Installation of external lift shaft through existing conservatory roof (glazing to be removed) with three sun tubes and grey Canadian slate roof to match house roof
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Policy Weight
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 12 September 2023
by K Reeves BA (Hons) MA MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 19 October 2023
Appeal Ref: APP/B9506/D/22/3307359
Little Sequoia, Hazel Grove, Woodlands, Ashurst, Southampton, Hants
SO40 7AJ
• The appeal is made under Section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr Stuart Clarke against the decision of New Forest National
Park Authority.
• The application Ref 22/00222, dated 14 March 2022, was refused by notice dated
21 June 2022.
• The development proposed is the installation of external lift shaft through existing
conservatory roof (glazing to be removed) with three sun tubes and grey Canadian slate
roof to match house roof.
Decision
1. The appeal is allowed and planning permission is granted for the installation of
external lift shaft through existing conservatory roof (glazing to be removed)
with three sun tubes and grey Canadian slate roof to match house roof at Little
Sequoia, Hazel Grove, Woodlands, Ashurst, Southampton, Hants, SO40 7AJ in
accordance with the terms of the application, Ref 22/00222, dated 14 March
2022, subject to the following conditions:
1) The development hereby permitted shall begin not later than 3 years
from the date of this decision.
2) The development hereby permitted shall be carried out in accordance
with the following approved plans: 1, 2, 4, 5, 6 and 7.
3) Prior to their installation on the development hereby permitted, samples
of the materials to be used in the construction of the external surfaces of
the development shall be submitted to, and approved in writing by, the
Local Planning Authority. The development shall be carried out in
accordance with the approved samples and retained as such thereafter.
Preliminary Matters
2. New Forest National Park Authority’s decision notice submitted by the appellant
does not include a reason for refusal. However, the Committee minutes show
the reason for refusal. I base my main issue on the reason for refusal
contained within those minutes.
Main Issue
3. The main issue is whether the proposed development would affect the range
and mix of house stock in the New Forest National Park and whether that would
result in a conflict with the development plan.
Appeal Decision APP/B9506/D/22/3307359
2
Reasons
4. Little Sequoia is a two storey dwelling that is set within a row of detached
residential dwellings on the edge of Woodlands, near Ashurst. The properties
face towards open fields and have long gardens, some with detached
outbuildings.
5. The proposed external lift shaft would emanate from the roof of the
conservatory attached to the dwelling and connect the ground floor with the
first floor. I understand that the reason presented for the lift is to allow
continued living at the property despite mobility issues of an occupier.
6. New Forest National Park Authority’s (NPA) reason for refusal raises a conflict
with Policy DP36 of the New Forest National Park Local Plan (LP). It is stated by
the NPA that the original dwelling that occupied the site and was replaced by
the current dwelling under application reference 09/93865 was less than 80
square metres and therefore the policy restricts the current dwelling’s habitable
floorspace to no more than 100 square metres.
7. The conservatory that is attached to the dwelling was allowed under appeal
reference APP/B9506/D/12/2188225. Conservatories are exempt from the
policy restriction of 100 square metres of habitable floorspace if they comply
with the definition set out in Paragraph 7.82 of the LP. As part of the proposal,
the glass roof of the conservatory would be replaced with slate tiles. This would
take the conservatory beyond the acceptable tolerance of an exempt extension
set out in Paragraph 7.82. As such, the conservatory and the external lift shaft
would cumulatively increase the habitable floorspace of the dwelling beyond
the 100 square metres allowance for smaller dwellings.
8. However, I note that there is the ability under Policy DP36 to increase the
habitable floorspace of the dwelling up to 120 square metres where exceptional
circumstances arise from a genuine family needs of an occupier who works in
the immediate locality. A genuine family need is defined as an exceptional and
unique family need that could not have been reasonably anticipated at the time
of purchase of the property.
9. The appellant has provided medical letters from their consultant and GP that
explain the current health issues they are suffering. I consider that there is
substantive evidence to demonstrate that the medical issues the appellant is
experiencing are unlikely to get better and navigating the stairs within the
property present a significant challenge. I consider that the appellant has a
genuine need for the external stair lift and it was potentially unforeseen that
their condition would worsen to its current state when he moved into the
property many years ago. Consequently, I find that the enlargement of the
dwelling up to 120 square metres is acceptable under the policy due to the
exceptional circumstances in this case.
10. The NPA state that the proposed external lift shaft would take the habitable
floorspace of the dwelling beyond the 120 square metres limit by
approximately 2.2 square metres. The exceedance of this limit results in the
proposal conflicting with the floorspace limit in Policy DP36.
11. Paragraph 7.79 of the LP states that proposals to incrementally extend
dwellings in a nationally designated landscape can affect the locally distinctive
character of the built environment of the New Forest. Additionally, extensions
Appeal Decision APP/B9506/D/22/3307359
3
can over time cause an imbalance in the range and mix of housing stock
available. The paragraph also refers to maintaining a stock of smaller sized
dwellings.
12. It is debatable whether the external lift shaft would technically increase the
floorspace of the dwelling as it would be a moveable floor with a void left on
the ground floor or first floor when the lift is at the other level. Notwithstanding
this, the proposal would minimally increase the floorspace of the dwelling and it
would not provide space for a bedroom or additional living space. I have been
provided with limited evidence to demonstrate that the small-scale
enlargement would have an effect on the affordability of the property.
13. I have already considered that the policy criteria for an enlargement up to 120
square metres has been met and I now find that the proposed increase by an
approximate 2.2 square metres would not result in a material impact on the
range and mix of house stock within the National Park. There is little
substantive evidence before me that would lead me to find that the proposed
external lift shaft would harmfully conflict with, or undermine, the aims and
objectives to Policy DP36. This lends further support to my findings.
14. Moreover, I note that the NPA have not raised a concern with the proposal’s
impact on the built environment or landscape of the National Park. I therefore
find that the proposal does not conflict with Policies DP2 and SP17 of the LP,
which were also referenced in the NPA’s reason for refusal.
15. Having regard to all of the above, I conclude that whilst the new extension
would conflict with the 120 square metres habitable floorspace limit in Policy
DP36 of the New Forest National Park Local Plan, the proposal would not
materially affect the range and mix of house stock in this part of the National
Park. Accordingly, the proposal would not result in harm to, or conflict with, the
aims and objectives of Policy DP36. Taking all of this into account, the
proposed development in this case would not conflict with the development
plan when read as a whole.
Conditions
16. I consider that the standard time limit condition and a condition listing the
approved plans are necessary for the avoidance of doubt and in the interests of
proper planning. The NPA have suggested a condition requiring the submission
and approval of external materials. I concur that such a condition is necessary
to ensure the conservation of the protected landscape. However, I have
amended the wording of the condition in the interests of preciseness, and I
have altered it from prior to commencement to prior to installation in the
interests of reasonableness.
Conclusion
17.For the above reasons, I have concluded that the installation of an external lift
shaft through the existing conservatory roof, together with the installation of
sun tubes and a slate roof, would not conflict with the development plan when
read as a whole. Accordingly, I conclude that the appeal should be allowed.
K Reeves
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Technical Appeal Representation
This Other minor developments requires a bespoke technical strategy to succeed.
Contact Planzo for a professional review and quotation.