Construction of a single- and 1.5-storey front extension
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Character & Appearance
Residential Amenity
Rural Impact
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 15 September 2022
by J D Westbrook BSc(Hons) MSc MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 17th October 2022
Appeal Ref: APP/C3105/D/22/3302659
2 Dewars Farm Cottages, Ardley Road, Middleton Stoney, BICESTER,
OX25 4AE
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr Owain Morton against the decision of Cherwell District
Council.
• The application Ref 22/00642/F, dated 2 March 2022, was refused by notice dated
27 April 2022.
• The development proposed is the construction of a single- and 1.5-storey front
extension.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issues
2. The main issues in this case are the effects of the proposed extension on:
• The character and appearance of the area around Ardley Road to the north
of Middleton Stoney, and
• The living conditions of the occupiers of No 1 Dewars Farm Cottages by way
of light and outlook.
Reasons
3. Nos 1 and 2 Dewars Farm Cottages are a pair of semi-detached houses
situated in open countryside on the eastern side of Ardley Road, some 400
metres north of the village of Middleton Stoney. They are stone-built houses,
set around 6 metres back from the front boundary. Each has a pitched roof
with gable end, and each includes a gable front elevation of similar appearance
and dimensions. No 2 also has a projecting front porch with a north-facing
front door, a small first-floor front dormer, and a large two-storey rear
extension. No 1 has only a small front porch and no two-storey rear extension.
The plots are relatively shallow, but have wide side gardens.
4. Policy ESD 15 of the Cherwell Local Plan (LP) indicates that new development
will be expected to complement and enhance the character of its context
through sensitive siting, layout and high quality design. Policy C28 of the
Cherwell District Plan (DP) indicates that control will be exercised over all new
development, including extensions, to ensure that the standards of layout,
Appeal Decision APP/C3105/D/22/3302659
2
design and external appearance, including the choice of external-finish
materials, are sympathetic to the character of the context of that development.
Policy C30 of the DP indicates that design control will be exercised to ensure
that any proposal to extend an existing dwelling is compatible with the scale of
the existing dwelling, its curtilage and the character of the street scene.
Development should also provide acceptable standards of amenity and privacy.
5. Chapter 5 of the Home Extensions & Alterations Design Guide (DG) advises
that extensions to the front of houses can disrupt the pattern of the buildings in
a street and obscure the original elevation, so they are generally discouraged.
Small and suitably designed porches at the front may be acceptable while, as a
general rule, flat roofed extensions are discouraged unless they are well
designed and are appropriate in the context of the existing building and the
wider area.
6. The Council contends that the proposed extension, by virtue of its size, design
and positioning would result in an overly prominent feature that detracts from
the character and appearance of the existing dwelling, the pair of dwellings of
which it forms a part, and the wider street scene. It would fail to complement
and enhance the character and appearance of its context and would result in
significant harm to the visual amenities of the area. Further, the 1.5-storey
extension, by virtue of its size and positioning, would result in significant harm
to the living amenities of the occupiers of the adjoining No 1 Dewars Farm
Cottages through an overbearing appearance, loss of daylight and outlook.
7. The appellant contends that the appeal property is in a relatively isolated
position with strong front boundary planting and a lack of any pedestrian
pavement, and is not, therefore, readily visible in the street scene. Moreover,
the proposed extension has, been designed in a sympathetic, proportionate and
vernacular manner to the features of the existing property and its neighbour.
Nos 1 and 2 Dewars Farm Cottages are not a matching pair in design
appearance terms and may be considered an unbalanced and asymmetrical
pair of properties. Finally, the appellant contends that the window in the
ground-floor front elevation of the neighbouring property serves only as a
secondary window to a kitchen, and that the proposed extension at No 2 would
not, therefore, have any significant impact on the light received by that room.
Character and appearance
8. The proposed 1.5-storey front extension would project some 5.4 metres
beyond the existing main front elevation of the appeal property. This would
result in it extending virtually to the front boundary of the property. The front
boundary is currently marked by both a 2 metre high fence and a tall mature
hedge fronting the road. The road has no pavement at this point and the
hedge abuts the roadway itself. In addition to the 1.5-storey element, there
would be a single-storey enlarged hall and utility room area, with a crown roof.
9. The appellant contends that the strong front boundary planting and lack of any
pavement, would mean that the extension would not be readily visible in the
streetscene. However, the front elevation of the extension would be in very
close proximity to the boundary hedge, and would have windows in the front
elevation. As a result, I have significant concerns that the extension could
adversely impact the health of the hedge and, in addition, I consider that there
would, in any case, be a strong possibility that the boundary fence and hedge
would, in the future, be significantly reduced in height or removed to allow light
Appeal Decision APP/C3105/D/22/3302659
3
into the downstairs habitable room and the first-floor bedroom/ensuite
proposed. This would bring the extension into very close proximity to the edge
of the carriageway and make it highly prominent in the street scene. On this
basis, it would become an uncharacteristic and dominant feature, harmful to
the context of its surroundings and the appearance of this otherwise open area
of countryside.
10. The main front elevations of Nos 1 and 2 follow a largely consistent building
line and the properties appear from the front as a combined unit, each with a
similar scale and design. The proposed front extension would obscure the
current front elevation and would appear as out of scale and character with the
rest of the host property and the pair of houses of which it is a part. In
addition, the crown roof of the single-storey part of the extension, with its
combined hipped and flat-roofed elements, would not match the roof profiles of
the rest of the house and would appear as an unsympathetic, somewhat
confused, feature.
11. In conclusion on this issue, I find that the design and external appearance of
the proposed front single- and 1.5-storey extension would not be sympathetic
to the context or appearance of the pair of dwellings, and would not be
compatible with the scale of the existing dwelling and the character of the
street scene. On this basis, it would be harmful to the character and
appearance of the area along Ardley Road and the wider area of open
countryside to the north of Middleton Stoney. It would conflict with Policy
ESD15 of the LP, Policies C28 and C30 of the DP, and with guidance on front
extensions in the DG.
Living conditions
12. The proposed extension would project some 5.4 metres beyond the existing
front elevation of the house at a point a little over 0.5 metres from the
common boundary with No 1. There is a kitchen window in the front elevation
of No 1, but any view of the proposed 1.5-storey extension would be largely
obscured by the porch at No 1, which leads off the kitchen. In addition, the
proposed extension would be to the north of No 1, and I do not consider that it
would have any significant harmful impact on the light received by the front
kitchen window at No 1.
13. The proposed extension would be a dominant and somewhat oppressive feature
when viewed from the front garden of No 1, but I do not consider that, on its
own, this limited harm would be sufficient to dismiss this appeal. In
conclusion, therefore, on this issue, I find that the proposed extension would
not be significantly harmful to the living conditions of the occupiers of No 1 and
would not conflict with the Policies in the LP and DP referred to above.
Conclusion
14. The proposed extension would have only very limited harm to the living
conditions of the occupiers of No 1, but it would be significantly harmful to the
character and appearance of the area along Ardley Road and the surrounding
countryside. In view of the combined harm, I dismiss the appeal.
J D Westbrook
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.