Appeal Against Conditions
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Heritage & Conservation
Character & Appearance
Extensions
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 5 December 2022
by Eleni Randle BSc (hons) MSc FRICS FAAV MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 4th January 2023
Appeal Ref: APP/L5810/D/22/3303873
244 St Margarets Road, Richmond Upon Thames, Twickenham, TW1 1NL
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission under section 73 of the Town and
Country Planning Act 1990 for the development of land without complying with
conditions subject to which a previous planning permission was granted.
• The appeal is made by Mr and Mrs James and Rachel Luke against the decision of the
London Borough of Richmond Upon Thames Council.
• The application sought planning permission for loft conversion consisting of a rear
dormer and one rooflight to the side. Loft space to include a bedroom and en-suite
bathroom without complying with condition 2 attached to planning permission Ref
APP/L5810/D/21/3276033 (21/0230/HOT allowed on appeal), dated 15 September
2021.
• The condition in dispute is No 2 which states that: The development hereby permitted
shall be carried out in accordance with the following approved plans:
1579.01.03.Exg.001; 1579.01.03.Exg.002; 1579.01.03.Exg.022; 1579.01.03.Exg.023;
1579.01.03.Exg.024; 1579.01.03.Exg.060; 1579.01.03.Exg.061; 1579.01.03.Exg.062;
1579.01.03.Exg.063; 1579.03.03.Pln.023A; 1579.03.03.Pln.024B;
1579.03.03.Pln.060B; 1579.03.03.Pln.061B; 1579.03.03.Pln.062B; 1579.03.03.Pln.063
• The reason given for the condition is: for the avoidance of doubt and in the interests of
proper planning.
Decision
1. The appeal is allowed and planning permission is granted for loft conversion
consisting of a rear dormer and one rooflight to the side. Loft space to include
a bedroom and en-suite bathroom at 244 St Margarets Road, Richmond Upon
Thames, Twickenham, TW1 1NL in accordance with the application Ref
21/0230/HOT dated 25 January 2021, without compliance with condition
number 2 previously imposed on planning permission Ref 21/0230/HOT
(allowed at appeal - APP/L5810/D/21/3276033) dated 15 September 2021 and
subject to the following conditions:
1) The development to which this permission relates must be begun not later
than the expiration of three years beginning with the date of planning
permission 21/0230/HOT allowed at appeal;
2) The development hereby permitted shall be carried out in accordance with
the following approved plans and documents, where applicable: Location
Plan 1579.01.03.Exg.001; Proposed East Elevation 1579.03.03.Pln.062.C C;
Proposed First Floor Plan 1579.03.03.Pln.023.B; Proposed Loft Plan
1579.03.03.Pln.024.C; Proposed North Elevation 1579.03.03.Pln.063.A A;
Proposed South Elevation 1579.03.03.Pln.061.C C and Proposed West
Elevation 1579.03.03.Pln.060.C C;
Appeal Decision APP/L5810/D/22/3303873
2
3) The materials to be used in the construction of the external surfaces of the
development hereby permitted shall match those used in the existing
building.
Main Issue
2. The main issue is the impact of the increase in size of the side rooflight upon
the character and appearance of the host property and the St Margarets
Conservation Area.
Reasons
3. The appeal site is a semi-detached dwelling on the east side of St Margarets
Road within a predominantly residential area which is located within the St
Margarets Conservation Area (CA). The existing permission allowed a rooflight
in the same location as that before me within this proposed variation of
condition so, looking at the plans before me, I do not find that siting,
fenestration or lack of set back can be validly used to refuse the proposal in
this case. It falls to consider the impact of the variation, i.e. the increase in
size and scale with regard to the host property and CA as is the main issue.
4. Section 72 of the Planning (Listed buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990
requires that special attention shall be paid to the desirability of preserving or
enhancing the character or appearance of the CA. In this context preserving
can also be taken to mean doing no harm. In accordance with paragraph 199
of the National Planning Policy Framework 2021 when considering the impact of
the proposed development on the significance of a designated heritage asset,
great weight should be given to the assets conservation.
5. There is some inconsistency between the sizes stated in writing by the
appellant and the Council, however, it is clear from the submitted drawings
that the proposed rooflight would be increased in height and width with the
depth to remain the same as that which has already been approved. The
materials would also remain the same as that already approved. I do not find
that the proposed increase would result in a large and bulky addition to the
roofscape. The South elevation plans, and the comparative images in the
appellant’s statement, evidently show an enlarged rooflight but I do not find
the difference between the already approved and the revised proposals to
result in the proposal not being subordinate to the host property. The revision
is, I find, appropriate for both the character and appearance of the appeal site.
6. The Council have stated that the larger rooflight would materially harm the
pattern of development along St Margarets Road but provide limited evidence
of assessment as to support this point. Despite this, at the time of my site visit
I noted that there are a variety of rooflights and dormers within the local and
wider street scene, including in the group of properties within which the appeal
property is situated. Rooflights and dormers are, therefore, characteristic
within the immediate area. The proposal would not be uncharacteristic as a
result of the general variety noted at the time of my site visit and as also noted
by a previous Inspector visiting the site.
7. The proposed rooflight would not affect the sense of spaciousness around the
property and its relationship with the neighbouring property. As a result of the
rooflight siting it would not be readily visible in relation to the semi-detached
pair in terms of any impact upon the symmetry between them, generally
Appeal Decision APP/L5810/D/22/3303873
3
viewed from the street scene, nor would be it unduly prominent as a result of
generally limited views within the wider street scene. I find this is well
demonstrated by the illustrative drawings within the appellant’s statement and
consequently, I do not find that the proposal would impact upon the
appearance of the CA. The proposal would have little consequence or harmful
impact and would, on the basis of doing no harm, preserve the character and
appearance of the CA.
8. Varying the plan condition, to allow the proposed changes, would not materially
alter the development for which permission was originally granted. The
proposal would be consistent with London Borough of Richmond Upon Thames
Local Plan 2018 (LP) Policy LP1 which seeks to maintain high-quality character
and heritage and demonstrate understanding of the site and how it relates to
its existing site context, including character and appearance. The proposal
would also be consistent with LP Policy LP3 which seeks to avoid harm to
designated heritage assets and secure appropriate materials.
9. The Council’s refusal reason references the Supplementary Planning Document
House Extensions and External Alterations 2015 (SPD) and this document is
listed by the Council as of relevance in section 5. Despite this there is no
evidence of the proposal having been assessed against this document as part
of the decision made. A copy of the SPD has been submitted with this appeal
which I have reviewed and I consider the proposal is consistent with the
overarching objective which is to secure appropriate design as a result of
external alterations to dwellings.
Conditions
10. As an appeal under S78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990, S73 can
be used to make minor material amendments if there is a condition on the
original permission which lists the approved plans which can be varied. Given I
am allowing this appeal, this essentially grants a new permission for the
development subject to the modified condition. For this reason it is necessary
to restate all the conditions to which the new permission will be subject and
this is reflected in the Council’s suggested conditions, without prejudice, in the
event the appeal is allowed.
11. I am satisfied that the conditions meet the necessary tests within the
Framework and I have re-applied all of the conditions of the original
permission. A time condition is attached to comply with section 51 of the
Planning and Compulsory Purchase Act 2004 to coincide with the date of the
previous approval. A condition requiring the development to be in accordance
with the approved plans is required to control and define the development
which is granted consent. I have, however, amended the approved plan list to
include those which are proposed only and omitted those which are existing
albeit it I acknowledge these were updated to reflect a measured survey
information. The proposal is, evidently, only required to comply with the
proposed plans as a result of any permission granted and implemented. A
materials condition is required to ensure an appropriate finish.
12. The Council have suggested a condition regarding obscure glazing and being
non-opening (unless more than 1.7m above floor level). This condition was not
applied to the scheme previously approved and the Council have provided no
justification for this condition in their discussion as to neighbouring amenity
(which is the reason given in the conditions list) in the submitted delegated
Appeal Decision APP/L5810/D/22/3303873
4
report. In addition the drawings show the rooflight over a staircase with the
whole rationale behind the variation being to allow for head height over the
staircase itself as circulation space. Based upon the evidence before me I do
not find that a condition regarding obscure glazing or restrictions would meet
the tests within the Framework and I have not applied this condition for these
reasons.
13. The Council have outlined a recommended condition relating to a Fire Safety
Strategy stated to be in accordance with (an unspecified version of the London
Plan) Policy D12, however, I have no copy of this policy before me with section
5 of the Council’s report still referencing the 2016 London Plan and not the
replacement Plan published in 2021. On this occasion I have insufficient
information before me to justify the application of this condition, against a
relevant policy requirement, to the newly granted permission as a result of this
appeal.
Conclusion
14. For the reasons outlined above, and taking account all other matters raised, I
conclude that the appeal should be allowed subject to conditions.
Eleni Randle
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.