Part two storey and part single storey extensions to rear and new entrance door to side elevation
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Extensions
Residential Amenity
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 26 October 2022
by D Hartley BA (Hons) MTP MBA MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 31 October 2022
Appeal Ref: APP/W0734/D/22/3303819
10 Kilvington Grove, Middlesbrough TS7 0RL
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr & Mrs Ross & Lara Murdoch against the decision of
Middlesbrough Borough Council.
• The application Ref 22/0269/FUL, dated 18 April 2022, was refused by notice dated
21 June 2022.
• The development proposed is part two storey and part single storey extensions to rear
and new entrance door to side elevation.
Decision
1. The appeal is allowed and planning permission is granted for part two storey
and part single storey extensions to rear and new entrance door to side
elevation at 10 Kilvington Grove, Middlesbrough, TS7 0RL, in accordance with
the terms of the application Ref 22/0269/FUL, dated 18 April 2022, subject to
the following conditions:
i)The development hereby permitted shall begin not later than three years from
the date of this decision.
ii)The development hereby permitted shall be carried out in accordance with
the following approved plans: 1.500 block plan, 1:1250 red edged site location
plan, drawing 01 Revision B (Existing and Proposed Plans and Elevations) and
drawing 02 Revision B (Proposed Plans).
iii)The materials to be used in the construction of the external surfaces of the
development hereby permitted shall match those used in the existing building.
Application for costs
2. An application for costs was made by Mr & Mrs Ross and Lara Murdoch against
Middlesbrough Borough Council. This application is the subject of a separate
Decision.
Main Issues
3. The main issues are (i) the effect of the proposal on the character and
appearance of the area and (ii) the living conditions of the occupiers of No 11
Kilvington Grove in respect of outlook and daylight.
Appeal Decision APP/W0734/D/22/3303819
2
Reasons
Character and appearance
4. The appeal property is detached and falls within a modern housing estate
where there is a mixture of dwelling designs. Each dwelling has a steeply
sloping gabled roof and there is consistency in terms of the use of roofing and
walling materials. The dwellings generally include small front garden spaces
and more spacious rear gardens some of which include detached garages
staggered back from the position of the rear elevations of the host dwellings.
In the main, the dwellings do not follow a straight building line. The building
line of the properties is more haphazard providing some design interest to the
street-scene along with the varied house designs.
5. The proposed door to the ground floor side elevation of the dwelling would be
acceptable in design terms and would not cause any material harm to the living
conditions of the occupiers of neighbouring properties.
6. Part of the rear extension would be single storey and part would be two storey.
I acknowledge that the proposal would represent a sizeable increase in the
overall size of the detached dwelling. Nevertheless, the proposed roof of the
two storey rear extension would be gabled and set well below that of the main
roof. Furthermore, the single storey element of the proposal would have the
effect of reducing the scale and bulk of the extension as a whole. In addition,
the proposal would ensure that a sizeable rear garden space was retained for
occupiers of the host property. Given the position of the existing dwelling
relative to others, the proposal would not bring the property materially closer
to Dixon Bank than existing surrounding development. Consequently, I do not
consider that the proposal would have an adverse effect on the pattern or
character of development in the locality.
7. The proposed materials would reflect those used on the original house. While
there is no doubt that the proposal would change the appearance of the rear of
the house, I am satisfied that it would be in proportion and scale with it and
would not therefore appear as a dominant or incongruous addition.
8. It is of note that that Council has approved a very similar development
proposal at No 43 Kilvington Grove1 (KG) and there has been no material
change in local or national policy since this decision was made. The Council has
not provided any reasonable evidence to indicate why it made a decision to
refuse the appeal proposal in the context of the aforementioned decision. To
this extent, I have some concern about consistency in the decision making
process. I was able to see as part of my site visit that owing to intervening
buildings and boundary landscaping the proposed development would not
actually be as conspicuous in public views when compared to the approved
development at No 43 KG.
9. The Council has made reference to the Middlesbrough’s Urban Design SPD
2013 (SPD) which states that a two storey extension should be ‘restricted to no
more than 3.0 metres in length set in off the common boundary by 2.5
metres’. The SPD also states that single storey extensions in excess of a 3.0
metre projection should be inset from the boundary to a sufficient distance
dependant on orientation, roof type and the distance of the neighbouring
1 Planning permission Ref 18/0473/FUL
Appeal Decision APP/W0734/D/22/3303819
3
principal windows. I deal with the effect of the proposal on the living conditions
of neighbouring properties below but it is of note that the SPD does not
actually prohibit single storey extensions in excess of 3.0 metres.
10. In respect of this main issue, I do acknowledge that that at five metres the
proposed two storey rear extension would conflict with the SPD. However, and
despite this technical conflict, I have found that no harm would be caused by
the proposal from a design point of view. In this case, I find that there is
justification for allowing an extension that exceeds 3.0 metres in depth.
11. For the reasons outlined above, I conclude that the proposal would be
acceptable in terms of design and that no material harm would be caused to
the character and appearance of the area. Consequently, the development
would be in accordance with the design, character and appearance
requirements of policies DC1 and CS5 of the Middlesbrough Core Strategy 2008
(CS).
Living conditions
12. The rear of the appeal dwelling is positioned behind the rear elevation of No 11
KG. While the proposed rear extension would project marginally beyond the
rear elevation of No 11 KG, the two storey element would be positioned well
away from the boundary with this neighbouring property.
13. While the single storey part of the rear extension would be close to the
boundary with No 11 KG, there would be no material loss of outlook to the
occupiers of this property as windows on this side elevation are non-habitable
and fitted with opaque glass. Given this arrangement, coupled with the
staggered relationship of the neighbouring properties and position of principal
windows, I find that there is justification for allowing the proposed five metre
projecting single storey rear extension to be built close to the party boundary.
In this regard, I do not find conflict with paragraph 5.6 (b) of the SPD.
14. The single and two storey rear extension would only be noticeable from rear
elevation windows of No 11 KG at an oblique angle. The two storey element of
the development would be positioned away from the boundary. Overall, I do
not find that the development would have a dominating or enclosing impact. In
this respect, I do not find conflict with paragraph 5.4 (l) of the SPD in so far
that the extent and presence of brickwork from the proposed rear extension
would not result in an overbearing impact when seen from primary room
windows.
15. The rear extension would be noticeable from parts of the rear garden area of
No 11 KG, but not to the extent that it would have a detrimental impact on the
outlook enjoyed from this relatively large neighbouring garden. Owing to the
separation distance of the rear extension from No 9 KG, and the intervening
detached garage, I am also satisfied that the rear extension would not cause
harm to the outlook enjoyed by the occupiers of this neighbouring property in
respect of rear elevation windows. The rear extension would be visible from
parts of the rear garden of this property, but not to the extent that it would be
enclosing.
16. The Council object to the proposal on the basis of loss of daylight to No 11 KG.
While part of the rear extension would be close to the boundary with No 11 KG,
this would be single storey in height. While there are opaque glass windows to
Appeal Decision APP/W0734/D/22/3303819
4
the side elevation of this neighbouring property, the evidence from the occupier
of this property is that they serve non-habitable rooms, i.e. bathroom, ensuite,
and utility. Given that the two storey part of the extension would be set a
sufficient distance away from the boundary of the appeal property with No 11
KG, I find that there would not be a material loss of daylight penetration to
existing windows. In any event, the evidence is that these windows serve non-
habitable rooms. Furthermore, owing to the position and scale of the proposed
development, I equally find that there would be no significant loss of light to
the rear elevation windows or garden areas of Nos 9 or 11 KG.
17. While the proposal does conflict with the SPD in so far that the proposed rear
extension would project more than 3 metres from the rear elevation of the
existing dwelling, and the two storey part of the extension would not quite be
positioned at 2.5 metres from the neighbouring boundary with No 11 KG, for
the above reasons I conclude that in this case no unacceptable harm would be
caused to the occupiers of neighbouring properties in respect of outlook,
daylight or in respect of any other living conditions. In reaching this view, I
have also taken into account the supportive comments made by the occupier of
No 11 KG. In respect of this main issue, I therefore find that the proposal
would not conflict with the amenity requirements of policies DC1 and CS5 of
the CS.
Conditions
18. Planning permission is granted subject to the standard three year time limit
condition. It is necessary that the development shall be carried out in
accordance with the approved plans, for the avoidance of doubt and in the
interests of certainty. I have therefore imposed a condition to this effect. In
order to ensure that the extension is acceptable in design terms, it is necessary
to also impose a materials condition.
Conclusion
19. While there would be some minor conflict with the SPD, I have concluded that
no harm would be caused to the character and appearance of the area or to the
living conditions of the occupiers of neighbouring dwellings. Consequently, the
appeal should be allowed.
D Hartley
INSPECTOR
£
Costs decision section
Costs Decision
Site visit made on 26 October 2022
by D Hartley BA (Hons) MTP MBA MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 31 October 2022
Costs application in relation to Appeal Ref: APP/W0734/D/22/3303819
10 Kilvington Grove, Middlesbrough TS7 0RL
• The application is made under the Town and Country Planning Act 1990, sections 78,
322 and Schedule 6, and the Local Government Act 1972, section 250(5).
• The application is made by Mr & Mrs Ross and Lara Murdoch for a full award of costs
against Middlesbrough Borough Council.
• The appeal was against the refusal of planning permission for part two storey and part
single storey extension to rear and a new entrance door to side elevation.
Decision
1. The application for an award of costs is allowed in the terms set out below.
Reasons
2. The Planning Practice Guidance (PPG) advises that, irrespective of the outcome
of the appeal, costs may only be awarded against a party who has behaved
unreasonably, and thereby caused the party applying for costs to incur
unnecessary expense in the appeal process.
3. The PPG states that Local Planning Authorities (LPA) are at risk of an award of
costs where there is a ‘failure to produce evidence to substantiate each reason
for refusal on appeal’ or where there are ‘vague, generalised or inaccurate
assertions about a proposal’s impact, which are unsupported by any objective
analysis’ or ‘not determining similar cases in a consistent manner’.
4. The evidence is that the LPA case officer did not visit the site and that reliance
was instead placed on photographs. The case officer report refers to the
proposed extension’s relationship with the rear of No 11 Kilvington Grove as
being an ‘excessive extent of overlap’. While this is a matter that requires some
subjective planning judgment, I am not satisfied that the Council’s concerns
about harm to the living conditions of the occupiers of this property have been
reasonably substantiated. Indeed, the case officer report does not provide
adequate reasoning about the existing orientation and relationship between the
two properties, or in fact the evidence from the neighbouring occupier about
windows on the side elevation being opaque and serving non-habitable room
space. Furthermore, from a design point of view I do consider that the LPA has
reasonably taken into account site specific circumstances as part of its
assessment of the planning application.
5. Given the above, I do not find that the Council has reasonably substantiated its
view that actual harm would be caused to the character and appearance of the
area or to the living conditions of the occupiers of neighbouring properties. In
reaching this view, I have also taken into account that there are a number of
Costs Decision APP/W0734/D/22/3303819
2
vague and inaccurate assertions in the case officer report about the proposal’s
impact. For example, it says that the neighbouring gable projection benefits
from being ‘stepped away from the boundary, which overlaps’. This is not the
case and in fact it is very close to the shared boundary. I am concerned that
the stated absence of a site visit by the LPA may have led to this error.
6. The case officer report also states that ‘the impacts of the development could
be overbearing’ and ‘the proposal will result is a loss of daylight although it is
considered that this aspect would not be so significant as to warrant refusal of
the application in its own right, however it does add to the weight against the
proposal’. Given the use of the word ‘could’ it is not clear if the Council
considered that actual harm would be caused. This demonstrates weak
reasoning and, in any event, there is an absence of detail from the LPA in
terms of specifically why and how harm would be caused. While the LPA assert
that there would be a loss of daylight, this is not actually supported by any
reasonably detailed reasoning or evidence. Furthermore, I am not persuaded
that the Council reasonably took into account the supportive comments made
by the occupier of No 11 Kilvington Grove as part of the overall planning
balance.
7. In addition to the above, I do not consider that the LPA reasonably took into
account other decisions that have been made for similar development in the
immediate locality, including a two storey rear extension at No 43 Kilvington
Grove. In allowing a similar extension at this property, also in conflict with size
restrictions expressed in Middlesbrough’s Urban Design SPD 2013, the LPA
outweighed such conflict on the basis of no actual harm being caused to the
character and appearance of the area or the living conditions of the occupiers
of neighbouring properties.
8. While I accept that each planning application should be determined on its own
planning merits, in this case I find that the failure to differentiate between the
planning permission at No 43 Kilvington Grove and the appeal proposal
amounted to unreasonable behaviour. I have found that the appeal
development would also not cause harm in respect of these matters. I find that
it is a reasonable expectation of any applicant that LPA decision making is
consistent. The LPA did not provide acceptable reasoning to indicate why
planning permission was refused for development which was very similar to
that approved for a dwelling nearby. This is particularly important in the
context that there has been no change to development plan policies or to the
SPD for the area.
Conclusion
9. For the above reasons, I conclude that unreasonable behaviour resulting in
unnecessary or wasted expense, as described in the PPG, has been
demonstrated. Therefore, the application for a full award of costs is allowed.
Costs Order
10. In exercise of the powers under section 250(5) of the Local Government Act
1972 and Schedule 6 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 as amended,
and all other enabling powers in that behalf, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED that
Middlesbrough Borough Council shall pay to Mr & Mrs Ross and Lara Murdoch
the costs of the appeal proceedings described in the heading of this decision;
such costs to be assessed in the Senior Courts Costs Centre if not agreed.
Costs Decision APP/W0734/D/22/3303819
3
11. The applicant is now invited to submit to Middlesbrough Borough Council, to
whom a copy of this decision has been sent, details of those costs with a view
to reaching agreement as to the amount.
D Hartley
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.