2-storey extension to the rear
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Residential Amenity
Extensions
Policy Weight
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decisions
Site visit made on 25 January 2023
by S R G Baird BA (Hons) MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date: 14 February 2023
Appeal A Ref: APP/A0665/D/22/3303909
52 Cromwell Road, Northwich, Cheshire CW8 4BN
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by V Forrest against the decision of Cheshire West and Chester
Council.
• The application Ref 21/04503/FUL, dated 5 November 2021, was refused by notice
dated 19 July 2022.
• The development proposed is a 2-storey extension to the rear.
Appeal B Ref: APP/A0665/D/22/3303910
50 Cromwell Road, Northwich, Cheshire CW8 4BN
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr M Nixon against the decision of Cheshire West and Chester
Council.
• The application Ref 21/04462/FUL, dated 3 November 2021, was refused by notice
dated 19 July 2022.
• The development proposed is a part 2-storey and part single-storey extension to the
side and rear.
Preliminary Matters
1. The application form describes the extension to No. 52 Cromwell Road
(Appeal A) as a 2-storey rear extension. However, the submitted plan shows
a part single-storey, part 2-storey rear extension and referred to as such in
the decision notice. As a more accurate description of the proposal, Appeal A
is determined based on a part single-storey, part 2-storey rear extension.
2. The Grounds of Appeal for No.52 (Appeal A) refer to the submission of a
revised plan reconfiguring the proposed bedrooms. However, no plan has
been provided and this appeal has been determined based on the plans
submitted with the application.
3. The Grounds of Appeal for No. 50 Cromwell Road (Appeal B) refer to the
appellant’s willingness to accept a condition limiting the projection of the
extension to 4m. No plan has been submitted to show the implications of the
proposed change on either the extension at No. 52 or No. 48. Appeal B has
been determined based on the submitted plan.
4. Separate planning applications for Nos. 50 and 52 were submitted, the
Council decided each application separately and separate appeals were
submitted. Despite the separate applications and appeals, the grounds of
appeal indicate that, the extensions would be implemented as a joint project.
Moreover, the plans show that the rear extensions would share a party wall
Appeal Decisions APP/A0665/D/22/3303909 & APP/A0665/D/22/3303910
2
and the rear roof planes of both extensions would extend over the common
boundary. Thus, it appears that neither extension could be built without the
other. I have considered the appeals on this basis.
Decisions
Appeal A
5. The appeal is dismissed.
Appeal B
6. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issues
Appeal A
7. These are, (a) the implications for neighbour’s living conditions with reference
to outlook, privacy and light and (b) the occupiers’ living conditions with
reference to bedroom size.
Appeal B
8. These are, (a) the implications for neighbour’s living conditions with reference
to outlook, privacy, and light and (b) the effect on the character and
appearance of the host property and the area.
Reasons
9. The development plan includes The Cheshire West and Chester Council Local
Plan Parts 1 and 2 (LP). Providing generic guidance, The House Extensions
and Domestic Outbuildings Supplementary Planning Document (SPD) is read
alongside LP policies and is a material consideration.
10. LP Part 1, Policy ENV 6 and LP Part 2, Policies DM2 and DM 3 seek high quality
design, in particular extensions that respect the scale, character and
appearance of existing buildings and are subordinate to the original dwelling
and surrounding properties. LP Part 1, Policy SOC 5 and LP Part 2, Policies
DM 2 and DM 21 seek to ensure that domestic extensions do not have a
significant adverse effect on the amenities of neighbours with reference to
outlook, privacy and on the amenity of future occupiers of the dwelling.
Appeal A
Neighbours’ Living Conditions
11. The SPD says that single-storey rear extensions projecting up to 4m from the
original rear wall will usually be supported. Here, the submitted plan shows
the depth of the extension matching that proposed for No 50 at some 5m.
The ground floor extension would conflict with the SPD guidance.
12. Two-storey rear extensions projecting up to 4m from the original rear wall of
a house will usually be supported, if the extension would not cross a 45-
degree line taken from the closest part of any rear wall of a neighbouring
house containing a habitable room window. The first-floor extension would
project some 3.6m from the original rear wall. Whilst the appellant asserts
that the 45 guidance would not breached, the approach used is inconsistent
Appeal Decisions APP/A0665/D/22/3303909 & APP/A0665/D/22/3303910
3
with the SPD. Given there is no plan showing this exercise, it cannot be said
with any certainty that the SPD guidance has been breached.
13. The proposal has been assessed on a worst case scenario that the extension
would breach the 45 guidance. Given the conclusion that neither of the
extensions could be implemented without each other, in respect of the impact
on No. 50, there would be no change in terms of light, privacy, and outlook.
14. SPD guidance is generic and recognises that each proposal must be assessed
on its own merits and circumstances. Here, No. 54 is located to the west and
as such there would be no material impact on daylight or sunlight to the rear.
Given the topography and the depth of gardens on this side of Cromwell Road,
and houses to the rear on Alderley Road, these houses enjoy a substantial
open aspect to the rear. Whilst the ground-floor extension would be closer to
the common boundary, the first-floor extension would be set back. Given, the
open aspect, the extension would have no material impact on the outlook of
No. 54. Other than bringing the furthest first-floor bedroom window from No.
54 forward by some 3.6m, there would be no material change to the degree
of overlooking of the rear garden/amenity area of No. 54.
15. Drawing the above together, notwithstanding a potential breach of the 45
guidance, the part single-storey, part 2-storey extension would not
unacceptably affect the living conditions of the occupiers of Nos. 50 and 54
through loss of outlook, privacy, daylight, and sunlight or conflict with
development plan policy.
Occupiers’ Living Conditions.
16. The Council refer to the size of the proposed bedrooms falling below those set
out in the Technical Housing Standards – Nationally Described Space
Standard, March 2017. However, the introduction to the document sets out
unequivocally, that, “The… standard for bedrooms… are relevant only in
determining compliance… in new dwellings and have no other statutory
meaning or use.” Whilst LP Part 2 Policy DM 21 refers to the resultant
development not having a significantly adverse effect on the amenities of
future occupiers, I can find no specific guidelines on room sizes in the LP or
SPD. The inclusion of the word “significantly” in the policy indicates a high
bar. Here, the resultant rooms sizes are such that what is proposed would
not result in a significant adverse effect on the occupiers’ living conditions.
Accordingly, there would be no conflict with development plan policy.
Appeal B
Living Conditions
17. Here, the ground and first-floor extension would project some 5m from the
main rear elevation. In addition, the first-floor extension, supported on brick
piers at the front and rear corners, would extend out to the side, almost up to
the common boundary with No.48. Given the conclusion that neither of the
extensions could be implemented without each other, in respect of the impact
on No. 52, the extension would not change the existing situation in terms of
light, privacy, and outlook.
18. The appellant uses an approach to the 45 guideline that is inconsistent with
the SPD. However, given the scale of the projection to the rear and side, I
Appeal Decisions APP/A0665/D/22/3303909 & APP/A0665/D/22/3303910
4
am confident that the proposal would breach the guidance in the SPD to a
material extent.
19. SPD guidance is generic and recognises that each proposal must be assessed
on its own merits and circumstances. No. 48 sits to the east of No. 50, and
notwithstanding the open aspect to the rear, there would be a material and
unacceptable reduction in the amount of daylight and sunlight received by
patio area and rear habitable rooms of No.48. Moreover, the substantial area
of blank gable wall at first-floor level projecting 5m behind the rear elevation
would appear dominant and overbearing when viewed from the rear patio and
habitable room windows of No.48. The unacceptable loss of light and outlook
would make No. 48 a materially less pleasant place to live. As such there
would be conflict with the development plan.
Character and Appearance
20. The SPD indicates that side extensions have the potential to unbalance the
symmetry of groups of existing buildings. Side extensions of similar height to
the existing dwelling are supported where they are subordinate to the main
building, set back at least 1m from the main part of the front wall and at least
1m from the side boundary and properly integrated into the main roof of the
dwelling. Whilst the side extension would be close to the common boundary,
the setback from the front main wall would be substantial. Thus, whilst the
proposal would be glimpsed from Cromwell Road, the substantial setback
would ensure that there was no unacceptable impact on the street scene.
Whilst the extension to No. 50 would be larger that proposed at No. 52, given
the proposed lower ridge line, the use of a hipped gable and the extensive
open aspect to the rear would ensure that the extension would appear
subordinate not overwhelm the character of these houses. Accordingly, there
would be no conflict with the relevant policies of the development plan.
Conclusions
21. Notwithstanding my favourable conclusions in relation to Appeal A and the
impact of the side extension to No. 50, given the respective extensions are
proposed as a joint project and the conclusion that neither could be
constructed in isolation, the unacceptable effect the extension to No. 50 would
have on the living conditions of the occupiers of No. 48 means that both
appeals must fail. Accordingly, given the conflict with the development plan
and having considered all other matters, these appeals are dismissed.
George Baird
Inspector
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.