy CS5 of the Core Strategy and the Framework.
Amongst other matters, these seek to ensure that developments protect the
openness and character of the Green Belt.
Other considerations
22. The proposed development would result in an enlarged dwelling. This would
therefore result in improved living conditions for the occupiers of the dwelling,
including their family. However, it has not been demonstrated that there is a
significant need that would render the provision of a larger dwelling a necessity
in this specific location. In result, I can only give this a limited amount of
weight.
Appeal Decision APP/A1910/D/22/3313973
4
23. The proposed development would generate some economic benefits arising
from the construction process. However, by reason of the scale of the
development, these benefits are likely to be relatively small-scale in impact.
Furthermore, some of these are also likely to be of a time-limited duration. In
consequence, this matter can also only be given a limited amount of weight.
Other Matters
24. Concerns regarding the manner in which the Council determined the planning
application fall outside of the scope of this decision.
Planning Balance
25. The development plan and Framework set out the general presumption against
inappropriate development within the Green Belt. They explain that such
development should not be approved except in very special circumstances.
Very special circumstances to justify inappropriate development will not exist
unless the potential harm to the Green Belt, by reason of inappropriateness,
and any other harm, is clearly outweighed by other considerations.
26. I have concluded that the appeal scheme would be inappropriate development
and would, by definition, harm the Green Belt. In so doing I have found harm
to the openness of the Green Belt. Paragraph 148 of the Framework requires
substantial weight to be given to any harm to the Green Belt.
27. The other considerations I have identified individually and collectively carry a
limited amount of weight in favour of the proposal. As such the harm to the
Green Belt is not clearly outweighed by the other considerations identified, and
therefore the very special circumstances necessary to justify the development
do not exist.
Conclusion
28. The scheme would therefore conflict with the development plan taken as a
whole. There are no material considerations, including the Framework, which
indicate the decision should be made other than in accordance with the
development plan. Therefore, for the preceding reasons, I conclude that the
appeal should be dismissed.
Benjamin Clarke
INSPECTOR
£
Costs decision section
Costs Decision
Site visit made on 1 August 2023
by Benjamin Clarke BA (Hons.) MSc MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 21st August 2023
Costs application in relation to Appeal Ref: APP/A1910/D/22/3313973
• Lower Farm End, Luton Road, Markyate, Hertfordshire AL3 8PZ The
application is made under the Town and Country Planning Act 1990, sections 78, 322
and Schedule 6, and the Local Government Act 1972, section 250(5).
• The application is made by Mr Toby Wright for a full award of costs against Dacorum
Borough Council.
• The appeal was against the refusal of planning permission for a replacement roof
extension.
Decision
1. The application for an award of costs is refused.
Reasons
2. Parties in planning appeals normally meet their own expenses. However, the
Planning Practice Guidance (the PPG) advises that costs may be awarded
against a party who has behaved unreasonably and thereby caused the party
applying for costs to incur unnecessary or wasted expense in the appeal
process.
3. Local Planning Authorities are encouraged, through the PPG, to exercise their
development management responsibilities by relying only on reasons which
stand up to scrutiny on the planning merits of the case.
4. In this instance, the Council identified areas of national and local planning
policies that are relevant to the proposed development. In addition, the Council
explained how they considered that these policies were breached and the harm
that would arise from these breaches. Therefore, I find that the Council
properly substantiated the reasons for refusal.
5. Although the Council referenced the presence of an outbuilding in their
delegated report, it is clear that this is only one of the material considerations
that the Council considered relevant to the determination of the planning
application. In consequence, I cannot find that the references to this building
by the Council to be unreasonable.
6. It has been suggested that the Council may have granted planning permission
for a different form of development. Irrespective of whether this is the case, a
planning application was submitted to the Council and therefore, the Council
was entitled to determine the application. In consequence, the fact that the
applicant submitted their appeal against the refusal of planning permission is
not evidence of wasted or unnecessary expense given that it was in response
to a conclusion that the Council could be reasonably expected to reach.
Appeal Decision APP/A1910/D/22/3313973
2
7. Given that the Council outlined areas of national and local planning policies,
which they considered had been breached by the development and harm that
would arise from this, I am unable to conclude that the Council prevented or
delayed development which should clearly have been permitted.
8. The applicant has suggested that the Council’s Planning Officer indicated that
the scheme was acceptable prior to the determination of the planning
application. Whilst this may be the case, the Council’s reasons for refusal are
properly substantiated and have relied upon relevant policies. This is therefore
not evidence of unreasonable behaviour that has created wasted expense.
9. I understand that the Council has previously permitted other developments at
the appeal site. However, it is clear from the Council’s delegated report that
these have differing forms and purposes to the appeal scheme. In result, a
differing approach is justified in this instance. I therefore do not find that this is
evidence of unreasonable behaviour.
10. In consequence, I cannot agree that the Council has acted unreasonably in this
case. As such, I do not believe that the appellant was put to unnecessary or
wasted expense. Therefore, an award of costs is not justified.
Conclusion
11. I find that unreasonable behaviour resulting in unnecessary or wasted expense,
as described in the PPG, has not been demonstrated.
Benjamin Clarke
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.