Combined Appeal
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Heritage & Conservation
Residential Amenity
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 6 September 2022
by A.Graham BA(hons) MAued IHBC
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 29th September 2022
Appeal Ref: APP/Q4625/D/22/3301334
100 Grange Road, Olton, Solihull B91 1DA
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr Osman Aslam against the decision of Solihull Metropolitan
Borough Council.
• The application Ref PL/2022/00246/MINFHO dated 9 February 2022, was refused by
notice dated 17 May 2022.
• The application is for two storey rear extension and front extension with internal
reconfiguration.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issues
2. The main issue is the impact of the proposal upon the character and
appearance of the area and the impact of the proposal upon the living
conditions of neighbours.
Reasons
3. The appeal property is a detached house of late 20th century suburban design
located approximately midway along Grange Road. Grange Road runs in
roughly an east west direction from St Bernard’s Road. St Bernard’s Road
appears to form something of a spine route through the Olton Conservation
Area with Grange Road running at right angles downhill from there. The
property is part of a row of modern detached houses that are sited so as to
stagger somewhat along the street. Despite this they each have a relatively
regular plot width and are set back some distance from the road frontage with
foliage, trees and shrubbery providing a softening appearance.
4. The existing property is something of an asymmetrical design with an integral
but protruding garage to its left hand side and a mix of materials using off
white render and reddish brick. To the side the neighbouring property has
seemingly been extended with a simple gable extension that has protruded
somewhat in front of the appeal property itself making the appeal site more
recessive within its plot. To the opposite side of the property there is a large
hedge seemingly marking a small change in level before the hipped roof of the
neighbouring property becomes noticeable. To the rear the property has a long
garden with a small lean too element to its rear ground floor elevation with
other windows facing out towards the lawn.
Appeal Decision Appeal Ref: APP/Q4625/D/22/3301334
2
5. The proposal before me seeks to enlarge the existing house to both front and
rear so as to substantially increase the living accommodation within. This would
include a large kitchen diner with large windows facing onto the garden and a
roof conversion with five pitched roof dormer windows serving an office,
bedroom and gym.
6. The design aesthetic of the property would be substantially altered through the
introduction of a full height pitched roof glazed atrium feature that would give
light into the circulation spaces within and serve all the three storeys of the
house. The roof form of the proposed design would be partially pitched to the
front and rear but, presumably in order to keep the overall height low, a large
area to the top of the roof would be flat.
Impact of the proposal upon the character and appearance of the area
7. The Olton Conservation Area was designated in September 1980 and it appears
that the extant Conservation Area Appraisal was last revised in 2005. In
considering this appeal I am therefore required by Section 72 of the Planning
(Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990 to pay ‘special attention’ to
the desirability of preserving or enhancing the character or appearance of the
Conservation Area. The Act is reflected in The National Planning Policy
Framework (The Framework), which illustrates the positive contribution that
heritage assets can make to the creation of sustainable and economically viable
communities.
8. Olton appears to have Medieval origins but much of what makes it distinctive
today is its high quality early suburban development that consists primarily of
Victorian and Edwardian properties of various scales, from villas to small
terraces. Many of the distinctive characteristics are therefore dictated by both
the architectural details, materials and quality of these designs as well as a
strong influence of the Arts and Crafts movement. Such features as Mock Tudor
gables and simple neo vernacular forms utilising simple materials such as red
brick and render are therefore common. Although most properties occupy
relatively regular plots, these plots are generally well proportioned and heavily
and richly landscaped, often using hedges or low walls to demark their
frontages.
9. The adopted Conservation Area Appraisal document identifies a major threat to
this architectural and historic significance of the area as being through
insensitively designed buildings or infill development. I saw on my site visit
that the overall character of the area still predominates however despite some
newer interventions whose appearance I consider fails to abide to the overall
characteristics as identified above.
10. The case before me would result in a series of large extensions that would,
perhaps intentionally, contrast with the overall character of the area. Although
materials could be conditioned, I consider that the overall scale, height, flat
roof and full floor to roof glazed gable would introduce something of a contrived
design that would fail in terms of scale or proportion to relate to its surrounding
context. Even were the glazed gable feature to be considered a modern
interpretation of a traditional gable, it would still fail to respect the
fundamentals of quality or proportion that is so important within the more
traditional designs nearby.
Appeal Decision Appeal Ref: APP/Q4625/D/22/3301334
3
11. Further to this the proposed flat roof would introduce a large and noticeable
roof form that would be largely alien within this context where full pitched or
hipped roofs still predominate. As a result, the flat roof would appear as a
contrived roof form whose principal purpose appears to me to be to disguise
the excessive overall massing of the proposals.
12. Although I consider that there would be numerous ways in which to extend this
property, perhaps to a significant degree, that could respond well to the
character of the area, I consider that the proposal before me would represent a
poor design response to its context and would introduce harm to the character
and appearance of the Conservation Area though representing a poor infill
development.
13. As a result the proposal before me would introduce harm to the historic
environment and would fail to preserve or enhance the character or
appearance of the Olton Conservation Area through its largely unresponsive
design and overdevelopment of the plot. As such I consider the proposal would
be contrary to Policies P15 of the Solihull Local Plan (2013) that seeks to
conserve and enhance the character, streetscape and quality of new
developments within the built and historic environment.
Impact of the proposals upon the living conditions of neighbours.
14. The proposal would extend the property to a relatively large extent and much
of this added structure would run alongside the common boundary with its
neighbours. Neighbouring residents at number 98 have raised concerns with
regards the impact of the proposal upon their living conditions through both
overshadowing and over looking.
15. In considering the impact of the proposed extensions I consider that only a
relatively small proportion of the proposed two storey building would protrude
beyond the front and rear facades of number 98. The Architect’s plans show
clearly that the proposed front extension would abide by an approximate 45
degree angle to the neighbour’s front window and the first floor rear extension
would only slightly protrude beyond the rear building line of the two properties.
The rest of the rear extension would be a single storey structure and would
therefore have little appreciable impact especially when constructed behind the
existing boundary treatment.
16. Nevertheless, I consider that there could be some slight overshadowing of a
limited area of rear garden of number 98 on a late summers evening. Similarly,
there could be some modest overshadowing of the rear elevation of number
102 Grange Road in the early morning. I consider however that these impacts
would be comparable to the existing situation due to the angle of the sun at
certain times of year and the orientation of the properties themselves.
17. To the front also the protrusion forward of number 98 may result in some
modest impact upon late afternoon sun to rooms here, however any loss of
daylight here would be mitigated due to the generally southerly orientation of
the properties and the existing hedge. As such I conclude that there would be
only very limited impact upon the living conditions of neighbours through loss
of sunlight or overshadowing.
18. I note the neighbours concerns regarding overlooking. Whilst I consider it
unlikely that such overlooking could occur from the proposed side elevation
Appeal Decision Appeal Ref: APP/Q4625/D/22/3301334
4
windows, most of which would be secondary, I consider that a condition to
secure these windows as being obscured glass would suffice in mitigating such
an impact. In terms of the potential overlooking from the proposed rear
windows, I consider that this situation largely exists already and that the
proposal would not result in any added disbenefit to neighbours through this
proposal.
19. In considering the effect of the proposal upon the living conditions of
neighbours therefore I find such little harm to the current situation so as to
lead me to the conclusion that the proposal would comply with Local Plan Policy
P14.
Other Matters
20. The Appellant has directed my attention to other such developments of a
similar nature within close proximity to this site. The Appellant’s appeal
statement also outlined several other harmful additions to the Conservation
Area that they feel has undermined any special or architectural merit to which
the area possesses.
21. I saw on my site visit that the area has seen some development of a similar
nature to the scheme before me. I understand that one such property is
located within the Conservation Area boundary. However, I have no details
before me as to the precise nature of these proposals or the process that lead
to this scheme gaining planning approval. As such I can give these examples
only limited weight.
22. In terms of the overall quality and character of the area I saw that the Olton
Conservation Area does still exhibit a high degree of architectural quality within
its historic buildings. Although I saw some less sensitive design that have
undoubtably eroded this significance I do not consider that the presence of
such examples justifies the need for more similarly harmful additions that
would erode this special character further.
Conclusion
23. Although I have found no harm to the living conditions of neighbours through
this proposal that could not be satisfied through an appropriately worded
condition, the harm that I have identified to the character and appearance of
the area is significant enough to lead me to conclude that the appeal before me
should fail.
A Graham
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.