Formation of a garage with office and storage above
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Residential Amenity
Character & Appearance
Extensions
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 4 October 2022
by Paul Martinson BA (Hons) MSc MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 27 October 2022
Appeal Ref: APP/A4710/D/22/3302115
194 Hebble Lane, Wheatley, Halifax HX3 5JN
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr Izaac Beaumont against the decision of Calderdale
Metropolitan Borough Council.
• The application Ref 21/00331/FUL, dated 14 April 2021, was refused by notice dated
30 May 2022.
• The development proposed is described as: ‘the formation of a garage with office and
storage above’.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Applications for costs
2. An application for costs was made by Mr Izaac Beaumont against the decision
of Calderdale Metropolitan Borough Council. That is the subject of a separate
decision.
Preliminary Matters
3. I have used the description from the application form, in doing so I have
removed words that are not acts of development.
4. Planning permission1 for the demolition of garages and change of use of land to
facilitate annexe building ancillary to dwelling has been previously granted at
the appeal site. This has not been constructed, although the Council has
indicated that the permission may be extant. This would occupy a similar
footprint to the appeal proposal.
Main Issues
5. The main issues are the effect of the proposed development on the character
and appearance of the area, and the effect of the proposed development on the
living conditions of the occupiers of the neighbouring properties.
Reasons
Character and Appearance
6. The appeal site is located along a back lane that serves the rear of a terrace of
houses located on the north side of Hebble Lane. The terrace occupies a
prominent and elevated position within the streetscene and sits alongside a
1 Ref 18/01407/FUL.
Appeal Decision APP/A4710/D/22/3302115
2
pair of semi detached dwellings. The more modern housing development of
Heatherdale Close, located on rising land to the rear of the terrace, is visible
through the gap between the end of terrace dwelling, 194 Hebble Lane, and the
semi-detached dwelling 196 Hebble Lane.
7. The appeal site is located on the opposite side of the back lane to the rear yard
of No 194. The land rises steeply at the back of the site and a retaining wall
has been constructed forming the boundary with Heatherdale Close. The land
sits amongst similar plots of land to the rear of neighbouring residential
properties located on the opposite side of the back lane running to the rear of
the terrace. There are a number of different garage buildings that have been
constructed within these plots with access off the back lane. Although these
vary in appearance and materials to an extent, there is nonetheless a degree of
consistency between them.
8. These buildings tend to have a linear form, being noticeably longer than they
are wide. Furthermore, they typically have a low roof height, whilst they are
mostly constructed of either timber or concrete blocks. Whilst some are
positioned further back into the site to allow parking to the front, they
nonetheless tend to be set substantially forward of the rear boundaries,
typically with enclosed garden areas to the rear. The scale and form of the
garages and their position within the plots contribute to a coherent pattern of
development with a distinct residential character that is readily observable
along this part of the back lane.
9. The proposed garage would be large and occupy much of the depth and width
of the appeal site. It would present a gable to the back lane which would be
considerably taller than any other garage building here. It would also have a
vastly greater bulk than its neighbours on the terrace which would be
exacerbated by the provision of a dormer window to the side of the roof. As
such, the building would become a prominent and incongruous addition to the
streetscene that would be at odds with the prevailing character. Moreover, it
would be highly discordant in views from Hebble Lane in the gap between No
194 and No 196 where the bulk and height of the gable would be highly
evident. Furthermore, due to its scale and large dormer window, it would have
the appearance of a small dwelling, rather than a garage, in these views, at
odds with the prevailing pattern of development.
10. For the above reasons I therefore conclude that the proposed development
would have a harmful effect on the character and appearance of the area. The
proposal would therefore conflict with Policy BE1 of the Calderdale Unitary
Development Plan (2006) (the UDP) which, amongst other things, seeks high
standards of design for new development that respects the established
character and appearance.
Living Conditions
11. The rear yards of the terrace are set down from the level of the back lane and
accessed from here via a short flight of steps. At present No 194 and No 192
nevertheless currently enjoy reasonable levels of outlook due to looking out
onto the open appeal site and low level garage buildings.
12. However, the proposed construction of a substantial building with significant
massing a short distance away from the rear yard is likely to significantly
reduce the outlook from the rear yards of No 194 and, to a lesser extent No
Appeal Decision APP/A4710/D/22/3302115
3
192. The large gable and dormer window is likely to appear oppressive in views
from these areas and would adversely affect the living conditions of the
occupiers of No 194 and No 192.
13. The boundary between the appeal site and No 196 comprises a blockwork wall
with a fence to the top. The fence and wall increase in height towards the back
of the site and form a boundary structure of considerable height. This has the
effect of reducing light levels in the garden of No 196 and limiting the outlook
towards the appeal site.
14. The existing fence would obscure much of the side elevation of the proposed
garage although the roof would be easily seen from the garden and rear
windows of that property. Nonetheless, the building would be set away from
the boundary slightly and the roof would slope away from No 196.
Consequently, I am satisfied that the proposal would not significantly reduce
levels of outlook from No 196 to the extent that this would adversely affect the
living conditions of the occupiers of that property. For the same reasons I am
satisfied that the proposal would not significantly reduce the light levels to that
property or cause significant overshadowing.
15. Nevertheless, having regard to my above reasoning the proposed development
would adversely affect the living conditions of the occupiers of No 194 and No
192. The proposal would therefore conflict with Policy BE1 of the UDP which,
amongst other things, seeks to preserve the living conditions of residents and
other occupants. As I have found that the proposal would not significantly
reduce light levels to No 196, I have not found conflict with UDP Policy BE2.
Other Matters
16. Whilst I have taken into account the 2018 permission, it is not clear if this is
extant or not, given the Council’s comments referred to in the preliminary
matters above. In the absence of a lawful development certificate or any
confirmation from the appellant in this regard, I cannot therefore be certain
that this represents a realistic fallback option for the appellant. Nevertheless,
even if that permission were extant, this did not include a dormer window and
was orientated so that the gable was not prominent from Hebble Lane or the
dwellings opposite. As such, were the previous approval implemented, it would
be less harmful than the scheme before me both in terms of the effect on
character and appearance and the living conditions of No 194 and No 192.
Conclusion
17. For the reasons given above, having considered the development plan as a
whole, along with all other relevant material considerations, I conclude that the
appeal should be dismissed.
Paul Martinson
INSPECTOR
£
Costs decision section
Costs Decision
Site visit made on 4 October 2022
by Paul Martinson BA (Hons) MSc MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 27 October 2022
Costs application in relation to Appeal Ref: APP/A4710/D/22/3302115
194 Hebble Lane, Wheatley, Halifax HX3 5JN
• The application is made under the Town and Country Planning Act 1990, sections 78,
322 and Schedule 6, and the Local Government Act 1972, section 250(5).
• The application is made by Mr Izaac Beaumont for a full award of costs against
Calderdale Metropolitan Borough Council.
• The appeal was against the refusal of ‘the formation of a garage with office and storage
above’.
Decision
1. The application for a full award of costs is refused.
Reasons
2. Parties in planning appeals normally meet their own expenses. However, the
Planning Practice Guidance (PPG) explains how costs may be awarded against a
party who has behaved unreasonably, and thereby directly caused another
party to incur unnecessary expense at appeal.
3. Paragraph 49 of the PPG states that local planning authorities are at risk of an
award of costs if they behave unreasonably with respect to the substance of
the matter under appeal, for example, by unreasonably refusing or failing to
determine planning applications, or by unreasonably defending appeals. The
PPG gives examples of this as: ‘not determining similar cases in a consistent
manner’ or ‘preventing or delaying development which should clearly be
permitted, having regard to its accordance with the development plan, national
policy and any other material considerations’.
4. The applicant’s case for a full award of costs is that the Council should have
granted permission as the proposal is similar in scale to that of the previously
approved application Ref 18/01407/FUL.
5. However, the Council clearly sets out in its report why it considers the appeal
proposal to be different to that of the previous approval. The delegated report
states: ‘The previously approved scheme has a much more subservient feel and
would appear to provide the required secure vehicle parking and office facilities
whilst having a much reduced visual and physical impact upon both the
streetscene and the dwellings opposite along the terrace’. As can be seen from
my Decision, I also took the view that the change in orientation and the
provision of a large dormer window would result in significantly greater harm to
character and appearance and living conditions.
Costs Decision APP/A4710/D/22/3302115
2
6. As such I am satisfied that the Council’s reason for refusal was not
unsubstantiated. For the same reasons I am also not persuaded that it has
failed to determine similar cases in a consistent manner.
Conclusion
7. I therefore find that unreasonable behaviour resulting in unnecessary or
wasted expense, as described in the Planning Practice Guidance, has not been
demonstrated.
Paul Martinson
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Technical Appeal Representation
This Other minor developments requires a bespoke technical strategy to succeed.
Contact Planzo for a professional review and quotation.