Construction of detached garage after demolition of existing concrete garage and construction of new driveway
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Trees & Landscape
Heritage & Conservation
Policy Weight
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 24 November 2022
by G Powys Jones MSc FRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date: 13th December 2022
Appeal Ref: APP/N1730/D/22/3307417
46 Church Road, Fleet, GU51 4NB
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 against a
refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr James Abley against the decision of Hart District Council.
• The application Ref 22/00990/HOU, dated 5 May 2022, was refused by notice dated
5 August 2022.
• The development proposed is construction of detached garage after demolition of existing
concrete garage and construction of new driveway.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issue
2. The main issue is whether the proposed development would preserve or
enhance the character or appearance of the North Fleet Conservation Area
(CA).
Reasons
3. The appeal property is a substantial detached dwelling set in a spacious
garden, sited at Church Road’s junction with Avenue Road. Both the site’s
frontages are heavily treed, with a generous number of lower-level plants,
including evergreens also in evidence. The trees and planting contribute
positively to the sylvan character of this part of the CA. They also effectively
screen extant development within the site, even when I visited when
substantial winter defoliation had taken place.
4. The Council has no objection to the demolition of the existing garage, which
has a utilitarian appearance. I have no reason to object either. The Council’s
concerns centre on the scale and location of the replacement garage, its
alleged consequential impact on the CA and its potential effect on trees.
5. The appellant points to some examples of other garages in the area, including
one built at the front of the property on the opposite side of Church Road. A
comparison is made with a garage permitted previously at the site, but this
attracts little weight in my considerations since the previous permission has
expired, and is no longer capable of implementation without a fresh
permission.
Appeal Decision APP/N1730/D/22/3307417
2
6. The proposed garage is of a greater scale than those seen in the area
generally, but it is a structure quite capable in my view of being acceptably
assimilated into the spacious grounds of the dwelling, albeit probably not in its
currently proposed siting1. Views into the site are limited, not only because of
the screening afforded by trees and other vegetation, but also because this
part of Church Road is tortuous and as a result forward visibilities are curtailed.
The clearest view towards the proposal, if built, would be available to those
approaching from Church Grove, whose junction with Church Road is virtually
opposite the site. However, current views into the site from the junction are
limited such is the effectiveness of the vegetative screening.
7. I note that a tree report was presented with the application, which amounted
to a survey of some of the existing trees. The Council’s tree officer pointed out
that the application was not accompanied by further reports which may have
assessed the effect of the proposal on trees, and possible mitigation2. I share
the tree officer’s concern, particularly since the proposed garage would be sited
within the root protection area of the closest, most significant tree and partly
under its canopy. Other trees and vegetation on the frontage may also be
affected by the proposal, not only directly by the structure itself, but during
construction.
8. The issue of trees to my mind is not sufficiently addressed in the appeal
documentation, which leads to considerable uncertainty in my mind as to
whether the screening currently in evidence and the attractive beech, and
possibly other trees, would survive the construction process. No thought
appears to have been given to a possible re-siting deeper into the site, thus
avoiding conflict with the trees and other vegetation.
9. To my mind the proposal as it stands, in the absence of evidence to the
contrary, would probably lead to the destruction of a significant tree and other
vegetation, which contribute positively towards forming the character of this
part of the CA. Given its closeness to the site’s frontage this would expose the
proposed garage to public view, where it would be perceived as a dominant
structure harmful to the local visual scene.
10. Accordingly, a clear conflict arises with those provisions of policy NBE8 of the
Hart Local Plan (Strategy and Sites) 2032 and policy GEN1 of the Hart Local
Plan (Replacement) 1996-2006 requiring new development to conserve or
enhance heritage assets and their settings, and to be in keeping with local
character.
11. The harm that I have found is less than substantial, but I have not been made
aware of any public benefits arising from the proposal, if implemented.
Indeed, it appears to me that only the private benefits accruing to the
appellant would arise.
Other matters
12. I have taken account of all other matters raised in the representations
including the objections made by neighbouring residents and those of the Town
Council. I note the references to other development plan policies, but those to
1 For reasons explained below
2 Such as an aboricultural impact appraisal; a method statement and tree protection plan.
Appeal Decision APP/N1730/D/22/3307417
3
which I have referred are considered the most relevant having regard to the
particular circumstances of this case.
13. No other matter raised outweighs those considerations which led me to my
conclusions.
G Powys Jones
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.