Ground floor - Rear extension, Side extension, Garage conversion, Internal alterations First floor - Side extension, Internal alterations, Rooflights Loft floor - Make habitable, Rear dormers, Internal alterations, Rooflights
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Trees & Landscape
Character & Appearance
Extensions
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 4 April 2023
by D Wilson BSc (Hons) MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 09 May 2023
Appeal Ref: APP/Y1945/D/22/3312954
19 Pinewood Close, Hertfordshire, Watford WD17 4NP
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr Ibrahim Siddiqui against the decision of Watford Borough
Council.
• The application Ref 22/00997/FULH, dated 15 August 2022, was refused by notice
dated 11 October 2022.
• The development proposed is Ground floor - Rear extension, Side extension, Garage
conversion, Internal alterations First floor - Side extension, Internal alterations,
Rooflights Loft floor - Make habitable, Rear dormers, Internal alterations, Rooflights.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Preliminary Matter
2. In October 2022 the Watford Local Plan 2021-2038 (the ‘Local Plan’) was
adopted. The Watford District Plan 2000, referred to in the decision notice, has
been superseded. I have based my decision on the new Local Plan.
Main Issue
3. The main issue is the effect of the proposal on the character and appearance of
the area including the effect on protected trees.
Reasons
4. 19 Pinewood Close (No.19) is a detached house that sits on a corner plot. The
area nearby is residential and due to the variety of mature trees that line the
roads, as well as the front and rear gardens of the houses, it has a verdant
character and appearance.
5. No.19 has a large garden which is within proximity of several trees protected
by a group tree preservation order1. In particular the garden contains a mature
Norway Spruce (identified on the TPO plan as T105) which is a significant
height and extends above the dwelling. There is also a Lawson Cypress tree
(T104) which sits adjacent to the dwelling, next to the road and an Ash tree
(T103) that is located towards the rear of the neighbouring garden. These trees
make a significant positive contribution to the verdant character and
appearance of the area.
1 Tree Preservation Order 63
Appeal Decision APP/Y1945/D/22/3312954
2
6. The proposal would extend the rear of the property and result in an extension
that is close to T105. I have had regard to the appellant’s arboricultural impact
assessment which includes details of how the roots will be protected during
construction as well as the proposed piled foundation and cantilevered capping
slab method that could be utilised to construct the proposal.
7. Tree roots are significant and visible across the garden and due to the large
section of the Root Protection Area (RPA) that would be occupied by the
proposal, it is likely that damage would be caused to the roots during
construction, even with the method proposed and taking account of the area
that is already a brick paved surface.
8. The proposal itself would extend into a significant proportion of the RPA which
could also lead to a restrictive effect on future root growth. Both this and the
potential for root damage during construction would affect the vitality of the
trees and could result in their loss, which would be to the detriment of the
character and appearance of the area.
9. The proposal includes works to prune and crown lift some of the trees to
facilitate the works. The works to the majority of trees would be minor and
would unlikely result in any substantial change in appearance of the trees.
However, whilst it might be common practise and not have a discernible impact
on the tree’s longevity, the raising of the crown of T105 to achieve ground
clearance of 4 metres would significantly alter the appearance of the tree.
Particularly when viewed from Maple Grove which would erode some of the
positive contribution to the verdant character and appearance of the area that
the tree provides.
10. During my site visit I saw that T105 has significant needle, cone and twig litter
which covered a large proportion of the garden and likely also the roof and
guttering of the house. I appreciate that this may already be a nuisance which
is managed by the occupiers however the closeness of the rear extension and
provision of 4 rooflights would exacerbate this nuisance further and likely
require more frequent management of the gutters, roof and rooflights. Gutter
guards could be fitted and rodding points to allow maintenance of the system
however the increased nuisance caused would result in increased pressure in
the future to continue to carry out works to the tree and lead to the potential
for felling.
11. The proposal would be close to T105 and whilst I acknowledge that trunk
expansion is unlikely to have an impact there is no substantive evidence to
suggest that the foundation design would be sufficient in order to protect the
proposal from future structural damage from tree roots.
12. I have considered the possibility of securing any permission with a condition to
ensure that the development is constructed in a way that the foundations are
able to withstand structural damage from tree roots. However, I do not
consider it appropriate to secure the fundamentals of construction by condition
without some reassurance beforehand that the methods proposed could be
delivered on site. As such, based on the evidence before me it is likely that the
proposal would lead to structural damage in the future which would further
lead to pressure to fell the trees.
13. Although the current occupiers value the trees due to the privacy provided,
wildlife attracted and verdant character and appearance of the area which
Appeal Decision APP/Y1945/D/22/3312954
3
means they have no desire to remove the trees, I must consider the likely
wishes of future occupiers too. As these trees make a significant positive
contribution to the verdant character and appearance of the area, their loss
would be harmful.
14. In summary, the development would be likely to result in pressure to remove
the trees which would harm the character and appearance of the area. The
proposal would conflict with Policy NE 9.1 of the Local Plan which amongst
other things, seeks to protect Watford’s natural and environmental assets.
Other Matters
15. I have no reason to conclude against the Council’s assessment that scale and
design of the proposal is acceptable and that it is deemed acceptable in terms
of its effect on the living conditions of neighbouring occupiers, however these
matters do not outweigh the harm I have identified.
16. The appellant has referred to a planning application elsewhere that used a
similar approach to constructing foundations within RPA’s. However, very little
information has been provided about the circumstances of this particular
application and in any case, I am only in a position to consider the proposal
before me.
Conclusion
17. For the reasons set out above, having had regard to the development plan read
as a whole, and all other material considerations, I conclude that the appeal
should be dismissed.
D Wilson
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.