Construction of enlarged lower ground floor level, and rear extensions at lower and ground floor levels, installation of two front-garden lightwells, new boundary treatment, along with partial enlargement of existing rear dormer window and installation of two roof-lights in the front roof slope. Installation of air source heat pumps within rear garden and photovoltaic panels to flat top section of rear roof dormer and addition of three roof lights to flat top section of rear roof dormer
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Extensions
Heritage & Conservation
Noise & Disturbance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decisions
Site visit made on 22 March 2023
by A Price BSc MA MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 20 April 2023
Appeal A Ref: APP/U5360/D/22/3304626
7 Meynell Road, Hackney, London E9 7AP
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr Gibson against the decision of the Council of the London
Borough of Hackney.
• The application Ref 2022/0839, dated 30 March 2022, was refused by notice dated
25 May 2022.
• The development proposed is the construction of enlarged lower ground floor level, and
rear extensions at lower and ground floor levels, installation of two front-garden
lightwells, new boundary treatment, along with partial enlargement of existing rear
dormer window and installation of two roof-lights in the front roof slope. Installation of
air source heat pumps within rear garden and photovoltaic panels to flat top section of
rear roof dormer and addition of three roof lights to flat top section of rear roof dormer.
Appeal B Ref: APP/U5360/D/22/3304625
7 Meynell Road, Hackney, London E9 7AP
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr Gibson against the decision of the Council of the London
Borough of Hackney.
• The application Ref 2022/0828, dated 30 March 2022, was refused by notice dated
25 May 2022.
• The development proposed is the construction of enlarged lower ground floor level, and
rear extensions at lower and ground floor levels, installation of two front-garden
lightwells, new boundary treatment, along with re-cladding of existing rear dormer
window and installation of two roof-lights in the front roof slope. Installation of air
source heat pumps within rear garden and photovoltaic panels to flat top section of rear
roof dormer and addition of three roof lights to flat top section of rear roof dormer.
Decision
1. Appeal A is allowed and planning permission is granted for the construction of
enlarged lower ground floor level, and rear extensions at lower and ground
floor levels, installation of two front-garden lightwells, new boundary
treatment, along with partial enlargement of existing rear dormer window and
installation of two roof-lights in the front roof slope. Installation of air source
heat pumps within rear garden and photovoltaic panels to flat top section of
rear roof dormer and addition of three roof lights to flat top section of rear roof
dormer at 7 Meynell Road, Hackney, London E9 7AP in accordance with the
terms of the application Ref 2022/0839, dated 30 March 2022, subject to the
conditions appended to this decision.
Appeal Decisions APP/U5360/D/22/3304626, APP/U5360/D/22/3304625
2
2. Appeal B is allowed and planning permission is granted for the construction of
enlarged lower ground floor level, and rear extensions at lower and ground
floor levels, installation of two front-garden lightwells, new boundary
treatment, along with re-cladding of existing rear dormer window and
installation of two roof-lights in the front roof slope. Installation of air source
heat pumps within rear garden and photovoltaic panels to flat top section of
rear roof dormer and addition of three roof lights to flat top section of rear roof
dormer at 7 Meynell Road, Hackney, London E9 7AP in accordance with the
terms of the application Ref 2022/0828, dated 30 March 2022, subject to the
conditions appended to this decision.
Applications for costs
3. An application for costs was made by Mr Nicholas Gibson against the Council of
the London Borough of Hackney. This application is the subject of a separate
decision.
Preliminary Matters
4. As set out above there are two appeals on this site. They differ only in the
detail of the design of the proposed development. I have considered each
proposal on its individual merits. However, to avoid duplication I have dealt
with the two schemes together, except where otherwise indicated.
Main Issue
5. The main issue in both Appeal A and Appeal B is the effect of the proposed
development on the character and appearance of the area, including heritage
assets.
Reasons
6. The appeal site comprises a three-storey dwelling, with converted roofspace,
set within a large garden plot. The appeal property lies within Victoria Park
Conservation Area and is a locally listed building. Statute places a duty on me
to pay special attention to the desirability of preserving or enhancing the
character or appearance of this conservation area (CA) and the significance of
the locally listed building.
7. The appeal building forms part of a wider complete terrace (Nos 1-11 Meynell
Road). The principal qualities of the locally listed building are its generous
proportions and unusual decorative features, particularly its classical porch.
The significance of the CA lies in the historic, largely nineteenth century,
development of terraced housing, including some larger houses around Well
Street Common, the principal open space of the area. The CA appraisal (CAA,
2012) specifically marks the terrace at Meynell Road, built in the 1870s, as
forming important buildings in views along streets.
Lightwells
8. The Council’s Residential Extensions and Alterations Supplementary Planning
Document (the SPD, 2009) seeks to restrict the installation of basement
lightwells within shallow front gardens where these are not a traditional feature
of the street. Nevertheless, the principle of the installation of lightwells within
the front garden of the appeal site was established under planning permission
reference 2021/1783. That permission included lightwells in front of both
Appeal Decisions APP/U5360/D/22/3304626, APP/U5360/D/22/3304625
3
ground floor windows, preserving 50% of the depth of the front garden, with a
flush fitting grille over.
9. The current proposals, under both appeals, include two front lightwells in the
same position as those previously approved. However, these would be of a
greater width, extending across much of the front elevation of the property.
The Council contends that the size, scale and location of the proposed lightwells
would be excessive and uncharacteristic of the street scene.
10. From the plans before me, the proposed lightwells would be only marginally
wider than those previously approved at the property, would be fitted with a
flush grille and would retain 50% of the depth of the front garden. Moreover,
the lightwells would be largely screened from view by the proposed
replacement boundary wall and planting, ensuring that no visual clutter would
result and that the architectural integrity of the front elevation would be
retained. Accordingly, this element of the proposal would not have an adverse
effect on the significance of the locally listed building or the character or
appearance of the CA, which would be preserved.
Dormer extension
11. The SPD sets out that dormer windows and rooflights will normally be
acceptable on rear roof slopes, and that these should reflect the architectural
character of the existing building and its neighbours, in their form, detailing
and materials. The guidance specifies that dormers should be set in from the
party wall on each side and down from the ridge. Generally, dormers are
required to exceed no more than half the width of the existing roof. An
exception to that guidance is where a number of large rear box dormers
already exist within the immediate vicinity. In those cases, larger dormers may
be acceptable.
12. Whilst there are few examples of larger box dormers within the immediately
surrounding area, the existing roof extension at the appeal site could
reasonably fit that description. This is of a relatively contemporary design, with
large window openings and timber boarding. Whilst elements of the existing
extension conform with the guidance in the SPD, the proportion of window
openings and the use of materials are not in keeping with the original property.
Nevertheless, the extension appears to have been in-situ for a considerable
period of time, and it consequently forms part of the character and appearance
of the property and immediately surrounding area.
13. There is no dispute between the Council and appellant in respect of the
proposed dormer alterations under Appeal B. That proposal seeks to replace
the existing dormer with one which is of a similar scale and bulk but which is
faced in natural slate and incorporates three smaller sash windows. I have no
reason to disagree with those findings.
14. The proposal under Appeal A seeks to increase the size of the existing dormer
to form a stepped structure. Like the design of the dormer under Appeal B, it
would be faced in natural slate and feature three sash windows. Although I
concur with the Council that the proposed stepped dormer is not a requirement
of the SPD, the relatively limited extension of the existing dormer, particularly
once finished in slate, would have little appreciable effect on the street scene
compared with the existing structures. The proposal, in my view, could not be
described as ungainly or visually obtrusive when compared with the existing
Appeal Decisions APP/U5360/D/22/3304626, APP/U5360/D/22/3304625
4
appearance of the building. Accordingly, this element of the proposal, in this
particular case, would not have an adverse effect on the significance of the
locally listed building or the character or appearance of the CA, which would be
preserved.
Basement extension
15. There is no dispute between the Council and appellant in respect of the
proposed rear basement extension under Appeal A. The proposal under Appeal
B seeks to provide a larger basement extension which would project further
into the rear garden than is currently the case or has been approved
previously.
16. The garden at the rear of the property is relatively long and well landscaped.
Although visible from some private vantage points, the rear garden is not
readily visible from public vantage points. The basement would sit mainly
under the proposed rear extension, but would also project beyond its rear wall.
It would be covered in natural paving to provide an external terrace area.
17. Given the nature of this element of the proposed development, retaining a
largely open garden area to the rear, and positioned entirely to the rear of the
property in a part of the site which does not contribute to any substantial
degree to the significance of the locally listed building or CA, it would not have
an adverse effect on the significance of the locally listed building or the
character or appearance of the CA, which would be preserved.
18. Overall, I conclude that the proposed development would not have an adverse
effect on the significance of the locally listed building or the character or
appearance of the Victoria Park Conservation Area, which would be preserved.
The proposal is therefore in accordance with the relevant provisions of policies
HC1 of the London Plan (2021) and policies LP1, LP3 and LP4 of the Hackney
Local Development Plan (2020). These policies, when taken as a whole, seek to
ensure high quality of design in development that preserves or enhances the
character and appearance of heritage assets. This is in a similar vein to the
aims of the National Planning Policy Framework in respect of good design and
the protection of the historic environment, the SPD and the CAA.
Conditions
19. The Council has provided a list of conditions that it suggests should be applied
in the eventuality that the appeals were to be allowed. I have assessed those
with reference to the advice in the Framework and Planning Practice Guidance.
I have amended the wording of some and combined provisions of others
without altering their fundamental aims.
20. In addition to requiring commencement within the relevant statutory period, I
have imposed a condition requiring adherence to the relevant plans for
certainty. A condition (condition 3) in respect of external materials is necessary
in order to protect the character and appearance of the area.
21. Condition 4 requires the submission and approval of sustainable water
management measures. This is necessary in the interests of flood prevention
and water management. Both conditions 3 and 4 are pre-commencement
conditions as they are necessary to ensure that any potential mitigation is
properly designed into the scheme prior to the commencement of
development.
Appeal Decisions APP/U5360/D/22/3304626, APP/U5360/D/22/3304625
5
22. I have imposed a condition with regard to noise levels connected with the air
source heat pump (condition 5). This is in the interests of the living conditions
of neighbouring occupiers.
23. Given the detail and specifications set out in the plans and the provisions of
condition 2, the Council’s suggested conditions relating to pipework and
external equipment are unnecessary and have not been imposed.
Conclusion
24. For the reasons given above, and having had regard to all matters raised, I
conclude that Appeal A and Appeal B should be allowed.
A Price
INSPECTOR
Appeal Decisions APP/U5360/D/22/3304626, APP/U5360/D/22/3304625
6
SCHEDULE OF CONDITIONS
Appeal A
1) The development hereby permitted shall begin not later than 3 years
from the date of this decision.
2) The development hereby permitted shall be carried out in accordance
with the following approved plans: 0101 Rev D; 0102 Rev D; 0114 Rev
D; 0115 Rev D; 0116 Rev D; 0117 Rev D; 0118 Rev D; 0211 Rev D;
0212 Rev D; 0311 Rev D; 0312 Rev D; 0313 Rev D; 0314 Rev D; 0315
Rev D; 0316 Rev D; 0317 Rev D; 0318 Rev D; 0319 Rev D;
Arboricultural Impact Assessment.
3) No development shall take place until full details of the materials to be
used in the construction of the external surfaces, including the metal
grille to the front lightwell, roof covering materials, bricks and pier caps
to the front boundary treatment and bricks, coping stones and natural
stone for the rear extension, have been submitted to and approved in
writing by the Local Planning Authority. The development shall be
constructed in accordance with the approved details.
4) Prior to the commencement of superstructure works, a detailed
specification and a management & maintenance plan (where applicable)
of the blue roof (substrate depth of 80-150mm excluding the vegetative
mat), permeable paving, and geo-cellular attenuation tank shall be
submitted to, and approved by the Local Planning Authority, in
consultation with the Local Lead Flood Authority. It must be
demonstrated that there will be no increase in surface water flow being
discharged offsite and an overall reduction in peak flow rate and volume.
Surface water from the site shall be managed in accordance with the
proposal referenced in the Flood Risk Assessment (Ref: DMAG-2128-FRA-
002) and Drainage Technical Note (Ref: DMAG-2128-DTN-002). The
development shall be constructed in accordance with the approved
details.
5) Noise emitted from the air source heat pump equipment hereby approved
shall be -10dBA below the existing measured lowest LA90(10min)
background noise level at any time when all plant is in use. Where the
plant noise source is tonal it shall be -15dBA. The noise emitted shall be
measured or predicted at 1.0m from the façade of the nearest residential
window or at 1.2m above any adjacent residential garden, terrace,
balcony or patio. The equipment shall be serviced regularly in accordance
with the manufacturer’s instructions and as necessary to ensure that the
requirements of the condition are maintained. If at any time the plant is
unable to comply with this condition, it shall be switched off and not used
again until it is able to comply.
Appeal Decisions APP/U5360/D/22/3304626, APP/U5360/D/22/3304625
7
Appeal B
1) The development hereby permitted shall begin not later than 3 years
from the date of this decision.
2) The development hereby permitted shall be carried out in accordance
with the following approved plans: 0101 Rev C; 0102 Rev C; 0114 Rev C;
0115 Rev C; 0116 Rev C; 0117 Rev C; 0118 Rev C; 0211 Rev C; 0212
Rev C; 0311 Rev C; 0312 Rev C; 0313 Rev C; 0314 Rev C; 0315 Rev C;
0316 Rev C; 0317 Rev C; 0318 Rev C; 0319 Rev C; Arboricultural Impact
Assessment.
3) No development shall take place until full details of the materials to be
used in the construction of the external surfaces, including the metal
grille to the front lightwell, roof covering materials, bricks and pier caps
to the front boundary treatment and bricks, coping stones and natural
stone for the rear extension, have been submitted to and approved in
writing by the Local Planning Authority. The development shall be
constructed in accordance with the approved details.
4) Prior to the commencement of superstructure works, a detailed
specification and a management & maintenance plan (where applicable)
of the blue roof (substrate depth of 80-150mm excluding the vegetative
mat), permeable paving, and geo-cellular attenuation tank shall be
submitted to, and approved by the Local Planning Authority, in
consultation with the Local Lead Flood Authority. It must be
demonstrated that there will be no increase in surface water flow being
discharged offsite and an overall reduction in peak flow rate and volume.
Surface water from the site shall be managed in accordance with the
proposal referenced in the Flood Risk Assessment (Ref: DMAG-2128-FRA-
002) and Drainage Technical Note (Ref: DMAG-2128-DTN-002). The
development shall be constructed in accordance with the approved
details.
5) Noise emitted from the air source heat pump equipment hereby approved
shall be -10dBA below the existing measured lowest LA90(10min)
background noise level at any time when all plant is in use. Where the
plant noise source is tonal it shall be -15dBA. The noise emitted shall be
measured or predicted at 1.0m from the façade of the nearest residential
window or at 1.2m above any adjacent residential garden, terrace,
balcony or patio. The equipment shall be serviced regularly in accordance
with the manufacturer’s instructions and as necessary to ensure that the
requirements of the condition are maintained. If at any time the plant is
unable to comply with this condition, it shall be switched off and not used
again until it is able to comply.
£
Costs decision section
Costs Decision
Site visit made on 22 March 2023
by A Price BSc MA MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 20 April 2023
Costs application in relation to Appeal A Ref: APP/U5360/D/22/3304626
7 Meynell Road, Hackney, London E9 7AP
• The application is made under the Town and Country Planning Act 1990, sections 78,
322 and Schedule 6, and the Local Government Act 1972, section 250(5).
• The application is made by Mr Nicholas Gibson for a full award of costs against the
Council of the London Borough of Hackney.
• The appeal was against the refusal of planning permission for the construction of
enlarged lower ground floor level, and rear extensions at lower and ground floor levels ,
installation of two front-garden lightwells, new boundary treatment, along with partial
enlargement of existing rear dormer window and installation of two roof-lights in the
front roof slope. Installation of air source heat pumps within rear garden and
photovoltaic panels to flat top section of rear roof dormer and addition of three roof
lights to flat top section of rear roof dormer.
Costs application in relation to Appeal B Ref: APP/U5360/D/22/3304625
7 Meynell Road, Hackney, London E9 7AP
• The application is made under the Town and Country Planning Act 1990, sections 78,
322 and Schedule 6, and the Local Government Act 1972, section 250(5).
• The application is made by Mr Nicholas Gibson for a full award of costs against the
Council of the London Borough of Hackney.
• The development proposed is the construction of enlarged lower ground floor level, and
rear extensions at lower and ground floor levels, installation of two front-garden
lightwells, new boundary treatment, along with re-cladding of existing rear dormer
window and installation of two roof-lights in the front roof slope. Installation of air
source heat pumps within rear garden and photovoltaic panels to flat top section of rear
roof dormer and addition of three roof lights to flat top section of rear roof dormer.
Decision
1. The application for an award of costs is refused.
Reasons
2. Parties in planning appeals normally meet their own expenses. However, the
Planning Practice Guidance (PPG) advises that costs may be awarded against a
party who has behaved unreasonably and thereby caused the party applying
for costs to incur unnecessary or wasted expense in the appeal process.
3. The application for costs in this case was made by the applicant against the
Council on two grounds. Firstly, in relation to the substance of the appeal and
secondly in respect of procedural matters.
Substantive matters
4. There are several strands to the applicant’s case for an award of costs. These
are contained within the initial application for costs and the applicant’s
Appeal Decisions APP/U5360/D/22/3304625, APP/U5360/D/22/3304625
2
supplementary information provided in response to the Council’s costs rebuttal.
These include: a) preventing or delaying development which should clearly be
permitted, having regard to it being in accordance with the development plan,
national policy and any other material considerations; b) a failure to produce
evidence to substantiate each reason for refusal on appeal; c) vague,
generalised or inaccurate assertions about the proposal’s impact, which are
unsupported by any objective analysis; d) acting contrary to, or not following,
well-established case law; and e) not determining similar cases in a consistent
manner.
5. Planning law is clear that decisions should be made in accordance with the
development plan unless material considerations indicate otherwise. The
Council’s reasons for refusal are set out in the decision notice for each case.
These reasons are complete, precise, specific and relevant to the applications.
They also clearly state the policies of the development plan that the proposals,
in the view of the Council, would conflict with. This is a matter of planning
judgement. I have found that these reasons were adequately substantiated by
the Council in its officer report for each case. Moreover, officers are entitled to
take into account the advice of consultees in coming to a decision, particularly
where specialist heritage matters are concerned. I do not find that the Council
has acted unreasonably in these matters.
6. The applicant makes reference to the Council’s assertion of a purported power
to control development of the interior of a locally listed building (the appeal
property). However, this refers to pre-application advice of September 2020
and it is unclear if this refers directly to the appeal schemes before me. I have
no substantive evidence before me to conclude that the Council has acted
unreasonably in this matter.
7. From the evidence before me, it is clear that the Council have had regard to
previously approved decisions on the site. However, it is a matter of fact and
degree that the appeal proposals are different. In respect of the reference to
permissions at other sites, each site and location is different and the
circumstances that apply there, and the planning balance, are not always
directly comparable. Not least in cases where sites are located in different
streets, parts of the borough or in a different conservation area. I do not find
that the Council has acted unreasonably in this matter.
8. Whilst I appreciate that the applicant does not agree with the outcome of the
applications, and I have made my own views on the planning merits of this
case in a separate decision, I find nothing to suggest that the Council has acted
unreasonably.
Procedural matters
9. In respect of the Council’s contended failure to adhere to deadlines and co-
operate with the applicant, the applicant has set out a series of events which
took place during the course of the pre-application and planning application
stages, as well as at the start of the appeal process.
10. I sympathise with the applicant in respect of delays and dissatisfaction during
the pre-application stage, which they had diligently engaged in, and which
have clearly caused them concern. Nevertheless, I find nothing to suggest that
subsequent planning decisions were reached other than on the basis of the
merits of the proposals. Pre-application advice is given without prejudice and
Appeal Decisions APP/U5360/D/22/3304625, APP/U5360/D/22/3304625
3
cannot pre-determine the outcome of a subsequent planning application, which
must take account of all relevant factors.
11. The applicant claims that the Council failed to co-operate during the course of
the planning application and that had they been provided with the opportunity
to discuss matters, particularly the response of the heritage consultee, that a
suitable response could have been provided and the appeal avoided or reduced
in scope.
12. Whilst the applicant could reasonably expect a reply to queries during the
course of an application, I have not been made aware that emails or telephone
calls went unanswered. On the contrary, the evidence before me shows that
the Council broadly kept the applicant informed of progress and responded to
emails, albeit sometimes at short notice or in brief. I note that the senior
colleagues of the case officer were also involved in the review of proposals.
Even had the applicant formally responded to the concerns of consultees and
officers prior to determination, this is not to say that the outcome of the
application would have necessarily been different. Ultimately, I do not find that
the Council has acted unreasonably in this matter.
13. It is apparent from the applicant’s submissions that despite some frustrating
delays in documentation being provided by the Council at the appeal stage,
that the applicant has nonetheless had full opportunity to review and respond
to submissions. I have seen no evidence of the Council deliberately delaying or
concealing relevant evidence.
14. Overall, although I have reached a different judgement to the Council
regarding the acceptability of the proposal, I find that unreasonable behaviour
resulting in unnecessary or wasted expense, as described in the PPG, has not
been demonstrated.
A Price
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.