Erection of first floor extension to form habitable accommodation
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Fallback Position
Extensions
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 14 February 2023
by Ann Veevers BA(Hons) DipBCon MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 8 March 2023
Appeal Ref: APP/N4720/D/22/3313338
4 Smithy Lane, West Ardsley, Wakefield WF3 1QG
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant approval required under Article 3(1) and Schedule 2, Part 1,
Class AA of the Town and Country Planning (General Permitted Development) (England)
Order 2015 (as amended).
• The appeal is made by Mr and Mrs Rall against the decision of Leeds City Council.
• The application Ref 22/06662/DPD, dated 29 September 2022, was refused by notice
dated 24 November 2022.
• The development proposed is erection of first floor extension to form habitable
accommodation.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Preliminary Matters
2. The application form and appeal form refer to different addresses. For clarity,
the address in the banner heading above has been taken from the Council’s
decision notice. I am satisfied no party would be prejudiced by my use thereof.
Background and Main Issue
3. Schedule 2, Part 1, Class AA of the Town and Country Planning (General
Permitted Development) (England) Order 2015 (as amended) (the Order)
permits development involving the enlargement of a dwellinghouse by
construction of additional storeys, subject to specified limitations and
conditions. Therefore, it is necessary in the first instance to determine whether
the proposal falls within the scope of permitted development.
4. The Council concluded that the proposal would comply with the conditions and
limitations set out at paragraph AA.1 of Class AA, such that it would fall within
the scope of permitted development rights, subject to the consideration of
relevant matters of prior approval. From the evidence before me I see no
reason to take a different view.
5. Paragraph AA.2.(3)(a) sets out four matters for which the developer must
apply to the local planning authority for prior approval. The Council refused
prior approval only in respect of matter (ii): the external appearance of the
dwellinghouse, including the design and architectural features of (aa) the
principal elevation of the dwellinghouse, and (bb) any side elevation of the
dwellinghouse that fronts a highway. As before, I have no evidence to dispute
the Council’s conclusions in respect of the other prior approval matters under
sub-sections (i), (iii) and (iv) of Paragraph AA.2.(3)(a).
Appeal Decision APP/N4720/D/22/3313338
2
6. Notwithstanding that the introduction of Class AA was, in part, to give freedom
to householders to extend properties, recent case law1 has confirmed that, for
Class AA proposals, the control of the external appearance of the dwelling is
not limited to impact on the subject property itself, but also includes impact on
neighbouring premises and the locality.
7. Therefore, the main issue is whether prior approval should be granted having
regard to the effect of the proposal on the character and appearance of the
area and the host dwelling.
Reasons
8. The appeal dwelling sits within a row of 4 detached bungalows fronting Smithy
Lane. The group of bungalows are located between playing fields and the
junction of Smithy Lane with Constable Road. Dwellings to the rear, including
Nos. 10 and 12 Smithy Lane, along with those on Perth Drive, are also
detached bungalows or dormer bungalows. This gives a spacious character to
the western side of Smithy Lane as levels rise towards the junction with
Constable Road. Residential properties on the eastern side of Smithy Lane and
along Fairleigh Road are predominantly two-storey and as such are significantly
higher and distinctly different to properties to the west.
9. Whilst the appeal dwelling has a hipped roof design and the immediately
neighbouring dwellings have gabled roofs, the consistency of comparable eaves
and ridge lines, roof materials and set back from the road is obvious in views
along Smithy Lane from both directions. There is therefore an overall regularity
of size and scale amongst all 4 bungalows.
10. The proposal would add an additional storey to the appeal property, designed
with matching features, roof form and materials to the existing building.
Nonetheless, the addition of the extra storey would create a jarring and
discordant change in height in the group of bungalows, which would severely
disrupt the harmony of the group and result in a property that would be
harmfully at odds with the appearance of the existing dwelling and its
immediate surroundings. Furthermore, the additional storey above the existing
front projection would emphasise the overall mass of the building and
exacerbate its prominent appearance, creating an uncharacteristic feature on
the front elevation, not seen at two storey height elsewhere in the street.
11. My attention has been drawn to a number of other properties in the locality
that have been extended. Whilst there are substantial extensions to
No. 2 Smithy Lane, aside from a dormer, they are single storey. The two
properties at the rear of the site are dormer bungalows. Although there are
two-storey dwellings on the eastern side of Smithy Lane and in the wider area,
the proposal would not be seen in the context of these dwellings, but alongside
the predominant group of single storey dwellings lying between the playing
fields and Constable Road, against which it would appear significantly out of
place.
12. Consequently, the external appearance of the dwellinghouse would significantly
harm the character and appearance of the area and as such the proposal would
be contrary to the requirements of paragraph AA.2(3)(a)(ii) of Article 3(1) and
Schedule 2, Part 1, Class AA of the Order. The Order sets out that National
1 CAB Housing Ltd, Beis Noeh Ltd & Mati Rotenberg v SSLUHC [2022] EWHC 208 (Admin)
Appeal Decision APP/N4720/D/22/3313338
3
Planning Policy Framework (the Framework) can be considered relevant in prior
approval cases where relevant to the subject matter of the prior approval, as if
the application were a planning application. The Council has referred to the
Framework, which I have considered only insofar as it is relevant to this
appeal. I find that the proposal would conflict with the advice of the
Framework, which seeks to achieve well-designed places.
Other Matters
13. The proposed development would provide a contemporary, larger family home
and I note there is support from neighbours to the scheme. Nevertheless, I
have found the proposal would be unacceptable and do not consider the harm
would be outweighed by these other considerations.
Conclusion
14. For the above reasons, and taking account of all other matters raised, I
conclude that the appeal should be dismissed.
Ann Veevers
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.